6 ms·
Buster: Captcha Solver for Humans
- squigz 2y ago> reCAPTCHA challenges remain a considerable burden on the web, delaying and often blocking our access to services and information depending on our physical and cognitive abilities, our social and cultural background, and the devices or networks we connect from. I'm a visually impaired user, and watching captchas get more and more hostile to people like me has been... difficult.
- throwup238 2y agoI imagine it’s going to result in some ADA suits sooner or later, like when people went around suing business who didn’t have a ramp alternative to stairs.
- mjcohen 2y agoThere seems to be quite a business with small businesses being sued for violating the ADA. They can pay about $10,000 to make the lawsuit go away.
- chii 2y ago> visually impaired user i would've thought the audio version of the captcha can still work for such a user?
- techsupporter 2y agoI suppose because a bunch of the automated solvers use the audio as a workaround, the audio ones have become borderline (or even over the line) unlistenable. The most recent few I've done have sounded like someone whispering "they threw their hair through the chair there" next to a propeller plane in a heavy thunderstorm.
- Semaphor 2y agoI can barely understand them, but my automatic solver still can, without issues, luckily.
- squigz 2y agoThose aren't always available, and as others point out, they've gotten very hostile too.
- dangsux 2y ago[dead]
- jfengel 2y agoI'm kinda surprised captcha still exists. It's pretty clear that the robots have beaten it, and when they haven't you can hire armies of humans for the price of a latte. Not that I want trillions of bots hitting up every resource on the Internet. But I don't see how to stop it at this point except by excluding a fair number of regular people.
- freedomben 2y agoFor big sites I agree, but for small to medium it's clear to me. The amount of shit thrown your way drops dramatically with a captcha in the way. It's enough to stop the barely interested scanners/attackers, which in my experience is a huge number of people.
- daguava 2y ago[dead]
- immibis 2y agoThis argument might have flown a decade ago, but our current economic environment is largely characterized by ignoring reality - creating vibes for upper management and shareholders is what really matters. And telling them we implemented a CAPTCHA solution creates that vibe.
- teeray 2y ago> you can hire armies of humans for the price of a latte. I’ve heard this before, but where does one actually hire these humans? Mturk is the only thing that comes to mind.
- michaelt 2y agoFor example https://2captcha.com/ https://2captcha.com/ https://anti-captcha.com/ https://anti-captcha.com/ https://www.capsolver.com/ https://www.capsolver.com/ https://deathbycaptcha.com/ https://deathbycaptcha.com/ https://nextcaptcha.com/ https://nextcaptcha.com/ seems like about $1 for 1000 solutions I suspect these businesses do a first pass of ML in case the captcha is easy, before sending it to a human to be solved manually.
- neilv 2y agoA separate concern I have is that Web sites running ReCaptcha often require leaking privacy-invasive information to Google, in the course of using the site. Not only does Google presumably usually know exactly who you are when you visit that site, but even if you normally block other Google hidden Web trackers, you can't block the ReCaptcha tracker, so in some cases Google can have a very good idea of what you do on the site. So, while this browser extension might relieve some of the visible annoyance, it doesn't relieve the more insidious problem.
- lelandfe 2y agoUsers are punished if Google is unaware of them. I built an iOS app for a major brand but the web view would load with no cookies in a sandbox, and we realized after roll out that all users were needing to solve 10+ hard CAPTCHA challenges to be let through, as Google was unfamiliar with the users. You’ll get a similar experience loading over a VPN. We removed it. It’s easy to why device attestation is so alluring to these companies. Anonymity and bots look alike.
- pennybanks 2y agoi didnt even think of that but makes sense. valuable pov. either way im sure most people are just annoyed with the gate code then they are with the tracking and would take the cookie everytime. and i feel like this is similar to many things especially with google. but people just would rather just believe these companies are against them haha. kinda silly imo
- yreg 2y agoUnfortunately it's not just getting the difficult captchas. If you try enough to maintain privacy and become invisible to the likes of Google/Meta, you have trouble creating accounts. Like you might create an Instagram account and be automatically banned in an hour for no apparent reason. But as you say, it totally makes sense.
- rustcleaner 2y agoIt's time to build for the bots instead of fighting them.
- Onavo 2y agoIf you want to take a look at a more professional grade tool (used by webscraping companies, with API access), take a look at NopeCha https://github.com/NopeCHALLC/nopecha-extension https://github.com/NopeCHALLC/nopecha-extension
- askvictor 2y agoI've found that since switching to Firefox I get a lot more captchas than in Chrome or chromium.
- capitainenemo 2y agoIt's even worse if you enable Firefox's fingerprinting resistance. For example Drupal.org is essentially unusable with Firefox anti-fingerprinting (even for basic things like patch information). Ditto Zillow. I have to use a separate "fingerprint me" profile.
- usr1106 2y agoI use Firefox exclusively with default anti-tracking settings plus CookieAutoDelete. But I guess I see less than 1 captcha a week. AWS on my private, hardly used account was the most annoying one in the past because I had at least a 50% chance to get it wrong. But that does no longer come up after I enabled 2FA.
- poikroequ 2y agoIt's interesting to think, using AI to solve captcha requires some compute time, effectively turning captchas into proof of work.
- chii 2y agowhich also solves the bot problem - by making it more expensive to bot a site.
- reginald78 2y agoSo why not switch directly to proof of work instead of hassling humans?
- ianpurton 2y agoBecause PoW would only slow the attack. Bots networks are often malware running on infected machines, so there's no cost to the hacker. Captcha is supposed to stop the attack altogether.
- poikroequ 2y agoMore and more botnets are being sold as a service. By that, I mean things like DDoS as a Service. So it's not quite correct to say there's no cost to the hacker.
- Nextgrid 2y agoBecause part of the purpose of the captcha (or at least most of their uses on the modern web) is to ensure human time is wasted. It’s “proof of suffering” more than proof of work or proof of payment.
- sebastiennight 2y agoI've tried throwing CAPTCHA challenges at gpt-4o, and it has so far solved all of them for me, except for OpenAI's challenge (the one where you align a hand with an object). I'm assuming they fine-tuned the model to make it less capable of solving those. An issue with the extension mentioned here is that it's not helping against the fingerprinting... it's actually leaving even more of a fingerprint.
- nullc 2y agoI wonder what the risk of getting your google account banned by using tools like this is?
- 1oooqooq 2y agorepeat after me: recaptcha is not about thwarting evil bots. It's about making hard-to-monetize sessions from privacy nerds more painful. Bots cost nothing to google. Heck google main business IS a huge freaking bot! this project is awesome. but it will only make google go harder against accessibility in the long run.
- johnisgood 2y agoHow do captcha's work on Tor webites? It has to do with CSS magic and presumably OpenResty (or without). Anyone familiar with it? I think we should diverge our attention to that.