7 ms·
Game Informer shutting down after 33 years
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoBut I thought GameStop stock, the meme-y one beloved by Matt Levine was riding high. Surely GameStop has sold enough stock to meme-y retail Investors to afford a couple of yachts for each board member and keep a game magazine going - send a free copy to every stock owner surely ? What a waste of marketing
- kortilla 2y ago> Investors to afford a couple of yachts for each board member Board members generally hold stock and don’t receive large cash payments from the company. The board represents the shareholders so there would be a massive conflict of interest if they made more money from the company in cash than from shares.
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoThe point I was making is that an irrational rise in your stock price is the perfect time to sell stock in order to capture that rise - it’s almost a fiduciary duty. So selling 100 million of inflated stock should give them the opportunity to fund a lot of marketing projects, focus on the underlying business - not to cut costs and hope to survive. Either you believe there is a world for real world shops in a market dominated by Steam or you give the keys to the stores back.
- dwighttk 2y agoBeloved by Matt Levine? It’s been a a few weeks since I read him but do you mean something more than beloved for providing grist for the “look at this absurd thing” mill?
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoBeloved as in “writes about quite a lot, snorts derisively too, but still it’s stuff like this that gets the readers in, so beloved, yeah maybe.”
- eropple 2y agoIf anyone reads anything Matt Levine writes about GME and goes "ooh, I want that", they have conclusively failed at literacy, both media and mathematical.
- ThinkBeat 2y agoWas the magazine any good?
- kevingadd 2y agoIt was always kind of undermined by being tied to GameStop, but they did serious journalism from time to time and would have detailed behind-the-scenes/preview pieces and exclusive announcements. I can't remember ever seeing anything bad published by them, unlike some other outlets, even if I didn't visit their website regularly
- rootsudo 2y agoI never thought so. I considered it fluff when getting a Gamestop Pro membership. I'm surprised that so many people here considered it a high piece of journalism. The Pro membership did pay for itself, in some effect but after once or twice, I did not renew the subscription and went out of gaming entirely. Imagine that, a magazine, marketing puffery designed to push the very product that said store was selling - is going to be missed. But then again people had the same outcry when, say, the Sears Catalog went away. -- As for magazines I personally missed, Nintendo Power, EGM, Playstation Magazine were all of a higher tier and quality, and I'm sure I'm aging myself there. :)
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Some more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41141260 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41141260
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xyst 2y agoSeems like “gaming journalism” has been replaced by independent journalists or random social media “influencers”. Mostly the latter. Gaming mags like Game Informer used to be the premier source of gaming industry news - exclusive interviews with publishers and studios, and game reviews. The reception of these quality articles largely determined the success of games. But now? Just buy off a few “influencers” with significant following, have them play through the happy path, review, edit and approve videos for positive vibes. Formula for success. No need to push out quality anymore. Keep milking the cash cow game series. Very hard to find a good game these days. Have to sift through at least a dozen of shit games in the marketplace before settling on something half decent.
- Spivak 2y ago> Just buy off a few “influencers” with significant following If it was that easy there would be no unsuccessful games. > Very hard to find a good game these days Hard hard disagree. We're drowning in great games. The 90% of everything is shit rule is the same as it's always been so I'm sympathetic to having to sift through hay but there are more needles than ever before.
- zoogeny 2y ago> No need to push out quality anymore At some point in my life I started watching people play games on YouTube far more than I play games myself. There are a handful of channels I follow where the creator (influencer?) plays a wide variety of new games completely uncut. Very often, for a single game there are 100+ 30 minute videos of the entire game. I find this kind of deep-dive into the game to be invaluable. Good creators/influencers make it abundantly clear when they are taking a sponsorship. It is also usually clear when a sponsored game gets 4 videos (total of 2 hours of content) how the creator feels, even if they don't explicitly criticize the game. Although, the better creators will offer unbiased opinions even on sponsored content. When I compare this to the vast majority of gaming "journalism" that I grew up with, I am more than happy with the new status quo.
- DataDaoDe 2y agoJust out of curiosity about the gaming journalism you are talking about, what gaming era did you grow up in? For instance, for me it was the mid 90s to early 2000s, the days of the demo cds, etc. Somehow the whole watching other people play games movement missed me, not saying that's good or bad, maybe its just an artifact of my own life and has little to do with my generation in general.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- BoredPositron 2y agoSo GameStop comes in as the savior earlier and just as the CEO goes totally nuts on Twitter they release bad news after bad news. What a coincidence.
- monetus 2y agoI don't reader twitter, thanks for posting a heads up.
- acjohnson55 2y agoI wasn't familiar with what Ryan Cohen's been to on Twitter, but just looked and at risk of overusing the word, that's some weird behavior. It has been truly strange to see business leaders revert to acting like they have the impulse control, sensibilities and perspective of middle school boys.
- hnpolicestate 2y agoI remember being wowed by the Dreamcast and Shenmu review. Good times.
- wildpeaks 2y agoThe Dishonored/Prey/Deathloop covers were wonderful: https://x.com/Sinnoware/status/1819421747399250198 https://x.com/Sinnoware/status/1819421747399250198 https://x.com/jlmonnet/status/1716026320822399158 https://x.com/jlmonnet/status/1716026320822399158 The Cyberpunk2077 AR one was amazing too: https://x.com/gamebowski/status/1281003400403042305 https://x.com/gamebowski/status/1281003400403042305
- phendrenad2 2y agoGaming magazines were magical 30 years ago when game companies were black boxes. Games just appeared on shelves one day and you had to rely on the publisher's brand name as a guarantee of quality. Simpler times. You could maybe get a highly-editorialized sneak peak from a gaming mag a few months early. Now, it's almost like games are made in public. Everyone knows what you're working on thanks to leakers and court filings. Every developer's life is analyzed and used as fodder for the rumor mill. Companies are basically forced into early-access because the cost of a bad review by a prominent influencer post-launch is too high.
- layer8 2y ago> you had to rely on the publisher's brand name as a guarantee of quality I only relied on the pictures on the box. ;)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- celdon25 2y agoAdditionally, those magazines were a good source of game hints. Nowadays, most games are developed with the assumption that players will already have the knowledge passed to them from the Internet. You don’t see nearly as many games where the emphasis is on discovering tricks and quirks. It’s now about cold optimization or just going through the motions. That’s not to say games were better back then. But the newer generations will never know the joy of checking the mailbox every day and seeing that brand spanking new issue of Ultra Game Players Magazine, then being the only kid in the neighborhood to know about the next gen console specs, and feeling cool about it.
- w0m 2y agoThe Internet existed back then, but 20 years ago there was no real great way to get discussion on the newest games. gamefaqs.com existed, but it wasn't comprehensive by any measure in letting you figure out if a game was worth trying. Game Informer on the crapper was the best use of time. What probably killed it for me/caused me to cancel my subscription was the rise of cellphone use on the toilet.
- phatfish 2y ago"In March, Game Informer introduced out a way to subscribe to the magazine directly — previously, you could only get the magazine by buying issues on their own or through a GameStop Pro subscription." Huh, that sounds crazy. Even back in the 90s subscriptions were common in the UK. I would get a 6 month/1 year sub to a magazine i liked for a birthday every now and then. There would always be a page trying to get readers to sub. I assumed this is how the likes of Edge still survive.
- kinlan 2y agoI hope so, I'm seeing fewer and fewer stores stocking Edge magazine directly.
- Triphibian 2y agoIt might seem counter-intuitive, but Game Informer was fairly recently (and for a good stretch) in the top ten of US print magazine circulation -- mailing out 6-7 million copies a month. As people stopped subscribing to magazines and buying them at newstands the top circulation magazines were magazines that came with another product or service. Current tops are the AARP Newsletter and the Costco magazine because every member of those clubs gets a magazine in the mail as part of their membership. Game Informer benefited greatly from being a free add-on to a membership GameStop employees pushed hard.
- acjohnson55 2y agoI wouldn't have guessed Game Informer was still around. Growing up, I felt it was like the little brother of GamePro and Electronic Gaming Monthly, both of which published much bigger issues. But my parents were frugal, so Game Informer was the first magazine subscription I ever had. I credit it with greatly improving my reading skills by exposing me to journalism.
- lofaszvanitt 2y agoIt was good 15 years ago. Now, it has become a pretty mediocre, borderline boring magazine.
- danielscrubs 2y agoI think people want to feel angry, it’s a shot of adrenaline with the same feeling as drinking coffee. The ones that panders to rage bait like Washington Post and IGN are doing relatively well in a difficult landscape. It is horrible, but is probably how we are wired and something deeply unconscious, and I try to combat this by asking myself what kind of feeling a certain website will give me, before clicking, which seems to do the trick.