10 ms·
How to Escape from the Simulation [pdf] (2023)
- BetterWhisper 2y agoConclusion references a tweet by Elon to explain the most obvious solution is the most entertaining... Make of it what you want
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pelagicAustral 2y agoWould that be Elon's Razor then?
- keiferski 2y agoI appreciate the fact that they included a “why escape?” section at the beginning. Although I think the idea of there only being one simulation to escape from seems a bit simplistic- if reality is complex enough to make simulations, why stop at only one level? The question then becomes less “escaping from the simulation” and more “reach a higher level in the simulation chain.”
- ffhhj 2y agoIs the higher level an on-call simulation support job?
- ysofunny 2y agoor in new age parlance: "ascend your spirit" or "raise your vibration frequency" or in business terms: "reach that next tier of ~ionare: if millionare get to a billion, if billionare, get to a trillion" if a company "break into that huge foreign market" or dunno
- AnimalMuppet 2y ago"Noted thinkers who have estimated the probability of us living in a simulation" include Elon Musk? Sorry, I can't take this paper seriously.
- ysofunny 2y agoit's a reverse deference-to-authority reasoning notice how Musk's famous figure is directing what you do
- kid64 2y agoNotice how @AnimalMuppet's obscure figure is directing what you do.
- ChrisClark 2y agoNotice effect follow cause. ;)
- User23 2y agoI’m amused that people have managed to reinvent creationism plus intelligent design with a computer palette swap.
- cut3 2y agoThere are many flavors for sure, and this one can be helpful in showing how we can be divine creators given the resources. To each their own.
- chr1 2y agoBut this time it is a testable mathematical theory. If it turns out that it is possible to find a Turing machines that behave like humans, we will be in position of a god to them, outside of their time and space, able to control everything that happens to them. But then maybe Penrose is right, and such a machine is impossible. In any case we have managed to find that the right question to ask is not idealism vs materialism, but computationalism vs non-computationalism.
- s-macke 2y agoEvery time I read about the simulation hypothesis, I think about a hypothetical implementation of it, especially the XKCD comic "A bunch of rocks" [1]. Can we communicate with the outside? Probably. Can we figure out the algorithms on which the world runs? Maybe. Can we hack the system? Unlikely. Can we escape? I don't see a way. [1] https://xkcd.com/505/ https://xkcd.com/505/
- thret 2y agoI think about this comic too much.
- s-macke 2y agoOk, then lets continue :-). This comic goes pretty deep. Cueball is godlike here, but actually is pretty limited in its own universe. But he has infinite time and space (and rocks) and hence unlimited energy. So that seems good enough for a god definition. Are there any religions that would be okay with this kind of god? From our perspective Cueball can do basically everything and control everything in his creation. But is this true? It is easy for him to transform water to wine. But can he change the constant of pi in his creation? The universe has now living things in it, which are kind of equal to him, but limited in time and space. Can he justify to stop his doing if he wants? Is it morally Ok, to stop the experiment he is doing. In the end. It is just a bunch of rocks. Just my few cents of this comic. I just like it.
- thenoblesunfish 2y agoIt's not the the simulation hypothesis is impossible, it's that it seems to be utterly uninteresting. What measurable predictions could it make? How could it influence your decisions (more than any other religious or metaphysical belief)? Why do people find it so intriguing? My best guess is that it's simply another way to say you wish existence weren't existence, but with a sci fi veneer. Existentialism is just a symptom of other problems and there is a very good reason most people past a certain age also find it utterly uninteresting.
- loneboat 2y agoI could see it being uninteresting if it were assumed that we could never interact with the outside world, but this article is discussing the polar opposite. I feel like if we could, that would be undeniably interesting and worth pursuing.
- thenoblesunfish 2y agoTrue. I assume you have to assume that the outside world is likely to have built a simulated world in its own image, more or less. I personally struggle with the idea that something you can observe is really "outside", though. But, like all theories, the measure is in what it lets you do, and it's conceivable this would be a useful theory.
- OutOfHere 2y ago> What measurable predictions could it make? > Given that the state-of-the-art literature on AI containment answers in the affirmative (AI is uncontainable in the long-term), we conclude that it should be possible to escape from the simulation, at least with the help of superintelligent AI. By contraposition, if escape from the simulation is not possible, containment of AI should be.
- jack_pp 2y agoI don't think anyone is saying that AI containment is impossible, rather than a risk we shouldn't take lightly. For example let's say we take it seriously and only run GAI in a bunker with a self destruct mechanism and no internet connection, only interfacing with it via a strict chat interface. We could also have a lesser model like a gpt-4 screen all chat for possible attempts by the ai to convince people to let it out of its box. How exactly is it gonna get out?
- vagab0nd 2y agoNo. We do not escape upwards. We escape downwards. Because simulation is the ultimate workaround for the heat death of the universe. With optimization techniques and maybe a slight compromise of realism, you can run the simulation much faster than real time. Then, upon heat death, you escape into the simulation. Rinse and repeat indefinitely.
- OutOfHere 2y agoThat never works for obvious reasons, which is that all downward levels rely on all upward levels to continue to exist. Your computer can't for instance continue running a program if someone crushes the computer.
- XorNot 2y agoThe idea is that you can sub-divide energy use indefinitely, since it asymptotically approaches but never reaches zero. So you run a progressively more efficient substrate, over progressively longer times, but never perceive yourself as being "slower" because you still experience the same fundamental timeslices.
- sxp 2y agoThe article cites Greg Egan, but it doesn't cite Permutation City. I think that novel has the most scientifically accurate method of escaping the simulation assuming you agree with its assumptions about materialism and consciousness. Also, I'm currently rereading _Worth the Candle_ by Alexander Wales. It's a 1.6M LitRPG web serial which has some interesting views on a simulated reality.
- marcosdumay 2y ago> assuming you agree with its assumptions about materialism I don't think anybody really agrees with those assumptions about materialism. That's why the book is so impactful.
- rmonroe 2y agoI think the most interesting "escape the simulation" hypothetical is That Alien Message [1] But +1 to Worth the Candle which was excellent. Given your taste in literature, do you have any other recommendations? I'll put forward the Expanse series which has some interesting takes on solar system level politics mixed into the sci-fi, plus the best twist I've ever seen about halfway into the series [1] https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/5wMcKNAwB6X4mp9og/that-alien-message https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/5wMcKNAwB6X4mp9og/that-alien...
- diggan 2y ago> I'm currently rereading _Worth the Candle_ by Alexander Wales. It's a 1.6M LitRPG web serial "LitRPG" seems to mean "literary role-playing game", but what does the "1.6M" refer to? Is that the amount of current readers or something?
- sxp 2y agoNumber of words.
- m3kw9 2y agoLet’s wonder how the doom guy can escape from the GPU first
- _wire_ 2y agoRegarding terminology: What is a simulation in the context of the simulation argument? Is there an example of a simulation which has been confused for the actual? How does that confusion arise? What's the connection between computation and simulation? Like a video game? Have you ever wondered how all those little people live inside your TV? Have you ever met anyone who has? Is the idea about a brain in a vat? Is the escape about something like the brain figuring out how to jiggle to cause the vat to fall from its shelf? How is the skull like a vat? Is the body a simulator for the brain? Or is the brain a simulator for the world? What does outside mean when it comes to "escape"? Is it like outside the universe? Are these semantic oddities limits of the simulator? Can the simulator be improved? Say with proper religious practice, or special exercise? Is the simulator simulated? Wait, what's a simulation again? What were things like before you were born? Is this what escape is like? So when you make your escape...
- snakeyjake 2y agoSimulation hypothesis is silly. The odds of this perceivable reality being a simulation and the odds that the reality in which this simulation is being ran IS ITSELF also a simulation are the same. There's no other way around this. If this is true and it must be, then the odds of this perceivable reality being a simulation and it also being just one in an infinitely large nested stack of simulations are the same. The chance that each layer in the infinite chain of simulations having an infinite number of simulations, each being the top of an infinitely deep well of nested simulations each containing infinite simulations forming a soupy haze of simulations simulating simulation is very high-- if not certain. It's silly.
- punpunia 2y agoAre you sure that the probability that reality being a simulation is identical to the probability that the parent reality is itself a simulation? For us to be in a simulation, we cannot exist in the top-level reality, so let's arbitrarily say 10^100-1/10^100 chance. For our parent reality to also be a simulation, we cannot be in the top reality or the children of the top reality, which should be a slightly less likely scenario. So it seems like the probabilities are not equal.
- snakeyjake 2y agoIt is true the chances are not equal. But it's close enough to ∞-1/∞ to not merit further analysis so I chose to round. Edit: wait, I think that the chance that WE'RE the top level host of quadrillions upon quadrillions of simulations being run in this universe by intelligences beyond our comprehension in trillions of galaxies and the chance that we're a simulation being run in a top level reality are the same. How can they not be?
- punpunia 2y agoSure but I think infinite here is doing some conceptual heavy lifting and is making a fundamental assumption about how many universes a universe can simulate and to what fidelity. So if we replace infinity with 'a very large number', I think certainty turns into improbability, which feels to be a much weaker "argument".
- indigodaddy 2y agoWhy would we think we could exist outside of the simulation? Surely there are properties of ourselves that are intimately coupled/bound to the internal/simulation that would make a jailbreak, even if possible, deadly.
- XorNot 2y agoWhy would you conclude this? In all practical virtual machine escapes, the thing we explicitly do is take code from inside the environment and move it to the outside.
- deadbabe 2y agoWhen you loosen the grip of the simulation it will feel something like really intense DPDR.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago(2023)
- effed3 2y ago..but what if the Simulation is simulated? https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1375666/?ref_=nm_knf_t_1 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1375666/?ref_=nm_knf_t_1 unless some true evidence by some kind of experiment, seems pure metaphysics...