6 ms·
Robin Warren, pathologist who rewrote the science on ulcers, has died
- yakito 2y agoThe vast majority of people still today directly associate any stomach pain with stress as their first thought. I would even venture to say that many doctors still inquire about stress during a consultation. Even though it is not the cause of ulcers, it is true that stress amplifies the symptoms of existing ulcers and increases stomach acid production. Personally, I find stress fascinating.
- vjk800 2y agoI'm still waiting for a similar discovery to treat GERD. Having the condition, I've become a bit of a couch expert on GERD literature and it seems that everyone and their dog have a completely different opinion on what, in the end, causes it.
- apwell23 2y agoSame. It has been bane of my existence for last 3 years.
- te 2y agohttps://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/8098-hiatal-hernia https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/8098-hiatal-h...
- vjk800 2y agoThere are people with giant hiatal hernias and no GERD and there are people with bad GERD and no hiatal hernia. Hiatal hernia seems to at least make GERD worse, but is not the only factor and the causal link between hiatal hernia and GERD seems to run both ways (i.e. people with GERD also develop hiatal hernia over time instead of just hiatal hernia causing GERD). Other possible explanations found in the literature are at least: small intestine bacterial overgrowth; dysbiosis of the esophagus; food intolerances; postural problems; incorrectly (for some reason) functioning LES (or other related) muscle etc. It's possible that all of these contribute a little bit to GERD and whether you get problems depends in all of these factors in some non-trivial way.
- amluto 2y agoThis paper was entertaining at least: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9106553/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9106553/ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36059247 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36059247
- vjk800 2y agoWith a little bit of search, it's possible to find lots of papers that claim to solve the issue with some kind of novel treatment. Sometimes it's training the LES or other muscle (like in the article), sometimes it's correcting some sort of dysbiosis of the gut or the esophagus (see e.g. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6469450/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6469450/), etc. It's possible that they are all true, though, and GERD can either result from multiple different causes or from a sum of different causes. If that's the case, we would need better diagnostics to figure out what is causing each individuals problems in particular.
- ilamont 2y agoMy father is a GI researcher, and gave a talk on Warren and other innovators and innovations in the field (which includes endoscopy, the direct result of an innovation in computer networking, Narinder Singh Kapany's paper on fiber optic cable). Anyway, the term that was used to describe the resistance to Warren and Marshall's resesarch was "the Acid Mafia." Barry Marshall realized that some of the patients that Robin Warren was telling him about were his own patients. He had learned fiberoptic endoscopy, and he was performing biopsies on these same patients and knew their medical histories. So this clinical connection lit a spark, and the two of them teamed up and made a remarkable discovery. What they did was to simply correlate this finding with the presence of active chronic gastritis. They published their first paper, a brief letter to the editor in Lancet in 1983t, which described a series of their patients with active gastritis and the present of this curved bacillus in their stomachs. They went on then to make further correlations between the curved bacilli and peptic ulcers and eventually gastric cancer. This discovery was innovative and totally new. and was met with huge resistance by the medical establishment. The notion that peptic ulcer was an infectious disease met with near universal rejection. I actually remember the journal club in a Boston teaching hospital near here where this was first presented. The discovery was universally rejected by most of us in attendance. The problem was that in certain parts of the world, 80% of the population were infected. How could something that common be a cause of a disease like peptic ulcer that only occurs in, say, 1% of the population? Barry Marshall wrote in his note cards and some of his later publication “Everyone was against me, but I knew I was right.” So who was against him? The acid mafia, a powerful group of senior investigators who championed the idea that hydrochloric acid was the key to formation of stomach ulcers. When we were residents and fellows we had to know a lot about gastric hydrochloric acid secretion. So those who believed in the primacy of stomach acid were definitely strongly opposed to these Australian upstarts, Marshall and Warren. (https://archive.blogs.harvard.edu/lamont/2020/01/30/advances-gastroenterology-medical-rounds/ https://archive.blogs.harvard.edu/lamont/2020/01/30/advances...) Another pattern that came up in these discoveries was the doctors and researchers experimenting on themselves. For example: In this instance the experimental subject was Barry Marshall himself. He swallowed a pure culture of Helicobacter pylori that he had isolated from one of his patients that he had previously biopsied and cured. So he knew that the strain was treatable and curable. He drank the culture of H pylori and over the next several weeks developed severe acute Helicobacter infection with nausea, vomiting, and severe dyspepsia. He stated that his halitosis was so bad, that his wife told him that he had to sleep on the couch. After the infection was established he treated himself with the anti-Helicobacter therapy and completely recovered. His experiment was soon published in the Medical Journal of Australia in 1985. Basil Hirschowitz, the godfather of endoscopy, also followed the self-experimentation path: Hirschowitz heard about [the fiber optic] paper from a cardiology resident who had heard about it at journal club in London. Hirschowitz flew to London, met Kapany and Hopkins in a pub, and discussed their invention. They were very encouraging to Hirschowitz and gave him a few glass fibers to take back to Ann Arbor. Hirschowitz returned to his fellowship at Michigan and built the first fiberoptic gastroscope with help from Larry Curtis and Wilbur Peters who were physicists. After a few years of trial and error, they produced the first gastroscope ... Like a lot of fellows and young researchers in science, first tested the device on himself in February 1957. He managed to control his own gag reflex, passed through his esophagus and looked around in his own stomach.
- deangiberson 2y agoI was diagnosed with ulcers at the age of 10, well before Warren's work. For 11 years I dealt with constant pain and people telling me I just needed to learn how to relax. At the age of 21, at my next twice-yearly doctor appointment, my doctor asked me if I had heard about this news. I had, and I was willing to try it out as an experimental treatment. Eight weeks later I was cured. No pain. No after effects. Robin Warren impacted my life in a very real way.
- 01100011 2y agoCounterpoint: I was diagnosed with a duodenal ulcer at 12. It was from stress. My dad has a large amount of scar tissue in his stomach from repeated ulcers. They magically went away when the doc lit a cigarette and told him they were gonna remove part of his stomach if it happened again. Never had an ulcer after that. Instead he would break out in hives when his stress level rose.
- istultus 2y agoHow is that a counterpoint? You're just presenting a rare case, like Zollinger-Ellison, or some genetic or physiologic Vagal over-stimulation. 80%+ of ulcers are caused by H. Pylori infection. Next largest group is misuse of NSAIDS (also the most common causes for pediatric ulcers). Why would a doctor not first test and treat the common things, rather than do an invasive procedure?
- cocok 2y ago> Why would a doctor not first test and treat the common things, rather than do an invasive procedure? For the money he/she would get for doing the invasive procedure. This happens even in developed countries.
- pfannkuchen 2y agoLike you tested negative for h pylori? How do you know it was from stress?
- paulmac_ie 2y ago
- memcg 2y agoI had a bleeding ulcer in high school in the 70s, so assuming it was stress, the staff at my all male Catholic HS started to treat me like a human being. It wasn't stress, but I enjoyed the change. I believe that my ulcer was caused by daily doses of the antibiotic Tetracycline which the family Dermatologist prescribed for acne. Once I stopped taking it, my symptoms were gone.
- dekhn 2y agoThis is one of those situations where the narrative is fairly simple: people believed X, it was wrong, a few iconoclasts demonstrated in a fairly convincing way that Y was indeed the case, and then over time, the story got rewritten in the literature. But in practice it turned out to be more complicated than the narrative; X is still somewhat true and ulcers and gastric disorders are both caused by, and affected by, multiple factors. Certainly, stress can exacerbate an existing latent ulcer or gastric disorder, making many people attribute the cause to stress, but this quickly gets into "proximal causes" and "ultimate causes". As for working with doctors who didn't get the memo, I've learned that you sort of have to sneak up new information to them without making them feel challenged by a non-expert. It's a form of social engineering.
- codesnik 2y agoHuh. Could you tell more on ways of sneaking up information to them? I personally am so undiplomatic I have hard time even to imagine, how to do it.
- dekhn 2y agoI typically made a dumb reference to something I saw in the literature (JAMA, BMJ, etc) while also saying "but I guess that's just a controversial new opinion". Basically you want to avoid directly confronting them by implying they are dumb or wrong. Instead, appeal to authority, but in a soft way, and downplay the confidence of the new result. I had many years of being undiplomatic until I saw a video of Kevin mitnick. His normal nature was quite undiplomatic and fairly autistic, but when he did social engineering, he did an amazing job of telling people what they wanted to hear. Now, when I think something, instead of stating it in a clear and undiplomatic way, I rewrite it in a way that my mental model suggests increases the probability the listeners will change their minds and agree with me. This took a great deal of practice to be able to do in real time.
- Buttons840 2y agoI've sometimes noticed myself giving ideas in passing during a friendly conversation where nobody is defensive, my idea is passed over initially, but some days later the person has the same idea and doesn't remember that I suggested it. This might be some kind of bias on my part though. Point being: Offer your idea during a friendly time where it will not cause the other person to be defensive and then you have to wait. You might find that the next time you bring it up the person is more receptive.
- ein0p 2y agoSeems like there wasn’t really any “science of ulcers” before he wrote it, so saying that he rewrote it is inaccurate
- AlbertCory 2y agoThere is little, if any, penalty for being wrong. There's a substantial penalty for being right. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Robin-Warren https://www.britannica.com/biography/Robin-Warren > It defied the conventional wisdom that bacteria could not survive in the highly acidic environment of the stomach, and many scientists dismissed his reports. There is some point in the process where those "many scientists" should have been prevented from doing any further peer reviews, at the very least. If you always say No, your opinion has no value.
- don_neufeld 2y agoI still remember the sound of my doctor’s voice when he looked through the endoscope as 20 yr old me laid on the table. “Man, we find your problem” Fortunately, the Canadian medical system knew about Dr Warren’s work and so I was properly treated with antibiotics and completely cleared up in 2 weeks, never had a recurrence. I owe that guy a lot, I’ve heard many horror stories about ulcer treatments since then, it’s shocking this isn’t known by literally 100% of doctors (of all specialties)
- jiggawatts 2y agoThink about a field that you know, like software development or whatever. Now say: “Surely by now everybody knows about SQL injection!” Meanwhile it’s the third item in the OWASP top ten: https://owasp.org/Top10/A03_2021-Injection/ https://owasp.org/Top10/A03_2021-Injection/ Now that you know how ignorant supposed experts can be in a highly paid intellectual profession, extrapolate to every other field of study and weep.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jfil 2y agoI'm a fellow Canadian, and in my early 20s I realized that the normal hunger pain I was feeling... wasn't normal. Instead of pain, others experienced a different feeling that told them "I could eat right now". After an endoscopy and a biopsy, they found that I had H. Pylori and stomach inflammation (no ulcers). After a vaccine + course of antibiotics, I stopped feeling pain whenever I was hungry and started feeling a normal appetite sensation. I'm posting this comment in case anyone is in the same situation with hunger pain.
- beefman 2y ago"Gastric cancer prevention by community eradication of Helicobacter pylori: a cluster-randomized controlled trial", published 7 days after his death https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-024-03153-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-024-03153-w
- anon115 2y agoi had h pylori and got infected twice resulting me in having chronic gastritis,daily heartburn, and esophagitis and ppi' made it worse had to eat plain foods for about approx 3 years to get better.and also drink cabbage juice daily, and eat brocolli sprouts (it kills the bacteria) you can also increase the potency of broccoli sprouts with mustard seeds. and their was another way of having to heat the broccoli sprouts but i forgot the process
- themadturk 2y agoMy mother-in-law suffered from ulcers for years before this discovery. She was successfully treated and lived the rest of her life ulcer-free.
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/V6n3e https://archive.ph/V6n3e
- neonate 2y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20240801085715/https://www.washingtonpost.com/obituaries/2024/07/31/robin-warren-nobel-ulcers-dies/ https://web.archive.org/web/20240801085715/https://www.washi...
- quantumwoke 2y agoThis guy was a true unsung hero of the medical world and he really embodied the hacker spirit. Thank you for your contributions.
- rvnx 2y agoCan help to fix the: "this is caused by stress", when actually you needed antibiotics that already exists and were known at the time :|
- cpncrunch 2y agoThats a bit of a myth though. Stress is still known to be a factor in causing ulcers. https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/ben/cpd/2020/00000026/00000025/art00006 https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/ben/cpd/2020/00000026...
- cue_the_strings 2y agoI had gastritis (duodenitis, in fact) a couple of years back, and the first thing they did was test me for H. pylori. I didn't have it. Doctor told me a vast majority of people with such issues do. After a gastroscopy, they concluded that it was just stress and nothing else, but inflamation wouldn't heal on its own, so I got pantoprazole (PPI) and stopped ingesting potentially irritating food (caffeine, alcohol, spicy food). I also shortly changed jobs, which alleviated the stress. Mind you, I never had heartburn, just pain. My condition didn't improve for a while after that, until I stopped drinking carbonated water (the only carbonated beverage I consumed), that fixed it in less than a month. After that, I gradually weaned myself off of pantoprazol in 6 months. There literally was no other probable cause except for stress (I was stressed, wholly self-induced), and after I switched industries and no longer felt that I'm wasting my time working for peanuts, the PPIs helped cure the symptoms.
- raincom 2y agoWow, carbonated water is not good overall.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoRelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41118638 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41118638
- dang 2y agoI've moved those comments hither. Thanks!
- toomuchtodo 2y agoPlease accept this comment as my perpetual permission to edit or remove my stub comments in this regards, and replace them with your own references.
- erikig 2y agoI didn’t know the wholes story but I thank Robin. As a teen, I remember the relief when the years of advice to “learn to relax” and “stop stressing out” was replaced by meds that fixed my ulcers in weeks.
- adamc 2y agoHere's a guy who had epilepsy severe enough that his parents feared to send him to college who made an enormous difference in the lives of many people.
- tombert 2y agoI got an ulcer about ten years ago, well after Warren's research, I went to a doctor and he told me that the ulcer was caused by stress. I said something like "didn't someone get a Nobel prize proving that ulcers were bacterial?" and the doctor hadn't heard that and "prescribed" me to get more rest and try and be less concerned about work. I got a different doctor after that. Robin Warren is someone who I respected the hell out of. It takes a lot of tenacity and determination to go against something when everyone is constantly telling you you're wrong. He will be missed. ETA: I should point out that I am aware that stress can aggravate and (potentially) cause some forms of ulcers, though I really wasn't terribly stressed at that point in my life, which I tried explaining to the doctor and he wouldn't hear it. My job was going fine, I didn't really have any debt, I had a decent relationship with my girlfriend (now wife), I really didn't feel stressed out at all.
- Retric 2y agoThere’s an interesting level to this as there is a link between stress and ulcers. Stress reduces the mucous barrier and how quickly you heal, so reducing stress actually was helping people with ulcers. Antibiotics however where more effective in most but not all cases.
- tombert 2y agoYeah I made an edit to kind of clarify on that. I really wasn't stressed at that time; outside of the typical annoyances of being alive, my life was going pretty ok at that point, which I tried telling the doctor and he didn't believe me. After that I went to a different doc and she gave me antibiotics and I healed after a few weeks. I am extremely thankful that I have not had an ulcer again since then, because it was the worst thing ever.
- dralley 2y agoThe handful of times I've had ulcers in the past it was certainly correlated with stress. Perhaps indirectly through some other effects, but stress feels like part of the equation IME, at least for some people.
- yread 2y agoAnother important pathologist who died recently is Dr. Fletcher (he was a president of USCAP at some point) https://oncodaily.com/stories/115317.html https://oncodaily.com/stories/115317.html