7 ms·
Why is it so expensive to make games in the United States?
- dgfitz 2y ago15% of the screen is not an ad or a popup, on mobile. 15%. What the fuck.
- wil421 2y agoShow Reader worked on this link but it’s not always available. Lately, it seems like websites are starting to block reader view.
- sickofparadox 2y agoBrave has a mobile browser on Android that blocks most ads.
- beloch 2y agoGive this a try: (Kill sticky) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32998091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32998091 It's a javascript snippet that you stick in a bookmark and click on when you encounter a site like this. Results vary, but it did a great job of making this site readable.
- OnionBlender 2y agoWhy don't you use an ad blocker? I don't see ads on Android with Firefox and Block Origin.
- corysama 2y agoI set FireFox Focus (the browser) as the ad blocker for mobile Safari (without running FireFox). Works great. Maybe not as hardcore as uBlock Origin.
- apples_oranges 2y agoI thought Canada is where games are made now
- bko 2y agoGame development is an interesting industry where both happen to be true: 1. It's too expensive to make a game 2. Employees in the industry don't get paid enough Similar industries include childcare, where you hear politicians decry the cost of childcare in the same breath and how little the workers in their field are getting paid. Maybe the costs are somewhere else, not employees? Nope. From the article: > That cash flow is essential because a studio's operational costs remain fixed (or even increase) while revenue fluctuates up and down. Like most software companies, game development operating costs are derived almost entirely from salaries. And in the United States, there are dozens of factors that drive salaries upward. So I guess the article is arguing salaries are too high, which is not something you hear too often in the game industry context.
- jandrese 2y agoIt might not be salaries directly but things like healthcare costs and retirement savings. So a developer can still be "poorly paid" but costing the company a fortune in benefits.
- bko 2y agoAre there any unique characteristics to game development workforce related to healthcare costs or retirement savings? If not, it's not particularly meaningful to bemoan games as expensive compared to any other labor intensive industry.
- jandrese 2y agoProbably not, healthcare costs are eating America alive. As a country America is willing to try anything except the one thing that has worked everywhere else.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoI'm all for universal healthcare and think the system we have in place is idiotic, but other developed countries are struggling with healthcare as well (they'll say their system is the worst, just not as bad as America's). But universal healthcare is one way we can really fix our labor market: by making it a public benefit with mean-based contributions, labor markets would relax a lot: more jobs become viable even if they otherwise don't economically meet the bar to provide healthcare, because they don't need to. No one stresses about losing their healthcare when they lose a job, or want to switch, or have to switch. Similar support for retirement savings would help also.
- ghaff 2y agoThe article sort of answers this. There are so many other opportunities in the US that pay better (and have a saner lifestyle) for many of the same skill sets.
- pizzathyme 2y agoExactly. Other parts of the US economy (tech giants) have grown much faster than the games industry. A UX designer at Apple makes multiples of a UX designer at Blizzard.
- corysama 2y agoThere was some grumbling a few years ago that game engine devs were hard to retain because they keep getting pulled away by FAANG cash to optimize servers. I did game engines for a long time. Now I optimize robots.
- surfingdino 2y agoThat's how capitalism is supposed to work, no?
- zx8080 2y agoActually, yes. PS. Why is the above comment being downvoted?
- ghaff 2y agoI suppose it could come across as a cynical capitalism-bad take. However, read literally, it's just that people take jobs with appropriate rewards (financial and otherwise) for their situation which seems perfectly reasonable.
- corysama 2y agoYep.
- beloch 2y ago
- pizzathyme 2y agoI used to work for big game studios in the bay area, and changed careers to big tech because of this. Games don't bring in enough revenue to sustain employees in high-cost-of-living areas ($7B revenue for EA versus $305B for Google in 2023). From the business perspective it doesn't make sense for a game company to pay SF Bay Area tech salaries when it's making so much less revenue, so the result is more and more game development shifts overseas. Then from the employee perspective, it's already a brutal nights-and-weekends industry. "Crunch time" is normal. If you add to that poor relative pay for where you live, it's just not worth it anymore to chase a dream you once had as a kid. I personally am much more satisfied with my life as a result of the shift. But it is a sad trend for the US.
- bitmasher9 2y agoAs a consumer, how can I ethically purchase games in such a way that the developers can have a good life?
- pizzathyme 2y agoThis is a very kind question. The long answer is I'm not sure. Crunch time is driven by the fact that making games is one of the coolest businesses you could be in, which means everyone wants to do it. Supply is overwhelming against limited demand and it's winner-take-most. There are hundreds of games released every day. In that environment, who rises to the top? It's the studios who are willing to make it their life's purpose to make the best game possible, which means 70+ hour weeks. What they produce is awe inspiring but it's a sweatshop. I literally interviewed once at a game studio that told me, "You will not do well here if you have a family." Kudos to them for being upfront about it. A friend who took their offer told me they expected him to work Thanksgiving and Christmas day.
- bitmasher9 2y agoIs this also true of European and Japanese game studios?
- ajuc 2y ago> In late 2023 the average monthly gross salary of Polish workers is almost 8,000 pln (about $2,000) or about $24,000 per year. In the United States the monthly average salary was about $4,941 per month, coming in at about $59,300 per year at the same time period. In other words, investors and employers can pay for more Polish workers than American ones with the same amount of cash. While this is true - in Poland the difference between IT and non-IT salaries are higher than in US, so it's not a good comparison for cost of hiring programmers in particular. The differences won't be as big. Funnily enough the higher taxes in Poland are the main reason cost of development is effectively LOWER here - because you don't have to save for crazy expansive medical insurances or university funds for your kids - cause it's provided for free by the state - and the private alternatives have to compete with that - so they are cheap as well.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoYeah, don't want to get too political here, but I was read through that section and could only envison an ouroboros. - The country nixes Universal Health care but companies then complain about needing to fund healthcare benefits. - They kill Pension decades ago and slowly shift to a attrition oriented recruiting and they wonder why workers leave after 6-18 months. - College becomes 3-4 times more expensive than 40 years ago, and then companies complain that entry level wants more money coming out to pay the unbankruptable debt (thanks Sallie Mae!) they had to take at 18 just to get noticed by recruiters at 22-23. - Then instead you ask for "3-4 years of experience with a shipped game" for "entry level", but college doesn't count for experience. All while being unwilling to train juniors and just hope they hit the ground running. Yes, the system is broken and companies have been hammering at the window for decades to help. No wonder it eventually broke.
- AndrewGaspar 2y agoInsane how many words the author uses to capture "costs are higher for US game studios because salaries are higher". There's no actual secret second thing and it's hilarious watching the author try to find a way to spin "people make more money" into a problem with capitalism.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoThat begs the question though. That's what the "many words" are used to explain. But yes, inflation + rising housing costs + a lack of retention + a lack of governmetn interest in the arts are all indeed "a problem with capitalism". You should read those words a bit more closely.
- fatbird 2y agoEvery time this topic comes up I point to the fact that the television industry makes gigantic volumes of content, reasonably on-schedule and on-budget. Movies have somewhat different math, but there's a huge economic segment routinely producing creative content with a high proportion of salary expenses, much of which is unionized. It seems crazy to discuss gamer salaries without discussing how normally dysfunctional game studios are, with crunch time all year round, intense burnout of young employees, terrible working conditions, and rarely hitting schedule or budget constraints. In other words, there's a huge opportunity cost in reforming the process by which studios make games, and all they need to do is look at TV to see how to do it. Hell, just hiring some television producers would probably bring a level of sanity as-yet-unseen. Part of what drives high salaries in gaming is the terrible working conditions. You could pay less just by saying "we work 9 to 5 and value quality of life."
- aschearer 2y agoI would love to hear more concrete recommendations or reading. It's an interesting hypothesis! That said I am a bit skeptical given the game industry has failed to sort this out for several decades... perhaps it's simply ignorance but occam's razor has me thinking there's another factor. Still, it would be interesting to hear more.
- surfingdino 2y ago> Every time this topic comes up I point to the fact that the television industry makes gigantic volumes of content, reasonably on-schedule and on-budget. Movies have somewhat different math, but there's a huge economic segment routinely producing creative content with a high proportion of salary expenses, much of which is unionized. TV and movies are produced by people who understand storytelling. This is something that has been discussed in the game dev industry ever since the arrival of CD-ROMs. Suddenly, free of the constraints of floppy disks, devs thought they could create huge fantastic worlds to roam in. They sure did, but they have lost the plot. CD-ROM and then DVDs removed one of important constraints that forced creativity; cheap 24bit 3d cards removed another. And yet, one of the most fun games in recent history is Minecraft, a game that does not need gigabytes of textures or fancy 3d hardware.
- 2y ago
- laser 2y agoHow could a journalist write so much and research so little as to completely miss any mention of the ongoing section 174 disaster? They even mention “tax” eleven times and specifically mention small studio cash flow issues and costly salaries, but payroll taxes and tax credits are all nothing-burgers, not worth the words on the page, compared to the insolvency insanity of being only able to expense and deduct 10% of a developer’s salary in the first year and depreciate the rest over five years.
- speckx 2y agoAlso relevant to this is the Game Industry Layoffs tracker @ https://publish.obsidian.md/vg-layoffs/Archive/2024 https://publish.obsidian.md/vg-layoffs/Archive/2024
- xyst 2y agoAnybody that has worked in a large American game studio also knows it’s a high pressure environment. Burn out is very common because these studios demand so much. Yet because of poor management (or overly paid management), Americans produce subpar products and studios like Rockstar Games continue to milk their cash cows (ie, GTA V - a 10+ yr old game that shits money due to GTA Online and micro-transactions). No innovation in this market. EA continues to milk the sports series with minimal to no improvements in underlying engine (ie, Sims, FIFA and whatever the American Football one is called now). Epic Games just milks Fortnite (again with microtransactions). Mobile game studios are more like nanotransaction based “games” using tactics from casinos to get older and younger populations to spend money. Activision/Blizzard hasn’t pumped out anything new in a long time and continues to milk their cash cows (Call of Duty, Overwatch “2”). Riot Games building off predecessors with F2P w/ microtransactions. RG produced games are _okay_, but really only LoL and Valorant are the ones I play. Indie game studios sort of gaining traction but often overshadowed by larger game studios. Also let’s not forget the monopoly that Microsoft has over gaming. Want a AAA game? Got to use their proprietary shit (DirectX) to build it and ship it. Probably need to obtain Windows licenses as well for dev purposes. Some advancements in agnostic APIs such as Vulcan and alternative game engines (bevy). But so far haven’t seen them used in AAA games.
- StressedDev 2y agoGTA is made in the UK. It’s not an American game.
- StressedDev 2y agoAlso, Blizzard recently released Diablo 4. Finally, you do not need a license to use DirectX. It’s a public API.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoVulkan has been used in quite a few AAA titles now (including the mass success that is Baldur's Gate 3). https://vulkan.org/made-with-vulkan https://vulkan.org/made-with-vulkan And while UE/Unity power a lot of games, many studios do opt for some propreitaty engine. All the big studios are still maintaining their own tech for sure. But I agree, I am waiting for that "third pillar" to emerge, ideally an open source one to prevent the possibiliy of a Unity mishap. We'll see how that dust settles.
- aschearer 2y agoI'm in the trenches. Making games is amazing, but the business is brutal. Very hard to find a "geyser of money" and monopolize it for years let alone decades. Contrast with Google search or Microsoft Office, etc. The tech advances quickly, dating past work. One fad gives way to the next. There's a fixed amount of attention for an ever growing amount of content. etc. etc. Meanwhile, the technical work is very sophisticated and game engineers can work elsewhere, so they justifiably want to be paid well or they will leave to adjacent industries. Plus life is expensive in America. Six figure salary ain't what it used to be. People overseas, including western Europe, will do comparable work for peanuts. Article basically gets it correct. Not sure the problem can be solved. Joe in Seattle wants $150,000. Jozef in Poland wants $50,000. Case closed. Still, I'm grateful to get to make games with cool people every day. Carpe diem!
- coding123 2y agoCompany I am at is also employing Jozef in Poland and has resulted in a company with 5 or 6 US engineers and 45 engineers in Poland.
- Clubber 2y agoHow many state side engineers are the 45 Polish engineers replacing? Also, are they willing to put up with game studio industry bs?
- Jensson 2y ago> How many state side engineers are the 45 Polish engineers replacing Probably 45? It isn't like USA is dominating the video game space, unlike most other IT sectors, you find talented video game engineers in many places.
- lowbloodsugar 2y agoIt is more expensive to do anything in the USA. This did not matter in the past, because US consumers also had vastly more disposble income. Now, however, nobody has any disposable income. Adjusted for inflation, SNES games cost over $100. Now games are 100x larger in terms of content, and while the market has increased, the price is halved at best. $100 got you a game made by 1 or two people. Now $50 gets you a game with a thirty minutes credits roll. Microsoft and Sony offer games for a monthly price, and budget consumers buy games used - such that GameStop captures the additional value. In 2000 I was paid just over $100k as a game developer. Adjusted for inflation that's $182k. I'd be almost tempted to go back if someone could pay that much, reliably. They don't pay that much and they certainly aren't reliable. Underlying it all is that the USA is no longer the only industrialized nation in the world, as it once was after everywhere else was bombed flat. So just as countless TV shows are made in Canada and elsewhere, so too games can be made elsewhere.
- Bluescreenbuddy 2y agoHoly cow. Were you an engineer?
- johnnyanmac 2y agoIt's not impossible today to make that much in games. 2022 I was making 160k at a startup and probably had way less YOE than you back in the day. Main thing is that you give up any stock compensation, so you'll still take a hit in total comp compared to traditional tech.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- surfingdino 2y agoIt's amazing to see how much money is spent on not much playability. The teams are too big and there are too many managers. Cost cutting by moving jobs abroad doesn't solve the core problem of games not being very enjoyable. I'd rather trade fancy graphics for something that is fun to play.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoGameplay is king, but Art sells. It may not work on you, but so many people just see a pretty game, and go to buy it. They don't mind $70 because they only buy a few games per year. Especially with so many F2P options out now. Ofc this model doesn't work with GaaS, which isnt the new golden goose. They try for 6 months, realize they didn't get fortnite money (even though Fortnite had to do a lot just to get off the ground) and shut down in a year to try the same insanity again. This is what happens when you have Business driving games instead of creatives, and I'm not quite sure when they'll learn the lesson (or go back to non-GAAS where this strategy works).
- Sleaker 2y agoWhen the chief marginal cost of your product is employee wages why would anyone be surprised that the country where wages are most expensive makes it the hardest to produce a profitable product as the marketplace opens more and more globally and gets saturated?
- pandaman 2y agoIt's incentives. A studio nowadays is either outright owned by the publisher or is signed up for development with little or zero equity. In this situation the only source of income for a studio is the milestone payments or salary paid by the publisher so the longer development goes on, the more it gets paid and the more is the cost. If American studios could find publishing contracts leaving them more than 50% of equity like they used to in 1990s-early 2000s they would be making games much cheaper. Even though you might get cheaper developers elsewhere, few have skills and spend most of the time on learning how to make games through trial and error, running costs up. I remember how expensive Killzone appeared to the American game developers: the Dutch studio, apparently had hundreds of staff and tens of millions cost in early 2000s, when a better selling American game had been usually developed by a couple of dozens staff for under 10mil.
- lowbloodsugar 2y agoIn the early 2000s? Couple dozen staff? Making games that rival Killzone for revenue? Shadow Fall was the first PS4 game to hit the million sales mark, for example. Killzone 2 hit a million after a few months.
- pandaman 2y agoShadow Fall was a PS4 game. Killzone was on PS2, and has not made any significant sales (and a million in sales on PS1/PS2 was par for the course, Crash sold multiple millions and had <50 dev team, for example).
- lowbloodsugar 2y agoRight, so crash sold multiple millions and cost under $10m you’re saying? Was the question about Killzone being expensive or was it that they had a large team so it was assumed to be expensive (because US devs got paid more)?
- pandaman 2y agoYes, Killzone, a PS2 game. Not PS3 game Killzone 2 or PS4 game Killzone: Shadow Fall. We don't have benchmarks for the studio model from PS3 on as by the time PS3 came out the studio model was dead and AAA development was done by publisher-owned studios with few independents signed up on shitty contracts. >Was the question about Killzone being expensive or was it that they had a large team so it was assumed to be expensive (because US devs got paid more)? The rumored budget for Killzone (not 2, not Shadow Fall, the plain old PS2 game) was ~40M dollars. Guerrilla had over 200 people at the time it shipped and the development time was well over a AAA game normally took in that generation. Just looking in credits you can see 18 engineers, something that nobody has seen until PS3 generation. It might have been that they have already staffed up for the KZ2 and PS3 development but nevertheless American developers were shocked by the waste of the resources on the game that barely sold.