5 ms·
An ordinary day with a Linux mobile device
- arnaudsm 2y agoI'm grateful for the non-Android mobile OSS ecosystem. Android is increasingly user hostile, notably the apps and features that block you when you obtain root access on your own device you paid for. I'm about to quit Android, and I'm looking forward using and contributing to true open platforms.
- kccqzy 2y agoAndroid is increasingly power user hostile. General users don't want root and don't want malware to obtain root access. This is an HN bubble where people talk about rooting their devices. Years ago I would have argued for better education of users so that they can all become power users. These days I see that as a lost cause.
- fsflover 2y ago> General users don't want root and don't want malware to obtain root access "Ordinary people do not need freedom of speech, since they have nothing to say, or right to repair, since they can't do it anyway".
- arnaudsm 2y agoI disagree, everyone is concerned. The vast majority of apps on the android ecosystem are adware with dark patterns all over the place. My mother complains about it every day. Google is currently blocking many quality open source apps like VLC and Termux from updating on the play store, because they require the signing certificates, in their quest of controlling everything. VLC is not for power users, it's the most common player in the world. Recently I wanted to reencode a video to upload to Whatsapp. I tried 10+ apps, all freemium and terrible, 4 tried to trick me into a 1 year subscription. ffmpeg did it in 5 seconds.
- nolist_policy 2y agoSamsung Gallery can edit and reencode videos.
- andrepd 2y agoOf course not, just Google-approved malware, right?
- vundercind 2y agoIs this… parody? It reads like it but is done so straight that I can’t tell for sure.
- isodev 2y agoWhat makes you say that? The tech they reference is quite real. The setup is somewhat unique but I see it as one of the superpowers of a Linux mobile device - one can do whatever one wants without a big corp dictating the rules or locking down the experience.
- vundercind 2y agoBecause if this were a Reddit post I’d be 100% sure it’s parody. It describes some Rube Goldberg stuff to achieve extremely basic stuff that folks using a smartphone get with no extra effort. Text interface with an onscreen keyboard to manually trigger updates to your podcast? Those screenshots scream parody. The notes near the end of “Bluetooth works… except not really because Bluetooth. But the headphone jack is haunted so I use Bluetooth anyway. Conclusion: works pretty good doesn’t even crash!” I mean… that’s parody, right?
- pockybum522 2y agoSome people have different priorities than you. As for myself, and growing increasingly frustrated with Android letting me have less and less functionality in my mobile operating system and device that I paid to purchase, I didn't read this as parody at all.
- tylerritchie 2y agois the problem Android, for you, or is the problem "Google Android", "Samsung Android", "Motorola Android, by Verizon"?
- kelnos 2y agoGiven that third-party Android OSes are missing features that many people consider essential (like anything that requires passing SafetyNet), I don't believe these OSes are a general solution, applicable to the masses, even if installation were dead-simple and reliable. I ran CyanogenMod for years, and every app I ran and every feature I used on the stock Android OS worked properly on CM. I loved it. But these days that's just not the case on Lineage or Graphene or Calyx or any of the others. So I think for many people, it doesn't matter. "Google Android", "Samsung Android", etc. are the only realistic options, so they are just "Android" to them.
- Almondsetat 2y agoSeeing the abysmal state of non-Android Linux on mobile really puts into perspective the sheer amount of skills and professionalism that it takes to create smartphone. It's 2024 and these phones do not have even 1/10th of the reliability, smoothness and features of the original 2007 iPhone. Heck, even a 2005 BlackBerry. Heck, even a 2003 Nokia.
- fsflover 2y ago> these phones do not have even 1/10th of the reliability, smoothness and features of the original 2007 iPhone As someone daily driving Librem 5, I completely disagree. Yes, it's somewhat less smooth and reliable, but the amount of available features is much more than in 2007 iPhone. Some features aren't available anywhere else, like desktop mode with desktop apps.
- mattl 2y agoHow many more of those do they need to make before all the preorders are released now? I see they’re pushing the assembled in USA one for a few thousand dollars now, presumably they have the parts in stock and can put one together fairly easily.
- fsflover 2y agoWhat are you talking about? All preorders have been shipped. The shipping time is 10 days now: https://puri.sm/posts/all-librem-5-smartphones-have-shipped https://puri.sm/posts/all-librem-5-smartphones-have-shipped.
- mattl 2y agoI check the Purism Reddit from time to time and see people still waiting on devices and with horrible delivery times. I know a lot of free software purists. I don’t know anyone who actually has a Librem 5.
- 2y ago
- mattl 2y agoThe things I do daily on a smartphone are: - Web browsing - iMessage - WhatsApp - Social media - Photography - Music - Email - Maps - Medical stuff When I see articles like this, it’s a stark reminder of just how wide the gap between iOS and any of these community Linux phones is. I’m also sure it’s a similar gap between a modern Android phone and the same community projects.
- SoftTalker 2y agoI'm on iOS but I only use my phone for a few things: iMessage/SMS, maps/navigation, and the occasional phone call. I have very few apps installed that did not come with the phone. Web is awful on mobile. Email not much better. The rest of it I don't use.
- mattl 2y agoMost of my personal web usage is mobile at this point. As is a large part of my job. Email on mobile isn’t amazing but if you’re okay top-posting it can be bearable.
- pona-a 2y agoIt's not as wide as you'd been made to believe. Ubuntu Touch does around 50% of what you're listing. Web browsing works fine, though the older Chromium is showing its age and may not be running with full hardware acceleration. iMessage is a non-starter, unless someone wants to implement a client for AirMessage, which would itself be fairly simple. WhatsApp works through a web-app with some rudimentary push (if I remember correctly), but a native app is not outside possibility. Social media could be done through the browser, several Reddit clients and one for HN exist, and I personally have written a YouTube client (needs to be adjusted for API changes). Photography is possible, though maybe not on Google Camera level. Email clients exist. A navigator app with OpenStreetMap data too exists. As for medical stuff, unless it runs in the browser, it likely won't even run in Waydroid (Android compatibility) because SafetyNet. The UI itself is very snappy even on older devices and the battery lasts enough of the day, through not as much as on Android. While it may feel a bit locked down with its immutable FS (you can unlock it, but OEM updates will reset root) compared to other mobile Linux distros, you can still do a lot, from running desktop apps through DosBox and Wine, to editing the shell's QML for custom UI, to automating system actions with the shell. If you have a Pixel laying, I highly recommend you at least try it. Things aren't perfect, there's a bit of legacy code that needs people, but it's a good daily driver.
- kelnos 2y agoMan I would love love love love to be able to have mobile device running a stock or near-stock Linux distro. But I also want to be able to use things like contactless payment and banking apps. I actually wish in some ways that Jobs had kept with his original plan not to release an iPhone SDK (that was the original plan, right? I'm not misremembering?), and push the web platform hard for apps. Then mobile apps would have been naturally cross-platform, or at least cross-platform-possible, only requiring new JS APIs to be implemented in whatever available open-source browser. It's a little ironic, because these days I advocate against closed, walled-garden platforms. But this unrealized future (well, present, I guess) would have required an iPhone that was even more locked down than it is, not allowing any non-Apple native apps on it.
- xethos 2y agoWould it have had to be more locked-down? I think letting the web be a first-class citizen would have been enough; economic incentives would have taken care of the rest, because few companies want dramatically more paid devs on staff (for iOS, Android, BBOS10, Windows Mobile, etc) for a marginally better experience "Just throw out a PWA" would have been enough for most execs to get behind, IMO, especially in the early days when who knows which platforms will stick around and have been worth developing for in the first place.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- synicalx 2y ago"Sorry I left you on read babe, Wayland broke again". Joking aside this is kinda cool, I'd love to have something like b/dmenu for Android.