5 ms·
> at any level This is nonsense advice. Would you take the advice of someone who recommended never driving because any level of driving risks death? That's obv
by IshKebab 2y ago
> at any level
This is nonsense advice. Would you take the advice of someone who recommended never driving because any level of driving risks death? That's obviously stupid. Or it should be anyway though I suspect some pendants will try to argue it. If you're one of those people what about never going outside? The sun's deadly rays might give you cancer and there's no safe level of sunlight!!
Risks are about trade-offs. If the American Cancer Society wants to be helpful and actually listened to they need to provide practical actionable advice, not this cop-out.
- jakupovic 2y agoTell it how it is. No cigarettes either. But it's OK to go camping and live in a cloud of smoke for days. I wonder how many cigarettes a day equals being in a big campground with fires everywhere for 2 days is?
- iancmceachern 2y agoAn AQI of 250 plus is equivalent to 7 cigarettes a day: https://woods.stanford.edu/news/health-impacts-wildfire-smoke#:~:text=Communities%20exposed%20to%20wildfire%20smoke,were%20outside%20the%20whole%20time https://woods.stanford.edu/news/health-impacts-wildfire-smok....
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoIt depends how much time you spend outside? I’m just thinking back to my days in Beijing when 250 PPI was not a bad day.
- iancmceachern 2y agoThe parent commenter was referring to camping, therefore all day.
- mgarfias 2y agoWhat about an AQI of ~1500? Yeah, we lived through that here 4 years ago during the fires here in Oregon, while waiting to find out if we’d told to evac.
- hollerith 2y agoOnce the AQI exceeds 300 or so, I would run an air purifier at home (keeping the windows closed) and wear an N95 mask whenever I venture outdoors. Air filtration works very well for smoke (and other particulates).
- pfdietz 2y ago"Daddy, what is 'whataboutism'?"
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- IshKebab 2y agoPresumably the risk with cigarettes is addiction, whereas that is less of an issue with alcohol because alcohol is significantly less addictive than nicotine.
- deafpolygon 2y agoAlcohol is more addictive than nicotine. The "advantage" of nicotine is that it creates a physical dependence more readily at smaller doses, but alcohol is psychologically pervasive. To the point where entire cultures have gone to war over it throughout history.
- IshKebab 2y agoUgh I knew there would be someone who tried to push this ludicrous claim. Obviously we are talking about physical addiction, not some cultural nonsense.
- dns_snek 2y agoThe belief that moderate consumption alcohol isn't just harmless, but in fact beneficial to your health, is extremely widespread in my personal experience. It's past time to change that if the science disagrees. And you're right, risks are all about trade-offs and how you implement that advice into your own life is entirely up to you. Crucially, they're not making recommendations to make anyone feel better about their harmful decisions, they're making them to help people make informed decisions.
- hollerith 2y agoDriving cars and riding in cars tend to have large benefits whereas alcohol does not.
- scientator 2y agoAlcohol can have large benefits for helping people to bond and socialize. The article itself pointed this out. Of course people can socialize without alcohol. But I think it's plausible to argue that alcohol in moderation can improve and deepen the experience.
- hollerith 2y agoOK good point, but MDMA is much better for that according to many comment here on HN over the years. Also if I go drinking with someone I don't know well, the risk of their becoming violent is quite high.
- scientator 2y agoMany drugs promote socialization. To the point that you have to question the distinction between drugs and food/drink. Take sugar. It's often the focus of social gatherings. But the bad effects of sugar arguably outweigh those of alcohol, given the epidemics of diabetes and obesity. Alcohol happens to have 10,000 years of cultural tradition behind it. Plus, it pairs well with food.
- coldtea 2y ago>Also if I go drinking with someone I don't know well, the risk of their becoming violent is quite high In what kind of society or social circles is this true? Here it's common to socialize and meet strangers over a drink or two, and the risks of their becoming violent is near zero.
- IshKebab 2y ago> MDMA is much better for that according to many comment here on HN over the years. Maybe but it's also much harder to obtain due to being illegal. > the risk of their becoming violent is quite high. Jesus who are you going drinking with??? That's not normal.
- anal_reactor 2y ago> Risks are about trade-offs. If the American Cancer Society wants to be helpful and actually listened to they need to provide practical actionable advice, not this cop-out. I feel like the medical community is slowly starting to finally realize that they can't force patients to minmax their lives. Why would I live a long life that isn't enjoyable?
- pfdietz 2y agoI'm sorry if you feel the ACS is trying to force you to do something just by making a recommendation. Feeling a bit fragile, are you?
- anal_reactor 2y agoOf course I am fragile, I'm just a single individual thrown into the society of 8 billion people, what are you expecting
- pfdietz 2y agoI'm expecting you to not confuse someone informing you with someone forcing you. I mean, they are very different, unless you have the will of a wet noodle.
- anal_reactor 2y agoWet noodle slides effortlessly into you. What do you do?
- ryandrake 2y agoI think we learned in 2020-2021 that if the medical community doesn't put out an extremely strong statement about something, the general public won't take it seriously at all. When the ACS recommends avoiding alcohol consumption at any level, they don't think people are actually going to suddenly quit drinking. They're just trying to convince that guy who drinks two six-packs a night to cut down to one six-pack a night.
- stephenbez 2y agoI wish they would be more clear about how bad drinking is otherwise everyone tends to see it the same. A friend of mine wouldn’t eat non-organic blueberries because he heard they suck up tons of pesticides so ate more eggs and sausage instead for breakfast. Is the magnitude of health benefit of going from 2 drinks a day to 1 drink a day equivalent to or 1/20th the benefit of an average American walking an additional 20 minutes per day? I don’t have the source with me now but I read that in my example above, it would save about 650 lives a year compared to 175k+ due to overall alcohol use.