4 ms·
Cars Are Now Computers, So How Long Will They Get Updates? Automakers Can't Say
- speckx 2y agoPhones are supported well beyond their average ownership lifetime. In stark contrast, automakers are struggling to work out how long their “smartphones on wheels” can be kept on the road.
- jagged-chisel 2y agoMore likely they're struggling to understand the minimum the public will tolerate and put that into acceptable marketing copy. With the history of the automobile industry, they have a fabulous amount of data on how long vehicle bits last in different configurations. The only minor variable is the computerized bit. I say "minor" because they can use older COTS electronics to do all the things a car needs, and then stick an iPad[1] on the console. 1 - another tablet, touchscreen, whatever. Notwithstanding the arguments against touch interfaces in cars.
- bell-cot 2y agoWhile their own stupid fingerprints are all over the footgun's trigger...I for-sure don't envy the auto makers here. An "old" phone is what, 4 or 5 years old? At least on the iPhone side, Apple is [in]famously vertically integrated, to have the all the resources needed to update iOS. And Apple kinda-famously issued a security patch for iOS 12 (released Sept'18) in Jan'23, because pre-2015-ish iPhones could not run any newer version of iOS. Vs. the computing hardware and software in a modern car comes from how many different supplies, spread across how many tiers, with how little visibility from the PoV of the computers-ain't-their-forte auto makers? And an "old" car can easily be 10 to 25 years old.
- jerlam 2y agoFor a very long time, Apple refused to commit to any kind of update policy, but people could simply see their update history. I see they did commit recently (five years since release) and that was due to a legal requirement.
- andrewstuart 2y agoThere’s good argument for hardware and software to be 100% open.
- realce 2y agoIt's such a lucrative revenue stream that I doubt companies will be convinced of any utility in open-sourcing. Similar to AI regulation, the car companies can just claim that any public access to the code will make cars more dangerous.
- Zambyte 2y agoThe comparison to AI gives me hope for the automobile space given this weeks releases :>
- Zigurd 2y agoVW's new Rivian-based UX platform is based on AOSP Android, without Google Automotive Services (GAS). Bad news: You don't get the Play Store. Good news: Rivian could choose to open source the parts of the system that replace the GAS bits.
- Damogran6 2y agoMy 2014 Acadia had Wifi, a 4GLTE modem, a phone app, and two streaming audio apps on the radio. It was never updated. Possibly because I wasn't going to give them $70 a month for On-star, internet, and GM super naggy status stuff. (Hey! Come pay more for an oil change with us, your car told us you neeeed it!)
- criddell 2y agoIt's one reason I want a car with CarPlay or Android Auto. My phone is updated all the time and the software is usually higher quality than whatever the automakers put out. It's interesting that you mention GM because they are ditching CarPlay / Android Auto support in some of their vehicles. They think doing so will generate billions in revenue for them.
- wlesieutre 2y agoVW says their android-based infotainment will be updated for at least a "lifetime" of 15 years: https://arstechnica.com/cars/2023/03/android-infotainment-will-be-supported-for-at-least-15-years-vw-says/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2023/03/android-infotainment-wi... I expect at some point that stops being feature updates because new features rely on different hardware, but at minimum it means 15 years of security updates... in which case 15 years isn't enough. My last two cars were both on the road longer than 15 years. Thankfully they weren't connected to the internet. And the other thing they don't commit to is that they'll have 15 years of updates where the maps app runs at more than 2 frames per second. So this had better not be anything like phone updates, where a 5 year old phone is sometimes allowed to run the modern OS update, but it doesn't run well. Will they maintain multiple branches based on different hardware requirements so they can keep shipping performant OS updates on old hardware? It's a big reason I won't buy a car without CarPlay, I need the escape hatch of being able to run the new maps app from my phone manufacturer, on eventually 10+ years newer phone hardware. Even if the car's infotainment is amazing today, there's no guarantee it will be any good in 10 years and I'd rather have a backup plan.
- Scoundreller 2y agoYeah, I’m in the rust belt and cars are easily going over 15 years of age.
- bzzzt 2y ago> It's a big reason I won't buy a car without CarPlay Isn't it a bit naive to suppose CarPlay will still be a thing in 10+ years? Maybe the iPhoneVR 28 glasses will have a completely different UX and the idea of letting it take over a small part of your car dashboard will be a historic curiosity.
- wlesieutre 2y agoMaybe, but when we're talking average price of around $50,000 for new car purchases, I'd just as soon hedge my bets that if CarPlay still exists in 15 years I'd rather have it than not have it. Rivian's position is "you would have to close CarPlay to use the vehicle menus to open your frunk" which is a) not true, and b) says more about their being too cheap to have a frunk release button than it does about CarPlay.
- globular-toast 2y agoSigh... they aren't "computers". It really sucks that we've lost that word. What do people say now if they specifically mean a general-purpose computing machine? Cars also depend almost entirely on the road infrastructure. The automakers don't support that. People need to realise if they want interoperability they need to choose open standards that their community can maintain. This isn't just a problem with cars.
- Zambyte 2y ago... In what sense are they not "computers"? > What do people say now if they specifically mean a general-purpose computing machine? "General-purpose computer" seems fine to me.
- jwsteigerwalt 2y agoCan you play Doom on it?
- Zambyte 2y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5mmiPT2avrY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5mmiPT2avrY Newer cars are probably less likely due to how arbitrarily locked down they are, rather than being incapable. The manufacturer could run DOOM on their car that you bought, but you probably can't.
- pixl97 2y agoQuite often yes, if you can get past any bios security locks.
- mavhc 2y agoYes, because it runs in a browser https://uacorp.space/ https://uacorp.space/
- tempfile 2y agoI don't think I understand your objection. Would you prefer it if they said "cars have computers"?
- argiopetech 2y agoLots of things "are computers" (thermostats, refrigerators, cameras, etc.), but most of those things don't get updates. They're shipped in working order, and they go in working as intended through their service life. Why are cars different? Personally, I would rather not have the UX of my car be subject to arbitrary change.
- quonn 2y ago> Why are cars different? Price.
- jameson 2y ago> Why are cars different? Safety
- grumpyprole 2y agoThere no problem with this, as long as these cars and other appliances aren't plugged into the internet.
- Zigurd 2y agoCars used to be the same as everything you cite as examples of ordinary embedded systems. Adding Android Automative-based UX, for example, puts a general purpose OS and app suite in your car. It will probably work better than the Android refrigerators. Probably.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 2y agoBecause they need updates to fix security holes in the network stack that is required for doing the updates, don't you know? And of course also to facilitate all that juicy surveillance backhaul and anti-ownership decommodification. What we've needed the whole time is mandated open standards and open documentation for both the local buses and any WAN communications. There's really no reason that center console units from cars aren't widely interchangeable with each other, rather than being specific even down to the model year. But instead, companies use software complexity as a hook to perform wealth extraction, and then respond to any public pushback by marketing the extractionary dynamic as "innovation" and trumpeting the revenue numbers as if they represent legitimate economic activity.
- Workaccount2 2y agoThe thing is that if you mandate updates for x years, automakers will just push "empty" updates to fill the quota. Because of this, it should be mandated that 3rd parties be allowed full hardware access/documentation once the warranty period expires. Automaker wants you to use their software forever? Good. They can out-compete the third parties. You are allowed to buy third party auto parts, no reason you shouldn't be allowed 3rd party software.
- tpxl 2y ago> You are allowed to buy third party auto parts They're working damn hard to prevent that with signing.
- bzzzt 2y agoThat's difficult with oil though. At least my airbags aren't stolen every few months like with some brands here since the manufacturer made it hard to swap them between cars.
- bzzzt 2y ago> Because of this, it should be mandated that 3rd parties be allowed full hardware access/documentation once the warranty period expires. Mandating that would also mean the 3rd party also would have to take responsibility that the updated software conforms to spec and doesn't kill someone. Who's going to pay for that?
- CogitoCogito 2y agoHaven't third parties been repairing cars for all automotive history?
- bzzzt 2y agoRepairing by swapping parts is a bit different than completely rebuilding the software stack.
- Phiwise_ 2y agoWhy would a high-end car need regular updates? The only thing it needs to do that isn't guatanteed to not change without physical service is entertainment, and it's a safe bet anyone who can afford one has a smartphone they keep updated. Just make the pocket supercomputer do all the work and use the car as an input/output interface. This problem was solved decades ago on the internet, funnily enough by the same guy who founded this forum. Why is the industry at large so bad at retaining good practice knowledge?
- josephcsible 2y ago> Why would a high-end car need regular updates? Because they have Internet connections now, which means they can have remotely exploitable security vulnerabilities.
- jerlam 2y agoEventually, the input/output interface between the car and smartphone will also require an update to work correctly. Android Auto and Apple CarPlay are only 9 or 10 years old, not quite "new", but approaching the time where companies want to make major, incompatible changes. I do not know if I would take a bet that a user can seamlessly connect CarPlay on their 2014 car with their brand new iPhone 25.
- exar0815 2y agoI always love when people with background in software talk about the car industry. Noone is interested in Software. Software is what is outsourced to India. Software is the super-annoying thing on there very annoying thing(electronics) that is sadly necessary to keep the mechanical marvels developed by the wrench-swinging monkey equivalents of real engineers relevant. Most in-car ecus are not updatable, that would be 10ct more expensive per part. If updates are possible, please pay through your nose at the certified repair shop for them to plug a SD card in you have to buy. Most Car Execs think of software as something that is developed in the same process as a bearing. And it shows.
- paxys 2y agoSoftware in cars is more than just the entertainment system UI. If you think systems like ABS, drive by wire, transmission control, auto braking, lane change assist, engine control and fuel injection are being outsourced to the lowest bidder in India, you haven't been in the industry for at least two decades.
- exar0815 2y agoInterestingly, I am in that Industry. That's why I have such a cynical view of it and why I drive an ancient shitbox. Interestingly, a lot of Automotive EEs I know do. I wonder why...
- hanniabu 2y agoHow is this not a safety issue?
- chaostheory 2y agoThe only scenario I can think of not being a safety issue is if the car has no endpoints that’s externally accessible. Unfortunately, a lot of these cars have wifi, cellular data, and even satellite network access.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- eschneider 2y agoI work on vehicle ECUs and we tend to generate updates for a really, really long time. There aren't really any technical issues preventing, say a dealer, from having the capability to update vehicle firmware easily. It's mostly a question of manufacturers making a commitment to do this.
- 39896880 2y agoYeah. Nothing stopping dealers from charging out the ass for a few gb of data transfer. A scam as old as time, I remember my mom almost paying $500 in the early 2000s for a new maps DVD for her lexus. I found the iso on usenet and did it myself.
- orev 2y agoI was recently charged for a few updates to the head unit to fix issues that had a TSB, and that was annoying and I think that kind of thing should be free. However maps data is licensed so the cost makes more sense for that.
- eschneider 2y agoSoftware for a TSB absolutely should be free. That, sir, is a bug fix.
- jmclnx 2y agoHow long ? Look at IOT for an example. But this is what I expect, unless you maintain your auto at the dealership paying exorbitant prices for simple things, no updates will ever be done. It is time for a federal law on this.