3 ms·
I'm having strange nostalgic flashbacks the '90s where I kept wondering why nobody offered a hard drive with a physical read-only toggle button. (Mounted to the
by Terr_ 2y ago
I'm having strange nostalgic flashbacks the '90s where I kept wondering why nobody offered a hard drive with a physical read-only toggle button. (Mounted to the front of the 5.25 inch bay in a tower chassis, as was the style of the time.)
Obviously you need some read+write storage elsewhere on the same computer, but you could reliably freeze large chunks of stuff in a way that would be impervious to viruses or hackers.
- drhagen 2y agoI remember USB drives in the '00s that had a read-only toggle. They were useful for rescuing machines that had a virus. Edit: A quick search reveals that, of course, you can still buy them today. I have not felt a need for one in ages.
- Terr_ 2y agoHmmm, I would absolutely buy one of those if it also had a hardened case and a firm connection point for my real-world keychain. The use-case is a "my house burned down what next" backup, password-manager stuff and other details I might need before/without accessing any cloud-backup services. I may need to read some of its files on a not-very trusted device, and I don't want to risk that device also tampering/trojan'ing other files, like backup copies of the software needed to decrypt the data files. A simpler scenario might be a USB stick that I use for carrying files to be printed at the local library.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Hizonner 2y agoI strongly suspect that most or all of the modern "hardware" write-protect switches are actually just suggestions to the drive firmware. Which may very well itself be modifiable.
- Gormo 2y agoI can't imagine how it would be possible to do it any other way for a flash storage device. A mechanical hard drive could at least theoretically have a physical lock attached to the drive head which prevents it from approaching the platters if it is engaged.
- Hizonner 2y agoErm. The read head and the write head in a magnetic drive are the same head. You can't keep the head away from the surface if you want to read the disk. But you can disable power to the driver that puts write current into the head. ... and you could absolutely build similar functionality into a flash chip. But most likely you can't actually buy such chips, at least not with any real capacity.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mypalmike 2y agoThere are multi-actuator hard drives out there. I don't know if any of them separate read heads from write heads, but it would certainly seem possible for such a drive to exist.
- schmidtleonard 2y agoWriting flash takes (relatively) high voltage and the voltage boosting circuitry could be routed through a switch. It generally isn't, and the voltage converter is often an on-chip charge pump so this wouldn't be an easy retrofit, but the current state of affairs is due entirely to lack of interest rather than lack of possibility.
- upwardbound 2y agoDo those charge pumps use external capacitors? If so, you could disconnect/float those capacitors, or if that would damage or glitch the chip, you could replace the real capacitors with some circuit like a voltage regulator + diode that would be designed to provide the charge pump output rail with a voltage that's high enough not to glitch the chip but low enough to be unsuccessful in writing to the flash. Would one of those ideas work, and allow the retrofit you envision to be designed with existing flash memory silicon + a few additional components?
- GuB-42 2y agoI have one of these as a boot disk (Medicat) for this exact reason. Also because some of the software included in Medicat is flagged by some anti-virus software and I don't want them removed.
- CableNinja 2y agoThere were things like this, but it was more to prevent accidental writes. Some of the old 10" drives had a write enable toggle.