10 ms·
Health care 'job lock' stifles entrepreneurship
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- payne92 18y agoI've never had trouble getting health insurance as an individual/family -- you just have to be willing/able to pay the premiums. It sometimes helps to incorporate as a small business, but that's easy to do and doesn't cost much. If you can afford COBRA, you can usually afford to pay directly for a plan. (BTW, I'm not suggesting that healthcare is screwed up in a number of dimensions, I just think the premise of the article is flawed).
- skmurphy 18y agoIf you picked the wrong parents it's not difficult to become effectively uninsurable unless you are part of a group plan.
- tednaleid 18y agoI'm guessing neither you, or any of your family members covered by your insurance have any significant pre-existing conditions. The premiums are much less "affordable" if this is an issue for you or your family.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoInsurance is there to protect you against high cost, low probability events; basically events where you can afford the expected cost, (probability of becoming sick) x (cost of treatment), but you can not afford (cost of treatment). If you have a pre-existing condition, (probability of becoming sick) == 1. In this case, insurance is pointless.
- jerf 18y agoI sometimes think that half the problem with employer-provided health care is that people have stopped thinking of it as insurance, as you describe. Instead, you get people who think that they have some sort of right to pay $10 and get $100 of treatment in return, every year, for perpetuity. The vision plan at my recent open enrollment demonstrated this clearly. You pay $X, and everyone's sitting there determining if they get $X+ back from the plan. And in this case, the vision plan isn't even insurance, because basically the only people going on it have a 100% chance of paying out. And it turns out that if you work the math, for one person, or one person + spouse/SO, you pay in $X and the max payout is $X-, precisely because the probability of payout is so very close to 100%. (This is because the plan only covers glasses and routine eye exams; catastrophic eye damage is covered by normal health insurance.) (I further note that vision coverage has been one of the most free market of medical endeavors, precisely because of this math.) How do we know the system is distorted? Because almost nobody actually realizes that this is an insurance system, that you should be expected to pay routine costs out-of-pocket, and that the system is physically incapable of giving everybody in the pool more than they pay in. Unfortunately, this attitude is so ingrained that every government plan I've ever seen also reifies this mindset too, and I think any plan that is conceptualized that way will fail because from the very beginning, you've built it on a shoddy foundation. We have got to pry insurance away from the employers. (Once again, I note that we've managed to export this problem to the rest of the world. Similarly, I often think that the US would be really screwed by our crappy school system, except that we managed to export it to the entire rest of the world first, so nobody actually has a good system, just slightly different iterations of the same crappy model. "Fortunately" for the US!)
- jbjohns 18y agoWhen you say "exported to the rest of the world" what countries do you mean? I live in western Europe and health insurance must be covered by the individual, and the school system is a lot better then what I experienced in the US.
- jerf 18y agoYour school system is the same fundamentally broken system of corralling children into a pen and expecting them all to learn the same basic things at the same basic rate. Every industrial society seems to do it this way. I'd argue that some systems are slightly less broken and some slightly more, but compared to what could be, none of them are even close to their potential. And maybe you should specify your exact country. For instance, France (http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=92419273 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=9241927... ): "France, like the United States, relies on both private insurance and government insurance. Also, just like in America, people generally get their insurance through their employer." Government health care as seen in the UK is hardly any different from employer health care in practice... it's slightly more disconnected from feedback, but employer health care is already pretty disconnected. So, exactly which country has fully individual health care with no government or employer involvement?
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- anewaccountname 18y agoYou pay in after-tax dollars as an individual, right?
- russell 18y agoMedical and health insurance costs over 7% of income are deductible. Could be different this year, I haven't checked. If you have a business, it can be all deductible.
- russell 18y agoWrong. If you have a preexisting condition, you can't get individual insurance. If you have more than two prescriptions, you can't get insurance. I can afford it, but I can't get it. Even if you have COBRA, the premium goes up by 50% in 18 months and runs out completely in 36.
- thinkcomp 18y agoThis is a very real problem, and probably the biggest problem I face right now running my company. Through no fault of my own, I'm uninsurable as an individual, but I'm also an entrepreneur. It makes life rather difficult, and it's an obvious disincentive for people to start businesses. It's also one of many reasons why I'm hiring right now!
- hs 18y agoover my 9 years studying in usa, i never used my health insurance (always paid due to school regulation) then 4 years in my country, i never buy one actually over my lifetime, i never ever go to hospital and ask my insurance to pay for it (too much hassle and i hate meeting doctor) the fud tactic used (you will pay 1 million dollar when you visit a hospital) always amuses me maybe a better way is to take care of yourself, exercise, read health textbooks, read wikipedia on generic OTC drugs, eat real food, avoid extreme sports, don't smoke, use common sense etc never ask an insurance company, "do i need coverage?"
- jraines 18y agoBelieve the FUD. In the U.S. an appendectomy can easily run you $20,000, and this is one of the most common non-elective surgeries. Then look at car accident stats and the cost of trauma care. Then look at new cancer incidence rates (there will be ~1.3 million new cases next year - CDC) and treatment costs.
- kingkongrevenge 18y agoThe costs are absurd because of insurance. People are too isolated from prices and all the money the government pumps into the system inflates prices. The whole healthcare cost problem would disappear almost immediately if people paid medical bills directly and were reimbursed for only the truly unforeseen medical expenses. If doctors and hospitals were forced to compete on price like normal businesses, costs would plummet. It's the lack of a real market that's the problem. What other business has no prices out on display or in advertisements? Try calling up a hospital and asking the cash price for a procedure. It typically doesn't even exist; they're only set up to bill insurance companies and the government at different rates. "Healthcare in the US is socialism without a central plan and capitalism without markets or prices."
- jraines 18y agoYou're at least partly right. Some treatments would plummet, some would remain expensive. We really have no idea, the market is so distorted and the perfect system will always be subject to debate. In my opinion, we can't ever have a true capitalist market for healthcare because the price elasticity of demand for some treatments is so high.
- incomethax 18y agoIs there some kind of startup association that startups could join to negotiate better healthcare insurance plans as a collective? Seems to me like it would provide many startups a large cost savings if one were to join.