3 ms·
Microsoft Blames European Commission for Major Worldwide Outage
- legitster 2y ago> Back in 2009, Microsoft agreed to interoperability rules that provide third-party security apps with the same level of access to Windows that Microsoft gets. Microsoft agreed to provide kernel access in order to resolve multiple longstanding competition law issues in Europe. > Apple has not been forced to make changes to how Macs work, but the European Commission has been targeting the closed nature of iOS, and Apple has warned that the updates that have already been implemented could lead to security risks in the future. This is a valid and interesting comparison - Microsoft complied and Apple fought tooth and nail. But also, it's kind of a moot point because absolutely no one is running Apple hardware at a flight kiosk.
- bilbo0s 2y agoJust Devils advocate, but, If MS is really not allowed to protect their kernel, that part of whatever EU understanding they have should probably be revisited. I’m not sure it’s gonna hamper things legally too much to let MS, and everyone else for that matter, Apple, Linux, Android, whoever, erect defensive walls around their own kernels. This is just security 101 for devices these days, and it doesn’t stop anyone else from participating in the windows, android, apple ecosystem.
- lazide 2y agoThe issue is Defender and equivalents. Those would have access of course, and hence have an extreme competitive advantage relative to other products. Even more than they do now. Kiss any non-Microsoft antivirus or security software goodbye.
- Rinzler89 2y ago>The issue is Defender and equivalents. Not just that, but that would break backwards compatibility with a lot of niche but important apps, since Windows was very popular with use cases where companies have developed kernel space drivers for their Windows products. Yanking that away for security with break backwards compatibility.
- lazide 2y agoAre you talking hardware drivers or something else?
- whimsicalism 2y agoI think userspace AV would work fine for 99%+ of usecases, not some extreme competitive advantage.
- lazide 2y agoNot even close - real time memory scanning? Suspicious memory access detection? Suspicious file access detection? Suspicious network traffic? Suspicious kernel calls? Introspection on running program code? It’s already a major performance impact, throwing it into user space would kill those products entirely.
- whimsicalism 2y agowhat mac AVs support this?
- lazide 2y agoMac’s are a tiny segment of the business market, and hence get almost none of the attention from attacks.
- CRConrad 2y ago> Just Devils advocate, but, But misguided, as usual when someone defends Microsoft. > If MS is really not allowed to protect their kernel, that part of whatever EU understanding they have should probably be revisited They are allowed to protect “their kernel”. (And / or everything else, which AFAIK is what anti-virus software is supposed to do.) It's just that they're only allowed to do it the same way they allow everyone else to do the same thing. So, being the lazy arseholes they are, they let everyone else into the kernel like they do it, in stead of doing what they should have done: Do it from userspace like anti-virus software used to work, or build a secure API that lets software protect the kernel without being able to take it down / prevent it from booting up — and use that API themselves, in their own separate anti-virus product. Then that product would have been on an even footing in the marketplace with its competitors, which is what the agreement with the EU sought to achieve. But Microsoft cheaped out and took the easier, cheaper — and riskier! — route. This debacle is as much on them as on Crowdstrike.
- isodev 2y agoThis is ridiculous though. Nothing is stopping Microsoft from offering “safe” access to both themselves and third parties. Also, let’s not forget why these restrictions are applied in the first place - they kick in when the corp grows to become a gatekeeper, integrating multiple product categories and the expense of users and 3rd party vendors.
- Rinzler89 2y ago>Nothing is stopping Microsoft from offering “safe” access to both themselves and third parties. They are offering "safe" access, it's called userspace.
- isodev 2y agoThen the blame can safely go to the vendor who opted not to take advantage. If anything, the Crowdstrike incident highlights the lack of diversity in the OS/security space. Everyone using the same stack makes everyone vulnerable to the same bugs.
- MobiusHorizons 2y agoYou can’t write programs like CrowdStrike falcon in user space on windows, because windows doesn’t offer the right kind of APIs and hooks from userspace to provide that kind of protection. On Mac OS CrowdStrike falcon runs in userspace already, and on Linux, the kernel interface is provided by eBPF, which acts as a sandbox, preventing certain classes of crash. So it really is true that Microsoft does not provide safe access like other operating systems do.
- noahtallen 2y agoWell, last point isn’t quite true. Alaska Airlines is primarily iOS. So, iPads scan your boarding pass and are used for printing luggage tags outside security, Flight attendants use iPhones on the planes, etc. And they were of course mostly unaffected by the Cloudstrike outage. Either way, I think it’s a strong point for Apple that antivirus is not required because the iOS security model protects against viruses pretty thoroughly. That’s just not the case for Windows most of the time. Also, do tech companies run antivirus on their linux-based containerized cloud workflows? Not really, the security model doesn’t require it. Points against windows server here
- legitster 2y agoThis is incorrect: Alaska Airlines wasn't a Crowdstrike customer. They use SentinalOne, a competitor. They absolutely use Windows desktop environments across their infrastructure.
- jeroenhd 2y agoCrowdStrike is deployed on Linux servers as well, so clearly companies like these do run EDR software on their Linux hosts. Apple pretends they don't need antivirus the same way some Linux advocates will, but viruses exist on both platforms. Very few companies run their digital signage or internal application databases on macOS hosts, mostly because Apple stepped out of that market years ago. Whenever Apple or Linux are deployed at the scale these CrowdStrike desktops are, you can assume similar software is deployed on any platform. This time it was a kernel crash, next time it could be MDM software locking all iPads out of all network access, or null routing all I/O requests in eBPF.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- throw0101d 2y ago> Apple pretends they don't need antivirus the same way some Linux advocates will, but viruses exist on both platforms. Sure. But when was the last time a company was in the news when they were hit with macOS-, iOS-, or Linux-based ransomware? I'm in IT, but Windows was never my thing/niche. Generally I've viewed two problems with it: 1. when it becomes a monoculture where basically everything in the company runs on it 2. something about its architecture/designs appears (to me, at least) for very easy spreading of malware (does it have some weaker SSH-equivalent that allows easy remote control?) Just ask Maersk about these two points: * https://www.wired.com/story/notpetya-cyberattack-ukraine-russia-code-crashed-the-world/ https://www.wired.com/story/notpetya-cyberattack-ukraine-rus...
- twiss 2y agoIt seems like the biggest counterargument to this would be the one made in https://www.brendangregg.com/blog/2024-07-22/no-more-blue-fridays.html https://www.brendangregg.com/blog/2024-07-22/no-more-blue-fr... (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41033579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41033579), i.e. it should be possible to provide a safe API (like eBPF) to provide the access that third-party security apps need, without risking crashes.
- bilbo0s 2y agoI don’t know man? At some level, we would have to accept that if we’re giving people, many of them hackers, access to kernel level facilities, there is a risk involved. If you want no risk, use a walled off OS. If you want a more flexible or permissive kernel architecture, then accept that the burden of securing it is kind of on you after a point. Put in layman’s terms, I can put that riving knife on your table saw, but there’s still a risk to using it. It’s just a risky tool.
- layer8 2y agoEbpf provides exactly that wall.
- bilbo0s 2y agoSigh. Guys, eBPF provides more limited access to kernel features. That’s by design. Whatever the platform, the idea with eBPF is to limit kernel access and provide safe access only where ‘necessary’. The entire issue is that MS limited access to their kernel. If you want the people who use eBPF, windows developers, to have the same access to kernel features as the providers of eBPF facilities, MS themselves, then you’re effectively giving them kernel access. There is no such thing as safe full featured kernel access.
- freeopinion 2y agoI personally don't have problems with developers having kernel access. I can't imagine any open source OS fan objecting to this. I do have problems with MS or any other vendor using kernel access unnecessarily. MS Paint should not run in the kernel. Just because you can doesn't mean you should. The question is whether MS or any other vendor could provide the feature set their product enjoys without running in the kernel. If Windows offered anything like eBPF but MS security apps chose to run in-kernel instead of through eBPF, then MS should be forced to give competitors the same kernel access. If MS would play fair and restrict their non-OS teams to userspace they wouldn't have to play fair by providing access to kernelspace. The argument is that it is impossible for MS non-OS teams to play in userspace because MS doesn't provide the APIs to make it possible. It seems that some other OSes might not suffer from this deficiency.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jmclnx 2y agoKind of a dup: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41029590 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41029590 Microsoft points finger at the EU for not being able to lock down Windows
- lemoncookiechip 2y ago> The Falcon software was not able to wreak similar havoc on Macs because Apple does not give software makers kernel access. In macOS Catalina, which came out in 2020, Apple deprecated kernel extensions and transitioned to system extensions that run in a user space instead of at a kernel level. The change made Macs more stable and more secure, adding protection against unstable software updates like the one CrowdStrike pushed out. It is not possible for Macs to have a similar failure because of the change that Apple made. What about Linux though? Feels like this is just MS redirecting blame and using it as an opportunity to push the narrative that walled garden = good.
- Rinzler89 2y agoThat piece of text you're quoting is mostly incorrect. Falcon didn't break Linux now because they haven't shipped a broken extension for Linux this time, only for Windows, but if you want to, you can definitely cause the Linux kernel to panic quite easily if you start inserting buggy drivers in kernel space like Crowdstrike was doing on Windows.
- janice1999 2y agoSeparate issue from earlier this year, same product: "CrowdStrike's Falcon Sensor also linked to Linux kernel panics and crashes" https://www.theregister.com/2024/07/21/crowdstrike_linux_crashes_restoration_tools/ https://www.theregister.com/2024/07/21/crowdstrike_linux_cra...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lemoncookiechip 2y agoQuoting from another thread > mirashii 16 hours ago The primary one linked there is certainly not the same issue, it was a bug in the Linux kernel's ebpf handling. It happened to be triggered by Crowdstrike, but the bug is undeniably a Linux kernel bug which was subsequently patched, as ebpf programs should never be able to panic the kernel. That's not to say that there haven't been other Crowdstrike fails on Linux, especially pre-eBPF module, but that's not one, and that class of failures has been eliminated in the move to the eBPF based module.
- aneutron 2y agoEither someone is stupid enough to make this argument which I don't think is the case (The NT teams are crazy good), or they just want to use this opportunity to divert the blame, which is pathetic at best. UAC, virtualization, hybrid kernel/user-space shenanigans, all were not in the OS at some point, and research and development, listening to other parties and taking inspiration from other OSes brought these advancements in security. If Microsoft thinks offering kernel drivers for security (antivirus or otherwise) is a bad thing for the 3rd party companies, then by extension it is bad for any antiviral product they offer and they should absolutely find a new paradigm to securely implement them (eBPF like as some other folks suggested). But saying "but apple does it !" is not a reasonable demande when your software runs respirators and nuclear facilities. (Apple are still cunts for having everything locked down but that's another conversation)
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41029590 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41029590
- codeulike 2y agoMicrosoft didn't blame the European Commission for the outage (thats a ridiculous headline), they said they can't close off the Kernel due to agreements made with the European Commission. The original soruce macrumors is quoting is thie WSJ article, see last paragraph: https://archive.is/FLNKH https://archive.is/FLNKH A Microsoft spokesman said it cannot legally wall off its operating system in the same way Apple does because of an understanding it reached with the European Commission following a complaint. In 2009, Microsoft agreed it would give makers of security software the same level of access to Windows that Microsoft gets.
- Xylakant 2y agoThey absolutely could close of the kernel - it's just that Defender as an antivirus product would have to use the same APIs. Apple doesn't offer a defender-like product, so the move was easier for them.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y ago> Apple doesn't offer a defender-like product, so the move was easier for them. Isn't that XProtect?
- throwaway4pp24 2y agoHow do they close the kernel and provide API at the same time?
- geor9e 2y agoNot a kernel-level API - they'd move Defender to an API without kernel-level access. On Mac their API is called Endpoint Security Framework which lets antivirus monitor system calls without giving it kernel-level access. And System Integrity Protection is how they close the kernel. Microsoft would love to do the same, but also want their own Defender to have kernel-level access. The EU says they have to give third-party antivirus the same access they give their own antivirus, for anti-trust reasons. Personally I disagree with the EU here.
- 2y ago
- pradn 2y agoThe alternative is that everyone in the Microsoft security ecosystem gets off kernel-mode drivers. Once ebpf-for-windows lands, it should be possible for Microsoft, CrowdStrike, and everyone else to run their filters in user-land. That puts everyone on a level playing field, and makes the ecosystem more secure overall. https://github.com/microsoft/ebpf-for-windows https://github.com/microsoft/ebpf-for-windows
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- simonCGN 2y agoBig tech looking for a scapegoat for their own failings
- deathanatos 2y agoI'm not affected by this (we don't use Windows) but something that's confused me: most of the various clouds have published advisories/status page updates for this. Are they (e.g., MS) shipping VMs in their cloud (e.g., Azure) with CrowdStrike pre-installed? In which case I think people have a right to be upset with MS, as they've chosen an apparently poor quality vendor, and the EU argument seems like a complete distraction. Or is the market of "audit checkbox checking security software" just such a monoculture that nigh every Windows VM out there was running this thing, but that it was installed by the owners of the VM (i.e., not by the cloud vendor), and now we see what happens when unfettered updates hit a monoculture? In which case, … I don't see how MS is to blame here; seems like you, the buyer of CrowdStrike, chose poorly. (And the EU thing is even more of a distraction.) (And I guess the cloud status page updates are just out of the goodness of the cloud vendors' hearts, or we don't think Windows sysadmins are competent enough to not blame their cloud, or both.)