4 ms·
> People in a functioning society still have to work Why?
by rbanffy 2y ago
> People in a functioning society still have to work
Why?
- throwaway22032 2y agoHave you ever interacted with a free rider? You know, those guys who always dodge their round at the pub, they never pay you back that fiver, they always need somewhere to crash? Hell, have you ever dated someone like that, or known a friend that has? One person goes to work, cooks, maintains the home, the other just spends their time on highfalutin' ideas like their photography project? UBI to me sounds like a way of hiding that behind bureaucracy. I don't want to support people who don't do anything useful and purely consume resources.
- gwd 2y agoYou can see that they exist already, without UBI. So the question is, what effect will UBI have on freeloading if introduced? Will they contribute even less than they do now? Will there be more of them? Or will they stop free-loading off companies and individuals? If UBI means everyone at the place you work is actually motivated, and you never have to watch your friend support a free-loader again, I think we're probably better off as a society.
- throwaway22032 2y agoYou're forgetting about the bit in which you've literally given the person thousands of dollars. They use that free money to get you to do things for them. It's hidden behind bureaucracy but it's the same thing. Worse, even, because you don't have a choice. It's like the nonsense solutions the left propose for tackling crime. "If we give people X, they won't have to steal X". I mean, sure, because they have already gotten it from me for free...
- gwd 2y agoRight, but there are situations where you will pay for something one way or another; we'd like "not paying" to be an option, but trying to take that option causes you to pay in the most expensive way. If you have a piece of industrial machinery, you will have down time for maintenance: you can pro-actively schedule planned maintenance when it's less disruptive, or the machine itself can schedule unplanned maintenance without regard to the disruption; "not having maintenance" isn't an option, and trying to take it is actually taking the "expensive unplanned maintenance" option. If you're the parent of a toddler and that toddler wants your attention, they will get it one way or another: you can pro-actively make time for them, or you can re-actively make time when they act out, perhaps destroying something in the process; as frustrating as it is, "not making time" is simply not an option, and trying to take it is actually taking the "expensive re-active to acting out" option. Here in the UK several years ago they cut back severely on social services to people with low-grade emotional problems. So instead of calling the social workers, they started calling emergency services, who are required to send someone out. The result was that much more more money was spent on emergency services. One could of course jail people who falsely call 999, but then that's pretty expensive too. For better or for worse, "not paying for people for them to talk to" isn't an option; it turns into "pay expensive EMTs to talk to them". So, maybe there are these people who are just freeloaders; they get jobs and then do the minimal amount of work possible, they get boyfriends or girlfriends or spouses who will support their freeloading lifestyle. That cost is being paid right now, but in a damaging way: they're dead weight in companies and vampires on romantic partners. It would be nice not to pay that cost at all, but that doesn't seem to be an option. Maybe if we just explicitly paid them to freeload, then at least we'd have the benefit of not having them hurt our friends and our companies.
- throwaway22032 2y agoI don't agree with cutting mental health services and don't believe that it is equivalent to giving free money to people. > they're dead weight in companies and vampires on romantic partners This is trivially avoidable in both cases. The Offspring have a song that comes to mind.
- gwd 2y ago> I... don't believe that it is equivalent to giving free money to people. And I hope two things are clear: 1. I don't like freeloaders either. I don't ever plan to be a freeloader, and I don't like the idea of paying taxes to enable people to choose a lifestyle of taking and not giving. (Obviously there are people who create value for society that's harder to "capture", like working on open-source software or making art; and there are people who have a harder time contributing because of other limitations, not because of choice; we're not talking about those people here.) 2. I don't claim to know that giving free money to people will help. It's possible freeloaders will take money from the government and companies / individuals; it's possible that having free money available will significantly increase the number of freeloaders. We don't know because we haven't tried it. What I'm asking you to consider, however, is the possibility that 1) the overall benefits to society of UBI are greater than the harms caused by enabling freeloaders; and 2) there's no way to have UBI without enabling freeloaders. If that's the case, then our options are: 1. Take UBI and its benefits, gritting our teeth at the necessity of enabling freeloaders 2. Miss the benefits of UBI on principle to avoid enabling freeloaders. If UBI is a net benefit to society, in spite of freeloaders, I'd have to go with #1 instead of #2. Consider that our current capitalist system enables lots of other types of freeloaders: people who have inherited enough capital that they can live off the profits without doing any work whatsoever, companies or people who have patented something simple and obvious and are then able to extract rents from the people actually making things, people who buy things and sell them milliseconds later. We put up with this kind of freeloading in capitalism because it's hard to prevent it without damaging the benefits that capitalism brings. The same might end up being true for UBI.
- patmcc 2y agoBecause the food needs to come from somewhere?
- synicalx 2y agoBecause it's 2024 and we're not yet living in the world of WALL-E. I agree it would be nice to weight 300 pounds and float around on a levitating lounge all day doing nothing but sadly we're just not at that point yet.
- williamcotton 2y agoReally?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rco8786 2y agoSeriously?
- warkdarrior 2y agoBecause until we have unlimited robots with AGI, stuff needs to get done for the society to function. Growing food, building stuff, delivering stuff, fixing/maintaining stuff, etc.
- rbanffy 2y agoI appreciate the honest answer to what was a bit of a provocation. Can we assume a fraction of people would still be doing these relevant things and that it'd be enough to maintain a functioning society? If not, wouldn't that point towards the directions we need technology to evolve? Would paying more to the people who now don't need to work, but are willing to, suffice? One thing I would bet on is that, in that scenario, degrading working conditions (as we frequently see in agriculture, transportation, etc) would make it harder to find people willing to subject themselves to them.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoCards on the table: I think the vast majory of people would do less, and perhaps very little socially productive work without the current financial incentives. > Would paying more to the people who now don't need to work, but are willing to, suffice? This is not possible because you cant simultaneously pay workers more (as a whole) and have them subsidize the non-working. I admit it may be possible to reallocate compensation among the workers so that some get more, while collectively they get less.
- nehal3m 2y ago> Cards on the table: I think the vast majory of people would do less, and perhaps very little socially productive work without the current financial incentives. I don't disagree, but aren't you implicitly admitting here that the vast majority of people don't want to spend their lives doing work? We get a few laps around the sun, once, before we return to oblivion. It seems a tragedy to me to force almost everyone into spending that brief spark of life on the drudgery of increasing shareholder value. If you agree, would you then also say that it would be in humanity's interest to work toward a situation where people can lead happy, fulfilling lives? I'm not saying I have any answers, but I am saying that implicit in your own assumption is a problem that needs solving.
- eamsen 2y agoTo add value to society?
- rbanffy 2y agoWhy is value needed? How much of it is sufficient for society to function? Yes, it IS a provocation. Let's go deeper into this question.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Why is value needed? How much of it is sufficient for society to function? As much as people want. A subsistence lifestyle is incredibly cheap and accessible; most of us just don't want it.
- godshatter 2y agoBecause I want to live in an interplanetary society with awesome tech and flying cars and holodecks and life extending medicines and who-knows-what-else and we're not going to get there if people are content to sit around in their nondescript 1-person apartments eating pre-packaged meals and the occasional weekly piece of cake and play Call of Duty or watch YouTube all day.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI think it is because people consuming social value without adding to it leads to division and fracturing of that society. More simply, value production is needed because value consumption is occurring.
- eamsen 2y agoValue production is needed, because the value we produce is fleeting and healthy societies grow. How much value is needed is determined by the society through a free market.
- falcolas 2y agoHow much value can a disabled veteran provide to the free market? If that value is zero, should they just lay down and die? What if they're not a veteran, but just an unfortunate soul with a disability that provides "zero" value?
- throwawa14223 2y agoWhat's my incentive for subsidizing non-work in others?
- blooalien 2y agoWhat's your incentive for continuing to eat, drink, and breathe once your overlords have fulfilled their greatest dream and replaced their need for human labor with robots and machines and other forms of automation? Your purpose will have been fulfilled and your existence now meaningless. That is the ultimate goal we're all working for, right? Being freed from working for our overlords so that we can all just lay down and die and leave the world to the worst of humanity?
- throwaway22032 2y ago"Overlords" are a meme. In both the US and UK over 30% of households are owned outright with no mortgage. The economy is made up of us, it's not (predominantly) a downtrodden serving a tiny elite.
- fragmede 2y agothe "overlords" already have enough money to pay a team of real live human beings to tend to their every need until they die, AGI robots aren't going to change that for them.
- throwawa14223 2y agoIt isn't my ultimate goal.
- itronitron 2y agoYou are already subsidizing non-work in others, however currently their non-work is at a 'job' that they commute to every day.
- throwawa14223 2y agoDo I correctly understand that your argument is that because something undesirable currently is happening I should support policies to increase it?