7 ms·
> In every instance, the deaths were preventable, experts say. All but one of the victims were male; the youngest was 16. In many cases, the companies failed to
by Aurornis 2y ago
> In every instance, the deaths were preventable, experts say. All but one of the victims were male; the youngest was 16. In many cases, the companies failed to follow basic government rules for making trenches safe.
Having known someone in the construction industry, I don’t think this is as simple as blaming “the companies”.
One of his frequent frustrations is getting workers to actually use the safety gear and follow the company safety policies. This includes properly securing trenches with the equipment they provide and mandate.
I’ve heard stories about new guys who refused to wear safety glasses or hearing protection while working machinery. Some of them so defiant that they had to be fired within weeks.
Obviously we need to harshly fine the companies that fail to provide safety gear or pressure employees to do unsafe things. However, having had a peek behind the curtain I think this issue is more complex than a simple failure of companies to follow guidelines for providing gear and procedures to employees. You really have to be on top of work crews all the time to make sure they’re actually following procedures rather than cutting corners.
- freitzkriesler2 2y agoIt's a combination of many things up and down the chain. The work is dirty and grueling but even proper safety fails at times. Speed shoring trenches works but sometimes it doesn't for reasons that we don't know. Same for scaffolding and others. Construction is dangerous and those guys really do deserve the money paid to them.
- mattficke 2y agoIf the existing procedures aren’t ensuring a safe workplace, the procedures aren’t adequate. Job site safety can add time, and it’s the company’s responsibility to ensure that there is no incentive for a worker to be able to speed up the job by skipping a step. I’ve worked in places where the safety procedures were clearly perfunctory (drove a forklift in a warehouse for several years, among other jobs) and if I had insisted on following the actual safety procedures I would’ve gotten endless grief from other employees for slowing them down. This is a management failure.
- cjbgkagh 2y agoIn my experience it's the workers, and it's machoism amongst the workers that creates an intentionally anti-safe culture where such cultures are permitted. Where I live they remove the angle grinder guards off and use 'safety squints' when welding. A friend had people working on his house, when I visited I made them stop their work and put the recently removed angle grinder guards form their new tools back on. I also and got them a chepo welding helmet. Not long after I left that day they took the guards back off and a young worker cut off a 1/4 of his hand and had to be rushed to hospital. My friend had a 'let them do what they want to do' attitude to the workers which thankfully has now been replaced with a 'safety first' attitude. Unfortunately too late for the kids hand. This sort of stuff can't be done bottom up as there is huge social pressure to demonstrate manliness to peers through risky activity. Only strict top-down edicts where such digressions are severely punished can take away that pressure; i.e. instead of using safety equipment it's because they're a sissy it's because their mean old boss is a sissy and they're forcing them to use it. While OSHA can be a bit onerous it really does help to have an organization with teeth pushing safety culture. Instead of the conflict between the workers and their bosses 'stupid rules' it's the 'stupid rules' of some 3rd party.
- crhulls 2y agoI second this. My day job is tech but I redid a rental property. I told the workers to wear a harness on the roof. I didn’t cheap out and bought nice comfortable equipment. They told me they were wearing it, but I came by unannounced and there they were on the roof with no harness. I asked the supervisor what was up and they were doing the same thing to him. They would put it on then take it off as soon as no one was looking. It was Latin machismo - the social pressure was so strong to not look goofy in a harness. The second time I saw this happen I wrote a firm zero tolerance letter which I translated to Spanish and hand delivered. One of the crew still didn’t listen. I fired him. (Not saying that reckless bosses aren’t an issue, especially in these trenching incidents where the safety equipment didn’t exist)
- jeromegv 2y agoYou are proving this is a management issue. You took steps to address the issue. Fired people who didn’t listen. The fact they thought they could do it without consequences means they never got into trouble by management at other job sites. If your industry has a culture of not following safety procedures it’s only because bosses don’t enforce it.
- dahart 2y agoThis is an article about installing trench boxes, which is a decision made by the company, not individual workers, and has a long list of company execs admitting they didn’t follow the law because it cost them money. This isn’t that complicated and doesn’t really compare to individuals foregoing personal safety equipment.
- newsclues 2y agoIndividual workers at job sites decide what they do, from how to build to what safety gear they use. Project managers and engineers give instructions but workers can and do ignore them and do whatever they want.
- Jgrubb 2y agoYeah ok buddy, every job site everywhere is just anarchy. We have no idea how bridges and skyscrapers get built, really.
- dahart 2y agoIt seems like you didn’t understand the distinction between PPE and the project plan for trench boxes. In the case of PPE, the company is providing the safety equipment and asking workers to use it. Yes it’s true that some workers choose not to use ear plugs, glasses, harnesses, etc. (often because the PPE is uncomfortable.) In the case of trench boxes, companies have to keep the information away from workers in order to prevent their use, and the article cites multiple examples of that occurring. Trench boxes require company action and expenditure in advance of construction that is not up to individual workers. When the contractor rents or orders a trench box, delivers it to the site, arranges for the excavator, or even a crane for larger operations, and lays out the construction plan, there is no such thing as ignoring it. Just in case you missed it in the article, not only are trench boxes required by law in the US, a safety supervisor on site overseeing the operation is also required. The laws were written to prevent individual workers from being able to ignore the construction safety plan, and require company oversight. The only way it gets ignored is from the top.
- 2y ago
- RobotToaster 2y agoOften the safety equipment provided is the cheapest, most uncomfortable, version possible. Cheap safety glasses can fog up quickly or chafe, for example. The company does this fully expecting that it won't be used, but they can then blame the workers for not using it when something does go wrong.
- bloopernova 2y agoYeah, utilities have a constant battle to keep safety measures effective. Even when folks had recently been killed in the field due to basic safety equipment not being used, there would be people who would roll their eyes and bemoan the "red tape and bureaucracy".
- matwood 2y ago> I’ve heard stories about new guys who refused to wear safety glasses or hearing protection while working machinery. This is just crazy. It's low effort to protect the most exposed body functions while using machinery. I always cringe when I see someone doing any kind of that type of work w/o eye protection. Even something simple like hammering nails can cause a chip to fly off and into your eye.
- dboreham 2y agoHumans are on average very dumb. They'll say things like "I've done this 100 times and never taken my eye out".
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI work in a lab full of masters and Phd engineers and it is extremely difficult to get safety glass compliance above 50%. The company has mandatory yearly training, and leadership will discipline workers, but at the end of the day glasses are annoying and come off whenever supervisors arent looking
- KineticLensman 2y agoI've been gardening for 30 years, never any issues. Last year I pulled a broken branch out of a hedge and a bit I hadn't seen wacked me in the eye. Couple of hours later I was seeing flashes and a massive floater-like object appeared, a bit like a wobbling HUD graticule around my central vision. Turned out to be a posterior vitreous detachment which luckily settled down (mostly). Thank Christ. I bought some airsoft goggles which are reasonably comfortable and non-misting, and wear them when doing any significant work, even just gardening.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vondur 2y agoMy dad used to manage a heat treating shop. He came in one night to check on something and found one of the late shift workers had attached himself to the gantry crane and was flying around the shop on it. He was promptly fired.
- Aeolun 2y agoTo be fair, this sounds awesome to be doing yourself.
- deegles 2y agoI've read that workers are now refusing to wear masks for things like painting or sanding because of the peer pressure against wearing masks for Covid.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> All but one of the victims were male I assume this is simply a reflection of the construction industry and not specific to trenches? Most jobs that are dangerous are done almost entirely by men in virtually every country.
- cjalmeida 2y agoThis is no excuse. At least in larger companies, you have safety inspectors that routinely visit shops unannounced and will give you and your manager trouble if you’re not following procedures. They answer directly to higher up and can’t be pressured into letting it pass.
- njarboe 2y agoAn alternative perspective to making tools less functional for safety.[1] Handy when drilling a 5/8" hole through 10" of wood.[2] [1]http://www.team.net/mjb/hawg.html http://www.team.net/mjb/hawg.html [2]https://njarboe.com/chal/barn/barn4.html https://njarboe.com/chal/barn/barn4.html
- zymhan 2y agoYour anecdotes are far less valuable than the actual reporting in the article.
- sixothree 2y agoSo what. Fire them. They’ll wear the gear then.