7 ms·
Intel vs. Samsung vs. TSMC
- Olesya000 2y ago[dead]
- generatedtruth 2y ago[dead]
- kurthr 2y agoIf the development of modern chiplet/stacked die is interesting, semiwiki also has interesting articles from some of the vendors including breakdowns of design and integration costs: https://semiwiki.com/eda/synopsys/347420-the-immensity-of-software-development-the-challenges-of-debugging-part-1-of-4/ https://semiwiki.com/eda/synopsys/347420-the-immensity-of-so... TSMC also discussed some of the challenges for multi-die design a month ago: https://semiwiki.com/semiconductor-manufacturers/tsmc/345909-tsmc-advanced-packaging-overcomes-the-complexities-of-multi-die-design/ https://semiwiki.com/semiconductor-manufacturers/tsmc/345909... My take is that the rapid rise in heterogeneous solutions and complexity will provide some excess semi profitability, but at the cost of long run performance increases for "new nodes". Instead of one path forward there are now many. Or the most recent: https://semiwiki.com/semiconductor-manufacturers/347646-tsmc-foundry-2-0-intel-idm-2-0-and-samsung-idunno-2-0/ https://semiwiki.com/semiconductor-manufacturers/347646-tsmc...
- KK7NIL 2y ago> Instead of one path forward there are now many. This is a feature, not a bug. Leading edge nodes are becoming harder and harder to develop on, particularly outside of memory and logic. This is because of limitations in terms of Ft, max voltage, layout, poor scaling of analog, etc. Leading edge nodes nowadays generally release without a lot of key features and so can only be used for compute tiles, requiring other tiles for IO, analog circuits, etc. As the nodes mature these features will generally get added on (that might not even be possible in the future if the current trend continues), at which point you can do a SoC with all these things integrated on one die (which was essentially the only option before we had the packaging technology for heterogeneous chiplet systems). This is why heterogeneous chiplet designs are the future. Source: my job is helping to develop and test analog and mixed signal circuits on leading edge nodes at Intel.
- kurthr 2y agoTotally agree, the complexity of 3D, heterogeneous nodes, and chiplet integration are necessary. Thank you for your efforts, and I wish you great success. It's just that for over 50 years optimizing transistor pitch in 2D was sufficient to drive demand and investment. The clear winning single path forward provided the exponential growth we've come to expect. I suspect the complexity and uncertainty of this new heterogeneity does not. Underlying system and process simplicity and reliability support overlaying complexity in software and network. I started in semi with 68020/30 to see the huge jump from 2um to 0.8um and stayed in on the trailing edge of analog down to 28nm. Maybe there is another 40 years of growth, but it feels like even though 3D stacking increases the power law of dimensionality, it may reduce iteration rate more. We've got 8 high HBM, but will we have 100 in even 8 years or 1000 in another 8 more?
- KK7NIL 2y ago> We've got 8 high HBM, but will we have 100 in even 8 years or 1000 in another 8 more? No, probably not, but that's not the point. The point is that now memory and logic (in case of HBM) can be further decoupled, allowing us to use processes optimized for each, instead of having to compromise one for the other. This will allow for cheaper and faster iteration. You're correct that 3D scaling will likely not go very far, but that's not the key part; the ability to tightly couple heterogeneous dies, allowing for specialization and decoupling of processes, is the key to further scaling.
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoSo anyone want to hazard to guess if the node shrinks are going to go more than seven ignoring the half steps? If the article is correct that the major semis are going to kind of forge their own paths, in my opinion, that means marketing lots of even 1/3 or quarter steps.
- ksec 2y ago>going to go more than seven ignoring the half steps? What do you mean by that ?
- sbstp 2y agoChip design & manufacturing is probably the closest thing we have to witchcraft as a species.
- SkyMarshal 2y agoThat or cryptography.
- wzp 2y agohaha yea
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoEUV lithography might as well have been invented at Hogwarts as far as I'm concerned.
- nevdka 2y agoWe use invisible light to draw patterns on crystals to control the power of lightning. Definitely magic.
- timschmidt 2y agoDon't forget the cavernous structures which people are forbidden to enter, buzzing with the activity of objects controlled by those enchanted crystals, like the magic brooms in Fantasia, performing myriad arcane rituals with rare and exotic materials to make more enchanted crystals.
- 6510 2y agoAnd the high priests guarding the knowledge.
- timschmidt 2y agoAh yes, the sandbenders. [0] 0: http://catb.org/jargon/html/S/sandbender.html http://catb.org/jargon/html/S/sandbender.html
- localfirst 2y agoImagine if TSMC is out of the picture. Samsung would have de facto monopoly over semiconductor chips.
- Guthur 2y agoHow so?, is there not a glot of trailing edge semi manufacturers? We get dazzled by leading edge semi conductors by that's only part of the picture.
- localfirst 2y agoWell trump doesnt seem keen on protecting taiwan
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- jimnotgym 2y agoWould love to hear more about that. Do you have an article?
- Wytwwww 2y ago> Imagine if TSMC is out of the picture Wouldn't Intel actually become competitive? Of course without TSMC they wouldn't have had any incentives to open up their fabs...
- JonChesterfield 2y agoIntel is currently limping along on government handouts, hoping people don't notice their latest generations burn out if you leave them turned on. Taking their primary competition away would push up profit margins and push down the need to fix the engineering. If they aren't dead already, TSMC disappearing would do it. I wonder how global foundaries is doing these days.
- gradschoolfail 2y agoThe TSMC description language mentioned is an “open” standard. https://3dblox.org/ https://3dblox.org/ https://resources.sw.siemens.com/en-US/video-simplified-physical-verification-of-3dics-through-3dbloxtm/ https://resources.sw.siemens.com/en-US/video-simplified-phys...
- tenwz 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nabla9 2y agoPackaging has become so advanced that they now need similar accuracy and clean rooms as the chipmaking itself. When they add microfluidics it becomes even more difficult.
- robertwt7 2y agoI didn't understand how crucial chip manufacturing is until reading the book "Chip War".. What an amazing book. This is probably one of the greatest, if not the greatest invention in the human history.
- 3abiton 2y agoWe have some sand to thank. Jokes aside, it is still mind boggling how most of the manufacturing is still dominated by very few companies, it's the perfect setup for WWIII
- mrtksn 2y agoWhen I was a kid I was into electronics and remember being very annoyed when I found out about this chip stuff. I was happily building analog circuits using the basic building blocks like transistors, capacitors and resistors and it gave me the satisfaction of having great control over everything and being able to "see in 3D" when I look at my circuit as I had full mental model over what's happening. Chips are really great of course but at the same time its completely magic in a bad way. It haven't clicked for me how it all works until I watched videos of people building CPU analogs in Minecraft or something. Just don't like the feeling of not having an idea of how this thing works just by looking at it.
- tuyiown 2y ago> Just don't like the feeling of not having an idea of how this thing works just by looking at it. I find it pretty funny that, since we're no equipped to sens electrical flows just by looking at it, it's more the visual / sensorial support for you mental model that helps you. E.g. you don't really have more information by seeing the circuit physically than looking at plans, it just that your brain finds it easier. But it's also pretty clear that having physical objects in the loop actually changes the brain thought process, so it's not just an affair of having the information at hand, how it's presented to our senses must imply changes.
- mrtksn 2y agoThat’s right, the analog circuit has clear topology which I can easily imagine what’s going on just by looking at it and sometimes by manipulating it. It’s simply more enjoyable to look at, like looking at mechanical watches or industrial machinery. Chips are kind of dull. Not to take anything away from their enormous utility and impact of course.