7 ms·
I'm funding Ladybird because I can't fund Firefox
- dtx1 2y ago[flagged]
- apantel 2y agoWhat’s a Topah?
- imperialdrive 2y agoKlingon for animal?
- LinuxBender 2y agoWhat’s a Topah? Klingon slang for Idiot
- dtx1 2y agohttps://youtu.be/ibA7noX6rnc?t=63 https://youtu.be/ibA7noX6rnc?t=63
- Tao3300 2y agoI think it's like a jabroni.
- dfc 2y agoWhat is a Tophas?
- 1oooqooq 2y agohe's probably cursing in klingon. HN turns into slashdot on sundays, when all the MBAs are barbecuing.
- cassianoleal 2y agoI LOL'ed at your comment. It seems about right. It's also a reflection of itself.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- phendrenad2 2y agoHow much does Mozilla spend hardening Firefox? How much does Apple spend hardening Safari? I see no reason to believe that Chromium is so far ahead security-wise that the only way to compete is with Rust. Happy to be proven wrong, of course.
- xupybd 2y agoChromium is written in C++...
- 1oooqooq 2y agoHis point is correct. To pretend to make Cpp safe, you need google sized budget (if not in engineering, in marketing, but oh well)
- moooo99 2y agoELI5: as far as I know, „safe“ programming languages are able to avoid memory related issues that are/were prevalent in C(++). Is this actually the class of bug that causes most security related issues in the browser?
- 1oooqooq 2y agoHow do you carry water in a sieve? That's the personnel cost analogy to have safe cpp. His point is not about replacing the sieve, it is about having the money to still have some water across even when using sieves.
- dist1ll 2y agoYes, memory safety issues make up a large majority of high-severity security bugs in Chromium. See https://www.chromium.org/Home/chromium-security/memory-safety/ https://www.chromium.org/Home/chromium-security/memory-safet...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dtx1 2y agoAnd Google Spend roughly 100 Times more money on making it safe than ladybird will get in funding in total.
- _yb2s 2y agoNonsense, all 4 of the most widely used browsers were written in C/C++. A browser is basically an OS at this point, and these issues can be addressed in the design, just like in any OS kernel, which are also almost all written in C/C++. I think the demise of Firefox has been greatly exaggerated... I'm still using it as my main browser, and the user experience and performance are excellent.
- Xeamek 2y agoWhy do You think creating a browser in a 'safe' language would prevent security bugs from occurring?
- hollerith 2y agoBecause 70% of the security holes in C code bases tend to be things that never happen in a memory-safe language.
- Xeamek 2y agosource?
- dist1ll 2y agoFrom the chromium website > Around 70% of our high severity security bugs are memory unsafety problems (that is, mistakes with C/C++ pointers). Half of those are use-after-free bugs. https://www.chromium.org/Home/chromium-security/memory-safety/ https://www.chromium.org/Home/chromium-security/memory-safet...
- rvz 2y agoI mean, it doesn't get any more clearer that the Chromium team is already considering integrating Rust in Chromium to mitigate these sort of memory corruption vulnerabilities found in C and C++ and that is the main motivation here. [0] Given that Ladybird is yet another C/C++ browser, it will be riddled with these vulnerabilities waiting to be exploited. I don't think many here are thinking about the costs involved with security fixes and maintenance, at it is in the hundreds of millions of dollars a year just to keep up with Firefox alone. That is the minimum requirement for any serious competing browser. There's a clear reason why Chrome, Safari and Firefox need hundreds of millions of dollars of developer maintenance a year. [0] https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/refs/heads/main/docs/rust.md#why https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/refs/heads/...
- dtx1 2y ago
- apantel 2y agoGlad to see this challenge to the powers that be and the status quo.
- SahAssar 2y agoA bit funny, I donated and got redirected to https://ladybird.org/thanks.html https://ladybird.org/thanks.html which is a 404.
- QuiDortDine 2y ago"Thanks but no thanks"
- ecesena 2y agoHere you go :) Hello friend! Thank you so much for donating to support Ladybird! We believe the world needs a truly independent web browser. That's why we are funded entirely by voluntary donations, and we intend to keep it this way forever. Make sure you sign up for our newsletter below if you'd like to receive monthly updates on our progress! https://github.com/LadybirdBrowser/ladybird.org/blob/336f8926b411b8abb7f7b6518b577c136f5acbe5/thanks.html https://github.com/LadybirdBrowser/ladybird.org/blob/336f892...
- fabrice_d 2y agoFunding Servo is another good option: https://servo.org/sponsorship/ https://servo.org/sponsorship/
- slimsag 2y agoIsn’t servo Mozilla’s cancelled browser project? (Genuine question)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- adastra22 2y agoYes. It now has a life of its own.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- n42 2y agoIt moved to the Linux Foundation in 2020[0] and has been getting active development since about 2023[1]. I guess I should also add that it is just the rendering engine, not a full browser [0] https://servo.org/blog/2020/11/17/servo-home/ https://servo.org/blog/2020/11/17/servo-home/ [1] https://servo.org/blog/2023/01/16/servo-2023/ https://servo.org/blog/2023/01/16/servo-2023/
- rvz 2y agoSecond this. I'd much rather see more funding for a safer and secure browser than yet another browser that will have the same C and C++ memory corruption vulnerabilities again.
- _jackdk_ 2y agoThe FAQ at the bottom of https://ladybird.org/ https://ladybird.org/ has this easily-overlooked section: > However, now that Ladybird has forked and become its own independent project, all constraints previously imposed by SerenityOS are no longer in effect. We are actively evaluating a number of alternatives and will be adding a mature successor language to the project in the near future. This process is already quite far along, and prototypes exist in multiple languages. So it looks like there's a plan to refactor away from C++ as it spreads its wings. I'm in favour of people funding any browser engine with a realistic shot at viability.
- tills13 2y ago[flagged]
- lolinder 2y agoThe inability to fund Firefox development is completely baffling to me. The finances seem pretty obvious: Open up a fund for Firefox donations. Hire contractors under the non-profit to work on Firefox. When you have enough to pay a full time developer, hire one under the non-profit. Rinse and repeat. If, as some claim, there isn't ever enough money to really fund development, fine, they've now proven that. But not even allowing it as a possibility is completely insane! I'm left in a position where I'm assured repeatedly that the best way to fund Firefox development is to pay for a side project I have no use for like Pocket or their VPN and then hope that that payment doesn't get consumed paying for said side project or future side projects. OP's thoughts were mine the day that the LBI was announced: finally there's a non-profit that is actually committed to maintaining browser diversity. It's just a pity that it's one that's starting from behind and not the existing non-profit whose browser at one point enjoyed a majority market share.
- pipeline_peak 2y agoThey may be starting from behind, but a clean slate might be to their advantage. It takes a distinguished dev to jump into an old, large scale project. Firefox and Chrome definitely meets both of those factors.
- llm_trw 2y agoBut how will the CEO get millions in compensation for running the browser into the ground while funding her side projects? Oh sorry, she's chairwoman of the board now, completely different.
- smt88 2y agoI know they didn't do this on purpose and it was because it started as part of SerenityOS, but I'm unexcited by this project because it's written in C/C++. Rust was literally invented to solve the security and concurrency issues inherent in using C/C++ for a browser engine. You could argue that's the one use-case where it is objectively the best language to use. It's so valuable for that purpose that every large company has rewritten at least some crucial components in Rust. I also think Rust will be one of the only languages strict enough to enable the use of AI-generated code without compromising security. I certainly don't want AI-generated code for high-security applications, but there's nothing we can do to stop it at this point.
- atombender 2y agoI believe the team has said they are currently evaluating different languages, though they have not divulged which ones. From the FAQ on the Ladybird website: "We are actively evaluating a number of alternatives and will be adding a mature successor language to the project in the near future. This process is already quite far along, and prototypes exist in multiple languages." I assume it's either Rust or Jakt (the latter a language in development by the Ladybird lead dev), though I suppose Swift might be on the table.
- smt88 2y agoCreating a new language is almost as insane as building a browser engine. I do not expect this to become a viable browser regardless, but I guarantee it'll fail if they use their own new language for it.
- andtexasando 2y agoRust is great in theory. But idioms are still being teased out and it hasn’t been used on anything with more code than servo afaik. C/C++ is arguably the safer choice in terms of actually completing and maintaining a project of this magnitude.
- steveklabnik 2y ago
- 1oooqooq 2y agoYou can tell they are a fly by night meme enterprise for not starting from a Mozilla fork. Be realistic. For all bad mozilla foundation/corporation/toppahs did, the code is still open source and relatively free. If even something called IceWeasel almost had a shot at forking, the bar is pretty low.
- SahAssar 2y agoAndreas has been doing this for a long time. The difference is that now he is openly shifting focus from the OS to the browser. Having a fully new codebase implementing the web is a great thing. IceWeasel was a completely different thing mainly based around mozilla trademarks for logos/names that clashed with the FOSS policies of linux distros when shipping non-upstream binaries.
- 1oooqooq 2y agoHe is great and the project is awesome. But please, do tell me the goal of serenityOS?
- SahAssar 2y agoI think it was meant to be a recovery project first, hobby second, community third. Then ladybird started showing more potential so his focus shifted there. Sorry if I don't understand what you meant to ask.
- ethanol 2y agoA unix like os with user interface from the windows 2000 era that he could use as his daily driver at some point (instead of Linux). He said as much in some podcast I can't remember (probably cppcast).
- 1oooqooq 2y agoNo. He said it was occupational therapy. The goal was relaxed coding, not achieving anything at all.
- loufe 2y agoAnother comment brough up memory safety. I'm surprised myself that the project is moving forward without using a memory safe language at its core. A browser is a huge attack surface and all the example I know point to a necessarily enormous code base. I understand the project started as a hobby, and anyone who wishes to be involved has their own prerogative, but I'd have a hard time getting behind it myself.
- amelius 2y agoA memory safe language may force you to think about memory safety, but it can also work as a straightjacket that makes it more difficult to think about other security issues.
- timeon 2y agoSeems other way around. Since you can focus more on other security issues instead of memory safety and other security.
- amelius 2y agoNo, because the memory safety part comes at a cognitive cost. You may be right if you're talking about a GC'ed language, which gives memory safety and at the same time frees up the developer's mind. But if you're talking about constructs like borrow checkers then they do add cognitive load that is perhaps better spent elsewhere.
- bennettnate5 2y agoI've not found this to be my experience; if anything, working in Rust has freed me to think about other aspects of security in my project since I don't need to spend all my effort applying extra tools to find segfaults. Do you have an example?
- eknkc 2y agoAll the major operating systems these browsers are running on, are written in c and c++. How can you have a real memory safe application when the memory itself is managed by a shit ton of code written in an unsafe language?
- oldnetguy 2y agoIf you subscribe to Firefox services isn't that also funding Firefox?
- lolinder 2y agoHopefully, but you can only hope. My fear is that when people are crunching the numbers at Mozilla they'll see that Pocket (or whatever) is doing well and funnel resources to that, unable to distinguish between people who like Pocket and people who just want to help Firefox out. Giving me a donation box to pay for Firefox means that I can be very confident that they are getting the right message from my dollars. But for some reason they are very reluctant to do that.
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoAll hackers should understand this and use at least Firefox. Otherwise you are failing your duty of keeping hacking alive.
- formula1 2y agoWhy is Ladybird getting so much attention. Has anyone herd of servo? They're trying to offload css rendering to the gpu. That could be a big deal in the long run. https://servo.org/ https://servo.org/
- llm_trw 2y agoBecause ladybird is a browser, servo is a component of a browser. It could well be that Ladybird ends up using servo as a component.
- dzonga 2y agochromium is open source - have chromium standards set by a foundation instead of google. then funded by grants / taxes. etc and let the market work. browsers are a common utility, like water, internet etc - n should be treated the same.
- Finnucane 2y ago>let the market work. Chrome is a punch in the face by the invisible fist of the market.
- m463 2y agoI think you want: https://github.com/ungoogled-software/ungoogled-chromium https://github.com/ungoogled-software/ungoogled-chromium Without signing in to a Google Account, Chromium does pretty well in terms of security and privacy. However, Chromium still has some dependency on Google web services and binaries. In addition, Google designed Chromium to be easy and intuitive for users, which means they compromise on transparency and control of internal operations. ungoogled-chromium addresses these issues in the following ways: - Remove all remaining background requests to any web services while building and running the browser - Remove all code specific to Google web services - Remove all uses of pre-made binaries from the source code, and replace them with user-provided alternatives when possible. - Disable features that inhibit control and transparency, and add or modify features that promote them (these changes will almost always require manual activation or enabling).
- SahAssar 2y agoThis relies on both googles funding of chromium and the free work of people contributing to this repo. The parent comment (and this whole post) is mostly about the funding of browsers.
- m463 2y agofund the right browser/codebase. If you were to fund, say chrome, you might waste your money. Might be similar to funding firefox, which has lots of telemetry baked in. Unless you could fund a "no-telemetry firefox", or a version of firefox with easy to implement self-hosted firefox sync and auth.
- Osmose 2y agohttps://foundation.mozilla.org/en/donate/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/donate/ ???
- _jackdk_ 2y agoMozilla Foundation != Mozilla Corporation, so donations go where the Foundation wishes, not to Firefox development.
- atombender 2y agoThis is clearly explained in the article. The Foundation doesn't develop Firefox and can't transfer donations to the Corporation, which does.
- luuurker 2y agoThe "What we do" page doesn't even mention Firefox... https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/what-we-do/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/what-we-do/
- skissane 2y agoYes you can donate to Mozilla Foundation. But no guarantee any such donation will actually fund Firefox development, as opposed to some completely unrelated non-technical project of theirs.
- abryzak 2y agoAnd in fact their FAQ for donations doesn't even mention Firefox under their "How will my donation be used?" section: At Mozilla, our mission is to keep the Internet healthy, open, and accessible for all. The Mozilla Foundation programs are supported by grassroots donations and grants. Our grassroots donations, from supporters like you, are our most flexible source of funding. These funds directly support advocacy campaigns (i.e. asking big tech companies to protect your privacy), research and publications like the *Privacy Not Included buyer's guide and Internet Health Report, and covers a portion of our annual MozFest gathering.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- wslh 2y agoMy concern with Ladybird is the long timeline to deliver the alpha version. I think the development strategy should be discussed in the community because there could be good ideas to speed up the process.
- clircle 2y agoFeeling the same about emacs. Id like to donate to emacs, but the only option is to fund fsf instead. Last I checked.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- YmiYugy 2y agoI doubt this will work. Web browsers have an insanely large scope. Building a general purpose competitive web browser takes hundreds of full time engineers. I can't imagine you can fund such a thing with donations.
- bitfilped 2y agoIf you actually go give it a try, it's working fine. Not sure what all the hate is about.
- NekkoDroid 2y ago[flagged]
- LightHugger 2y agoThis is more telling about you. You immediately jump to a "with us or against us" attitude with nonsense like "wanting to be independent is an ideology". Good riddance to you and your ilk, i say.
- NekkoDroid 2y agoIts just that every time I've seen someone state something like that they turn out the be the same kinda person. Feel free to support them (or not) its just I've never had a good experience with those kinda people.
- LightHugger 2y agoYou sound very prejudiced.
- NekkoDroid 2y agoOfc I am. Everyone is and acting like one isn't is just doing everyone a disservice, being able to put that aside when directly interacting with others is what counts. But when their behavior indicates to me something I've seen multiple times before is going on again I am going to act accordingly.
- nathanasmith 2y agoDon't let the door hit you on the way out.
- lawgimenez 2y agoIt feels like websites are not testing their sites on Firefox anymore. Apple’s App Store Connect yesterday just won’t login anymore, tried Chrome and it works. So many broken headers, weird fonts, overlapping elements, etc.
- scoofy 2y agoI wrote a extension for a janky old website I used frequently that is broken for Firefox. It’s a simple js file, and I now have a couple dozen subscribers. A nice project.
- ReadCarlBarks 2y agoWhen a site is broken, try using a separate profile to make sure that the problem isn't caused by any of your settings or extensions: https://support.mozilla.org/kb/profile-manager-create-remove-switch-firefox-profiles https://support.mozilla.org/kb/profile-manager-create-remove... If the problem persists, use this form to report it to Mozilla: https://webcompat.com/issues/new https://webcompat.com/issues/new
- donatetomozilla 2y ago[dead]
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoMozilla wants web users to be targeted with online advertising and/or pay for online advertising not Firefox development. Mozilla is an online advertising advocacy project. Just try suggesting to anyone from Mozilla the idea of web without ads. They will be 100% opposed, unwilling to even consider alternatives, as if they are being paid to defend this pro-advertising position. They are indeed being paid indirectly from the coffers of an advertising company. "Free and open web" apparently means web open for advertising. The presence/absence of advertising on the web is a non-negotiable. Mozilla insists advertising is a must-have. Why was the original internet free of ads before it went public. Are there more important uses for a computer network. ISPs privatised the financing for the network. We pay for internet. It is not free. Funding from advertising has never been a necessity. But Mozilla argues advertising is 100% essential.
- shiroiushi 2y ago>But Mozilla argues advertising is 100% essential. Citation needed. I realize they get a ton of money (probably most of their funding in fact) from Google, but still have they actually made such a statement? For now at least, they support ad-blockers a lot better than Chrome (because of Manifest v2).
- ndriscoll 2y agoWhile it doesn't directly say it, their acquisition announcement for Anonym (an ad/tracking company) comes about as close as you can by saying Anonym believes it (and implicitly they support the viewpoint)[0]: > Anonym was founded with two core beliefs: First, that people have a fundamental right to privacy in online interactions and second, that digital advertising is critical for the sustainability of free content, services and experiences. Mozilla and Anonym share the belief that advanced technologies can enable relevant and measurable advertising while still preserving user privacy. Which completely ignores non-profit uses of the web, which is interesting since they're a non-profit and all. They've made similar statements in the past[1]: > Advertisements pay for all those “free” services you love, as well as many of the products you use on a daily basis — including Firefox. There’s nothing inherently wrong with advertising Which is of course true because they don't accept donations to fund Firefox despite people complaining that they want to be able to make such donations for years. [0] https://blog.mozilla.org/en/mozilla/mozilla-anonym-raising-the-bar-for-privacy-preserving-digital-advertising/ https://blog.mozilla.org/en/mozilla/mozilla-anonym-raising-t... [1] https://blog.mozilla.org/en/mozilla/the-future-of-ads-and-privacy/ https://blog.mozilla.org/en/mozilla/the-future-of-ads-and-pr...
- udev4096 2y agoAlthough I am stocked about the new browser getting all the attention it deserves, isn't chromium still the most secure browser to use? How long will Ladybird take to be as secure as chromium?
- TrevorFSmith 2y agoHey, ex-Mozillian here. For the old alt OS people, also an ex-NetPositive dev. With that context, I'm on board with not giving money to Mozilla Corp. Late last year I cancelled my subscriptions to Pocket, the VPN, and recurring donations. That said, I recommend that you support Servo instead of Ladybird. Reason #1) C++ is just dumb in 2024 and choosing it is a big red blinking sign that the devs make bad decisions. Now they're considering a rewrite in a better language? So, starting again from scratch... No thanks! Reason #2) Given the track record of the main author of being an ass to people who aren't willing to be marginalized, I don't have high hopes that he can lead anything as complex as a competitive browser. No, Serenity OS is nowhere near the same level of complexity thanks to el GOOGs insistence that the modern web includes every API found in OSes. Serial port access, really? Anyway, please don't just jump on a hype train. Fund Servo.
- dieulot 2y agoWhere is said track record of the main author being an ass to people who aren't willing to be marginalized, or anything along those lines?
- gatlin 2y ago> Please don't jump on a hype train > Give capital to another project because C++ is "dumb" and Rust is not. I applaud you for disclosing your biases at the top but I was so hoping the disclosure wouldn't be a spoiler for the rest.
- xigoi 2y ago> Given the track record of the main author of being an ass to people who aren't willing to be marginalized That’s a quite strong accusation without any evidence.
- r3db34rd 2y ago[dead]
- jadbox 2y agoHow is Servo going these days? I didn't even know that Servo was still active, but judging on the blog (https://servo.org/blog/ https://servo.org/blog/) it looks like a lot of recent development has been happening. Maybe it would help if Servo had an active browser implementation (beyond the downloadable shell).