4 ms·
>leadership that present anarchist You might see the conflict here in the wording... A successful meme is one that causes itself to be propagated. For example
by pixl97 2y ago
>leadership that present anarchist
You might see the conflict here in the wording...
A successful meme is one that causes itself to be propagated. For example most religions have a tenant of "have kids, teach those kids your religion" and "convert others to your religion". Leadership in a group that says get rid of leadership is never going to be as successful as a group that attempts to acquire more power. Or to say different, it's success measure would be in destroying itself.
- anamexis 2y agoI think you're responding exactly in a way GP is talking about, namely "that they can’t actually evaluate it the way that political philosophers define it." Anarchism does not mean that there are no leaders or leadership.
- AndyNemmity 2y agoAnarchism means there is no unjustified authority.
- pixl97 2y ago>unjustified authority That is a tautology. Who provides the justification and who gave them that authority. The king? The nobles? The learned? The majority? The masses? The individual? The problem with power is it is self justifying. If you have power you can justify anything, and if you do not, you exist at the mercy of those that do. One would think the most rational behavior would be to give those power that want it least (such as anarchists), but human psychology shows that significant portions of humanity want hierarchies and will gladly give their power to put a dictator/king into power.
- AndyNemmity 2y agoNoam Chomsky - "Anarchism is a tendency that is suspicious and skeptical of domination, authority, and hierarchy. It seeks structures of hierarchy and domination in human life over the whole range, extending from, say, patriarchal families to, say, imperial systems, and it asks whether those systems are justified. It assumes that the burden of proof for anyone in a position of power and authority lies on them. Their authority is not self-justifying. They have to give a reason for it, a justification. And if they can’t justify that authority and power and control, which is the usual case, then the authority ought to be dismantled and replaced by something more free and just. And, as I understand it, anarchy is just that tendency. It takes different forms at different times."
- pixl97 2y agoThis is just a continuation of the tautology... In this statement Noam manages to stick his head so far up his own ass that you can see his face inside his mouth... > And if they can’t justify that authority and power and control, which is the usual case, then the authority ought to be dismantled and replaced by By fucking what. Oh yes, by someone/something/some group with power. If you have the power to do this, you have the same power as a brutal dictator. If you have power to tear down these non-self justifying systems, you can use any fucking justification you want to tear it down. At the end of the day power is power. You just hope this power is wielded towards more freedom, but you're just a single orator away from tyranny.
- AndyNemmity 2y ago> By fucking what. By the workers, not the owners of capital. That is justified authority.
- pixl97 2y agoNow pull yourself out of the 1800's and ask that question of the face of further automation and replacement of employees by 'intelligent' machines. Workers rights are just a bullshit statement of the same classification as 'landowner rights'. Human rights should be paramount regardless if you have a job or not. But to have these rights, you must organize and concentrate this power or you'll just be scattered by the owners of capital that have already concentrated their power highly effectively.
- AndyNemmity 2y agoThe topic of the article this thread is about is Anarchism in the 1900s. I would have assumed at least your insults would have been consistent with the article.
- lumb63 2y agoA couple interesting points here. One is the supposition that something which is more “justified” is better. We humans do a lot of things which cannot be justified and are good, so this seems an odd position to me. The other is that “something more free” is coupled with something “more just”, and that that is also better than something which is less justified. The implication here would be that adding more freedom is always more just than something “unjustified”. I don’t think this logically holds, either.
- mejutoco 2y agoWhen you bring your kids to school, you expect the teacher to have some authority over them: to give them homework, ask them questions and stay quiet for at least part of the past. But you dont expect from the teachers corporal punishment, or religious indoctrination, etc. I think most reasonable people would accept this line of thinking without problem.
- laurex 2y agoI don't think anarchism is necessarily "get rid of leadership" - it can be more like "share leadership." In other words, to do this well, you must recognise and dismantle coercive structures and dominance. This of course takes work, but skipping over this work in favour of "output" type work has led to a great deal of output without consideration of consequences. If we learn to be leaders in a context of power-sharing, there's not necessarily a conflict in that power's expansion, though it's hard to make that legible in a world where power is regarded as a resource subject to scarcity.
- dingnuts 2y agoit's not possible to dismantle dominance structures. They're evolutionarily defined in our biology and are primordial. If you ban explicitly stated dominance hierarchies, they merely become implicit. Think about "flat" organizations. On paper, there is no power hierarchy. In reality, you have to join the group and observe to discover who is actually in power, because it's implicit, but there is always someone in power. This is then lamented as "politics." There is no evidence that implicit power structures, especially ones where everyone maintains the lie that there is no power structure at all, are better than explicitly defined power structures. In fact, history presents lots of evidence to the contrary, especially if you read Russian!
- laurex 2y agoDominance is a strategy among the ones we have evolved to employ, but it's not accurate to say it is "wired in" as the primary and inescapable strategy. At least as I understand it, anarchism does not deny our impulses to dominance exist, rather it seeks to put that tendency in check through processes of collaboration and checks to individual power. As soon as you begin introducing an argument that is about states or organziations, it becomes a little muddy, since at least in theory, anarchism is playing a different game, but there are examples even in our current era of rampantly dominant structures of this working at scale. For example, the 12-step programs are designed in such a way that their governance works by essentially anarchist, collectivist principles, and there are millions of people participating in them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AndyNemmity 2y agoAnarchism isn't about getting rid of leadership. It's about asking the question if authority is justified, and if it isn't dismantling it. Certainly there are cases where authority is justified. Just not in the case of unaccountable private dictatorships, or as they are known, corporations.
- goatlover 2y agoWouldn't anarchists also be opposed to the state, and any governments above the local level, which are to be determined democratically?
- AndyNemmity 2y agoNo. It would be justifiable to have a government at a national level democratically controlled to handle foreign policy for example. But it would be a real democracy, and would require consistent ratification from the population. Details on individual tactics like this depend on the technology and situation in existence. It's getting far easier to imagine a world where this is possible.
- orwin 2y agoSee: Switzerland
- lumb63 2y agoAs someone who formerly identified as a libertarian, this is the logic that made me question the position. A philosophy which when empowered aims to minimize its sphere of influence is self-defeating, unfortunately.