11 ms·
Aboriginal ritual passed down over 12,000 years, cave find shows
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- Uptrenda 2y ago[flagged]
- rhplus 2y agoI’m surprised by how tenuous the link is between the cave find and the archival find. Is the bar really that low for claims in archaeological papers or am I missing something? It’s a compelling story, but surely Occam’s razor would conclude that poking sticks into dead animals and fire pits is just what people have done for thousands of years? Where’s the evidence that there was chanting and a healing ceremony? Edit: full paper is freely available on Nature here: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-024-01912-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-024-01912-w
- gerdesj 2y ago"Each one was found in a separate fireplace around the size of the palm of a hand—far too small to have been used for heat or cooking meat. The slightly charred ends of the sticks had been cut specially to stick into the fire, and both were coated in human or animal fat." That's rather more than circumstantial evidence. Granted the ritual might have changed a bit over 12,000 odd years but where else have you seen people poke sticks into tiny hearth's?
- bena 2y agoIt’s all circumstantial evidence because that’s all we get. Circumstantial evidence is not “weak evidence”, it is evidence concerning the circumstances. For instance, DNA is circumstantial evidence. It’s evidence that can imply a connection between events, but it is not proof of such a connection. Fingerprints: circumstantial. Call logs: often circumstantial. The opposite of circumstantial evidence is direct evidence. Direct evidence is rarer and often not as useful. Direct evidence would be an actual witness to the event. To call back to prior examples: Fingerprints are direct evidence someone touched something. But they are circumstantial evidence they then used that object in commission of a crime. Here, the direct evidence is that things were burned and sticks were sharpened. The circumstances in which they were found implies the rest.
- shiroiushi 2y agoThis sounds like something out of law school, where for some reason "direct evidence" is oddly treated as superior to "circumstantial evidence". So, for instance, you could have a murder, and the prime suspect's fingerprints were found at the scene and on the murder weapon too. However, an eyewitness testifies that he saw the murder committed not by the prime suspect, but instead by furry space aliens who then departed in their UFO. We're supposed to believe the witness? After all the knowledge we have now about how utterly unreliable and frankly worthless most human testimony is, you'd think our courts would stop treating it as worthy of a conviction.
- ertgbnm 2y agoArchaeology is almost exclusively circumstantial evidence...
- tengwar2 2y agoIt varies a lot. Later European archaeology is generally quite well-founded as it ties in to a historical record. While I don't have any familiarity with the Colosseum, I have heard that there are records of payments to sailors for manipulating the shades. If you get further away from historical records, it does get more tenuous, but there is often a solid basis of scientific or technical evidence. My own doctorate is in use of physics for dating by thermoluminescence and optically stimulated luminescence, which together cover a lot of ground for stuff that cannot be dated by C14. There are several quantitative techniques like that, for instance for isotopic analysis which can be used for deducing trade routes. There are also many qualitative and semi-quantitative techniques, varying from traditional trenches and ground penetrating radar to pollen analysis (which gives you information on climate and ground cover). However all of this has to be tied together in to a picture of human culture. That necessarily has a large element of interpretation. This is not unique - you can see the same pattern in fields like astronomy. Generally I think archaeologists are reasonably good at knowing when they are on uncertain ground. If I may give an example: in Scotland, mainly on the north west coasts, there are the remains of pre-historic buildings called brochs. The biggest stands 40' high, and it is possible to walk up through the stairs between the double walls to the top. We know roughly when they were built, but not why. There are several theories, but I find it interesting that there is an absence of dogmatic assertion that one particular interpretation is true, and it is still possible to have a sensible discussion about a "fringe" theory (my own idea is that some of them may have been for excarnation) which will centre on what evidence you might need to search for (bone fragments in this case).
- gwern 2y agoIf they had been doing the ritual regularly enough to preserve it for over 12,000 years in a relatively small range, it seems surprising that the excavations didn't turn up way more instances than it did. They can find 2 perfect instances within centuries of each other 12kya in the same excavation, then it just teleports without a trace to the 1880s? This sounds more like a birthday paradox. There are so many rituals and superstitions in indigenous peoples over the millennia that it would be shocking if you could never find cases of things that looked vaguely similar when reduced to an archaeological residue and you cast a net as wide as 'anything which anyone has ever described which sounds similar no matter how many millennia'. (I would also note that 'fat smeared on stuff and involving fires' is not nearly as rare as it might sound. Fat is important and used in many sacrifices or medicines - eg Homer, with all that fat wrapped on or stacked on top of bones in a holocaust to the gods.)
- stubish 2y agoIts a stick in the ground. People might have tripped over thousands of them, and millions lost to the elements and time. This find was only noticed because someone with the right specialized knowledge was looking in a specific location for artifacts, bothered to test the stick, and managed to link it to an obscure document written 150 years earlier, itself amazing that this particular ritual from this particular region was documented, unlike the unknown but huge number that were not. It is surprising we find this sort of thing at all. They might have cooked their lunch with a 35,000 year old stick without realizing it.
- gwern 2y ago> People might have tripped over thousands of them Obviously not, because when these guys tripped over them, they were struck enough to then spend years looking for explanations. > unlike the unknown but huge number that were not. The more that are not documented, the more plausible it becomes that vaguely similar rituals which yield the same residue may exist in many times and places, and enter into the sum total of rituals available for birthday-paradox collision. Arguing that it must be the same with zero intervening evidence is like arguing that that because an Aboriginal word for dog is 'dog' (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mbabaram_language#Word_for_%22dog%22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mbabaram_language#Word_for_%22...) both Mbararam and English must be descended from the same language which existed hundreds of thousands of years ago and have remarkably preserved one word for all that time. What are the odds?!
- iLoveOncall 2y ago[flagged]
- the-smug-one 2y agoI really don't think that watching documentaries are equivalent to being able to discerning anything about an academic field. That reminds me of reading press releases to understand scientific papers, which we all understand to be a junk way of doing it.
- ninetyninenine 2y agoPsychology as well is built on a house of cards.
- bowsamic 2y agoI have a PhD in physics and even physics itself is in a poor state, yet I totally get why all the other sciences envy physics: they're even worse
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThis is explained by complexity. The more components involved in a field, the less feasible the scientific method is. (E.g. math > physics > chemistry > materials science > cell biology > human biology > psychology > sociology)
- ninetyninenine 2y agoMath is not a science. Math is fundamentally opposite of science. In science nothing can be proven. Proof is exclusively the domain of mathematics. The Lack of proof is foundational to science, it’s built into the core axiom of the scientific method. This axiom is actually the reason why science is so “bad” because nothing can really be confirmed. But something like psychology is on a whole different level because of the replication crisis. Psychology has outright fraud going on.
- gadders 2y ago[flagged]
- decremental 2y ago[dead]
- ecjhdnc2025 2y agoI know we're supposed to ascribe the most benevolent motive to a comment. So the above is both rather absurd and also rather patronising.
- gadders 2y agoSimilar things are happening in NZ: https://thespinoff.co.nz/atea/14-11-2022/busting-the-myths-about-matauranga-maori https://thespinoff.co.nz/atea/14-11-2022/busting-the-myths-a...
- nemo44x 2y agoIt’s such a weird pissing contest because if you’re alive today that means your ancestors survived to produce you and that’s saying something as most groups and cultures, etc have not survived to the present day. So just surviving as a group for thousands of years is quite the accomplishment. That’s good enough.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mistermann 2y agoHave you ever watched US State Department press briefings, and paid close attention to how they use language (ie: "X is linked to Y")? Or, heard the public subsequently discussing what was said in them (say, right here on HN)? Humans are a story based species...always have been always will be. Stories are our weak spot, the ultimate attack/control vector.
- walterbell 2y ago> Stories are our weak spot, the ultimate attack/control vector. Stories (and LLM 'story models') can be fine tuned and A/B tested against humans with live neural monitoring to evaluate narrative effectiveness.
- mistermann 2y ago"Evaluate", on what scale? Donald Trump can tell a story (which is what all humans run on) adequate to motivate thousands of people up to no good to descend upon the nation's capital, do you think LLM's (science, etc) can compete in that specific arena/domain, at that level? (To be fair though, the Normies have been motivated to do more than a few silly things themselves by their trainers. Donald is good, but he ain't the best.) There are readings of brain activity, and then there is brain activity that causes humans to do particular things with their bodies. One of these is more powerful than the other. (Pardon for the vitriol, no offense intended.)
- walterbell 2y ago12 years ago, https://www.motherjones.com/criminal-justice/2012/04/department-of-defense-neuroscience-bioethics-brains-law/ https://www.motherjones.com/criminal-justice/2012/04/departm... > FY2012 budget states a plan to “initiate investigations into the relationship between…neurotransmitters such as oxytocin, emotion-cognition interactions, and narrative structures.” What has transpired since then is left as an exercise for the reader.
- busterarm 2y agoHave to agree here. Also just kind of doesn't pass the common sense test. We all learn the "game of telephone" as a kid and how information can change even just being passed once. In fact I've heard archaeologists in the past specifically say that no oral tradition can survive intact more than 100 years. Usually this statement is in reference to certain creation myths being relatively modern inventions. A claim of 12000 years needs strong evidence. Given what I've seen from the field lately I have a counter-theory, but I'm not really comfortable sharing.
- cess11 2y agoWhere I grew up "game of telephone" didn't include repetition over and over and over again. It also didn't include meter or rhymes.
- busterarm 2y agoOkay. Take Shakespeare then. https://thegreatthinkers.org/shakespeare-and-politics/bibliography/brief-discussion-editorial-problems-various-editions-shakespeares-plays/ https://thegreatthinkers.org/shakespeare-and-politics/biblio...
- cess11 2y agoConfirms what I'm hinting at, through tradition a version is consolidated that becomes the consensus and can reach a very long-lived stability.
- alfiopuglisi 2y agoPlease do share! Often those are the most interesting ones :)
- danans 2y ago> In fact I've heard archaeologists in the past specifically say that no oral tradition can survive intact more than 100 years. Usually this statement is in reference to certain creation myths being relatively modern inventions. Maybe you meant 1000 years? If you really meant 100 years, there's an obvious counterexample: The "Happy Birthday Song", published in 1893. Arguably no one learns it by reading the words and notes from a page. Furthermore, considering that until pretty recently in history most people were illiterate, the stories they learned were transmitted to them orally (even if read from a book).
- ars 2y agoI came to post the same thing. You have a stick from 12,000 years ago, and a story from 100 years ago, and they link them because of a similarity "there is fat at the end of the stick". You could get fat on a stick by roasting a small mouse (so a small hearth), or tons of other ways. This really isn't enough evidence, not without a ton more findings of the same thing at various dates over the timeperiod.
- griffzhowl 2y agoIf tiny hearths with fat-covered sticks were common elsewhere, this would be a valid objection. But as it is, this seems to be a distinctive practice that is present at the same location separated by 12k years, and the ancient one was buried and so not observed for most of that time. What's the alternative explanation except a common root in a cultural practice?
- griffzhowl 2y agoIt's actually not that far-fetched when you consider the long view of human history. Hominins have been capable of cultural transmission for millions of years, and during most of that time it made most sense to repeat what the previous generation had done as closely as possible, since they had by definition survived and reproduced well enough to make a new generation. Among all those practices of toolmaking, hunting strategies, herbal knowledge, and whatever we call 'ritual', it wouldn't have been clear to the practitioners which were actually effective at increasing survival and which not, so everything gets repreated over generations (with occasional modifications catching on and producing cultural evolution ofc)
- Almondsetat 2y ago[flagged]
- jplrssn 2y agoThat was a cultural ritual, not scientific research. What scientific basis is there for Christmas or Thanksgiving?
- Almondsetat 2y agoIt's a healing ritual as per the article, it either works more than random chance or it doesn't
- wincy 2y agoNow now we aren’t allowed to assert that our culture is better or worse than any other, that is an inviolable cardinal sin for our pristine progressive rationalist minds. We have all of modern pharmacology and they have tiny sticks poked into burning animals in the fireplace. Different healing rituals for different folks.
- scotty79 2y agoThey more or less survived 12000 years healing themselves like that. Let's check back in 12000 years of what medicine that actually works leads to.
- galdosdi 2y agoConsidering what a huge percentage of modern US health ailments are self inflicted through lifestyle, it's hard to imagine future generations wouldn't look at our cars and our big macs with the same patronizing quaint view as we would healing with burning sticks. The modern person who sticks to a healthy lifestyle while still having modern medicine for emergencies and misfortunes will surely live better than just about anyone in the past, but, that person is not the actual average. The average person nowadays has their health dragged down by modern lifestyle problems so much, that I'm not sure if they're better off than someone in the past[1], even with modern medicine [1]: Cherry picking a pretty recent past, though. For example, the obesity epidemic was way less in full swing in 1970, but we already had modern sanitation, antibiotics, and vaccines by then, which eliminated the lions' share of illness. Once you go back before vaccines, it's a mixed bag. Still hard to say though, the diabetes epidemic is getting almost as bad as polio once was and trend lines keep pointing upwards.
- the-smug-one 2y agoVery cool :-). I don't know that much about the natives of Australia and their history, I wonder how many of these oral traditions have been written down. An immediate google gave me this document, seems interesting at a glance: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/159354575.pdf https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/159354575.pdf
- sandworm101 2y agoWhen I lived on the west coast a native friend of mine spoke of how some elders no longer wanted stories to be written down. They have seen how their oral stories get documented, effectively transforming them from a living secret into a fixed text in a dead book. The book then goes on a shelf, fodder for the endless stream of anthropology classes taught ay universities in distant cities. More people read the story in the book than ever come to listen to the story in person. After a few decades of this pattern, young anthologists are now hearing stories and asking questions about why the story today is possibly slightly different than what was written down a decade prior. There is an old stereotype of western Indians believing that cameras could capture one's soul. That is something to think about when we "document" an oral tradition.
- parasti 2y agoI come from a background with a strong folk singing tradition, and this reminds me of the two camps of folk singers within it: the purists who want to preserve the "original" tempo, lyrics, melody as it was recorded and documented a century ago and who frown upon deviation from that, and the modernists who adapt, improvise and reinterpret folk songs as they see fit.
- renewiltord 2y agoInteresting. I do like the documentation for immortality but with stories there is an obsession with "the actual" or "the original" and many people equate legibility with originality. "Source? The original documented here is blah blah". Sampling a continuous process once and describing it as the process. "The original value of sin(t) is sqrt(3)/2."
- 2y ago
- namanaggarwal 2y agoFascinating. Growing up in a Hindu household, a lot of our festivals involve listening to origin stories of the customs. A lot of those have of course been glorified to add an element of holiness, but it's possible they are actually derived from some small incident happened in the past. Like a butterfly effect, a small insignificant event leading to a major celebration for billion people continued over centuries
- bl4ckm0r3 2y agoI think you just found out the roots of every religion.
- mistermann 2y agoEvery ideology would be a more accurate story, though perhaps less satisfying.
- liquidpele 2y agoUh.. no?
- swatcoder 2y agoAn ideology can be seen as a collection of rituals in action, reasoning, and rhetoric situated among core beliefs about what life is, what the world is, and what's important to them. And each ideology has a specific history of events, founders, and later elaborators that shape what these rituals and beliefs are. Many ideologies reject deities or are at least ambivalent about them, but they're not really operationally different than religions. So for as much as little bits of history linger in relgious rituals, both blurred and resharpened in later years, the same is absolutely true for ideologies. The capitalism or feminism or humanism or atheism or whatever else you point to today is similar to the one sharing its name in the past, or in some other region, but is not the same, and these differences are all vestiges of little seed events that happened here or there.
- knallfrosch 2y ago[flagged]
- xattt 2y agoLikely suppressed by Colonialists.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Staple_Diet 2y agoWhen white Europeans invaded Australia they disrupted and displaced many indigenous people, either incidentally via colonising farmland, or intentionally via snatching kids and putting them in boarding schools etc. Slaughters/massacres also occurred, especially early in colonisation. Given indigenous Australians favoured oral storytelling rather than written records a great many traditions and histories were lost during that time. While efforts by Europeans to catalogue and record traditions has occurred (as seen in this piece), only in the past few decades have many tribes/nations been able to properly explore and research their past. A recent example I can cite, anecdotally, was an Aboriginal man who told me he was only able to learn his native language* because German missionaries has recorded it in the 1800s and released the records back to the people a century later. * There's hundreds of indigenous dialects throughout Australia.
- gizajob 2y agoYou’ve read Bruce Pascoe? His reputation tarnished or otherwise, Dark Emu was a brilliant book for me.
- xandrius 2y ago[flagged]
- v101 2y ago[flagged]
- gizajob 2y agoNo
- cschmidt 2y agoAnother article on the same topic: https://cosmosmagazine.com/history/archaeology/indigenous-australia-ritual-12000-years https://cosmosmagazine.com/history/archaeology/indigenous-au...
- discordance 2y agoHopefully Rio Tinto don’t blow it up: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/may/26/rio-tinto-blasts-46000-year-old-aboriginal-site-to-expand-iron-ore-mine https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/may/26/rio-t...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- RoboTeddy 2y ago> slightly charred ends of the sticks had been cut specially to stick into the fire, and both were coated in human or animal fat. Wait, what? Where did they get human fat from…?
- 4star3star 2y agoI also found this concerning.
- alecst 2y agoIn two books I've read recently (Conquistador about Hernan Cortes, and Civilized to Death which contrasts the lives of modern humans with ancient ones) the authors mention how fat was often poached from the dead -- animals and people alike. It was used like a grease for all sorts of things, including filling wounds to prevent infection. Pretty interesting stuff.
- hbossy 2y agoAustralians practiced ritualized cannibalism and infanticide as late as XIX century.
- delichon 2y agoI'm from a Jewish family that has been unable to pass down its rituals over the past few generations. My great-grandparents were observant on both sides. I have no religion or inherited rituals to speak of. So how does a ritual get successfully passed down for something like 500 generations? What must the observer get from it that motivated them so strongly to pass it along with the necessary vigor? Was it something in the ritual itself, perhaps an altered state drug experience? Or was the motivation just cultural? Is there anything in our culture that could possibly have such staying power, or is our cultural temperature so high that nothing can survive for long?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- troupo 2y ago> So how does a ritual get successfully passed down for something like 500 generations? There's literally nothing else but this. > motivated them so strongly to pass it along with the necessary vigor? There's no vigor. There are almost no outside influences. There's almost no rebellious thought. You're raised into this life, and you know the rituals by heart from a young age. > Is there anything in our culture that could possibly have such staying power, Any isolated/primitive culture with no outside influences. Throughout the 20th century ethnographers collected thousands of such rituals before they disappeared after contact with the outside world.
- pvg 2y agoYou can still go to or host, say, a Seder, no? That kind of cultural transmission doesn't rely on individual families but in the case of the rituals of Judaism and lots of other religions it seems to have been fairly effective.
- ozmodiar 2y agoI assume by unable you mean they had to stop due to persecution? It sounds from this article that this practice that had survived so long also hit an abrupt stop when faced with persecution from colonizers (at least that's why I'm assuming they have to go by records from 1880 and not just ask the current practitioners). I think this says more about the ability for persecution to shut down a cultural practice more than any quality that practice has to have to survive.
- empath75 2y ago> "Australia kept the memory of its first peoples alive thanks to a powerful oral tradition that enabled it to be passed on," Delannoy said. > "However in our societies, memory has changed since we switched to the written word, and we have lost this sense." I sort of think that this is a "what's water?" thing, because a lot of our ancient prehistorical traditions and practices that continued into the historical era and beyond are so embedded with how we see how ourselves and act and behave that it's impossible for us to even notice them. There's a lot that we have looked at in ancient sites and have just known what the purpose was for because we still do the same thing now, or at least we had recorded uses for it from historical texts, it's just said to be "obvious" and not really worth commenting about how interesting it is that we preserved these oral traditions. There's a kind of exoticism/noble savage thing going on here, I think.
- tivert 2y agoYeah. I can think of one ritual that's probably even older: burying the dead. However what interesting about this tradition is the degree of specificity that was preserved with this ritual (e.g. stick of same type of wood, coated with fat, put in a small fire to break), none of which has any real practical purpose.
- spacecadet 2y agoIts always awesome to read about finding early human tools and techniques. But, could the sticks have been 12,000 years old, but the event far less? Lots of people asking how they had human fat... you poke someone's wound with a hot stick, there is probably fat on it after. So they may have been using cauterization. They may also have been cooking small animals while trying to avoid the light, smell, and smoke plume a larger fire creates. Which would attract predators.
- dudeinjapan 2y agoIt had kangaroo fat too, leading me to infer that they were trying to create a super-race of human-kangaroo hybrids.
- spacecadet 2y agoI mean not much else to do back then but poke shit with sticks, am I right?
- sambeau 2y agoIt occurred to me recently that tig/tag has probably been passed down through oral tradition from child to child for millennia. It's possible that it's older than homo-sapiens, older than the taming of fire. Millions of years of tradition. And it still being passed on orally, child-to-child.
- psychoslave 2y agoWhat is tig/tag?
- BurningFrog 2y agoMy parents failed me too on that!
- popol12 2y agoI guess https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tag_(game) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tag_(game)
- angstrom 2y agoMy three-year-old daughter plays this with cat. It's a cross-species thing that is possibly part of mammalian brain development in origin. The cat is less than one year old. Our 17 year old cat does not engage in this at all and hisses at the kitten for even trying to start a game of tag. This makes me wonder if that origin is more related to predator/prey.
- ViktorRay 2y agoIn regards to your 17 year old cat… All mammalian species have something in common. When mammals are young we all love playing. This is true for humans, dogs, elephants, primates, cats and so on. But play ends up disappearing as the mammal gets older. Compare a playful baby elephant to an adult elephant. The baby elephant loves playing. Not just with other elephants but with humans and dogs and so on. But older elephants are more likely to watch and less likely to play. This is why your 1 year old cat loves playing while your 17 year old cat doesn’t. It’s a very interesting phenomenon
- openrisk 2y agoIts impossible to tell, but the sense of passage of time must have been dramatically different in earlier periods of human development. Persistent rituals passed on from elders to youngsters, oral transmission of huge poems and other such "low tech" information tools must have given some structure to what otherwise might have felt as an eternal reboot.
- tolerance 2y agoThe persistency that you're describing is key. I'd like to think that previous generations were far more content with time and what is associated with it. The mundane of the day-by-day, aging, death, etc.
- Anon84 2y agoI read somewhere (don't recall exactly where) that your sense of the passage of time is directly related to how much things change because that impacts how many memories you form. Essentially, when every day is the same, not many new memories are created, so you don't notice time passing (New Years was just a few weeks ago, how can it be July already!), but when things are constantly changing, time passes much more slowly. When you're a child and non-stop learning and exploring, 3 months seems like an eternity. I wonder if technology development has a similar effect. When the world essentially remains unchanged for your entire life, things must seem much faster with days blending together.
- qingcharles 2y agoHaving been to jail, here's what they say, "the days pass like years, and the years pass like days." Which is a hugely accurate interpretation of what happens. Nothing happens all day, and every day is the same, so the days drag on in the most mind-numbingly tedious fashion. But then you wake up and you notice six months have passed without you being able to name a single thing that happened.
- biztos 2y agoHerzog talks about this a bit in his cave-painting movie[0]. It's fascinating to think that for thousands of years, our ancestors lived without any significant change to their world. I like to imagine that they were pretty happy with that (subject to the normal animal stresses of survival) -- but as you say, it's impossible to tell. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cave_of_Forgotten_Dreams https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cave_of_Forgotten_Dreams Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmMUlNeLApU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmMUlNeLApU
- mritchie712 2y agothis ritual likely had a real effect on the person (similar to placebo effect). They probably wouldn't have kept it up for 12k years if they weren't getting some tangible improvement.
- xdennis 2y agoMultiple religions are thousands of years old and they can't all be true.
- llamaimperative 2y agoPlacebo effect absolutely can yield effects for all religions. That's pretty much what's interesting about it: it doesn't matter much what stimulus is producing the effect.
- adrianN 2y agoThey don't have to be true to have an effect on people.
- tgv 2y agoI think it argues against the claim that it must have had a (real) healing effect for it to be passed along. People are quick to call in the placebo effect, as a scientific sounding explanation, but is nobody reminded of faith healing? People get up out of wheel chairs, cast away their crutches and say they've been healed.
- krapp 2y ago>but is nobody reminded of faith healing? People get up out of wheel chairs, cast away their crutches and say they've been healed. That's just common fakery.
- greenhearth 2y agoIt doesn't sound like anything pure religious, but more of a psychotherapeutic technique, probably coupled with some folk medicine too.
- utkarsh858 2y agoIn India, there is a custom of passing ancient knowledge through poetic verses. Every poetic verses is sung in a specific 'meter'. If there is a discrepancy in recitation then remembering and passing knowledge 'letter by letter' can not succeed. Many of the verses are thousands of years old. I read some describing an ancient extinct river ~7000 years ago, later rediscovered through satellite imagery (don't know the right term).
- dyauspitr 2y agoThe river is the Sarasvati.
- RandomCitizen12 2y agoThat's an interesting way to do a checksum
- nsenifty 2y agoThe metre is a basic checksum, but there are more elaborated systems (pathas) of chanting verses that aids in correct learning and memorization. Some of it is described here - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vedic_chant#Oral_transmission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vedic_chant#Oral_transmission An example in action - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLdq15ptqUs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLdq15ptqUs
- swatcoder 2y agoYeah, in language that suits HN, formal poetic structure amounts to error correction in oral tradition. It dramatically narrows the possibilities of what idea or word or sound or whatever could fit in any particular place in the verse, making it easier to memorize and accurately recite. Clever (and some blundering) poets and changes in language still set up these recitations to evolve away from whatever they originally were, but the original seeds linger a long, long time.
- verisimi 2y agoYes poetry is a sort of decent checksum. However I think parables are an even better checksum, as they can be translated also, but if the meaning is altered the story fails to be coherent. Parables are imo, the best form of information transference across time, imo.
- poulpy123 2y agoIt's not the first time that I read hypothesis of Aboriginal oral traditions that stayed for much longer than anywhere else in the world. I wonder why it would be the case there and not elsewhere
- brabel 2y agoProbably because they were some of the only ones to remain almost entirely isolated from the rest of the world while civilization was happening elsewhere. They never developed writing. The rest of the word was quite likely very similar to them before writing. The article mentions that because we have invented writing, passing down oral traditions became much less important to us, and hence our societies have "lost" some of the old tales, paradoxically. That's because while people write down things they think is important, they couldn't have known that unlike oral information (which adapts as language evolves, imperfectly but enough to keep the basic structure of the original), the means on which they write decay rapidly, and due to the speed at which language evolves (without modern technology, a few hundred years is enough for isolated regions to develop their own language branches), much of what was written in the distant past would become unintelligible even to people living in the area, even if it managed to survive (though modern techniques using computers seem to have made it easier to do so). Not to mention that in much of the world, civilizations were constantly being replaced by newer ones or migrating to different areas as their neighbors expanded and faded. Much of the ancient texts in any given area would make no sense to the new inhabitants, who would have no qualms about destroying everything (in fact, they probably burned everything down as soon as they conquered a new area). Basically, the written word turned out to be much less resilient than people probably believed it would be. I think we are making the same mistake with digital information. It may look "eternal" but try to find websites from the early internet, for example. Almost everything is disappearing quickly.
- fsckboy 2y ago>Probably because they were some of the only ones to remain almost entirely isolated from the rest of the world while civilization was happening elsewhere. and, migrating farthest from Africa (can tell by red-shift :) they git the oldest branch of our oldest stories
- rhelz 2y agoKinda sad that the ritual was a way to curse somebody. 12,000 years of hurting each other. Side Node: computer programing is kinda cool. It is a set of incantations which actually does work. EDIT: Hello, all you down-voters and people who say I should read the article before commenting :-) I to, don't like it when people just start commenting without reading the article. I also don't like it when people take what a pop-sci writer too seriously. In this case, I was interested enough to read the original article in Nature, where it says this practice was for cursing (see quote at the end) Don't forget Gell-Man's Amnesia :-) "Howitt described how magic was employed to harm a victim using a ritual fire and a wooden object smeared or attached with a piece of human or animal fat (major sources of lipids): “In all these tribes a general, I may say almost an universal, prac- tice has been to procure some article belonging to the intended victim. A piece of his hair, some of his faeces, a bone picked by him and dropped, a shred of his opossum rug, or at the present time of his clothes, will suffice, or if nothing else can be got he may be watched until he is seen to spit, when his saliva is carefully picked up with a piece of wood and made use of for his destruction..."
- notjtrig 2y ago>One ritual involved tying something that belonged to a sick person to the end of a throwing stick smeared in human or kangaroo fat. The stick was thrust into the ground before a small fire was lit underneath. >"The mulla-mullung would then chant the name of the sick person, and once the stick fell, the charm was complete," a Monash University statement said.
- armoredkitten 2y agoWhere are you getting that from? The article states it was a healing ritual -- the ritual was something done to someone who was already sick. Presumably...to make them better. I have no idea where you got the idea that it was intended as a curse.
- rhelz 2y agosigh yet another victim of pop-sci.....I've edited the OP with an explanation.
- oigursh 2y agoInterplanetary Generation Ships might have a chance?
- aadhavans 2y agoSlightly off-topic, but I recently learned that the Aboriginals may have had contact with Tamil people from South India. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamil_bell?useskin=vector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamil_bell?useskin=vector
- pradn 2y agoThere are a few examples of oral cultures ensuring perfect transmission across a large expanse of time. One example is the several different recitation styles used to memorize Sanskrit verses. These methods give memorizers multiple ways to remember a line, and also prevent errors like the inadvertent mixing of adjacent words (" euphonic combination"). The "checksumming schemes" are far more elaborate than you'd imagine. [1] The result is perfect transmission of text and its pronunciation, including pitch accent. Another example is a "multi-party verification" scheme in some Aboriginal Australian cultures. "... storytelling among contemporary Aboriginal people can involve the deliberate tracking of teaching responsibilities. For example, a man teaches the stories of his country to his children. His son has his knowledge of those stories judged by his sister’s children—for certain kin are explicitly tasked with ensuring that those stories are learned and recounted properly—and people take those responsibilities seriously. ... the 'owner-manager' relationship, requiring a story to be discussed explicitly across three generations of a patriline, constitutes a cross-generational mechanism which may be particularly successful at maximising precision in replication of a story across successive generations". [2] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vedic_chant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vedic_chant [2]: "Aboriginal Memories of Inundation of the Australian Coast Dating from More than 7000 Years Ago", Patrick D. Nunn, https://doi.org/10.1080/00049182.2015.1077539 https://doi.org/10.1080/00049182.2015.1077539
- abc_lisper 2y agoI think the harsh conditions in Australia, where there a thousand ways to die, put the onus on truth and preservation of it in the oral tradition. Unlike most other cultures where it's kind of ok to gradually deviate from the truth. It is worth paying attention to the aborigine stories.They have also made astronomical observations that are pretty accurate to the date. https://cosmosmagazine.com/space/australias-indigenous-people-made-accurate-astronomical-observations-millennia-before-western-scientists/ https://cosmosmagazine.com/space/australias-indigenous-peopl... Singing/Ballads are also popular way of preserving information fidelity. Homer's works were based on ballads. We don't put premium on memory now, but before the invention of printing press, memory techniques were widely studied and used.
- 2y ago
- swayvil 2y agoWhen you understand it you call it "science" or "technology". When you don't understand it you call it "religion" or "ritual". These are smart people. Just like us. Time is money for them just like it is for us. They probably had a very good, practical reason to do this "ritual". As surely as tapping keyboards.
- dudeinjapan 2y agoIncorrect. "Science" is "science" because it works in a reproducible fashion--same applies to "technology", "modern medicine", etc. We don't have to fully grok a how a medicine works (example: SSRI anti-depressants) understand basically that it does work. We do need a double-blind study however. "Rituals" need not have any efficacy at all. Surely burning a stick smeared in kangaroo fat does nothing to cure ailments. It's entirely possible the only reason is "this is what our tribe has always done." Certainly rituals create tribe cohesion and can have a placebo effect, but it is a fallacy to equate these things to science-based medicine. "Tapping keyboards" is not a "ritual"--we are not typing to appease the great silicon gods--we are doing it as means of communication and performing economically valuable work. Rituals which do seem to work, e.g. plant-based medicine, can be used as an "intuition pump" for scientific study. The fact that a plant has been used for thousands of years is a good sign that it may have some effect, but that effect still needs to be verified.
- dkarl 2y agoI think you're assuming they're a lot smarter than us, not "just like us."
- swayvil 2y agoNot smarter, just different. People in Germany speak German. I can't speak German. That doesn't make them smarter.
- userabchn 2y agoIn Indonesia there are 35k+ year old cave "paintings" of hand imprints, and apparently it is still a custom for some in the area to put their hand imprint on their house. It's probably in the same area where just today they announced finding the oldest cave painting: https://www.reuters.com/science/worlds-oldest-cave-painting-indonesia-shows-pig-people-2024-07-03/ https://www.reuters.com/science/worlds-oldest-cave-painting-....
- jnurmine 2y agoOne thing that caught my eye was "both were coated in human or animal fat" and "throwing stick smeared in human or kangaroo fat". I mean the "human fat" part, that seemed strange. Getting human fat non-lethally is probably impossible using technology from 12000 years ago. If the fat was obtained from a human corpse, it would rule out at least burying the body. But still, wouldn't obtaining the fat from a non-buried corpse disturb the deceased on some religious-spiritual level? Or was it common to mutilate dead enemies or something like that? Edit: Oh, OK, I saw others asking the same question and replies which shed light on this.
- classified 2y agoHad those people lived by our enlightened standards, it would never have come to that. Replication of ritual would have drawn lawsuits for copyright infringement and brand dilution. No wonder they never became filthy rich.
- ryzvonusef 2y ago> One stick was 11,000 years old and the other 12,000 years old, radiocarbon dating found. so there were two sticks, at the same site/ritual, but one stick was a 1000 years older than the other? does that mean the ancestors of the present day people were coming to this location for the ritual for a 1000 years? but then for some reason stopped? This is so fascinating!
- barbariangrunge 2y agoImagine a smartphone lasting even 12 years