10 ms·
Coffee helped the Union in the Civil War
- vonnik 2y agoI never thought of Caffeine as the Pervitin of the civil war… or pervitin as the caffeine of WWII
- agtech_andy 2y agoIt is a very compelling article and nice to read about the Liberian farmer entreprenuer, but the South also had tea, tobacco, and yaupon (black drink) which are all stimulants.
- jb1991 2y agoAs the article states, it wasn't just stimulant qualities, it was also for morale. Imagine having no choice but to drink tea after decades of very rapid cultural absorption of coffee by every person.
- leereeves 2y agoWouldn't the lack of tobacco have similar effects on Union soldiers' morale?
- saalweachter 2y agoI'm curious now. The Union had some tobacco production -- 50 million pounds compared to 225 for the Confederacy. Was that enough for morale? Also, it looks like cigarettes weren't popular until after the Civil War. What would the morale hit be like for Civil War era pipe/cigar smokers running short, versus the meltdowns experienced by cigarette smokers?
- analog31 2y agoIndeed, I live in Wisconsin, and we were a tobacco growing state at one time. You still see old tobacco drying barns here and there. The folklore is that we grew the cheap stuff that was mixed with the nice stuff from further south, but during war time, it might have been a different set of priorities.
- saalweachter 2y agoActually, I wonder how much of the tobacco crop was for domestic consumption anyway -- it looks like 40 million pounds was going to the UK per year; that implies that a good portion of the 225 million pounds the South produced wasn't being withheld from the North. So I'm guessing the North had plenty of tobacco for domestic consumption.
- Projectiboga 2y agoMass market factory produced cigarettes came later in America. They were first mass produced in France around 1845, a guy in Mexico made first rolling machine. Here they were first sold for factory workers to have a quick smoke during breaks. Before that was cigars and more commonly pipes. There may have been hand rolled ones but the explosion of use happened after their manufacture was consolidated and mechanized. Also when they got taxed and had to carry tax markings. Cigars were hand rolled in dirty conditions until in NYC the industry was consolidated in the name of public health (big business grab). https://www.historyextra.com/period/modern/a-brief-history-of-smoking/ https://www.historyextra.com/period/modern/a-brief-history-o... When were cigarettes first mass-produced? In 1881, James Bonsack invented a machine that could produce 120,000 cigarettes a day. He joined forces with Washington Duke’s son and in their first year they produced 10 million cigarettes – more than they could sell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cigarette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cigarette
- richardw 2y agoFor a short while but surely reduced access to smoking would improve performance in the medium term? Both are obviously possibilities and it would be good to know if anyone had an answer.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoYou can smoke all day and be stimulated around the clock. Try drinking coffee all day every 30 minutes and you’d be bent over on the latreen after your tenth cup by noon.
- gerdesj 2y ago"You can smoke all day and be stimulated around the clock." .. and find out that you have trouble breathing after minimal exertion. I gave up fags after 30 odd years (20 or so a day), six years ago. I could drink coffee every 30 mins and no I won't be hitting the bog. I can quite happily drink "really shite" coffee - that awful desiccated stuff, but I go for 1/2 teaspoon of it and no milk. I start my day off with decent coffee at home and at weekends (bean to cup) - that's 85% Aribica and 15% Robusta, for me. Thank you Genoa! We gave you cricket and football, you gave us coffee as the good Lord intended it.
- IncreasePosts 2y agoYes, but the union soldiers could not have been smoking for 30 years, because they were on average 25 years old. You probably won't notice a major effect until you've been smoking for decades.
- gerdesj 2y agoIt's not that simple and sadly: "probably" doesn't always work out the way you want it to. For every Dot Cotton puffing away into her 90s, there is someone who dies in their 20s. Fairly recently: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-56801794 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-56801794 yes, the girl suffered from diagnosed severe asthma. The Coroner gave air pollution as the cause of death. Who knows what would have happened if she was a smoker, but I think we can make an educated guess. My mum suffered from severe asthma (and hay fever) - enough to have to go to hospital on many occasions. However she never lived in an environment like that girl nor did she really smoke. Oh apart from three years in London and that was back when lead was in petrol. Hmmm. Anecdotes are not data but I do recommend you avoid fags. Relying on the usual "my gran smoked woodbines until she was 105 and tripped over her old man" is not a particularly clever life choice. With hindsight I bothered to notice loads of effects that I had glossed over for years.
- silisili 2y agoSounds like a way to rile up a bunch of angry troops. "Hey fellas, if you want your cigarettes, you just gotta get through those guys over there - they have tons of tobacco."
- gullywhumper 2y agoJohn Billings Hardtack and Coffee is a detailed account of camp life during the war. Here’s the section discussing rations and (obviously) coffee: https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/72532/pg72532-images.html#CHAPTER_VII https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/72532/pg72532-images.ht...
- rurp 2y agoI went to a civil war reenactment as a kid where there were food samples from the era available to try. Who knows how accurate they were, but given how passionate folks can be about that history I imagine a lot of work went into the food. I remember eating hardtack and a couple other things that, at least to my young palette, tasted ok. Of course the hardtack I tried surely had fewer weevils and maggots than most did during the actual war.
- programmer3050 2y ago[flagged]
- bjourne 2y agoBut is the evidence sufficient to refute the null hypothesis, that coffee had no effect on the American civil war? Since the 19th century is behind us, randomized controlled trials is of course impossible, but there may be other evidence. Did Union regiments low on coffee supply fight worse than those with enough coffee? Afaik, while coffee has been drunk for thousands of years, there is zero evidence of long-term cognitive benefits of coffee.
- darby_nine 2y agoIdk about cognitive benefits (seems hard enough to measure that it doesn't even matter), but physiological benefits are well-documented. I don't understand what this has to do with the topic at hand, though. Presumably coffee was used as a mild stimulant and a large morale booster, not some nootropic bullshit
- billy99k 2y agoWhen I was in high school, I always had major anxiety issues. I realized later in life that it was my excessive amount of caffeine I was ingesting on a daily basis. I mostly cut all forms of caffeine completely out of my diet since January. As as long as I get 6 hours of sleep or more, I find that I can focus better, I have energy throughout the whole day, and the sleep I do get feels like I'm more rested. Even if I got the same hours of sleep every night, I had a hard time getting up in the morning with caffeine in my daily diet.
- 1oooqooq 2y agoGet ready for some mood swings and anger issues, unless you still drink tea or other caffeine sources. nobody cold quit caffeine after drinking if since highschool. my first attempt lasted 3mo, the second one 6mo. every I've settled in coffee only in the early morning. ... worst part is the headaches when your addicted brain crave it.
- John23832 2y ago> nobody cold quit caffeine after drinking if since highschool. That's your experience, not a fact. I cold quit last year after drinking energy drinks since college (right before I quit I was multiple redeyes a day). Yes there are withdrawal symptoms but, through force of will, it is doable.
- janderland 2y agoThis narrative is seen way too often. “Here is how a drug affected me so get ready for it to affect you the same way.” Gets really tiring if you browse drug forums.
- rubslopes 2y agoA physician told me that, while caffeine abstinence effects are real, they go away fast relative to other addictive substances.
- 2y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoWhy are these threads always full of anti-coffee weirdos? https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/is-coffee-good-or-bad-for-your-health/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/is-coffee... https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2023/02/coffee-caffeine-happiness-health-benefits/673158/ https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2023/02/coffee-ca...
- cafard 2y agoSee also https://antietam.stonesentinels.com/monuments/individuals/william-mckinley/#google_vignette https://antietam.stonesentinels.com/monuments/individuals/wi...
- CraigRo 2y agoThe traditional ratio is that one pound of coffee is 50 cups. So they drank about 5 cups per day. Though if the coffee came green, it might have been a little lower
- mgraczyk 2y agoInteresting article, but I wish they would give some numbers. I couldn't find good sources, but it sounds like the total volume of Liberian imports peaked at less than 0.1% of total coffee imports. So the Liberian coffee was an interesting footnote but not important for the actual supply of coffee.
- GastroLogic 2y agoThe union didn't caffeinate their way to victory, the southern men went off to distant battlefields and the morally bankrupted northern generals like (((Sherman))) (who traded letters with his wife wherein they exchanged hopes of driving southerners right into the sea) he led armies to farms and towns populated only by the women and children left behind. They fire-bombed entire cities "Stop there! Leave this building standing so they see a town once stood here." An actual quote. This was a war meticulously overseen by Honest Abe himself. No wonder Hillary Clinton likened herself to him for being two-faced: One for public consumption, and one for Satan. Do you see this tactic of deliberately targeting civilians, children, and infrastructure being employed anywhere else in the world right now?
- mrblampo 2y agoFun article! Particularly enjoyed the anecdotal evidence from individual soldier's writing.
- brightball 2y agoStudying the civil war is really interesting and I wish schools did a better job of it. There is so much material from letters people wrote at the time that is just fascinating to read.
- kristianp 2y agoReminds me of a recent story of how speed kept the germans advancing for days on end in WWII, in the blitzkrieg. "How Methamphetamine Became a Key Part of Nazi Military Strategy" https://time.com/5752114/nazi-military-drugs/ https://time.com/5752114/nazi-military-drugs/
- cj 2y agoStill in use by the US Air Force. Although it's amphetamine / modafinil instead of meth. I'm always curious if they train while medicated, which seems kind of necessary considering how it modifies decision making behavior. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go_and_no-go_pills https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go_and_no-go_pills Edit: Actually looks like amphetamine isn’t approved anymore.
- rafaelmn 2y agoModafinil doesn't really affect decision making ? Being exhausted is probably way bigger impact, even under Modafinil.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoVery much underestimate the impact of exhaustion. If I recall correctly, I read a study that driving after a long day of work was many times more dangerous than driving over the legal limit for alcohol. Kind of puts both into perspective
- BossingAround 2y agoWell, per [1], it increases dopamine, norepinephrine, serotonin, and other chemicals in the brain. It is highly unlikely that it has no effect on one's decision making (esp. when you take it when you are _not_ very tired). It's more likely that you don't notice the effects, but the effects would likely be measurable. It's the same with caffeine. I'd wager a guess that most people don't think it influences their decision making... And yet it seems it does (e.g. [2]). [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/medicine-and-dentistry/modafinil https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/medicine-and-dentistry/... [2] https://www.freethink.com/health/does-caffeine-harm-your-decision-making https://www.freethink.com/health/does-caffeine-harm-your-dec...
- bevan 2y agoThere’s a short and fun book called Blitzed about “PED” use in WWII. Covering German pharmaceutical industry’s monopoly over certain stimulants, Hitler’s unlikely doctor who shot him up with everything under the sun, and the ultimate consequences for everyone involved (addiction, exhaustion, insanity).
- BossingAround 2y agoMeth specifically is believed to be one of the contributing factor in the early success of the German army. Interestingly, I believe the same was used by the Japanese to encourage suicidal attacks, since, it turns out, it's easier to carry one when you're high as a kite.
- BossingAround 2y agoCaffeine is a very interesting drug that makes capitalism and just daily work bearable. It's interesting that this went all the way to 1800s for the US. After reading Your Mind on Plants [1], I decided to do an experiment, and stop any caffeine intake for ~3 months. After ~1 month, I felt "normal". Only when you cannot rely on a drug, a clutch, you realize how many pressures you face every day. One might have a deadline, something doesn't work, some part of work is boring... Maybe you just slept badly. Coffee fixes all of those. Nothing is free though, and soon, you'll discover your sleep is not the best pretty much every day of the week. That, in turn, forces you to consume more caffeine, and thus the addiction cycle begins. Interestingly, after being 3 months caffeine free, I succumbed to the pressure and started drinking some amount of caffeine again (work needs to be done, caffeine makes it easier to concentrate -> it's really difficult to say no). I would encourage everyone to examine their relationship with this particular drug. It's insane to me that the population in 1800s was already so addicted to the drug that the lack "plugs" threaten to lose the civil war. [1] https://www.amazon.com/This-Your-Plants-Michael-Pollan/dp/0593296907 https://www.amazon.com/This-Your-Plants-Michael-Pollan/dp/05...
- arbuge 2y ago> Maybe you just slept badly. Coffee fixes all of those. It doesn't fix sleeping badly for me anymore, at all. Perhaps it used to when I was younger, but after turning around 45, I increasingly found that the only fix for a poor night's sleep is a good night's sleep. or perhaps poor nights of sleep just didn't affect me much back then.
- slibhb 2y ago> Caffeine is a very interesting drug that makes capitalism and just daily work bearable. It's interesting that this went all the way to 1800s for the US. Michael Pollan's thesis is absurdly exaggerated. I've been on and off coffee for the past few years and it's not necessary to "make daily work bearable". His link between caffeine and capitalism is just silly.
- leobg 2y agoLaborers in Somalia chew khat Soldiers crave their cigarettes. Office workers need their cup of coffee. You can, of course, say it’s just human nature to enjoy an altered state of consciousness. but when it becomes a habit like that, it’s really hard not to see it as a symptom of the slave mentality. The little window of freedom that you have in your otherwise unfree life. Makes me think of billboards advertising cigarettes to taxi drivers. Trying to associate the break for a smoke with the feeling of freedom. Or television commercials for coffee. Suggesting you can have a stressful day, but never run out of energy because you “enjoy the aroma“. When I feel under pressure and have deadlines coming up, I definitely drink a lot more coffee. I do it because I feel like I cannot afford to take a nap. I pull that lever to make myself function. If my kids did that, I wouldn’t consider it healthy. Not saying Pollan is right. But I wouldn’t call it a completely absurd point of view either.
- mikemitchelldev 2y agoSounds like anything to eat or drink would have helped.
- morkalork 2y agoThe know how and ability to manufacture condensed milk is another famous example from the civil war.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- softwaredoug 2y agoConversely wouldn’t the south have a near monopoly on nicotine (also a stimulant). I wonder what impact nicotine consumption - if any - had on the war.
- crawfishphase 2y agothe outcome was that tobacco kills, and the surgeon general lee agrees
- TimTheTinker 2y agoThat was only a national conclusion after the advent of modern cigarettes. Cigars and pipes are more nuanced and far less harmful (especially because of the chemicals that aren't added, and the fact that you don't inhale)
- TeaBrain 2y agoBoth Ulysses S Grant and Grover Cleveland were heavy consumers of cigars. Both ended up with oral cancer.
- TimTheTinker 2y agoHot smoke in general causes cancer. Wood smoke (from fireplace, bonfire, etc.) is more carcinogenic per unit than pure (non-cigarette) tobacco smoke. There's a stronger link between regular wood fireplace use and cancer than there is between moderate pipe/cigar use and cancer. So moderate (not heavy like Grant) cigar and pipe smoking ought to be regarded as within the realm of acceptable risk, especially given the enjoyment and mental benefits that result. But if we're going to discuss carcinogens, a lot of other things ought to be considered too. For example, why isn't alcohol, a known carcinogen, considered socially taboo compared to pipe smoking? Why are burning wood fireplaces considered "a nice touch" when the second-hand smoke from them is far more dangerous than that from an outdoor cigar user nearby?
- 2y ago
- kaycebasques 2y agoThey touch on the political affinities between the Union and Liberia but no so much the Confederacy and Brazil. I wonder if something similar was going on? Brazil still had slavery at that time. After the Confederates lost I recall learning that some slave-owning farmers moved down to Brazil to continue their slavery-driven farming practices. They only had 20 years though because slavery was banned in Brazil in the 1880s.
- jhbadger 2y agoNo doubt Brazil and the Confederacy would have liked to trade, as there was a strong tie between them as you guessed from the slavery issue. After the war, a number of Confederates (some illegally with their enslaved people) moved to Brazil, where their descendants are known as "Confederados" [1]. However, during the war the Union blockaded Southern ports and few trade items (including coffee) got through. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederados https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederados
- nunez 2y agoWell, yeah, when you're hella sleep deprived, of course not having a stimulant readily available is a problem.