4 ms·
Very nice, but often minimum overhang is not the only constraint. Sometimes you want to take (directional) strength into account. And sometimes it simply looks
by amelius 2y ago
Very nice, but often minimum overhang is not the only constraint. Sometimes you want to take (directional) strength into account. And sometimes it simply looks better if an object is sliced in a certain way.
- VBprogrammer 2y agoIt's very familiar to anyone who's done some woodwork. Keeping the grain direction in the same direction as you require strength is 90% of joinery.
- progbits 2y agoThis might be good for slicing random decorative models that weren't designed with printing in mind. Because when I care about strength and printability I do so from beginning and base the whole design around it. There is no need for a tool to pick print orientation for me because I know before the first CAD extrude how it's going to be printed.
- Filligree 2y agoHow would you design a screw thread adapter that needs to resist shear?
- progbits 2y agoI certainly wouldn't 3d print it, that is a job for off the shelf metal part.
- Filligree 2y agoNobody has any clue what the thing is. :D It claims to be BSP, but it’s 1 inch (1.1?) with 19 threads per inch (18?), which matches no standard I’ve ever found.
- linsomniac 2y agoPrint a mold, cast it in wax, put that in casting sand, then do a lost-wax casting in aluminum or something more exotic if necessary and you're able?
- Filligree 2y agoI think at that point I'd have to ask someone to make it for me.
- r2_pilot 2y agoLathe would be the tool to use in that case.
- linsomniac 2y agoYou're absolutely right. But I have a 3D printer, casting sand, and a torch... I don't have a lathe, sadly.
- nmeofthestate 2y agoA 3D printed plastic part could be fine depending on the application. Certainly worth considering/testing. Printing it flat on the bed (with a small flat side) so layers are lengthwise may work.
- 83 2y agoIf it needs any amount of strength you'll want to find someone with a lathe. BSP tells me it may be tapered(?) so find someone with a taper attachment. Even as a hobbyist I could probably make one of those on my lathe faster than drawing it and printing it on my 3d printer.
- hinkley 2y agoSee also threaded inserts for the other half of that fastener.
- Aurornis 2y agoAt some point you have so many competing compromises that you're sacrificing one aspect to improve another. When this happens, I pick what's easiest to print and make up the strength with a lot of extra wall loops, slightly higher print temperature (for better layer adhesion, as print quality allows), and stronger material selection. If this is a critical or load bearing part, I'd skip 3D printing entirely and get it machined.
- sitkack 2y ago45 degrees to the bed, 3+ walls, gyroid infill 40%
- JofArnold 2y agoAlthough true, you can optimise this considerably by using materials with very strong layer adhesion like PET (which I've never had break along layer lines) or by annealing or even remelting. So for me at least who prints entirely in PET or PET-CF (note PETG to be clear) this is super helpful.
- lmpdev 2y agoTangental: Most consumer printers I’ve come across have differing XY and Z axis spatial resolutions I’ve been wanting a decent algorithm to determine the optimal angle to print models such that the result is aesthetically as high fidelity as possible Take for example a rigid model crane set to a non orthogonal angle. Is it pleasing to print with respect to one vertical column or the other? What if they are not equally sized? What about which is most likely to be viewed up close? Generalising that problem to more organic shapes is incomprehensible but I can’t even answer the aforementioned toy example I’m sure there are dozens of excellent potential approaches but I can’t easily find it for arbitrary XY and Z (or other combinations thereof) spatial resolutions
- dotnet00 2y agoIf you need detail in more than one axis, you should use a smaller nozzle and lower speed. Along z-axis, the feature size limit is layer height, and along XY it's linewidth. Layer height can be very small with any nozzle (I've seen as small as 50 microns), but linewidth will typically need a smaller nozzle hole to work well, particularly to get below 100 microns.
- jyxent 2y agoI think XY actually has better resolution depending on your perspective. I agree that the minimum extrusion is approximately a line width circle. But that circle can move less than the line width for features on larger surfaces. For example, if you emboss something on the side of an object with 0.3mm depth using a 0.4mm nozzle / line-width, it will work fine.
- dotnet00 2y agoYeah, I suppose it depends heavily on the kind of detail. I was mostly thinking along the lines of printing lithophanes or hueforge prints. With lithophones it's typically recommended to print upright so the image is formed by stacking layers, as that allows for "pixels" to be thinner. Hueforge instead is typically printed flat because color stacking/blending needs more resolution than the shapes.