8 ms·
Producing fuels from 1,500 degrees of solar heat
- ttt333 2y agoI have no idea if technology like this will prove to be scalable, economically competitive, or even practical… but it does seem pretty dang cool as a concept
- jfengel 2y agoIt's a great way to say "Absolutely no more fossil fuels. For things that need hydrocarbons we'll make them. They cost more but it's better than cooking the planet." With a side bonus of not sending money to oil rich theocracies like Saudi Arabia and Texas.
- mgerdts 2y agoWith methane as an input, I worry that this will be hard to scale up to the point of no more fossil fuels. Can we get that much methane from biomass?
- jaggederest 2y agoConsidering agriculture and forestry combined produce about 5 billion tons of methane emissions a year, I don't think there's a shortage of availability. It'll be a lot more work to capture and direct all that, but the biosphere spins off plenty of decomposition byproducts.
- defrost 2y agoIs it more or less energy dense than oil? The consumption of oil has steadily increased over the last three decades, totaling 4.53 billion metric tons in 2023, That's oil shipped and used, not methane drifting free from biowaste across the plant. How much can we actually capture, how much energy is that, and how great is the conversion challenge to shift most cars to methane, etc? It appears a little larger than a handwave problem IRL.
- waldothedog 2y ago> Can we get that much methane from biomass? I know that food waste generates a heck of a lot of methane in landfills, but I’d love if someone could add some rough napkin math on this!
- pfdietz 2y agoBiomass availability in the US: https://www.energy.gov/eere/bioenergy/2023-billion-ton-report-assessment-us-renewable-carbon-resources https://www.energy.gov/eere/bioenergy/2023-billion-ton-repor... One would like to focus on existing streams before having to increase area used to grow biomass.
- tejtm 2y agobe afraid. methane hydrates; strip mining ocean floors could keep fossil fuel consumption going at current rates for millennia. but before that we could get we stuff in the permafrost all terrible ideas ... so probable. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=methane+hydrates&t=lm&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=methane+hydrates&t=lm&ia=web
- osigurdson 2y agoTexas?
- wussboy 2y agoYup
- jfengel 2y agoAt the moment, Oklahoma next door is even more prominent: they just mandated teaching the bible in public schools. But it's much the same.
- selimthegrim 2y agoWere you thinking of Louisiana?
- tomcam 2y agoHow is Texas a theocracy?
- pfdietz 2y agoThis is just using solar heat to reform methane from biogas. I was hoping it would be using solar heat for production of the reduced chemicals from water or CO2. This latter problem is much harder, but there have been proposals, for example using heat to reduce transition metal oxides with evolution of oxygen, then reacting the oxides with steam to make hydrogen. M2O3 --> 2 MO + 1/2 O2 2 MO + H2O --> M2O3 + H2
- jillesvangurp 2y agoThe main issue with CO2 is that the concentrations in air are pretty low. A couple of hundreds of parts per million. So, most synthetic fuel generation is bottle necked on getting enough CO2. If you are processing a kg of air, you'd be getting only a fraction of a gram of CO2. So if you want to produce say a ton of fuel, you are looking at processing many millions of tons of air. That's why a lot of synthetic fuel generation is often paired with carbon capture schemes or bio mass (like this one). But of course a lot of those carbon sources aren't actually that clean. Biomass sounds nice until you realize that farming is a big emitter of CO2. And generating fuel from carbon capture of course defeats the purpose. You capture it at great cost and then you create a fuel. Which you then burn and dump in the atmosphere. This particular scheme in Germany exists because of the influence of car manufacturers there. Companies like BMW are dragging their heels getting rid of their ICE car manufacturing operations and pretending that there are unicorn solutions like hydrogen, synthetic fuels, etc. are great excuses to keep their factories going for a few years longer. Of course EVs are eating their lunch at this point and they are now actually producing lots of those as well.
- chii 2y ago> You capture it at great cost and then you create a fuel. Which you then burn and dump in the atmosphere. But if the need for carbon based fuels is not able to be eliminated, this is the next best thing. It is better than digging more of it out of the ground, and then burn and dump it into the air!
- jillesvangurp 2y ago
- bradfitz 2y ago> It uses an AI-based method involving drones to calibrate the mirrors 200 times faster compared to traditional techniques using cameras, Synhelion says. Precision is key to ensure the mirrors track the sun and efficiently reflect its light into a solar receiver at the top of a 20 m tall tower. Naively I would assume we know where the sun is and how to calculate the angles. What are drones and AI doing?
- ulfw 2y agoCreating investor hype. What else?
- XorNot 2y agoCalibrating out mechanical backlash and mis-alignment in the mountings I assume.
- usrusr 2y agoAs in fly a scanning pattern around the focus point and look for mirrors that blind the drone instead of frying the tower. Should be crazy efficient compared to the terrible alternative which would require something like deliberately de-focusing all other mirrors only to be able to verify that the mirror under test actually does project the sun where expected. Tempted to keep my initial upvote on the "investor hype" sibling, out of spite for all projects that do, but the ability to check arbitrary points in the nonilluminated volume for accidental illumination must really make do much of a difference I can't. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction!
- fl7305 2y ago> fly a scanning pattern around the focus point and look for mirrors that blind the drone instead of frying the tower. Or just put up a big black board with reference points on it, and point a camera at that?
- usrusr 2y agoSo then you have a live image of a big black board? The beauty of the misalignment patrol drone is that it does not leave you guessing wich one exactly of your large number of inexpensive mirrors is out of line. The culprit clearly lights up in the video feed.
- soist 2y agoThere used to be a company that tried to do this to directly generate electricity: eSolar (https://www.cbsnews.com/news/an-interview-with-esolars-bill-gross/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/an-interview-with-esolars-bill-...)
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoThere are lots of companies that used heliostats to generate electricity, but that's not really a problem anymore. My understanding is that: 1. Photovoltaic panels absolutely cratered in price, so they are, generally, much more economical. 2. Not mentioned in TFA but these things have environmental concerns because they are basically bird killing machines. Any bird unfortunate enough to fly through the concentrated "death rays" is instantly fried to a crisp. So these things need solutions like drones to keep birds away. Generating gas from solar is an attractive option because it's then basically just another form of storage. But it would be great if we could generate gas from solar to power existing gas power plants. The primary problem is that the efficiency of generating gas from (solar-powered) electricity is quite low.
- theamk 2y agoThis sounds very cool, but "annually producing several thousand litres of fuel"? An average US car consumes ~1800 litres/year... So this 600 kW solar facility is just enough for one or two cars? A random search shows you need ~2kW worth of solar to charge your electric car daily, so this technology needs to improve a lot to be competitive with batteries. Hopefully they figure it out before they build the full-size plant.
- Animats 2y ago> "annually producing several thousand litres of fuel." That's maybe 10 liters a day. Seems low for the size of the installation. A liter of gasoline is about 10KWh. So if this thing gets 5 hours a day of full sunlight, it's putting out 2KW. That's like 5 standard solar panels. Either I'm calculating this wrong or this is insanely inefficient.
- wolfi1 2y agoit is insanely inefficient. whereelse I read you need 3 liters of gasoline to produce 1 liter of synfuel
- ChuckMcM 2y agoWhat is your measure of efficiency? I ask because the cost of sunlight is nominally zero so 10kWh/$0 is a really big number :-). Note that the article said that as a thermal plant it operates 24/7 by storing heat in a high thermal mass fluid. Another shot at this is Terraform Industries (https://terraformindustries.com/ https://terraformindustries.com/) which is doing something similar with direct PV -> Fuel (rather than using CSP) The "magic bean", the "trick", the "secret sauce" here is that there are huge swathes of land that are currently both high sunlight receivers and not used (can't farm them, no one wants to live there, think deserts) That could be used to crank out liquid fuel that has no issue being losslessly transported over long distances and for applications that are unlikely to run on batteries any time soon. Making fuel for those by taking CO2 out of the atmosphere is a double win.
- roenxi 2y agoThe plant is physically quite large; the sunlight might be free but capital and deprecation will influence that ratio. Although if they can do this economically then good. I have a soft-spot for any solar farm that can be made to look a bit like a flower.
- chii 2y ago> sunlight is nominally zero the investment into the panels is not free though. But i do agree - converting electricity into fuels is great, but only if said electricity does not have another use and would've been wasted otherwise.
- nashashmi 2y agoThey should come up with a way to turn leaves into oil. Send it down fractured wells and pump it out 10 years later.
- peter_d_sherman 2y agoRelated: Fischer–Tropsch process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fischer%E2%80%93Tropsch_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fischer%E2%80%93Tropsch_proces...
- carbonguy 2y agoThis concept is not quite smoke and mirrors, since there's nothing wrong with the science, but this article definitely reads more like a breathless press release than something truly ground-breaking. More notes below: > Synhelion was founded in 2016 as a spin-off from ETH Zurich, sparked by what the company founders describe as a crazy idea they had: what if they could reverse combustion and turn carbon dioxide and water back into fuel? This is not a "crazy idea", but rather a straightforward description of the chemistry involved. We call one implementation of this process "photosynthesis", but there are others. > The technology they’ve developed relies on four key components. Mirrors – known as heliostats – that track the sun to focus its energy on to a solar receiver. This in turn produces very high process heat at temperatures exceeding 1,500°C. This heat powers a thermochemical reactor that turns CO2, water and methane into syngas, which can be processed via Fischer-Tropsch into fuels. Again, this is well-understood industrial process chemistry - absolutely a good thing, in my opinion, but not new and sexy by any stretch. > And finally, a thermal store to release energy when the sun goes down to allow the solar-powered facility to operate around the clock. This actually IS new and interesting in this application (or at least, it is to me) - a shame that this isn't fleshed out more in the article. I tried to see if there was more about this aspect of their process on the Synhelion website, but their pages were loading slowly and I lost patience. Sorry, team. > The company says the design of its ultra-thin hexagonal mirrors are key to achieving such high process heats. Any physicists out there who have a speculation about why the thinness of the mirrors makes a difference here? My understanding is that the maximum temperature that mirrors can get you is limited by the surface temperature of the sun, rather than the mirrors themselves, but I'm certainly no expert on this point. > It uses an AI-based method involving drones to calibrate the mirrors 200 times faster compared to traditional techniques using cameras, Synhelion says. Precision is key to ensure the mirrors track the sun and efficiently reflect its light into a solar receiver at the top of a 20 m tall tower. This bit smells like trying to shoehorn in an application of "AI" where it's not really needed - what's the actual improvement using "drones and AI" over just pre-calculating a tracking curve based on latitude + time of day/year? Or just putting down twice as many mirrors and not bothering to make them track? > “... The inauguration of DAWN marks the beginning of the era of solar fuels – a turning point for sustainable transportation. Our founding dream of producing renewable fuels from solar energy is becoming a reality.” This is hyperbole, as eg. Prometheus was doing this two years ago. Additionally, Synhelion will be hamstrung on growth as long as they depend on biomass methane as a feedstock, but they can solve that by buying methane from Terraform :)
- vixen99 2y ago> What if they could reverse combustion and turn carbon dioxide and water back into fuel? Humbling thought that the green weed outside your window is doing exactly that - plus, depending on the species, tens of thousands of variations on a carbon theme.
- phantom_wizard 2y agoSeems like cool concept, basically it's just solar furnace with extra steps - to me it is a bit nonsense that it is placed in Germany because there are far better locations on a globe like Chile with 10 times more solar energy per m2. I am glad, however, that the idea of solar furnace is still being explored. Yesterday I was wondering if such installation could be put on a large ship vessel which would solve problem of year season. Also with our knowledge about tornado formations the ship could be put in places with max solar input.
- habibur 2y agoReading the article I get a feeling that it's more like proof of concept, than a economically feasible project, as there's no mention of costs.
- fl7305 2y agoIn my view, it sounds like they're trying to tackle way too much at the same time. Just the core system that converts input chemicals and heat to a fuel is a major undertaking. Focus on that. Adding their own mirror system might be doable, but only if they use a well known and simple solution. Trying to add an "AI drone mirror autocalibration" is a major undertaking, enough to keep a medium sized company busy for a number of years. Likewise with the "solar energy storage system". Just run when the sun is shining, and produce as much fuel you can from that. If you have more incoming power from the sun than what you can produce fuel from, concentrate on solving that instead. Or just build something that is economical even if the mirror system is way oversized in order to always keep the fuel conversion busy.
- omneity 2y agoAt this feeble level of efficiency we’re probably better off using the energy to split water into hydrogen or producing ammonia. It’s a trade-off ultimately, either we get to use currently deployed ICE systems and feed them with this solar fuel, or deploy new engines to leverage hydrogen or ammonia based vehicles. Most probably better to bet on electricity storage tech catching up and just switch everything to full electric.
- jfengel 2y agoThere are some things that will be tricky to convert, notably airplanes. And it would be convenient to have synthetic gas for driving peaker plants on the occasions where they're needed. But yeah, ground transport needs to be electrified yesterday, and the grid upgraded to support it. That can be done incrementally, using existing technology.
- omneity 2y agoIn this case isn’t biogas a much better option efficiency-wise?
- cduzz 2y agoI think all of these approaches are not "or" but are instead "and" ... We need both PV solar and "let's get some heat" solar; we need LiFePO4 and nmc batteries; we probably even need to keep fossil fuels and biodiesel and other biogas. Every little incremental bit helps... It's a race between turning into venus and turning into mad max's thunderdome.
- mdale 2y agoI like how mad Max thunderdome is a given at this point and the env work is just to prevent Venus #2
- gwright 2y ago> the env work is just to prevent Venus #2 There is no science-based predictions that climate change as we understand it today, will lead to Venus #2. That idea is just fodder for climate hysteria and sci-fi fantasy films.
- alchemist1e9 2y agoMany years ago I remember seeing this same focused sunlight design being used to generate electricity directly from the heat.
- narrator 2y ago"This heat powers a thermochemical reactor that turns CO2, water and methane into syngas" The methane has to come from biomass, so this isn't quite closing the loop here on a full solar only process. Pure CO2 and water to synfuels is still wildly energy inefficient.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- adolph 2y agoWhen you say inefficient, do you mean that the process results in more entropy than work-producing fuel than another method of recomposing molecules into methane, such as biological processes?
- narrator 2y agoIf the Hysatas electrolyzer[1] is for real and scales up, making hydrogen is going to get way more efficient. They can make then make synfuels out of hydrogen for about a 40% loss. Eventually, they could put these electrolyzers at major airports and refuel hydrogen planes without having to move the hydrogen much. That's the big weakness of hydrogen is that it can't be moved around easily in pipelines. It can be stored in underground caverns under low pressure for cheap though. [1]https://hysata.com/news/hysatas-electrolyser-breaks-efficiency-records-enabling-world-beating-green-hydrogen-cost/ https://hysata.com/news/hysatas-electrolyser-breaks-efficien...
- adolph 2y agoOk, I see two semi-related assertions now: >>> Pure CO2 and water to synfuels is still wildly energy inefficient. > If the Hysatas electrolyzer is for real and scales up, making hydrogen is going to get way more efficient. From the article, Synhelion has a thermal reactor now: solar radiation directed by heliostats into a thermal reactor that feeds a Fischer-Tropsch process. It seems difficult to establish relative efficiency of the whole to the Hysatas electrolyzer which is one component of a larger chain to capture and transmit energy to perform work. If I were to assume a similar story for Hysatas where photovoltaics feed electricity to electrolyze water and a whole new infrastructure for fuel is stood up: What measure would measure and demonstrate the relative efficiency between the two processes?
- szundi 2y agoI’m looking forward to times when this silly technology kills all plants because no CO2 remained in the air but people need fuel
- LMSolar 2y agoSeveral comments... Disclaimer, I work in this space. a) Surprised that on HN no one has commented on the similarities with Heliogen: https://www.heliogen.com/ https://www.heliogen.com/ This US-based company backed by Bill Gates and Bill Gross similarly focuses on high-temperature heliostat applications, e.g. green hydrogen and concrete etc. They even have similar hexagonal-mirror heliostats. b) Why these CSP startups so often focus on moon-shot 'super hard' applications like the above baffles me. There are LOTS of great applications for lower temperature solar thermal systems - which are much easier to build and operate. Our plastic-molding systems are just one example: http://lm.solar http://lm.solar c) It's a little odd to be doing CSP in Germany - Heliostats need collimated light (non-diffuse light, e.g. light that casts a shadow) and Germany has pretty low DNI compared to, say, Morocco. I know the article says they plan to deploy commercially to Spain, but even a test system would be super hard to operate with frequent haze, high cloud layers, etc. To be clear, not saying PV-solar is impractical in Germany - PV can harvest diffuse light just fine. Funny that the photo of the solar tower / target in the article shows an overcast sky! Global Solar Atlas gives annual average DNI of @ 1000 kWh/M2/year at Jülich, which is way low. https://globalsolaratlas.info/detail?c=50.922093,6.361102,11&s=50.922093,6.361102&m=site https://globalsolaratlas.info/detail?c=50.922093,6.361102,11... I wish them luck, but there are likely more practical, impactful uses for CSP. PS Re the 'sunlight is free' comments... yes but if your process is very inefficient and/or requires a huge heliostat array then CapEx goes way up (which has to be financed = cost) and then you get into needing automated cleaning robots to keep your array working well (see Ivanpah - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivanpah_Solar_Power_Facility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivanpah_Solar_Power_Facility ), etc. The cascading effects of moon-shot application => huge CSP system => problems (high CapEx, huge physical sites, permitting problems, need for automated cleaning etc) are exactly why we're working on industrial uses for SMALL heliostat arrays. And why grid-scale CSP (electric generation) systems generally get trounced by PV+battery systems.
- generuso 2y agoIf they get some traction, it might be interesting. It reminded me of another project which I have almost forgotten about. David Doty is a respected name in a narrow circle of nuclear magnetic resonance scientists for the hardware that his company builds [1]. At some point about a quarter century ago, he became obsessed with what he saw as an impending energy crisis, and started to look precisely into the technical nuances and economics of Fischer-Tropsch process. It seemed like a potential solution to turn excess of renewable energy into an energy-dense liquid fuel, which could then be distributed using the already existing infrastructure. Doty was always exceptionally meticulous in anything he did, and so he went with a fine comb to find and eliminate inefficiencies in the fuel synthesis process, wherever it was physically possible. He funded a small team working on this, and they came up with some improvements [2] which they have patented, presented at conferences, etc. But despite all this work the economics of the process was still not favorable. [1] https://dotynmr.com/ https://dotynmr.com/ [2] http://www.dotyenergy.com/ http://www.dotyenergy.com/