4 ms·
Colorado has a first-in-the-nation law for AI – but what will it do?
- geodel 2y agoFor starters, catch the violators and fine them.
- flaque 2y ago> Whether (people) get insurance, or what the rate for their insurance is, or legal decisions or employment decisions, whether you get fired or hired, could be up to an AI algorithm This is a bit like trying to regulate horseshoes while everyone else is talking about speed limits & seat belts. Both parties say the word "carriage" and "passenger", but they have completely different ideas in their heads about what is about to happen.
- olliej 2y ago[flagged]
- ForHackernews 2y agoSame thing the Colorado law that required employers to include salaries in job ads did: exclude Colorado residents.
- dghlsakjg 2y agoHow are Colorado banks, landlords, and employers going to exclude their customers and employees? Right now the law just asks for disclosure and sets up a human appeal process for AI based decisions.
- jmclnx 2y agoYes, for local small business jobs you are correct. But these laws could cause large multinationals to leave Colorado. Plus, in reality, banks really do not "need" tellers since most people get direct deposit, use debit/credit cards and phones for transactions. So large banks could leave too. I remember reading somewhere banks do not really like saving accounts since most people keep a small balance in them. With that said, I wish the laws Colorado has for AI and salaries could be nation wide.
- dghlsakjg 2y agoDo you think that large multinationals are really going to pull out of a market over having to update their disclosures in fine print? Reducing your applicant pool in a state you don’t operate in because you can’t be bothered to disclose salary is one thing. Closing down branches, losing customers and firing hundreds or thousands of employees in a move that reduces your bottom line is a whole other thing.
- mattwad 2y agoYou have to start somewhere. There's now 13 states that require pay transparency, and more that are considering it. https://www.govdocs.com/pay-transparency-laws/ https://www.govdocs.com/pay-transparency-laws/
- soared 2y agoI’ve never seen a job excluding Colorado residents, and I live in Denver and search for jobs. Employers just ignore it for remote work, or put a really big range. Big ranges are still useful since it’s always enough to make a decision on whether to apply or not.
- lelandfe 2y agoI did see Colorado excluded, and even worked for a (Not Good) company that did it. I haven’t seen any examples this year, however, likely because California and New York followed suit.
- Jtsummers 2y agoWhen it first went into effect there were remote job listings that suddenly added exclusions for Coloradans. Also listings that were removed and re-added but with the exclusion added. My wife was in the middle of getting interviewed by Oracle when the law came into effect (she was on the last of several rounds of interviews), they dropped her and the listing and reposted it the next week barring people from Colorado from applying. I haven't seen this in a while, though.
- soared 2y agoYeah seems weird since oracle has a campus in Broomfield and office in DTC, but that company is a mess so doesn’t surprise me.
- throwaway48476 2y agoThe ads I've seen now exclude multiple states. At some point it just gets silly.
- yuliyp 2y agoSo this actually sounds like a realistic approach at managing the dangers of AI. It ensures that people have some sort of recourse against algorithms deciding to make their life miserable. This feels like an extension of similar approaches used in credit: credit rating agencies have to allow you to look at the data used, and are required to have flows for people to challenge the data there that may be harming them. Certainly it's a very different approach from people trying to mandate that AIs must be designed in ways so that they can't be used for bad stuff (which to me feels like a fundamentally broken approach).
- tensor 2y agoIt's unfortunate that these laws focus on AI. Why isn't it illegal to use traditional algorithms that have bias? Why aren't there regulations ensuring bias testing when humans themselves make decisions? In all cases the bias originates from human behaviour. The one advantage of AI being used is that now that bias is surfaced. But it's always been there, which is why the machine learning algorithms learn it. It's just that no one typically looks at the data in aggregate prior to AI. In any case, these rules should not be scoped to AI in my opinion. They should include algorithms and also require bias testing for teams of humans making decisions. If anything, I'd trust an AI system that has been analyzed for bias over a human making a decision.]
- carbocation 2y agoThe behavior should be the start and the end of the regulation. No need to specify AI, algorithms, etc, at all.
- doe_eyes 2y ago> In all cases the bias originates from human behaviour. The one advantage of AI being used is that now that bias is surfaced. I think that's an odd way to look at it. The bias originates from the training data, which was what - idle conversations on Reddit and other similar content pilfered on the internet? The bias is doing some harm in places like that, but we're now using that to make real decisions. That's... worse.
- walt_grata 2y agoI think the point is that bias happens in all human behavior, but with AI it's more visible than in the general population. Which I'd say is a positive, but I don't believe if it offsets the downsides.
- doe_eyes 2y agoBut that's not a given. We conduct ourselves differently at work and in private life. Further, workplace processes are often designed to minimize bias. And here, we have a system that is trained on content that's two rungs above 4chan, and then coerced not to say racist things via RLHF. I don't think it's comparable at all.
- w-ll 2y agoI thought Tennessee was first due to their massive music industry. https://www.npr.org/2024/03/22/1240114159/tennessee-protect-musicians-artists-ai https://www.npr.org/2024/03/22/1240114159/tennessee-protect-...
- jqpabc123 2y agoPeople make bad decisions too --- but they rarely do so alone. Try hiring someone in an established company without multiple levels of review. The problem with AI is that we know these models are flawed but they are being implemented anyway in an effort to save money. If you have to manually review all AI results, the cost savings start to evaporate. Particularly if it leads to lawsuits. Imagine trying to explain in court how/why AI decided to fire someone. The real culprit here is greed.