6 ms·
McDonald's AI Drive-Thru debacle is a warning to us all
- nextworddev 2y agoWonder how much of this failure was due to the IBM specific tech issues. Especially since McD is moving their POC to GCP
- csours 2y ago> "Developed by IBM" I wonder how many people got fired.
- alephnerd 2y ago> Especially since McD is moving their POC to GCP McD has been using GCP for sometime now so it's unrelated to this fiasco [0] The IBM-McD Voice Assistant project was actually a startup that McD acquired in 2019 that was sold to IBM in 2021 [1][2], and was even a thread on HN a couple years ago [3] [0] - https://corporate.mcdonalds.com/corpmcd/our-stories/article/mcd-google-cloud-announce-partnership.html https://corporate.mcdonalds.com/corpmcd/our-stories/article/... [1] - https://www.verdictfoodservice.com/news/ibm-mcdonalds-mcd/ https://www.verdictfoodservice.com/news/ibm-mcdonalds-mcd/ [2] - https://web.archive.org/web/20180902173557/https://www.apprente.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20180902173557/https://www.appre... [3] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18151768 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18151768
- waynecochran 2y agoAnyone feel another AI winter coming on?
- somenameforme 2y agoYip. Soooo want to short NVidia, but the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoMy elderly mother was just telling me how my elderly uncle is going hard on NVDA because they make the AI chips… So, it might be a good time to place some puts.
- gizajob 2y agoTotally true but every bone in my body is telling me that this bubble is going to burst in the next 18 months when the current generation of AI reveals its limitations more and more when put into production. But for now, I’m long on Nvidia but dying to short it.
- causal 2y agoNot really. The trough of disillusionment is not winter.
- tetris11 2y agoIf so, it will be much much shorter than the last one.
- krageon 2y agoSomeone has been saying this for every negative piece of AI news for the past four or five years. I'm going to go with "no".
- waynecochran 2y agoIt more the overshoot of expectations. Computer Vision, LLM's, etc ... are very cool but their usefulness is not as general as folks make the out to be. The idea the LLM's demonstrate emergent behavior was a huge overshoot. The bigger idea that we are near AGI and the end of the world is waaayyy overshoot.
- Someone1234 2y agoFrankly I wouldn't trust IBM to tie my shoes. How they keep getting these large multi-million dollar contracts is beyond me. Like, seriously, I'd go hire a small team of MIT grads (5-ish) and I bet they deliver a higher quality product than giving IBM four times as much and twice as long.
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoBecause they are BIG and they understand how BIG works. It’s very hard to be small and understand it.
- kstrauser 2y agoI'm not convinced that's true any more. Let me get this out of the way: McDonald's is BIG. I'm not going to argue against that. That said, BIG in this case means about 63 million customers a day[0]. Yes, they come in bursts. No, you can't divide 63M by 86400 to address their traffic. That said, 63M requests to do something per day is no longer IBM-scale volume. At a prior job we'd designed a system to handle about 30M transactions per second at peak (think "it's the Super Bowl: guess whether the offense is going to kick or run the ball in the next play! 5... 4... 3..."). McD's requests are more complex than that, but so is the technology available to work on it today. IBM knows BIG. I think the notion of what BIG means is a lot different now though. Lots of problems that were nearly intractable a couple decades ago genuinely are in the wheelhouse of clever startups today. [0]https://corporate.mcdonalds.com/corpmcd/our-company/who-we-are.html https://corporate.mcdonalds.com/corpmcd/our-company/who-we-a...
- fragmede 2y agoThere's usually some way to "cheat" to make things easier. In this case, orders don't need to ask go into a single globally accessible instantaneously updated database like BigTable. A McDonald's in San Francisco doesn't care what a McDonald's in Paris' customers have ordered right that second. Or even the one down the street. So the worst you could do is give each restaurant their own copy of the stack. And that stack meds to handle maybe 3 orders a minute? The busiest McDonald's still isn't going to be all that busy in orders per second, relative to a busy website. Everything you can do to optimize and use fewer resources per restaurant is an optimization and cost reduction problem, but the base problem is inherently tractable. Chick-fil-A runs an Edge Kubernetes cluster at each of their 2800 restaurants.
- micromacrofoot 2y agoI know this is being used as an "AI bad" parable... but it seems like a really poor understanding and use of the technology? I'm not a subject matter expert but this seems like it would fail immediately. Audio in controlled scenarios is really difficult, and the drive through experience can often go wrong with audio for real live people on both ends... why would they even expect this to half work?
- xyst 2y agoBecause I am willing to bet execs that greenlit this project have never worked a drive thru in their entire life. It was likely tested in ideal scenarios (ie, no background noise, order articulated clearly with no hesitation, happy path only tested).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- causal 2y agoWent into a McDonalds recently that was all touch-screen ordering. Could maybe get someone at the counter with enough patience. It made me feel so unimportant. It took a REALLY long time for orders to be fulfilled, and it was just me and a crowd of other customers standing around awkwardly hoping the touch screen listened to any of us. Awful experience, avoiding McDonalds for a while.
- ilamont 2y agoMore than once, I’ve gone through the touchscreen fast food checkout only to be shown a message at the end that the credit card reader doesn’t work. You have to print out the list of what you ordered and hand it over to the clerk after standing in line.
- LUmBULtERA 2y agoI know when I go to McDonalds, I go because the person behind the counter makes me feel powerful and important. It's the best. I'm flying high for a week after :). Naw, but I get that if it took a REALLY long time for orders to be fulfilled, I'd be disappointed.
- causal 2y agoYou're adding words I never said. I value the person across the counter from me as well, because in human-to-human interactions there is empathy and connection that transcends the business exchange. There is a person there that I care about way more than I care about fries, and usually that person cares more about me than they do the McDonalds Corporation. So if they mess up my order- no big deal, you're a person after all. Or if I need to run back to get my wallet I left in my car- no big deal, I'm a person after all. Humans generally care more about the people local to them than they do the faceless business operating in the background. But in the human-to-AI scenario, that connection is vaporized, and now it's just me and a machine whose only loyalties lie solely to McDonalds Corporation. It makes you feel unimportant in a very cold way.
- mattmanser 2y agoThat's been in the UK for ages. Like 5 years. Everything works fine, have been to a McD's dozens of times over the last few years and never seen a problem, apart from sometimes the printer is low ink. The reason it takes longer has nothing to do with the touch screens. It's because the stores that are touch screen are now cooking to order, no picking stuff cooked already off warming shelves. It is annoying when you want to grab something quick. But on the other hand, no more floppy, soggy, burgers. Everything is freshly cooked. Less waste. They just have coupled the two changes, touch screens + cook to order, together. So when a store gets one, they get the other. And if you look behind the serving counter you should be able to see the difference, no warming shelves, but a slide that fresh food is coming down, which gets immediately bagged and then put straight into your hand.
- davio 2y agoThis was predicted by SNL about a decade ago... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcwcU0ZG8nk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcwcU0ZG8nk
- isoprophlex 2y ago> Developed by IBM That's all you need to know, right there
- dehrmann 2y agoEven before the LLM AI hype, IBM talked a big AI game but rarely delivered. Their market seemed to be out-of-touch CEOs who fell for their marketing.
- dylan604 2y agoFrom TFA: "After a thoughtful review, McDonald's has decided to end our current partnership with IBM on AOT (automated order taking) and the technology will be shut off in all restaurants currently testing it no later than 26 July, 2024." I'm glad they thoughtfully reviewed after not thoughtfully reviewing the tech itself
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- wbshaw 2y agoOther than the egregiousness of 2,510 McNugget meal orders, I often find that human order takers are not particularly accurate either.
- TYPE_FASTER 2y agoIf I need to interact with a company for some reason, I will usually try the website first because it can be faster. If I can't do it using the website, I call the phone number. The automated phone system usually tries to send me to the website, so I yell "AGENT" into the phone until I talk to a person. I am tired of this.
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40701868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40701868
- tennisflyi 2y agoY’all are legit bad at ordering it appears. You’ll learn terse syntax to code but won’t accommodate the human order taker
- trealira 2y agoWho are you talking to? IBM?
- TASHANDIARISHA 2y ago[dead]
- Chinwe888 2y ago[dead]
- xyst 2y ago> Developed by IBM Not surprising there to be honest. Probably tested the tech in a room with no background noise, a couple of easy use cases, and an “ideal” customer that speaks clearly and knows what they want. But also not surprised that AI has failed to replace human order takers. The order taker software by IBM reminds me of Siri, maybe they picked up Apple rejects.