8 ms·
“Attention assault” on Fandom
- Sivart13 2y agoMoreso than just the visual assault from going to a Fandom page, these things have got to have an impact on global battery life. Having a couple Fandom pages open in tabs can drive my laptop fan crazy and turn my phone into a griddle.
- Dwedit 2y agoThe problem is that Fandom ends up with better search engine rank than the replacement wiki that the actual community moved on to.
- 2muchcoffeeman 2y agoWhat’s the replacement wiki?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- itishappy 2y agoWhat you move to when you quit Fandom. Super common for games. Examples: Fandom: https://noita.fandom.com/wiki/Noita_Wiki https://noita.fandom.com/wiki/Noita_Wiki Official: https://noita.wiki.gg/wiki/Noita_Wiki https://noita.wiki.gg/wiki/Noita_Wiki Fandom: https://terraria.fandom.com/wiki/Terraria_Wiki https://terraria.fandom.com/wiki/Terraria_Wiki Official: https://terraria.wiki.gg/wiki/Terraria https://terraria.wiki.gg/wiki/Terraria Fandom: https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Minecraft_Wiki https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Minecraft_Wiki Official: https://minecraft.wiki/ https://minecraft.wiki/ Two of the three Fandom wiki's above are still ranked higher than the official ones on Google.
- o11c 2y agohttps://nethackwiki.com/wiki/Main_Page https://nethackwiki.com/wiki/Main_Page is ranked above the Fandom version these days.
- Falell 2y agoThere isn't one, there are hundreds. Given that you end up on a small fandom wiki, you have no idea where 'the better community' is. You go to your search engine of choice and start clicking random wikis hoping at least one other one has decent info (most are useless). As a concrete example, Path of Exile moved to https://www.poewiki.net/ https://www.poewiki.net/ (which is a single MediaWiki instance not associated with a larger network). The content is quite good but it took probably 18 months for it to start reliably appearing in google search results.
- freehorse 2y agoIn many cases, it is not a big deal to just open a few links and figure it out. Fandom's content is usually too crap and incomplete. I have been mostly avoiding fandom and fextralife because of content reasons, and I had no idea of all the drama around them.
- Ukv 2y agoThe (Old School) Runescape wiki mentioned in the article (https://runescape.wiki/ https://runescape.wiki/ and https://oldschool.runescape.wiki/ https://oldschool.runescape.wiki/) is higher up than the Fandom one on all search engines I'm aware of. The Minecraft wiki (https://minecraft.wiki/ https://minecraft.wiki/) also generally beats out the Fandom one (on Bing, Yandex, ... - but critically not yet Google). Definitely takes a lot of effort, but can be done.
- lucb1e 2y ago> but critically not yet Google). My takeaway from the recent Google search engine ranking documentation leak was that they very heavily uprank big brand names. A page on reddit with various short comments (many of them useful I'm sure) is going to always outrank a random individual's blog with a well-researched article about the same topic. Same for Quora, Facebook, and the other websites with big moderation teams and where we all know what to expect. There is something to be said for it as well: the quality of a reddit discussion or quora answers will probably be more consistent than if you serve up random other pages (those may be content farms, ad farms, unresearched opinions...). Other pages on the web may be better, or may be worse. I'm guessing that Google figures/found they look better if they don't serve up (m)any bad results but rather pretend that big brands are the internet now, sticking to an average (mediocre-ish) quality Perhaps that's why Google likes big brand Wikia better than this new domain
- bisby 2y agohttps://libredirect.github.io/ https://libredirect.github.io/ LibRedirect has an automatic Fandom redirect option, so if someone sends you a fandom link, or you otherwise click one without realizing it, you won't wind up on fandom. You still give the analytics that you clicked a fandom link to whoever served you the link though.
- themagicteeth 2y agoDoesn’t it just redirect to BreezeWiki? BreezeWiki is just a Fandom mirror as far as I am aware. So while you won’t see Fandoms ads, the content is still on Fandom. Though, it is still better than the actual website by a lot… and the other redirects it offers are pretty great as well. https://breezewiki.com/ https://breezewiki.com/
- chgs 2y agoThat’s sounds brilliant. I typed “memory alpha” on the search page you linked to. Exception raised in Racket code at response generation time: json-pointer-value: contract violation Cest La vie. On desktop fandom is fine, ublock handles it. On an iPhone though forget it. It’s the videos.
- jabroni_salad 2y agoYeah. LibRedirect is a nice generalist tool, but for wikis you are better off with Indie Wiki Buddy[1] which is a community led tool to point to the best avaialble wiki, or breeze if there isn't one. You def want this because some communities have made it a point to poison the fandom pages (see Terraria which is full of fake items and crafting recipes now). [1] https://getindie.wiki/ https://getindie.wiki/
- starkparker 2y agoBreezeWiki isn't a mirror, it's an API client. It pulls the content from Fandom via MediaWiki API and renders it.
- wizzwizz4 2y agoIt's better to use https://getindie.wiki/ https://getindie.wiki/, which sends you to the specific replacement wikis rather than BreezeWiki (though it does support BreezeWiki).
- RheingoldRiver 2y agoI work for wiki.gg You can use one (or both) of these extensions to avoid Fandom: * https://getindie.wiki/ https://getindie.wiki/, should redirect you to any not-fandom equivalent * https://support.wiki.gg/wiki/Wiki.gg_Redirect https://support.wiki.gg/wiki/Wiki.gg_Redirect, is wiki.gg wikis only and will see updates for such wikis more frequently
- edflsafoiewq 2y agoSo?
- ziddoap 2y agoSo people looking for a wiki with a quick search end up clicking on the fandom link, being bombarded with ads as well as potentially outdated or incorrect information, instead of clicking on the wiki that doesn't have those issues. In turn, that gives fandom more ad views and potential clicks, perpetuating the problem.
- throwanem 2y agoSo search engines continue to serve the SEO-riddled landgrab garbage over the valuable resource, new visitors to the community continue to get served bad information and deterred from involving themselves further, the maintainers of the real wiki have to waste spare time figuring out how to deal with this nonsense over maintaining the resource, and Fandom continues to pollute the informational commons to its own gain and everyone else's detriment.
- 0xTJ 2y agoI'll take this chance to plug Kagi Search (a paid search engine), that I recently switched to, and have been loving. It's nice to actually be able to say "Hey, this site is trash, don't show it/de-rank it for me."
- layer8 2y agoThat doesn’t solve the problem that most people will find Fandom first when searching for it.
- 0xTJ 2y agoThat's fair, but it'll keep individuals from ending up clicking to so many junk sites. And the more people using search engines that allow them to fight back against enshittification, the better.
- teroshan 2y agoNot only this, but I've been using Kagi's Redirect feature to redirect fandom results if I see some. For instance for Path of Exile, simply: ^https://pathofexile.fandom.com|https://poewiki.net https://pathofexile.fandom.com|https://poewiki.net Alternatively the Redirector extension can also achieve similar results, without having Kagi, and converting all links, not just search results [1]. [1]: https://github.com/einaregilsson/Redirector https://github.com/einaregilsson/Redirector
- iamacyborg 2y agoYes and no. It definitely takes a little time but it’s not all that hard to outrank Fandom.
- rahidz 2y agoAnyone else find it a bit "conflict of interest"-y that Wikipedia often limits creation of niche articles because they have to be 'notable' enough, meanwhile its creator is heavily involved in running for-profit Fandom that just so happens to solve that problem?
- YawningAngel 2y agoI have had this exact thought and am deeply irritated by it
- pocketarc 2y agoI don’t even really understand why things have to be notable for Wikipedia. If people wanted to maintain all of the Runescape articles in Wikipedia (as mentioned by nouser76)… why not? Why not have Wikipedia literally be the central place for all information for all these different things?
- soulofmischief 2y agoThe most lazy approach possible to solve the issue that low-traffic and low-interest data becomes increasingly low-confidence as either no one is monitoring for changes, or due to information wars between parties with conflicting interest. I've personally been approached to build tech to monitor and revert changes matching keywords using residential proxy systems as a service for low-stakes clients (and declined).
- lolinder 2y ago> The most lazy approach possible to solve the issue that low-traffic and low-interest data becomes increasingly low-confidence Can you suggest some alternate approaches that you think would actually work? How would you approach removing the notability requirement without immediately opening the floodgates to hundreds of thousands of additional sketchy articles about niche topics that don't have enough interest to be vetted by more than one person per year?
- 2y ago
- Nouser76 2y agoOne of the best cases of leaving Fandom that I know of is the Runescape wiki mentioned in the article[0]. The community that ran the fandom wiki had buy-in from the creators of Runescape to assist with the transition, help with funding, and eventually direct integration into their games. In a game as information-dense as Runescape, that updates weekly, the wiki is basically a necessity for folks to play efficiently, or to find out how a new update actually works. Fandom isn't the only bad wiki site though. Fextralife had (has? I haven't kept up) an issue where they were embedding Twitch streams on each page load, which was boosting viewer counts for whatever streamer they decided to embed on every page. I'd love to see a world where more companies self-host the wiki for their game/TV show/etc, especially given the relatively low cost of deploying and hosting, but I also understand that most companies don't have the motivation to do that as it doesn't always directly impact their bottom line and it can take effort to moderate. [0]: https://runescape.wiki https://runescape.wiki
- soared 2y agoWould love to watch a documentary on the osrs wiki and especially the power transfer from fandom. Such a ridiculously incredible wiki. It makes me wish I never used it, as no other source of information (video game or not) is anywhere near as complete and knowledgeable. Anything you want to know about osrs, it’s in the wiki.
- spondylosaurus 2y agoI don't play OSRS, but my partner does, and on more than one occasion they've shown me a page from the wiki and I've felt the exact emotion you're describing. Even a lot of enterprise software tools struggle to produce docs as good as the OSRS wiki's.
- TZubiri 2y agoProbably related that it pertains to a game built on a 2000 engine. The lack of complexity and repetitiveness is built into the game, which directly correlates to the popularity among the autism community.
- labster 2y agoMiraheze is the main replacement to Fandom -- it's an ad-free, community-owned, nonprofit supported entirely by donations, grants and volunteers. We've been operating free wikis on MediaWiki for about 9 years now, supported through different organizations, but right now we're the fastest and most stable we've ever been. Like all OSS efforts, we can always use more technical volunteers. I'm Chair and Acting President of the WikiTide Foundation, the parent of Miraheze, and I'd be happy to answer any questions about the service. Our users are generally more anti-Fandom than this article is, in my experience. For paid offerings, with a little more freedom than a wiki farm host can allow, WikiTeq, MyWikis, and WikiWorks are all good offerings in the MediaWiki space. I currently work for WikiTeq, but they're all pretty good, and the owners are on friendly terms with each other, with a lot of them coming in through the Wikimedia community or staff.
- solardev 2y agoCan I ask what your stack is? I used to volunteer at another nonprofit wiki (not a host, just a single wiki). I had a lot of trouble trying to manage the MediaWiki LAMP stack, especially when you have to add things like Varnish with proper integration or Parsoid (I think back in the day it was a separate, standalone server that needed root). MediaWiki Updates weren't easy either. Is it still that difficult these days, or is there some readily-available containerized version now? Cloudways for a while had a managed MediaWiki VM offering, but they discontinued that I think. Are there standard best practices for hosting MediaWiki these days, or is that part of your secret sauce...?
- labster 2y agoThe stack at Miraheze is all open source, and almost entirely available free on GitHub. The overview is here: https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Tech:Home https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Tech:Home We do a few things that aren't recommended, like running WMF's own CentralAuth, which you definitely wouldn't want to do if you were hosting one or two wikis, as well as upgrading with every new MW release. Generally I would go with Canasta, a Docker image that's collectively maintained by a few MediaWiki companies. Canasta upgrades with every LTS release, which is a much easier pace for maintainers. https://github.com/CanastaWiki/Canasta https://github.com/CanastaWiki/Canasta
- mjamesaustin 2y agoAnd the saddest part is, even if all notable games migrate away from Fandom within the next year or two, how enormous will the pile of money be that those VCs and private equity firm managed to accumulate by burning it all down? Investors don't give a shit about making sustainable products or really anything valuable to society, as long as they can fleece unwitting consumers for massive eyeball money for a short time.
- Aardwolf 2y agoI liked it a lot back when it was named wikia. It was really awesome for niche communities as well as for the most detailed info imaginable on any game I was playing at the time (a use case gamefaqs used to solve). I also really liked the name wikia, it was like a wiki for anything too detailed for wikipedia. But today, yeah... P.S. I never knew it was founded by the same founder as wikipedia!
- etrvic 2y agoI had a similar experience this morning. I made the huge mistake of opening Famdom on my phone, and it took me a few minutes of blankly staring at the screen to realize this is actually a legit site. The amount of ads they managed to pack on a 4.7 inch screen was mesmerising. The problem is i got stuck at that game and searched for a quick solution. Then google straight up made me end up in that pile of ads. I hope people will start realizing what that website is and hopefully migrate their wikis to a better place, although it probably won’t happen.
- dimmke 2y agoI think it's funny that we're constantly reckoning with the issues that venture capital causes to various things in tech on a website that's funded and maintained by a venture capital fund. It can't be all bad, right? More and more, it seems like VC is the only way you can go in tech unless you have a really specific business model.
- sameoldtune 2y agoIt’s funny you say that, considering VC funding tends to elicit a “very specific” kind of business model—a kind of “consumer goodwill pump-and-dump.”
- __loam 2y agoMost businesses do not need and should not get vc funding. YC themselves say this: https://youtu.be/D81y-kh11oI https://youtu.be/D81y-kh11oI
- Larrikin 2y agoThe only useful information in the article is >download Indie Wiki Buddy Seems like a nice plugin. There are dozens of tools to block ads on all platforms and nearly all of the internet is a cesspool of ads. I don't know how anyone can browse it without an ad blocker. Not really an interesting topic to spend most of the blog talking about.
- mrkramer 2y agoI use ablocker but even with adblocker, Fandom's UI is so cluttered, that it is actually bloatware. It ranks high on Google and it is apparently one of the most visited websites in the world, undeservedly so.
- chungy 2y agoFandom will also not allow wiki owners to remove the wiki from Fandom servers. For several communities that decide to cut ties with Fandom, they effectively have to "fork" the wiki to a new domain and hosting provider, and all the while, search engines will almost always show the Fandom version first. I know it's happened with Doom, Simpsons, Futurama, Minecraft. It also draws would-be contributors to the Fandom site, make changes there, and since they are no longer supervised by the community 'elite', the quality of the Fandom version rapidly declines.
- kstrauser 2y agoWill they allow the bulk overwriting of pages?
- lucb1e 2y agoSure, until someone (anyone, since it's a wiki) notices the vandalism and reverts it and reports your account to probably get banned
- starkparker 2y agoFrom experience, Fandom will block and revert any attempt to do this. They assign employee admins for abandoned wikis who do nothing but revert any attempt to do this.
- jabroni_salad 2y agoThey have moderators who revert overwrites. However, one thing they don't do is fact check new pages. Some fandom pages are majority junk because the moderators aren't going to boot up the game and see if some new boss that supposedly appears 300 hours in to Terraria's calamity mod is actually real. It just isn't feasible for paid labor to do, and all of the community gardeners who give a shit have moved elsewhere.
- b800h 2y agoYep, enormously frustrating. Search 'minecraft granite' and the top result is still Fandom. EDIT: Hell, even 'Minecraft Wiki' still goes there.
- stevage 2y agoI think there's a big lesson about not investing your time and effort in anything controlled by venture capital.
- 0xcde4c3db 2y agoThe big problem with this is that quite a few things that start out principled and radical wind up controlled by (venture) capital retroactively through mergers and acquisitions. For instance, Napster still actually exists as a minor corporate brand and product line. You can literally subscribe to Napster today if you have $11 kicking around.
- red_admiral 2y agoIf you're an admin of something like a game wiki, then whether it's currently controlled by VC or not, think about how you could back up, export and migrate the data.
- stevage 2y agoYeah, but exporting data is only solving part of the problem. You can't export community, or reputation, or incoming links etc etc.
- account42 2y agoYes and the solution is the same as with email or your blog: own the domain. Domains are cheap enough that almost anyone should be able to afford one for their hobby. If the host doesn't let you bring your own domain, find a better one or self-host.
- lucb1e 2y agoYay for the Minecraft wiki migration! I was so annoyed by having to use Wikia while creating a minecraft scavenger hunt for my partner when wanting to do things with redstone or light level spawnproofing. Opening the wiki now on the domain they host themselves, it is also very noticeably faster to click around. Sounds like a big win for the Minecraft community and kudos on doing such a large migration! Having tried to migrate Telegram groups to Signal, among a group of people studying IT security no less, it became very clear to me how hard it is to migrate communities
- philipov 2y agoI found it easy to stop using Fandom, because their information sucks. It's always out of date, and grossly incomplete.
- TheRealPomax 2y agoWhether I use it or not, it's the first 50 search results: until that changes, fandom is going to keep getting used. It's basically the w3schools for game info: a takeover by people who actually care and then uplifting it to something that's actually good (like what happened with w3schools) is a far better road to victory than getting people to stop using fandom - there are too many people, and too few search engines.
- eluded7 2y agocan't upvote this hard enough
- wannacboatmovie 2y agoIs it fair to assume the guy who hates ads also doesn't want to pay for access? Because this road leads back to the AOL days of paid forum access.
- doublerabbit 2y ago> Because this road leads back to the AOL days of paid forum access. And such could be said that without an ad-block that this road leads to a gaping chasm full of forced malcontent and sponsored information.
- ziddoap 2y agoIt doesn't have to be a choice between numerous giant advertisements for non-gaming items or having a paywall, so I'm not sure why you are saying this as if those are the only two solutions.
- account42 2y agoThere are plenty of ad-free community-run wikis that disprove your point. Hosting costs for these things are quite reasonable even for individuals.
- evmar 2y agoNot that I'm a fan of ads, but I find it interesting that this post specifically complains that the ads aren't targeted enough ("my ad was for furniture - ah yes, just what i wanted" / "i do not have a dog" / "i don't need sunscreen") when I would expect the post's author also probably objects to being profiled by ad networks. It would be less curious if the post was saying something around like "I object to fandom monetizing at all", but also that also probably feels like a less sensible thing to say.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoThe third option that seems to always get overlooked for some reason is that you can target by the content of the page rather than by stalking the user. Someone looking at a ex. Star Wars wiki page is much more likely to be interested in buying sci-fi stuff than furniture.
- account42 2y ago> but also that also probably feels like a less sensible thing to say Does it? It's not like Fandom produces the content they monetize.
- Stagnant 2y agoThere was this site called LyricWiki[0] (lyrics.wikia.com) that was one of the larger wiki sites a few years back. Things went downhill quickly once wikia became fandom. Making new articles and editing was blocked in 2019 and the whole thing was wiped in 2020. It was the largest lyrics site for many smaller languages and as a result it seems lots of lyrics / information has been permanently lost. It also had artist pages which at times contained better information than the actual wikipedia page. I'd like to hear if by change someone had archived lyricwiki before its shutdown. I've looked in to it a couple of times but AFAIK the only pages that were preserved are the ones found in wayback machine. There is a dump of various wikia pages in archive.org but IIRC lyrics wikia is missing from that. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LyricWiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LyricWiki
- languagehacker 2y agoThe dude who made LyricWiki basically had a successful acquisition to Wikia, which is great because the legal trouble that wiki had was needless and profligate. This is one case where the creator had the best outcomes by parting ways with his creation.
- troad 2y agoLyrics are copyrightable literary works, aren't they? I imagine such a service would be quite challenging to host, legally speaking.
- qingcharles 2y agoYou just have to license them. Many sites have.
- troad 2y agoThat makes sense. Might be hard for an freely-editable wiki though.
- doublerabbit 2y agoAnd tvtropes is still holding strong, pretty much launched at the same time as. On interested, here's a 2005 - archived copy: http://web.archive.org/web/20051110015311/http://tvtropes.org/ http://web.archive.org/web/20051110015311/http://tvtropes.or...
- dabbz 2y agoHad to go in and make sure fandom was blocked by my Kagi search filters. We're good now.
- aendruk 2y agoEven better, you can have it automatically rewrite the search result, e.g.: ^https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/(.*)|https://minecraft.wiki/w/$1 https://kagi.com/settings?p=redirects https://kagi.com/settings?p=redirects
- dabbz 2y agoThat's sick! Thanks for the help kind internet stranger!
- languagehacker 2y agoI worked there when it was Wikia. I'm disappointed that the APIs have been hobbled, that the name became something so honestly lame, and that you can't even view images with mobile ad blocking on. It really is about moats and enshittification, which is sad because the communities put a lot of hard work into their content.
- dark-star 2y ago> browse a fandom wiki without an ad blocker you lost me here... Why would you do that?
- ergonaught 2y agoMost don't, particularly if they're on phones. Surely it's pretty easy to understand.
- account42 2y agoIf your phone browser doesn't have an ad blocker then you are making bad choices.
- rchaud 2y agoMost "websites" monetize in the exact same way, minus the McDonalds-specific thing mentioned here. There is no alternative business model. The volume and frequency of ads will increase as well, due to Google slashing premiums over the years. The days when the PlentyOfFish guy could bring in millions in AdSense revenue in a single month are long gone. High-traffic websites will still make more with ads than they will with paid subscriptions. If your website has 1 million users/month and no moat, you'd be doing very well to convert even 0.1% (1,000) of them into paying subscribers. Even that would put you at what, $10k / month? Would that stop you, the site owner, from double-dipping and running ads on paid subscriber accounts? "All the other companies are doing it!"
- rstat1 2y agoIf it were me, yes, yes it would, because those subs are paying to not see ads. If we're talking about a wiki, then there's no point in paying for the subscription if you still get access to all the content AND the ads. Plus for that kind of website that's pretty much entirely static text and images $10k a month should be more than enough to cover the cost of hosting.
- account42 2y agoA community-edited wiki does not need to have a business model. A business trying to monitize user contributions does not need to exist.
- OptionOfT 2y agoArs Technica did the same for a long while, autoplaying video. Many news sites do the same as well. I've been bitten by those before. You click the link to an article, video starts autoplaying, and I'm waiting for a video about the article, only to get a video that is completely unrelated. I actually find it appalling that browser don't have a proper 'do not autoplay video at all' setting.
- jimbobthrowawy 2y agoBrowser features to block autoplay do work. (most default to allow muted videos) Videos won't play unless they're started by javascript triggered by a small handful of user generated events. i.e. if the .play() is further down the call-stack than an .onClick() There's this thing called "click laundering" though. Where the website will take any qualifying event you trigger anywhere on the page and make it play the video. (I did it myself to make a gimmicky webpage work before) It's aggravating, but I think there's browser addons to fix it.
- account42 2y agoIn theory. At least firefox still allows playing audio via window.AudioContext without any user interaction. Audio isn't the only problem though. I'm starting to think that any non-trivial javascript execution should be behind a permission prompt.
- jimbobthrowawy 2y agoBrowser vendors are rightfully scared of "breaking" websites. I don't know how you'd define non-trivial javascript in a way that couldn't be circumvented.
- account42 2y ago> I don't know how you'd define non-trivial javascript in a way that couldn't be circumvented. One approach would be to start out with the interpreter only with extreme throttling. Then to remove the throttling and enable the JIT you'd need explicit permissions.
- PhasmaFelis 2y agoI dunno much about the indie wiki scene in general, but I discovered www.wiki.gg when the Helldivers 2 wiki moved* there, and it's really a breath of fresh air. One banner ad at the top of the page, one at the bottom. And that's page, not screen, you can scroll away from it and it won't follow you. I hear it's better for wiki admins, too, though I don't know the details. Quite a few pretty high-profile wikis seem to have relocated there. * Okay, most of the editors moved there, and apparently the ones that stayed on Fandom have developed a siege mentality and started banning anyone who mentions the new wiki on their Discord. It's very strange. Fandom is worse in every possible way, where's the loyalty coming from?
- liama 2y agoAre you actually charging for your expertise?
- TZubiri 2y agoWhat compels someone to complain about a free service, and even more write an article about it?
- ergonaught 2y agoThe user-hostile shit-down-your-throat user experience. Watching something that you loved and was genuinely useful and important in your life being utterly destroyed by this garbage is pretty motivating to "complaining" and "writing articles". What compelled you to comment about the compulsion? Geez.
- TZubiri 2y agoIt's a simple concept. You pay for services. Some services are free and funded by ads. Be thankful for the free shit instead of being salty about having to "pay" with ads.
- dchftcs 2y agoI think people have a unique edge here to counter your argument because most of the work that goes into fandom wikis are from unpaid volunteers, and they have every right to move somewhere esle.
- JustLeafy 2y agoThe problem here isn't necessarily being a free service and being run on a few ads, the problem is loading 15 to 20 advertisements, as well as the path of enshittification.
- watwut 2y agoIt is simple concept - just because part of your business plan is to give out some stuff for free and then lock the users, it does not make you uncriticizable. There is no reason to be thankful to Fandom in particular.
- ergonaught 2y ago"Paying" with ads and having the experience utterly ruined, highjacked in fact, by those ads, are distinct things. You already understand this unless you're an adtech executive, but you're picking nits because you don't want to engage with the point.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- vitiral 2y agoI enjoyed this. However, if the author is reading I was pretty sure the ASCII sun was in fact an ASCII hole, if you know what I mean. Not that I disapproved, it rather fit the site you were reviewing which is in fact a steaming pile of stfu8.
- jsrecovery 2y agoFormer admin of the Fallout Wiki here, (The Vault/Nukapedia) - the Fandom takeover absolutely decimated the quality of information we worked so hard to curate over the years. For example, we had an explicit “no strategy” rule for our quest related articles. We wanted to provide enough information about the quests without suggesting any “optimal” ways to beat it. Fandom carelessly injected autoplaying videos on said articles with random streamers/youtubers showing you how to best beat the quest. That, coupled with the horrible takeover of styling and structure, I felt Fandom really signed a death warrant for something we were all proud of.
- red-iron-pine 2y agoYeah mostly stopped using The Vault for that reason. You can really see the difference with UESP vs Fandom for the Elder Scrolls
- jsrecovery 2y agoI don’t blame you - there has since been a remerge of content after the Vault forked, so I’ll say there still is valuable information to be found, (I am no longer involved) but the user experience straight up sucks.
- bowsamic 2y agoPlease use capital letters I beg you
- account42 2y agothank you for your input. may i implore you to consider the use of punctuation?
- moritzruth 2y agoThere is a browser extension called "Indie Wiki Buddy" [1] that automatically redirects from a Fandom page to the equivalent community-run wiki. It also optionally replaces links in search results. [1] https://getindie.wiki/ https://getindie.wiki/
- busterarm 2y agoThe problem isn't Fandom, per se, but the ad-driven model for the internet.
- stijnveken 2y agoIf you do happen to land on a fandom wiki, replace "fandom" with "antifandom" in the url for a better experience.
- personjerry 2y agoSurely there's a way to build a wiki on top of GitHub? That automatically converts wiki changes to PRs for example. So that arbitrary wikis can be built open source and leverage github's free hosting
- buro9 2y agoThe problem with wikis is similar to the problem with forums... it's not that they do not work really well, they do, but it's that the cost of running a single wiki or forum in terms of operational overhead and hosting costs is significant. Dynamic user generated content is going to do two things: 1) it's going to result in you needing a database and a web server, capable of a few concurrent users (in addition to bots and guests) but likely sized to handle your spikes in traffic... i.e. over-sized, let's ballpark at $50 per month (people will argue some specifics, but in general this is indicative) 2) it's going to result in you needing to stay up to date, moderate new users, and manage spam... i.e. it requires a disproportionate time investment and the content is likely crappy, you were just having shits and giggles and nerding out on some small thing that you got excited about... not quite worth those costs. the solution then is a multi-tenant platform that distributes the ops, cost and moderation problem evenly across many sites, so perhaps the $ cost to you is $1 per month, and time is hardly anything. but now you've got a different problem, now there's a central entity that "owns" the platform and likely helped itself to a license allowing it to use all of the content, monetise away and profit of the fandom of others. there are anarchic platforms to counter this, but they're small and cannot be the destination for people to migrate to, and so we're stuck with either the high overhead, costs, and burnout of individual sites, or these crappy platforms taking their users for granted. though now I wonder... what license is fandom content under? can an independent entity scrape it and start over?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- re 2y ago> what license is fandom content under? Generally, CC BY-SA https://www.fandom.com/licensing https://www.fandom.com/licensing > can an independent entity scrape it and start over? Sure. The difficult part is migrating the community and competing in search results. Fandom can and does fight efforts to direct people from fandom-hosted wikis to elsewhere. See this other sub-thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40711726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40711726
- iamacyborg 2y agoHosting cost is actually super affordable, even for large and successful wikis. The guy who admins the independent Baldur’s Gate 3 wiki has mentioned it’s only single digits a month and they’re doing tens of millions of pageviews.
- renegat0x0 2y agoThe web search lies in the heart of the problem for me. Pages with ads will rank higher because of Google. It decides what is seen and what is not seen. It will definitely like pages with ads more. Google does not have to care about quality, as it does not have competition. Yet. Google search drowned other smaller communities. The Internet is run by ads. The search is run by ads. Why do we wonder that our content has ads? Now we observe how much a user can tolerate.
- iamacyborg 2y agoI was directly involved with forking the Path of Exile wiki if anyone has any q’s about process.
- NoGravitas 2y agoI really wish Memory Alpha would migrate off of Fandom the way some others have. It's a ridiculously complete and thorough resource, but it's taken significant tuning of my uBlock Matrix rules to make it usable, especially on mobile.
- account42 2y ago> the runescape[2] and minecraft[3] communities acted first If they have .wiki domains then they were not the first by a long shot.