14 ms·
How innovative is China in nuclear power?
- defrost 2y agoFrom the latest Information Technology and Innovation Foundation report (June 17, 2024) Though China built upon a foreign base of technology, it has become the world’s leading proponent of nuclear energy. Chinese firms are well ahead of their Western peers, supported by a whole-of-government strategy that provides extensive financing and systemic coordination. KEY TAKEAWAYS * China intends to build 150 new nuclear reactors between 2020 and 2035, with 27 currently under construction and the average construction timeline for each reactor about seven years, far faster than for most other nations. * China has commenced operation of the world’s first fourth-generation nuclear reactor, for which China asserts it developed some 90 percent of the technology. * China is leading in the development and launch of cost-competitive small modular reactors (SMRs). Overall, analysts assess that China likely stands 10 to 15 years ahead of the United States in its ability to deploy fourth-generation nuclear reactors at scale. * China’s innovation strengths in nuclear power pertain especially to organizational, systemic, and incremental innovation. Many fourth-generation nuclear technologies have been known for years, but China’s state-backed approach excels at fielding them. * Analysts assess that America and China are likely at par when it comes to efforts to develop nuclear fusion technologies, but warn that China’s demonstrated ability to deploy fission reactors at scale gives it an advantage for when fusion comes online. * Looking narrowly at scientific publications on nuclear energy, China ranks first in the H-index, a commonly used metric measuring the scholarly impact of journal publications. * From 2008 to 2023, China’s share of all nuclear patents increased from 1.3 percent to 13.4 percent, and the country leads in the number of nuclear fusion patent applications. Full report (PDF): https://www2.itif.org/2024-chinese-nuclear-innovation.pdf https://www2.itif.org/2024-chinese-nuclear-innovation.pdf In the press: US falling far behind China in nuclear power, report says https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2024/6/17/us-falling-far-behind-china-in-nuclear-power-report-says https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2024/6/17/us-falling-far-b...
- elric 2y agoSeems like China also has rather large uranium reserves, unlike many other countries, so it makes a lot of sense for them to go nuclear.
- preisschild 2y agoTbf importing uranium is fairly easy and relatively cheap due to the high energy density.
- rob74 2y agoYeah, and it's also a great way to reduce your energy dependency on certain non-friendly countries... oh wait: https://apnews.com/article/germany-france-russia-nuclear-power-rosatom-framatome-ce47027005349580306d55553c7f1142 https://apnews.com/article/germany-france-russia-nuclear-pow...
- preisschild 2y agoThat company is just using russian engineers for russian-designed Reactors. Not to mention that you don't even need to do that. Westinghouse already builds VVER fuel assemblies without Russians (they are supplying Ukraine's nuclear power plants, for example)
- elric 2y agoImporting it from where? Russia? Ukraine? China? Australia & Canada are probably viable options for Western nations, but that introduces more dependencies.
- chickenbig 2y ago> that introduces more dependencies Uranium does have the benefit of being very energy dense, so stockpiling it is relatively simple. Also see the IAEA Low Enriched Uranium Bank. https://www.iaea.org/topics/iaea-low-enriched-uranium-bank https://www.iaea.org/topics/iaea-low-enriched-uranium-bank
- seu 2y ago> “They don’t have any secret sauce other than state financing, state supported supply chain, and a state commitment to build the technology.” State, state and more state. I wonder how does this feel for those out there convinced that the state is just a hurdle to innovation and advance.
- baq 2y agoI'm sure a lot of party officials got plenty of nice gifts in the process of building out nuclear. But still - it got built. I guess we'll see in a couple of decades if the quality didn't get compromised.
- amelius 2y agoThe state gave us the internet. So I think those people are a small minority or they haven't paid attention.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoIt’s both, a good state sets up the rules that help solve the game theoretic tragedy of the commons. Without a good framework and smart investment by the state, the 1000x more individuals in the private sector wouldn’t have been able to physically build the internet.
- amelius 2y agoGovernment agencies like DARPA literally invented the internet, so it was definitely more than solving the tragedy of the commons, although that was important too.
- pfdietz 2y agoDARPA is designed to limit how long they will fund any technology, and be very willing to terminate funding for any effort that isn't delivering. As I recall, even a 1% success rate is considered acceptable there.
- 2y ago
- rob74 2y ago> China’s innovation strengths in nuclear power pertain especially to organizational, systemic, and incremental innovation. Many fourth-generation nuclear technologies have been known for years, but China’s state-backed approach excels at fielding them. ...not to mention being able to build a nuclear power plant anywhere they like without resistance from the local population, environmentalists etc.
- noxs 2y ago> https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-23298663 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-23298663 This is not true. People do protest, and project gets cancelled.
- rob74 2y agoThat was more than 10 years ago though. Back then, the Uyghurs in Xinjiang could still live in relative freedom (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Uyghurs_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Uyghurs_in_Chin...), people in Hong Kong could still protest etc. etc.
- alephnerd 2y agoProtests still happen in China very often. For example, the strike at BYD's factory due to wage cuts and silent layoffs a couple weeks ago [0] (the original QQ post was taken down under the NSL [1]), a work stoppages and strikes in Anhui [2], Guangzhou [3], and Shandong [4] a week ago, as well as Workers Call for Help (basically workers complaints to the govt that often turn into strikes if not listened to) [5] The issue is Western reporters don't really use Chinese social media and aren't monitoring it, and in a lot of cases can't even really speak or read Mandarin. Also, China is not that centralized. In most of these protests, the organizers take efforts to point out they are protesting against local functionaries, not Beijing - and they aren't wrong, as Deng's reforms devolved power significantly to the local and provincial level. In China, it tends to be the working class and poor (rural and urban) that tend to protest the most as they have the least to lose and are the ones that face the brunt of economic slowdowns. [0] - https://archive.is/dwGdd https://archive.is/dwGdd [1] - https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/io1cSoE_i_pohJEoDOjkgw https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/io1cSoE_i_pohJEoDOjkgw [2] - https://v.kuaishou.com/EokPBo https://v.kuaishou.com/EokPBo [3] - https://v.kuaishou.com/CXrU74 https://v.kuaishou.com/CXrU74 [4] - https://v.m.chenzhongtech.com/fw/photo/3xxbacwt646zfwu?fid=3734387189&cc=share_copylink&followRefer=151&shareMethod=TOKEN&docId=9&kpn=KUAISHOU&subBiz=BROWSE_SLIDE_PHOTO&photoId=3xxbacwt646zfwu&shareId=17932467184785&shareToken=X8OmQahpZ19EbLA&shareResourceType=PHOTO_OTHER&userId=3x2n4vut9xjzm24&shareType=1&et=1_a%2F2003417479494940818_scn0&shareMode=APP&originShareId=17932467184785&appType=1&shareObjectId=5206161305121962432&shareUrlOpened=0×tamp=1717947952977 https://v.m.chenzhongtech.com/fw/photo/3xxbacwt646zfwu?fid=3... [5] - https://liuyan.people.com.cn/threads/mobilelist?tid=20864736&from=search https://liuyan.people.com.cn/threads/mobilelist?tid=20864736...
- foobarkey 2y agoSo what’s the game plan to compete with industry in China in 30 years when they have built out enough nuclear to do anything? Adtech and LLM-s I guess :)
- NooneAtAll3 2y agospeaking of LLMs, energy grid is one of the bottlenecks predicted in its progress on the nation level...
- foobarkey 2y agoFair point, if the one with the most energy wins LLM-s battle then China looks like it will do even better At least West has chairs, chairs are like people :)
- pie420 2y agoIn 30 years the cost of solar panels+batteries will have fallen so low that power will be the least important part of any manufacturing process. In fact, it already is for everything but the most commodified, low margin products, things that first world countries have no interest in competing.
- aesch 2y agoChina is currently cornering the market on solar panels and batteries and some would say "flooding" the global market to lower costs. If the West doesn't figure out an alternative source for the solar+battery supply chain they could be at the mercy of China in 30 years.
- oezi 2y agoSolar has become a commodity technology and it largely won't matter who is manufacturing it. Solar also is primarily replacing energy imports. So many not spend on buying gas/oil/coal is now being spend on buying solar panels. Thus the petro economies have much more to worry about that money is directed from them to China.
- cm2187 2y agoThe fact that they are building known and tested nuclear designs is rather a good thing in my mind. Less chance of a major fuckup. It also illustrates that nuclear is not inherently more expensive. We just make it so with over regulation and lack of scale.
- jayd16 2y agoLet's wait until a few get done before we calculate how much it is.
- jpgvm 2y agoThey are actually building everything. They have traditional LWR reactors on legacy designs (VVER, EPR, AP1000), bigger LWRs on homegrown designs (Hualong One etc), breeder reactors (CANDU) new 4th gen pebble bed HTGR using acquired German technology and homegrown development and Thorium based MSRs (TMSR-LF1).
- ambicapter 2y agoSo are they innovating or are they using known and tested designs?
- petre 2y agoBoth. They are advancing tech from Germany, building pebble bed reactos for instance. In fact they do this with every design. They license, build, operate and then they build their own improved version. India did it as well with the CANDU, but they were rather forced to.
- throwaway4good 2y agoSo it is autocratic nuclear vs democratic nuclear now? Perhaps we could instead work together to tackle climate change and seek common prosperity ...
- ZeoVII 2y agoTBF, Nuclear is the most efficient and "cheap" way to lower greenhouse emissions and tackle climate change. It is nice to see China go this way, hopefully they will lower their dependency on carbon and fossil fuel sources for energy generation. If only the rest of the world would also adopt this mentality; Germany went the other way, rejecting nuclear and they are now dependant on carbon for their energy...
- cinntaile 2y ago> Germany went the other way, rejecting nuclear and they are now dependant on carbon for their energy... As you can see the data does not support this claim of yours. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-source-and-country?stackMode=absolute&country=~DEU https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-sou...
- cubefox 2y agoTotal power consumption went down due to industry moving out of the country due to increasing electricity cost due the country exiting nuclear power. It's depressing.
- imtringued 2y agoWhat's depressing is how wrong your comment is. You seemingly ignored the Ukrainian war which has lead to sanctioning Russia and the end of cheap Russian oil and gas in Germany. Spot electricity prices are at pre-war levels nowadays, so whatever lack of nuclear power you are imagining is seemingly irrelevant.
- 2y ago
- southEastRon 2y agoApplication error: a client-side exception has occurred (see the browser console for more information). Console: ReferenceError: SpeechSynthesisUtterance is not defined A client-side exception has occurred, see here for more info: https://nextjs.org/docs/messages/client-side-exception-occurred https://nextjs.org/docs/messages/client-side-exception-occur...
- alephnerd 2y agoAs I mentioned before on HN [0], ITIF is a Tech pressure/lobbying organization that has been supported by Gates and Schmidt Futures [1][2] (funding Terrapower and lots of next-gen energy startups now). [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34603490#34604022 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34603490#34604022 [1] - https://itif.org/publications/2016/12/12/itif-welcomes-announcement-breakthrough-energy-ventures-urges-government/ https://itif.org/publications/2016/12/12/itif-welcomes-annou... [2] - https://itif.org/our-supporters/ https://itif.org/our-supporters/
- defrost 2y agoFair call and worth mentioning, cheers. I made a deliberate point to highlight the report source but didn't delve into the backend support. All report producers have some spin direction and agenda, the amount of each varies and some think tanks are more notorious than others for bias (Heartland springs to mind). That aside, Australia has a small population and at this point in time a rudderless plan for a carbon future; their conservative wing are all in on a nuclear plan that makes little economic sense and pretty much just green lights immediate coal plant expansion and kicking emissions targets down the road, the opposing left and governing wing have been captured by promises of carbon capture from LPG gas producers that are technically more sky than pie. The technical report on Australian power futures: https://www.csiro.au/en/research/technology-space/energy/GenCost https://www.csiro.au/en/research/technology-space/energy/Gen... Some commentary on the nuclear 'plan': https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https%3A%2F%2Fwww.crikey.com.au%2F2024%2F06%2F17%2Fpeter-dutton-energy-policy-nuclear-coal-renewables%2F https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https%... ( webcache link to subscriber article ) and .. ffs I've misplaced an article shredding the opposition plan. Power for the future is an interesting space ATM. I've appreciated your comments here BTW :-)
- alephnerd 2y ago> Australia has a small population and at this point in time a rudderless plan for a carbon future I'd disagree. Australia is going all-in on Green Hydrogen for industrial usecases, and is working closely with Japan and India on this front [0][1] and has basically made production tax free [2]. Ik HNers are very negative in their views about Hydrogen Energy, but the slowness in the industry was due to the lack of funding and capital in the space, along with a relative lack of interest about the technology in the US. Now that the UAE [3], KSA [4], Australia [0], Japan [5], South Korea [6], USA [7], and India [8] have all begun investing billions in coordination with each other in these projects, we'll see it productionize in a decade - especially because all these countries have FTAs with each other and are working together on Hydrogen capacity and investments (almost $100B at this point just among those 7). [0] - https://www.dcceew.gov.au/energy/hydrogen https://www.dcceew.gov.au/energy/hydrogen [1] - https://www.dcceew.gov.au/climate-change/international-climate-action/international-partnerships/india-australia-green-hydrogen-taskforce https://www.dcceew.gov.au/climate-change/international-clima... [2] - https://www.spglobal.com/commodityinsights/en/market-insights/latest-news/energy-transition/051524-australias-a2kg-production-tax-incentive-for-renewable-hydrogen-to-help-energy-transition https://www.spglobal.com/commodityinsights/en/market-insight... [3] - https://www.investmentmonitor.ai/news/abu-dhabi-government-and-hycap-to-build-green-hydrogen-complex/?cf-view https://www.investmentmonitor.ai/news/abu-dhabi-government-a... [4] - https://saudiarabien.ahk.de/en/market-information/energy-sector-in-saudi-arabia-bahrain/hydrogen-central-role-saudi-arabia https://saudiarabien.ahk.de/en/market-information/energy-sec... [5] - https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/japan-invest-107-bln-hydrogen-supply-over-15-years-2023-06-06/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/japan-invest-107-bln... [6] - https://hk.boell.org/en/2023/04/26/wag-dog-hydrogen-scheme-south-korea https://hk.boell.org/en/2023/04/26/wag-dog-hydrogen-scheme-s... [7] - https://apnews.com/article/hydrogen-hubs-energy-biden-climate-pennsylvania-west-virginia-d609a455a6dd018fca5af785f245c6fd https://apnews.com/article/hydrogen-hubs-energy-biden-climat... [8] - https://www.nbr.org/publication/the-evolving-story-of-hydrogen-in-india-and-opportunities-for-global-cooperation/ https://www.nbr.org/publication/the-evolving-story-of-hydrog...
- grecy 2y ago> average construction timeline for each reactor about seven years China have 27 in construction right now, can someone knowledgeable explain why it still takes 7 years to build a single reactor? I've always read that if we were building more reactors we would get economies of scale, and things would happen quickly.. but that doesn't seem to be the case.
- godelski 2y agoOf those being built, most of them began construction in the last 2 years[0]. If you look at the timelines, China is doing much better than others on timelines. For the economies of scale, one needs to only look at the historical example of France (same link). This issue here is that when you infrequently build reactors you have to reinvent all the tooling to build the sub-components. This is actually what caused the Westinghouse bankruptcy. But your question is about 7 years being a long time. China seems to be pushing that down to 5, but how much time are you expecting? There's always a trade-off here and frankly big projects take time. I suspect you have an incorrect mental model where you think other energy systems are constructed much faster. I pulled a random US example from the list of photovoltaic systems[1] and so let's look at Westlands Solar Park which is a 2GW facility[2]. We can see planning began before 2014 (since that's when a real estate company was involved), initial demonstrations in 2014 (2MW), construction began in 2020, took another 1-2 years to get 250MW online, another year (2023) to get another 420MW online, and the facility isn't expected to be finished until 2025. So we can say that the time takes is at least 5 years. For reference let's look at Yangjiang, China is doing about 6 on their reactors which are around the 1GW scale. And you'll notice that while staggered, these are often parallel so the whole facility is going online in roughly 10 years, but that's 6GW where past the initial first 8 years, one is going online every year. This example was even slowed down by Fukushima. But you can see they've done that a few times and can tell that that was their foray into building nuclear power, and after success you do more. As long as they have good construction (and we should expect these to be higher quality than many other things in China because there are international inspectors and overseers), then I expect them to even get a bit faster. But the overall timeframe for building isn't significantly worse than building a solar plant of a much smaller capacity. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_commercial_nuclear_reactors#China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_commercial_nuclear_rea... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_photovoltaic_power_stations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_photovoltaic_power_sta... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westlands_Solar_Park#Phases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westlands_Solar_Park#Phases
- curtis3389 2y agoSome of China's new reactors are pebble-bed reactors, which I just think are super-cool: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pebble-bed_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pebble-bed_reactor
- iso8859-1 2y agoWhat I love about them is that they require a lot of investment, and investment means jobs. The decommissioning of the AVR in Jülich is estimated to cost 2.5 billion euros. That's a lot of jobs! It even translates to American jobs, since the relevant authorities (now public, of course) is planning to export the nuclear waste to USA.[0] It's a win-win! [0]: https://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/vorab/juelich-entsorgung-radioaktiven-muells-kostet-fast-eine-halbe-milliarde-a-919660.html https://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/vorab/juelich-entsorgung-radi...
- mcculley 2y agoBut if it required less investment, wouldn’t that free up cash for other investments and jobs? I don’t understand why projects which require more labor would be desirable.
- hnfong 2y agoIt seems like the problem with modern capitalism is too much money and too few real jobs.
- mcculley 2y agoThere are many jobs unfilled. The biggest problem right now is that unemployed people have the wrong skills for the jobs that need to be filled. This trend will accelerate along with technological advances, no matter which kind of economic system is involved.
- petre 2y agoThey have the right skills for storming the Capitol, unfortunately. And the time to do so.
- shrubble 2y agoSo Westinghouse sold the Chinese 4x AP1000, knowing full well that the Chinese would learn, document and then copy/clone the designs all over. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AP1000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AP1000 Which is exactly what happened; with the follow-on that any improvements are patented and the patent rights are owned solely by the Chinese: "In 2008 and 2009, Westinghouse made agreements to work with the Chinese State Nuclear Power Technology Corporation (SNPTC) and other institutes to develop a larger design, the CAP1400 of 1,400 MWe capacity, possibly followed by a 1,700 MWe design. China will own the patent rights for these larger designs. Exporting the new larger units may be possible with Westinghouse's cooperation."
- chickenbig 2y ago> Westinghouse sold the Chinese 4x AP1000 https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/countries-a-f/china-nuclear-power.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profil... > Westinghouse has agreed to transfer technology to SNPTC over the first four AP1000 units so that SNPTC can build the following ones on its own. So it seems a bit unfair to say the Chinese somehow reversed engineered the AP1000 design. This also happened when Combustion Engineering sold the System 80+ design (a derivative of that deployed at Palo Verde) to South Korea. Apparently Combustion Engineering were in financial trouble and did what was necessary to get the deal, although Westinghouse (who eventually came to own the Combustion Engineering intellectual property) are currently disputing this deal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OPR-1000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OPR-1000
- aeternum 2y agoBetter the Chinese actually use the tech than it sets in regulatory deadlock in the US. Sad to see the US lose freedoms just as rapidly as a Chinese citizens. One one case, onerous regulation and on the other a decrease of personal freedom but the overall result is surprisingly similar.
- autoexecbat 2y agoThis seems like a great thing for the environment (geopolitics aside)
- creer 2y agoCurrently I don't even know that "most innovative" really matters, compared to "being able to deliver". Between being by far the biggest market, AND demanding technology transfer here and there, AND using local (chinese) manufacturers and builders (even in some infrastructure export projects!), AND being ready to provide funding for export - well, that's bound to result in decent market competitiveness.
- cmarschner 2y agoMy prediction is that the world will stabilize somewhere around 80% renewables and 20% nuclear. Maybe less. Prove me wrong
- Smar 2y agoI'd think more nuclear would be better for environment. Since sun does not shine around the clock and other renewables have larger negative environmental impact. Batteries for storage is not good either with today's technology. Pure nuclear, or even as a majority production method, would be fool's errand, though. Unless someone manages to invent small enough reactors that can be started and stopped at will, to adjust a day's power demands. I doubt that can even be possible, though.
- cmarschner 2y agoIn the end it is a matter of economics. Right now there is no path towards nuclear becoming competitive again against wind, solar, battery. Plus, storage and cleanup costs in case of failures are not even priced in and left to taxpayers. This leaves nuclear to government actors influenced by lobbyists.
- rcxdude 2y agoGiven they don't complement each other, I predict that equilibrium to be unstable: either nuclear or renewables will grow to mostly replace the other, due to economic forces.
- 4fterd4rk 2y agoBut they do complement each other... Nuclear provides the base generation that's online 24/7 while renewables are unstable and able to provide the peak demand.
- pfdietz 2y agoNo, they are not typically complementary. The optimal solutions for powering a grid tend to either be all-nuclear or all-renewable (usually the latter now), depending on cost assumptions. Optimal solutions with a mixture are uncommon.
- credit_guy 2y agoChina is innovative, period. The whole song and dance about technology being known for decades is total nonsense. The devil is in the details, especially in the nuclear reactor industry space. The article mentions Westinghouse AP1000, but fails to mention that in the end China decided to not use it on a large scale. China is going full on with a different design, called Hualong One [1], which evolved from a French design from the 1980's. The 4 decades of subsequent iteration and improvement were all Chinese. China also built a small helium cooled gas reactor, HTR-10 [2] in the 90's. It operated it and learned from its operation, and built 2 more reactors of the same type, HTR-PM, each about 20 times larger. They got hooked to the grid late last year. There are too many good things to say about helium-cooled high temperature nuclear reactors. With these reactors in operation, China can learn so many lessons and go in so many directions. The article's assessment that the US is 10 to 15 years behind is spot on. China deserves all the praise. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hualong_One https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hualong_One [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTR-10 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTR-10