6 ms·
Edinburgh, Scotland makes it illegal to advertise SUVs
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-solutions/2024/06/15/fossil-fuel-advertising-bans-edinburgh/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-solutions/2024/06/15/...
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- josephcsible 2y agoI wish the politicians who enacted this ban were themselves forbidden from using or benefiting from any of the products or services that they banned advertising for.
- Retr0id 2y agoWhy?
- josephcsible 2y agoBecause it's a really bad double standard when the ruling class says "you should stop doing these polluting things, but we want to keep doing them."
- Retr0id 2y agoThe only "victim" here is SUV vendors (and to a lesser extent, billboard owners), which I'm perfectly fine with. People can still buy SUVs if they want to.
- loloquwowndueo 2y agoWhat makes you think they are not? Also it’s not like they’re banning existing SUVs or SUV sales altogether, just looking to reduce visibility a bit. They and anyone who knows they really need an SUV can still go buy one.
- treyd 2y agoThe extent to which this could be enforced would be fine, actually. These products/services should be phased out already, if not fully banned.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoSo instead of letting people choose through supply and demand the conveniences and trade offs they want, you want to force your will onto them through authoritarian censorship and bans?
- treyd 2y agoEspecially in the case of the heavy carbon emitters, yes this is ultimately one of many necessary steps to avert climate disaster. No person is having their right to free speech infringed and the bans actually serve the common good. It's a pretty reasonable compromise.
- mathgradthrow 2y agoMaybe just ban advertising altogether.
- Moldoteck 2y agoNice, a concept similar to advertising alcohol/tobaco in certain countries!
- Synaesthesia 2y agoIt's sad that SUV's proliferated, especially after the relatively climate and environment-aware decades of the 80's and 90's but I've realised that only governments can enact sensible environmental laws. Like for instance how China banned single serving plastic usage.
- lim_nick 2y agoWould love to hear some more about your realization. Any thoughts on what it is about either governments or sensible environmental laws that makes this the case? edit: After rereading I realized I misinterpreted your post. I read "enact" to mean "enact and enforce" but in a sense you are correct that only governments can enact legislation. I see now you made no claims about ability to design enforceable policy.
- trgn 2y agoA tragedy of the commons can only be solved top down.
- dredmorbius 2y agoActually, that's not the case, and wasn't even the argument made in Garrett Hardin's original essay on the topic, which suggested instead privatisation as a frequently-effective mechanism. Those who are opposed to that approach on the basis of criticisms of enclosures acts and the end of traditional commons have many arguments on their side, but the general effectiveness of privatisation in that particular case is not amongst them. (Hardin is also pointedly arguing about a far larger problem, including of commons which are less readily closed such as ocean fisheries, and of the total global human population of Earth, in which privatisation might not hold, or for which other approaches, some of which are strongly criticised today, might be applied.) The one dynamic which solving a tragedy of the commons requires is that it not be possible to privatise gains whilst socialising costs, which drives the entire logic of the tragedy. How that is arrived at still leaves multiple options.
- IX-103 2y agoI think the proliferation of SUVs in America is almost completely due to environmental laws. There are different fuel efficiency standards for cars and for trucks. Since the standards for trucks are so much looser, someone had the bright idea to build a car body on a truck frame. That way they only had to meet the truck standards. Later laws were changed to recognize SUV as a separate class, but the standards are still just a gradual improvement over truck standards, and not near where car requirements are.
- krsna 2y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20240615144519/https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-solutions/2024/06/15/fossil-fuel-advertising-bans-edinburgh/ https://web.archive.org/web/20240615144519/https://www.washi...
- gruez 2y agoSeems to be not just SUVs, but any cars that aren't electric/hybrid as well. Another source: https://www.campaignlive.com/article/ad-industry-bodies-criticise-edinburgh-ooh-ban/1874744 https://www.campaignlive.com/article/ad-industry-bodies-crit... >Councillors voted 15-2 yesterday in favour of a ban on ads for [...] cars (except electric and hydrogen vehicles), all SUVs
- graemep 2y agoIt is pretty limited. It only affects ads on sites controlled by the city itself. So ads on private property are allowed, and of course it has not effect on ads in any sort of publication, broadcast etc.
- Qem 2y agoWise move. The "car obesity epidemic" in the last ~20 years scares me as a pedestrian. It feels less safe to walk the streets. The average car I see in the streets got noticeably bigger, taking a lot of space. To see drivers navigating narrower streets today is like watching a tetris game, with vehicles barely fitting side-by-side, requiring curb climbing and/or a lot of skill. Rearview mirrors and tire caps get damaged very often. In the arms race for driving the largest car, everybody loses.
- bequanna 2y agoLiving in a somewhat rural area, I have no choice but to own a car. And since I have a family, I want to drive the safest, most practical car possible that can handle frequent needs like transporting children, pets, luggage, etc all at the same time. A "large" SUV checks all the boxes. If I lived in an urban area, I think it would be difficult and annoying to own a larger vehicle. Traffic, parking, narrow lanes, bikes, peds, etc would all make it pretty inconvenient. Many cities are charging vehicles to enter (like NYC). Maybe they could charge considerably more for larger vehicles or make it very low cost for small, compact cars?
- bobthepanda 2y agoThe minivan and station wagon both used to be more common and were generally safer. We just need to close the SUV mileage loophole. A lot of modern SUVs and crossovers actually have poor capacities relative to their size.
- bequanna 2y agoWell, station wagons and minivans still exist—-we now just call them “crossover” SUVs. And I’ve looked at those options: the storage, seating and safety is just not the same as a large SUV. If you are using the word “safety” to mean safety for peds and bicyclists, I would likely agree with you that smaller cars are better for that. There are many blind spots on larger SUVs.
- 2y ago
- windowshopping 2y agoArticle doesn't say anything about banning advertisements for SUVs. It only talks about banning advertisements for gas-powered vehicles. Kind of a strange bait and switch title.
- Drunk_Engineer 2y agoAutomakers spend anywhere from $20-$30 BILLION annually on advertising, largely on TV and internet. Good luck to Edinburgh trying to shut off that firehose.
- xenophonf 2y agoPerfect is the enemy of good.
- jll29 2y agoEdinburgh is such a walkable city, I had a fantastic half a decade living there (without a car, apart from the rental one when moving there). This sounds like the right move to maintain the pedestrian-friendliness and to keep the air cleaner. However, the houses there are often old/historic, with very inefficient heating systems (some even use electricity to heat up a bunch of bricks, which then emits the heat to keep warm) - shocking! Also, windows are not normally with double or triple glass, and sometimes it is not permissible to change these because many buildings are protected.
- sfeng 2y agoThose brick heaters are smart because they use electricity at off-peak times to heat the house for the whole day. What about it strikes you as less efficient than any other direct electric heating?
- nmeofthestate 2y agoThey're pretty dreadful in that they leak heat while charging up during the night, using (still-expensive) off-peak electricity, when you don't really need the heat, then run out of stored heat quickly during the day, failing to do their job. Maybe in a heavily insulated building they would work better - just my personal experience before ripping them out to install gas central heating.
- _Wintermute 2y agoThey don't work particularly well. You're roasting in the night when they heat up, nice and toasty at breakfast, but by the time you're back from work in the evening you're sat in the cold.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThey’re a suboptimal version of a boiler heat pump. https://electrek.co/2022/01/05/these-new-affordable-electric-heat-pumps-can-easily-replace-gas-boilers/ https://electrek.co/2022/01/05/these-new-affordable-electric...
- rdlw 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- egypturnash 2y agoMore precisely, Edinburgh just joined multiple other cities in banning the advertisement of an assortment of companies and products related to high consumption of fossil fuels. This does include SUVs. From the proposed amendment that this WaPo story cites (https://democracy.edinburgh.gov.uk/documents/s70730/9.1%20Policy%20on%20Advertising%20and%20Sponsorship%20-%20Proposed%20Amendments.pdf https://democracy.edinburgh.gov.uk/documents/s70730/9.1%20Po...), this is what kind of ads are banned, along with the comments regarding these things: Airlines and airports: all advertising by airports and airlines which might reasonably be deemed to promote more flying There are no low carbon options for commercial air travel available currently or for the foreseeable future, so air travel per se should be treated as high carbon. Fossil fuel companies: all firms and associated sub brands or lobbying organisations that extract, refine, produce, supply, distribute, or sell any fossil fuels This includes, regardless of the companies’ potential sustainability commitments advertising or sponsorship: • showing fossil fuel products, energy from coal or hydrogen • showing petrol stations, and any ads promoting the price of petrol/diesel Cars: exclude all advertising and promotions for petrol, diesel and hybrid vehicles and Plug-In Hybrid Electric Vehicles (PHEV) Advertising for Battery Electric Vehicles (BEV) and hydrogen fuelled vehicles are still permitted if these are not Sport Utility Vehicles (SUVs). PHEVs have been shown not to yield meaningful emissions savings over conventional vehicles. Cruise holidays: Cruise ships emit more carbon per passenger kilometre than flying. They also generate black carbon and produce a lot of waste which is often discharged into the sea. Their engines run 24/7, often even at port which has damaging impacts on air quality.
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- giantg2 2y ago"all firms and associated sub brands or lobbying organisations that extract, refine, produce, supply, distribute, or sell any fossil fuels" What about all the secondary products of refining? Things like plastics, waxes, etc? Seems like they should include those too.
- 2y ago
- toomuchtodo 2y agoYou love to see it. Onward! More of this!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThis is an absurd restriction on freedom of speech, and indicates Scotland has no foundational protection for basic rights.
- 28304283409234 2y agoCompanies do not have freedom of speech.
- anamax 2y ago> Companies do not have freedom of speech. Do I have freedom of speech? How about Joe Smith? Assuming that the answer is yes, why do Joe and I acting together/cooperating not have freedom of speech? I ask because a company is people acting together/cooperating. Also, what about unions and public advocacy organizations?
- CRConrad 2y agoIf you want to speak for your company, then you speak for your company. You have freedom of speech. Same goes for Joe. If a company is just "people acting together/cooperating", then there is no company -- it's not a person, nor even a thing; it's just something people do. ("Acting together" and "cooperating" are both verbs.) This "free speech for companies" malarkey is what "companies" (= (usually rich) people) hide behind when "the company" does bad shit. Granting "companies" legal personhood is one of the bigger reasons the USA are as fucked up as they are.
- thot_experiment 2y ago[flagged]
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThey already have a tax built into them, which is on gas. Just because you disagree with others wanting certain convenient doesn’t mean that you should be permitted to put them in literal danger by committing terrorism, which is what you’re advocating for.
- thot_experiment 2y agoThat tax is hugely not enough for how bad they are for society. It's not about convenience, it's about them literally killing people (through impacts and outsized tire microplasic contribution) and destroying our infrastructure at a rate much greater than small cars and (road wear is proportional to the FOURTH POWER of axle weight). Obviously people should just bike and use public transit, but we can start by taxing heavy/tall cars appropriately for their enormous negative impact.