6 ms·
YouTube embeds ads into videos to beat ad blockers
- superkuh 2y agoI have to wonder if the computational resource cost of this will outweigh the "lost" ad revenues in the short term at the very least. If it "works" then maybe it can be justified.
- NegativeLatency 2y agoDon't know much about video encoding, but I imagine there are some clever tricks google can pull to embed the ads with keyframes, since when you upload your video to youtube they already do re-encodes. I'm imagining there's some hand wavey stuff that would allow you to sorta concat the ad with different parts of the video. I'd also imagine that the newer video codecs were explicitly designed to make stuff like this possible without a ton of computational resources.
- poikroequ 2y agoThat sounds about right. I don't know much about video encoding either, but there is software which can losslessly splice videos on key frames. It's also possible to join multiple segments together, as long as all the segments have the same properties (codec, resolution, fps, etc). If this is true, then it would be relatively inexpensive to splice ads into videos like this.
- bishbosh 2y agoSome comments on the other posts on the topic went over this. Sounds like putting the ad before the keyframe makes it easy enough. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40658552 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40658552
- superkuh 2y agoIf that's true then maybe client side de-splice will be just as easy.
- NegativeLatency 2y agoI guess we're upping the ante on how to identify an ad. The next ad-blocking arms race will be between perceptual ad blockers and the companies trying to embed ads that look like part of the content (ai vs ai). https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.03194 https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.03194
- ztetranz 2y agoWay back in the days of video recorders, analog TV etc, I remember hearing talk of trying to detect ads on broadcast TV to either pause recording or maybe provide some sort of skip functionality on playback. I think they did something looking at the horizontal sync signal. The was a clear discontinuity when the station switched from program to ad and back again.
- snowwrestler 2y agoThere was an ad-skipping feature of early DVRs that reacted to a sudden increase of volume. Yup, TV stations would broadcast the ads louder than the shows.
- NegativeLatency 2y agoMy parents still use a TiVo and it as ad skipping features: https://tivoidp.tivo.com/tivoCommunitySupport/s/article/SkipMode?language=en_US https://tivoidp.tivo.com/tivoCommunitySupport/s/article/Skip... I think the ads might be manually tagged, which would be a lot easier with hundreds of broadcast shows, instead of thousands/millions of random videos on youtube.
- Loughla 2y agoSweet Christ that brings up horrible memories of scrambling across the living room to turn down the volume on a knob when I was seriptitiously watching late night tv. The volume on the shows were good, but the damn commercials were SO LOUD. I blame a local car dealer for most of my groundings as a child.
- 2y ago
- usernamed7 2y agoI really value youtube, but as long as google owns it I will never pay, never ever. Nor will I watch ads. But if youtube broke off one day and became independent like paypal did, i would gladly pay for it.
- edm0nd 2y agoPro tip, if you have a VPN provider and set it to Ukraine, YouTube Premium comes out to only ~$2.7x/month. Makes it way more enjoyable for a fraction of the price. Once you buy it, you dont have to keep your VPN or anything, it will always rebill at the $2.xx price each month.
- zelphirkalt 2y agoIf enough people do that, they will try counter measures.
- treflop 2y agoFor how much I watch and enjoy YouTube, paying full price is absolute worth it.
- verdverm 2y agoThe family plan is a good deal too
- Loughla 2y agoThat's an awesome note. Thank you.
- bdlowery 2y agoDon’t do this. Google will ban your account. My friends have done this before in video games and have gotten their accounts perma banned months / years later.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 2y ago
- nimbius 2y agoThis seems to cause playback failures in ublock from what ive seen. MPV doesn't appear affected though.
- abetusk 2y agoIs there any alternative right now that blocks these ads?
- etchalon 2y agoYouTube Premium.
- amne 2y agoyou mean pay actual money instead of time? what are we? savages?
- mdp2021 2y agoAnonymous electronic payments are not trivial. Edit: for the information of anyone not yet realizing the following: the chances that some of us will let anyone keep track of our cultural activities is much, much less than zero, and surely less than our disposition to extermination. It is called, "The Basics". I know they are missed by many, but they ought to be informed.
- epicide 2y agoI paid for YT Premium for years until I noticed just how atrociously YT runs in Firefox. There were also the accusations that YT slows down the video pages for anybody with an adblocker... even if they're paying for Premium. I block ads at the DNS level and am not about to tweak things forever just to de-mangle my paid-for YT experience. So I dropped Premium, started supporting channels that I actually watch directly via things like Patreon, and watch YT videos via tools like Invidious and yt-dlp. Local video players such as mpv and IINA are so much better than the YT player has ever been in any browser and I don't have to worry about buffering. The bonus is that I can keep a backup of favorite videos sans baked-in ads or whatever customer-hostile tactic Google dreams up next.
- etchalon 2y agoThis is what I always expected platforms would do if blockers became ubiquitous enough – make it impossible to easily separate first party and third-party content. Podcast platforms already have to do this – dynamic ad insertion is done within the file itself. I suspect we'll start to see sites use proxy server solutions to mask third-party ads on the web as well.
- seydor 2y agoi hope at least they embed in proper positions not awkward interruptions. also i hope it's not those 90 second ads. brainwash me quickly please
- bananapub 2y agoAnnoying, but fair. Unlike almost every other ad supported service, YouTube has an easy and fairly cheap way to eliminate these ads. So it’s really just a test of whether people hate ads or just want everything for free.
- beshrkayali 2y agoCan still be beat with SponsorBlock I suppose, but someone will have to submit the segments to skip first.
- jsheard 2y agoThey're not just burning the ads into the video once, they're splicing them in dynamically, so the location and duration of ads can be different every time you view a video. The article literally quotes the SponsorBlock dev saying this breaks SponsorBlock because it assumes the ads will always be at the same timestamp.
- Kim_Bruning 2y agoDoes sponsorblock block these? https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/sponsorblock/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/sponsorblock/
- jsheard 2y agoNo, the source of the information in the article is the author of SponsorBlock saying they currently have no way to distinguish the ads from the content for users who are getting these inline ads.
- slimginz 2y agoThe dev actually went on Twitter[1] to say this currently breaks the extension and they disabled submissions from users with embedded ads enabled [1] https://twitter.com/SponsorBlock/status/1800835402666054072 https://twitter.com/SponsorBlock/status/1800835402666054072
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Some more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40657933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40657933
- squigz 2y agoI'll say this every time this comes up: if YouTube wants money for their service, that's fine and their right, but they do not have the right to try to circumvent what my browser does. If they don't like that, they can block people who use adblockers. Simple.
- novagameco 2y agoWhy do they not have that right?
- DennisAleynikov 2y agoYeah technically they aren't trying to circumvent anything your browser is doing they are just serving you videos with ads in them instead of videos and ads served separately
- unsui 2y agowhy would they have that right?
- novagameco 2y agoRights must be negated, not affirmed
- atorodius 2y agoI don’t see how that is a logical set of sentenced. You try to circumvent their ads, they try to circumvent your ad blocking.
- judge2020 2y agoThey do have the right to try to circumvent what your browser does. They're not even circumventing it by trying to disable stuff in your browser; they're just changing their delivery mechanism. It's semantics but in reality they're not actually messing with your computer. The alternative is revoking your viewing privileges without having watched an ad for the video you clicked on, which they both morally and legally have the right to do if you decide not to pay for the service you're consuming.
- maxglute 2y agoWhat's next? Maybe jump by youtube thumbails +/- seconds. There's old project called timelens with youtube userscript that generates visual timeline like: https://timelens.blinry.org/assets/images/youtube-screenshot.png https://timelens.blinry.org/assets/images/youtube-screenshot... Matching bands of colours signitures that maps to whats actually onscreen seems more durable than timestamps. Until youtube gets rid of preview thumbnails.
- kawogi 2y agoI really wish that I could pay for an ad-free service, without being tracked on every site there is :( Just offer a plain youtube-Account and we have a deal.
- lumb63 2y agoThey might be able to beat “ad blockers” referring to the software that blocks ads; I don’t think they’ll ever beat “ad blockers”, the humans that are looking to block ads. There is a certain breaking point where people will simply not watch the content anymore. I am astounded that this hasn’t happened already and a migration to some other alternative site hasn’t ensued.
- smallerfish 2y agoNot that I like ads, but hopefully this will fix their stupid bugs integrating with chromecast, where the auto-switching to an ad sometimes throws to a different video in the playlist.
- zb3 2y agoNote that the frontend code still knows that an ad is played, and bytes of the actual video are still pushed without any artificial delay, so for now ad blockers can deal with this using a custom script.
- drowntoge 2y agoSponsorBlock is already available and does an excellent job of filtering out embedded ad content inserted by content creators themselves, which (IMO) tends to be much sneakier than anything Google could implement. I also can't see how they could hide the interactive part of the ad ('Click to buy' links etc.) from blockers, so even in the best case where the embedded video ad go undetected, the links will not appear/be clickable. Google probably knows that trying to dodge content blockers in a browser environment is a losing battle. But hey, it might bump up their numbers for the next earnings call. Being extremely short-sighted seems to be the name of the game in tech lately, so they'll probably go for it, and call it a success.
- tmtvl 2y agoI suspect that as Alphabet clamps down more and more on combating ad blockers the major competitors to YouTube (Tick Tock, Twitch, Odyssey, Nicovideo, Bitchute,...) will start gaining more and more traction until people start switching over en masse.
- vdnkh 2y agoTwitch has been stitching ads for years.
- BatFastard 2y agoSadly YouTube has become a NO GO site. I am willing to watch an ad for a video I want to see, but so often with youtube content I dismiss the video within 5 seconds of it starting. I am not willing to watch 2 minutes of ads to find out if I want to watch the video in the first place. What alternate sites are there?
- frizlab 2y agoNone. That’s the problem. My take is the video format is terrible and should not exist in the first place anyway, so I live happily far away from all the yt drama. For instance it was the WWDC this week and all the sessions are video. Most of them could be articles instead and it would be much better/useful. (Thankfully they provide full searchable transcripts now, so at least there’s that…) I do watch videos: TV Shows and movies. Which I pay other services to provide for me.
- tzs 2y agoTwo minutes of ads!? On desktop most ads YouTube gives me allow skipping after 5 seconds. Most of the ones that don't allowed skipping at 15 seconds or less. In back to back ads if the first cannot be skipped the second almost always can be skipped after 5 seconds. Ads are longer on my Fire TV Stick but almost never is the total time that cannot be skipped more than 30 seconds. Now I'm curious what other people are seeing? Is what I'm seeing closer to what most people see or is what you are experiencer closer to the YouTube norm?
- xnx 2y agoImportant topic that has been posted a few times: 2 days ago. 87 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40657933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40657933 2 days ago. 91 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40666304 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40666304
- pentagrama 2y agoNot sure if the mention of the SponsorBlock browser extension in the article is correct. To my knowledge, this extension doesn't block programmatic ads (off-stream) like regular ad blockers do. Instead, it "blocks" ads that creators include in their videos (e.g., "This video is sponsored by Squarespace") by automatically skipping these segments using crowdsourced timestamp data reported by users. It's similar to how you can manually jump ahead on the video timeline. I believe this extension was affected by YouTube's recent changes because now some videos are longer due to on-stream ads, causing the timestamps to be out of sync for users watching these videos. However, I could be mistaken.
- Bancakes 2y agoYes and YouTube wants to randomize these somehow
- jknutson 2y agoTechnically speaking, how do they accomplish this? Given the amount of advertisers they have, the amount of ads that each advertiser is showing, and the amount of variations of those ads that they’re showing (5s, 15s, etc), I think we can safely rule out the possibly that they’re just splicing together an infinite amount of permutations of ads and videos and saving them to disk. They must be doing some sort of on-the-fly streaming of these ads? It cannot be the case that they’re trying to actually transcode / edit all those different ad possibilities together.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoIs there really a belief that people who use ad blockers are worthwhile ad targets.
- jodybruchon 2y agoThis should be easy to defeat. YouTube videos are usually delivered as DASH streams and an ad would just send down a different fragment. Loading the video multiple times will load injected ads in different places but the core video segments will always be present. The differences could determine what's an ad and what's not. Detected ad segments can be added to a known ad bloom filter, correct segments could be added to a known valid bloom filter, or both.