6 ms·
We just broke ground on America's first next-gen nuclear facility
- chrisweekly 2y agoFantastic news! Better late than never. Aiming to come online in 2030. Hopefully to be followed in short order by many more.
- aussiegreenie 2y ago>Aiming to come online in 2030. That is a funny way to type 2080....
- shrimp_emoji 2y agoYou're thinking of the fusion plant. ;D This one's fission.
- onychomys 2y agoIn related news, if you've ever wondered how good Bill Gates is at poker, he played a little with some locals from Kemmerer while there for the groundbreaking. https://cowboystatedaily.com/2024/06/11/when-it-comes-to-poker-bill-gates-can-bluff-with-kemmerers-best/ https://cowboystatedaily.com/2024/06/11/when-it-comes-to-pok...
- mjhay 2y agoForgive me for being cynical at this point, but I'll believe it when it comes online. I sure hope they're successful, though. Nuclear is still the only thing we have going for relatively near-term non fossil-fuel baseload. Anything not near term is too late.
- hedora 2y agoIt's a race between nuclear, batteries, and using direct air capture to make up for remaining fossil fuels, concrete and other corner case greenhouse gas emissions. I think direct air capture is going to be the technology that gets us over the finish line, simply because it's the only one that has a path to net-zero. Nuclear, renewables and batteries all make carbon capture more affordable, so the ultimate answer is probably "all of the above".
- mjhay 2y agoDirect air capture is really about the least realistic of popular geoengineering proposals. The atmosphere is huge. We didn't get into this situation overnight - it took almost two centuries and oodles of factories, vehicles, concrete plants, etc. It's vastly cheaper just not to output more CO2 in the first place. Thermodynamic constraints mean that tremendous amounts of energy are required to do DAC in the first place, not to mention the knock-on biosphere effects of the production required to build that hitherto-unseen scale of capability. We can't magic-tech our way out of this situation. It will take huge effort, and more importantly, sacrifice of the unthinking low-value abundance we have. Nuclear power is hard, but it is still much more realistic than unproven wundertech like DAC.
- thehappypm 2y agoYep. We basically doubled the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere. If we had a machine that could take some volume of air and scrub all the C02 out, we’d need to pass half of the atmosphere through it to cut the CO2 in half.
- ElevenLathe 2y agoI think the point is that even if we can scale up DAC to work, we need some carbon-free source of energy to power it. Fixing the atmosphere essentially means we need enough non-emitting energy to run civilization since 1850 in reverse, and preferably much faster than 1x.
- nojvek 2y agoTrees are technically “direct air capture”. Trees capture C02 + H20 + sunlight into glucose/wood + O2. So if we can reduce our C02 output, and preserve the rain forests, they’ll do their job. Even getting to zero carbon electricity in top economies is going to be a huuuuge deal.
- mjhay 2y agoNo argument from me. Trees work. Stopping forest loss is an absolutely low-hanging fruit, but one that we still cannot achieve. Rewilding of massive areas must be a primary goal. If we can't do that, we certainly can't do DAC. In general, the Earth's homeostasis (and thus, thus homeostasis of human civilization) depends on continued, robust functioning of the biosphere. The biosphere is resilient and adaptable. However, it has never faced intelligence before. Humans - more and more unfettered by their own physical limitations - will seek (as always) to bend their environment to their own particular wills - even when it conflicts with the interests of humanity as a whole. Even in a decaying and impoverished environment, people may still seek out ever more marginal benefits at greater and greater social costs. I hope I'm wrong, but we may be at the great filter.
- readthenotes1 2y agoAnother article reported that the required fuel is only produced in Russia and China
- jillesvangurp 2y agoBetween now and 2030 there will be a lot of energy generation coming online. Hundreds of GW basically. The vast majority of that is going to be renewables. Nuclear is not going to contribute much at all. It might actually shrink proportionally as several reactors are scheduled to be decommissioned and there just isn't a whole lot being approved for construction. This project is only adding some 340 MW. Not nothing of course but probably expensive and just not a lot in comparison. And of course that 2030 target date will likely slip. And in good tradition the article doesn't actually talk about budgets or money. Because obviously, this being a nuclear plant, it will blow through whatever budget was defined. By about 2x at least. > Today couldn’t have happened without the Department of Energy’s Advanced Reactor Demonstration Program, which is supporting the project with the largest single contribution the federal government has ever committed to a private project. Which in short, is why Bill Gates is still involved at all: tax payer money is covering the budget and most of the risk. Which is substantial. And he gets to look all visionary if/when this thing comes online at great cost at some point in the 2030s.
- mjhay 2y agoI'm glad more renewables are coming online, but that's not the 24/7 base capacity that is really needed to fully replace fossil fuels. Solar and wind are cheap now, but they only generate power when the sun is shining or the wind is blowing. Thus, energy storage on a huge scale is needed if they are to replace fossil fuels. Power grid unreliability is politically untenable. People will march headfirst into the destruction of industrial civilization, ignoring the warnings of climate scientists, before they will accept an electrical grid that is offline for 5% of the time. For as difficult as nuclear is, storage is much harder yet. Nuclear is proven tech. It works at scale. The main obstacles political, but they are much more easily overcome than objections people would have with an unreliable grid.
- ViewTrick1002 2y agoBaseload power producers ceased to be relevant decades ago. The nuclear industry has coopted the term because they know they can’t compete on cost. With storage now coming online in large enough quantities to meaningfully affect the grid the window of opportunity for nuclear energy has passed. It had a chance if the reactors started in the 2000s had delivered on time and on budget. They did not deliver. https://blog.gridstatus.io/caiso-batteries-apr-2024/ https://blog.gridstatus.io/caiso-batteries-apr-2024/
- janice1999 2y agoThe last attempt at an SMR failed due to out of control costs and that was a conventional water cooled plant (NuScale Power). I would be shocked if TerraPower built anything before 2030 close to their projected costs.
- Herz 2y agoYou might be one of those who embrace electric vehicles today, yet it's worth remembering that electric cars were once considered obsolete. They were revived through persistent belief and innovation, despite the dominance of internal combustion engines. This same principle of perseverance and innovation applies to nuclear energy and solar panels. We cannot predict with certainty which technologies will dominate the future, but it's clear that innovation and research should always be our priorities. Dismissing nuclear power as a relic of the past is illogical. Instead, we should focus on improving it and continuing to explore all potential solutions for sustainable energy. Nobody can predict.
- esafak 2y agoAre the salt tanks expected to be periodically replaced due to corrosion?
- nine_k 2y agoI would expect a bunch of identical tanks working in parallel, so that some of them could be taken offline and fixed or replaced.
- hereme888 2y agoFrom their press release: "The project features a 345 MW sodium-cooled fast reactor with a molten salt-based energy storage system. The storage technology can boost the system’s output to 500 MW of power when needed, which is equivalent to the energy required to power around 400,000 homes. The energy storage capability allows the plant to integrate seamlessly with renewable resources and is the only advanced reactor design with this unique feature." Getting all the permits and passing all the reviews without running out of money, etc, is really difficult in these projects. I hope they make it.
- mikeyouse 2y agoPresumably this should be very well positioned to do so -- these projects are expensive but Bill Gates has a net worth of well north of $100 billion. If it's a "money" or "timeline" problem, he can solve it -- if it's an economics one in the end, he might not want to.
- fragmede 2y ago500 MW or 400,000 homes, but what is that in terms of data centers? Is that enough to power us-west-1? assuming 50kw per rack of Nvidia GPUs(which is high. usually it's closer to 10), that's 10,000 racks or about an acres worth of datacenter.
- spintin 2y ago[dead]
- doctoboggan 2y ago> and transfer the liquid sodium that will be used to cool the nuclear reactor. Wow, never would have considered using literal lava as a cooling fluid, but I guess its all relative to what you want to cool.
- amelius 2y agoMakes me wonder how fast it will wear out its container.
- Turing_Machine 2y agoThere are numerous alloys that work perfectly fine for containing liquid sodium.
- hwc 2y agoliquid sodium is worse than that. it will suck the water out of concrete and react violently.
- credit_guy 2y agoSodium melts 98°C, a bit less than the boiling point of water. For comparison, pressurized water reactors use water in a temperature range between 275°C and 315°C. The higher the temperature, the higher the thermal efficiency of the electricity generator. Because the critical point of water is 374°C, no pressurized water reactor can get beyond this temperature, and in fact they all stay well below it. This limits the efficiency to about 33%. Sodium stays in liquid form all the way to 883°C. They will not run the reactor that hot, for various reasons, but they can run it at more than 500°C. Still, well below lava levels. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium-cooled_fast_reactor#Advantages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium-cooled_fast_reactor#Adv...
- baking 2y agoBroke ground on the sodium test facility. Still waiting on the NRC permit to start construction of the reactor.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Animats 2y agoAt least it's in the middle of nowhere. Sodium reactors tend to have sodium fires. The track record on that technology, which goes back to the 1950s, is not good. Here's the NRC docket.[1] None of the documents seem to address sodium fires. [1] https://adams.nrc.gov/wba/?data=(mode:sections,sections:(filters:(public-library:!t),options:(within-folder:(enable:!f,insubfolder:!f,path:%27%27)),properties_search_all:!(!(DocketNumber,eq,%2799902087%27,%27%27))))&qn=New&tab=advanced-search-pars&z=0 https://adams.nrc.gov/wba/?data=(mode:sections,sections:(fil...
- nightowl_games 2y agoDo you think this is something that the team didn't realize or underestimated?
- Animats 2y agoNo, the paperwork isn't far enough along for the safety analysis. They decided to go ahead and build the non-nuclear parts of the system before getting approval for the reactor. Hence the "groundbreaking".
- johnea 2y ago[flagged]
- owenversteeg 2y agoThis is interesting news, of course, but I find it hard to get excited about nuclear power from fission these days. Ten or twenty years ago, sure, but not today. As with all things, it comes down to the unstoppable power of change over time; the situation today is almost irrelevant. The unfortunate reality is that barring a breakthrough, the passage of time will not be kind to nuclear power. Technologists forget that the main input of nuclear power is not fissile material but rather men and women. This small plant will require 1,600 skilled laborers to build; before them came a small army of designers and regulators; after will come yet more skilled employees for its operation. A comparable solar plant more than double its size, on-line today, employed seven hundred in its construction. What will happen in ten years' time? The cost of solar power and batteries will continue to fall off a cliff - and the cost of labor will rise. The far more labor-intensive nuclear sadly cannot win.
- Herz 2y agoSo, you confidently state that the cost of solar will continue to drop while the cost of nuclear will not. This prediction implies you can foresee future technological advancements and market trends with certainty. (funny) Let's consider the labor aspect. While it's true that solar panels require fewer workers during construction, the production, maintenance, and recycling of increasingly sophisticated solar panels also demand skilled labor. These panels rely on advanced materials and manufacturing processes that are continually evolving. Your argument seems to be driven by ideology rather than a comprehensive understanding of the energy landscape. Thankfully, companies invest in diverse research and development, ensuring a balanced approach to energy solutions. You might be one of those who embrace electric vehicles today, yet it's worth remembering that electric cars were once considered obsolete. They were revived through persistent belief and innovation, despite the dominance of internal combustion engines. This same principle of perseverance and innovation applies to nuclear energy and even to the solar panels you favor. Our current priority is to decarbonize, and nuclear power has already demonstrated its capability to significantly reduce carbon emissions. While your long-term prediction about solar might be accurate (or maybe not), we urgently need solutions for the immediate future, specifically by 2050. Nuclear energy has proven to be a reliable and substantial contributor to this goal. Dismissing nuclear energy outright suggests that your priority might not be decarbonization but rather an aversion to nuclear power itself. It's crucial to embrace a diversified energy strategy that includes nuclear as part of the solution.
- boojums 2y ago>TerraPower’s investors and development partners, including Bechtel, GE Hitachi, PacifiCorp, and Berkshire Hathaway. For people not familiar, PacifiCorp is majority owned by Berkshire Hathaway (Warren Buffett). They operate many coal-fired power plants in the region including near Kemmerer where the new TerraPower facility is. I see this as a positive sign for the success of the project.