4 ms·
iTerm2 v3.5.1 moves AI features into external plugin
- rasengan 2y agoThis is the way. Don’t make AI features opt-out. The very features of AI that are exciting are also the reason why it is so intrusive to our privacy and security.
- rapatel0 2y agoIt was never opt-in in the previous build. You had to explicitly enable and add the OpenAI API key. Vocal minority of users was hostile to the idea of integrating so the developer switched to a separate plugin model. Security theatre imho but understandable in some enterprises
- prymitive 2y agoIt might be one of the first examples of a piece of code getting “cancelled”.
- rasengan 2y agoI stand corrected. Thank you. AI doesn't need to be anywhere near the Terminal without explicit intervention from the user, and I'm glad it's now in an external plugin.
- dsr_ 2y ago"Security theatre" means doing complicated things which are claimed to increase security but don't do that. The classic example is making everyone at US airports take off their shoes, have their shoes x-rayed, and then putting them back on -- for decades after the single incident in which a man failed to blow up a plane with explosives in his shoes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Reid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Reid Moving code out into an optional plugin -- so that it can be verified not to be in use or even removed -- is not theatre.
- rapatel0 2y agoITerm2 is open source. You can already verify that the plugin is not being used. Also, how exactly is the functionality going to run without manually adding the API key? Its code to invoke a request to an API. where exactly is the attack surface? It’s not running an endpoint. Finally, it’s a terminal app. It has access to way more powerful and sensitive tools with higher security risk To be more accurate I guess i could have said privacy theatre but i think the point stands.
- yokoprime 2y agoit was never opt out! Even the previous version had AI as opt-in, you would have to turn it on and provide an API key. It was NOT on by default. Now even the code path is moved to an external component.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoGood. I want nothing to do with the trash that is AI.
- infotainment 2y agoI get that AI is overhyped, but calling it “trash” seems silly and hyperbolic. LLMs can do some pretty neat things if you understand their limitations.
- nunez 2y agoThe fact that we're all okay with software that frequently gets things very very very VERY wrong is extremely worrisome. AI in its current state is a high-speed misinformation machine.
- azemetre 2y agoFair enough, but in my experience when you run into anything outside the happy path it will become an exercise in extreme torment. Maybe it’s the language I was using to debug an issue (typescript and having click/drag events override each other), but chatgpt 4o (along with the previous versions) would get into this circular path of offering suggestions (would cycle the same three solutions). It was also interesting to note that when this circular debug path started it would start to remove random properties or objects or types from the code. It wouldn’t be noticeable reading it but if you have any modern editor you’ll see the issues with your lsp/linter. The removals had nothing to do with solutions proposed. This issue seemed to always happen to me, I think I have to relegate these LLMs to act like advanced scaffolding tools where I can include detailed instructions for basic capabilities as well (rather than writing them saving a decent amount of hours all things considered). I don’t know if other models are actually good at debugging (going to guess no because they don’t seem to actually understand context of the problem, just the relations of keywords when suggesting solutions). I agree with the other poster, maybe trash is a harsh word but it is extremely bad for debugging anything advanced it seems.
- tombert 2y agoIt's a bit weird; I've definitely observed the circular logic when using it for debugging, but occasionally when I've seen that and called it out for that saying "You've already suggested A, B, and C, there's no value in suggesting them again", it actually will come up with a unique thing that actually solves the problem. I guess by eliminating the most common problems it has to start looking for more obscure stuff? I've become a bit disillusioned by the idea of it being any good for direct code generation in its current iterations; nearly everything its generated has required pretty substantial fixes on my end, to a point where I'm not sure it's actually saving me time. The thing I mostly use ChatGPT for now is for parsing and digesting server logs.
- ayhanfuat 2y agoThis was also discussed in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40458135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40458135 (19 days ago, 104 points, 141 comments).
- JSDevOps 2y agoThis is one of the best examples of why shoving AI everywhere is totally the wrong idea.
- DHowett 2y agoIs it? It seems as though the maintainer moved it into an external plugin because they were told, loud and long, that “shoving AI [there] [was] totally the wrong idea.” It’s certainly an example of how public backlash can change the discourse, but it is not an example of why it was wrong to put AI there.
- joshstrange 2y agoI didn't care for the feature (I have no issues with AI/LLMs but it just wasn't useful IMHO) but the backlash was ridiculous and embarrassing for everyone complaining about an opt-in feature. The comments on the GitLab ticket and here on HN were examples of some of the worst people (or people at their worst) in our industry.
- bloopernova 2y agoYeah, iTerm is a labour of love for the author, George Nachman, and people were acting like the ragebait-hateporn-parasocial crowd, swarming onto anything that promises a hearty 2-minute hate. I have no idea how to solve that problem though, it's just part of our zeitgeist and I hope people get bored with it sooner rather than later.
- mostlysimilar 2y agoIt's useful to frame the event from the perspective of the users who were angry with the inclusion of the feature. AI is *everywhere* right now and the fatigue is getting to people. Many products are adding AI features that are genuinely useless and are only there for marketing purposes. Many products are putting their AI features front and center at the expense of their core competency etc. People who responded with anger ("ragebait-hateporn") at this feel pressured on all sides by this AI hype cycle (not saying all AI features are hype, just that we are in a hype cycle where many are useless). It's getting frustrating and tired. For many it feels like the crypto hype cycle again. It's easy to understand how "great, now even my terminal is putting AI features in?!" is the response, especially with a tool as beloved as iTerm, and as "close to the machine" as a terminal is. It's one thing for Notion to put AI things in, it's another for the interface where I regularly type sudo to do massive operations across my machine.
- soraminazuki 2y agoThe correct response to false allegations followed by insults and threats is anything but to admit it. The software in question is a popular free and open source software that has more than a decade of trust. The AI feature fundamentally requires the user to actively engage with in order to use it [1], with no nagging or coercion whatsoever. In fact, the only people reminding us of its existence are the Mastodon mobs, not iTerm. The feature wasn't added out of pure hype either. It was likely inspired by user feedback [2], and the dev ultimately added it because it was useful for him personally [3]. Despite all of this, people are raging about unprovable nefarious motives and making claims about spyware, as if it's Windows we're talking about. They pretend as if it's maintained by some faceless for-profit entity trying to screw us over instead of a sole developer trying to create good software in his spare time. Some are even openly fantasizing about inflicting physical violence [4]. This kind of behavior should be condemned, not praised. [1]: https://github.com/gnachman/iTerm2/blob/a3122c0100d8900a15cb46def59429849d7991e1/images/Onboarding/Onboarding-AI.png https://github.com/gnachman/iTerm2/blob/a3122c0100d8900a15cb... [2]: https://gitlab.com/gnachman/iterm2/-/issues/6955 https://gitlab.com/gnachman/iterm2/-/issues/6955 [3]: https://techhub.social/@gnachman/109542492387391561 https://techhub.social/@gnachman/109542492387391561 [4]: https://web.archive.org/web/20240613165712/https://archive.is/https://tau-ceti.space/@ics/%2A https://web.archive.org/web/20240613165712/https://archive.i...
- infotainment 2y agoI never understood the appeal of iTerm2. The built-in terminal app can do basically all the same things except tiling, but there’s always tmux if you need that.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoOne advantage is that you can define arbitrary margins for your terminal. Thus, you can make your terminal full-screen and write in vim with nice margins, instead of super-wide ones like in the default. Super-wide margins for text are ugly.
- cornstalks 2y agoThe one thing I miss in the normal Terminal app, coming from iTerm 2, is being able to cmd+click paths and open them.
- alwillis 2y agoMost modern terminals support clicking on urls these days. IIRC, there’s a plugin or something to enable this in iTerm. I use WezTerm currently and it supports it out of the box.
- latexr 2y agoiTerm2 supports it out of the box. The person you’re replying to is lamenting the absence of the feature in Terminal.app.
- cornstalks 2y agoTerminal.app supports clicking URLs (cmd+double click). But what I want is to cmd+click (relative) file paths, with no URL scheme prefix. iTerm 2 supports this, and I miss it when I use Terminal.app.
- hoherd 2y agoYou can also define custom clickable things via the "Smart Selections" feature. For instance I have all strings that match `\B#([0-9]{2,6})\b` open the page of that GH issue in my companies central issue tracker when they are cmd-clicked, and I have all strings that match `\bU\+([0-9a-fA-F]{2,6})\b` open up a details page for that unicode code point.
- wg0 2y agoSigns of things to come. In next 3 to 5 years, many of the sparkling icons next to input fields in many products summoning AI would be gradually removed. OpenAI will have the fate of Twitter. High valuation but not profitable. Subscriptions alone not offsetting the personal and compute costs.
- bdcravens 2y agoAnd still used despite all the claims of impending doom?
- tombert 2y agoWell that's the gamble with OpenAI isn't it? There's some utility now but it's currently unclear when we'll hit a hard wall on what's realistically capable with the models (and their direct successors), and how many things OpenAI will be able to with them. I don't think anyone knows for sure where that wall will actually be (including OpenAI themselves). While I don't actually think we'll get AGI any time soon from any company[1], if they did manage to fully crack it, then there's really no limit to how much they can actually do and how much money they can actually make. I certainly don't think we've seen the end of the capabilities though, even in the near term; I think the GPT models have a lot of room to improve and I think that newer models for generative images and video and music and 3D models are going to get substantially better. How "profitable" that will be will depend on a bunch of variables (e.g. costs of GPUs/TPUs/something else, energy costs, potential regulatory hurdles, etc.). [1] I don't really know what I'm talking about, I'm not a machine learning or AI expert, it's just a gut feeling I have.
- mmastrac 2y agoI still think the backlash was ridiculous and that a lot of people have a lot to apologize for towards the maintainer of this project, George Nachman. I'm surprised that the maintainer actually moved this code out. I would have told people to pound sand, personally, given the absolute vitriol sent his way. Remember the human on the other side of messages you are sending. This thread is nowhere near as bad as the previous but come on, people.
- latexr 2y ago> I would have told people to pound sand, personally, given the absolute vitriol sent his way. Sounds like a great way to get even more vitriol, and continue to get it for years afterward. Every time you released a new version, there it’d resurface again. Sure, you could block some people on GitLab, but then you’d see it on social media or what have you. Or you could just move it out to a plugin quickly (which is what happened, the beta for this version was out in a couple of days) and curtail the backlash. Being angry at the people angry about you is not a practical solution if your goal is piece of mind.
- DangitBobby 2y agoLetting entitled people be mad forever is absolutely a practical solution to peace of mind.
- latexr 2y agoWhich is all fine and dandy as long as you never have to interact with those people, but in this case the author would absolutely have to do that. If not directly in their issue tracker (though certainly there), then in every conversation about their project from then on. That would be quite tiring for most people and lead to burnout. You recently said (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40628935 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40628935): > Having a combative relationship with every stranger may not be the most productive way to conduct yourself. Which I agree with. It seems to concur with my point (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40658456 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40658456): > Being angry at the people angry about you is not a practical solution If you don’t think so, I’d be interested in understanding what you see as the principal difference between those statements. To clarify, I was also referring to (internet) strangers. In sum, why even bother in this case? Just rip it out to a plugin and never think about it again. Now that is pragmatic.
- tombert 2y agoUgh, I am pretty sick of people trying to shoehorn AI into everything. AI is cool, don't get me wrong, but it feels like every company and organization is trying to hop onto the bandwagon and add it to places where I really don't want it. I can understand how a terminal might be able to benefit from AI (in the same way coding does with Copilot), but I don't know if I really want it in my terminal; if nothing else I don't want my terminal sending lots of network requests behind the scenes. Maybe I'm in the minority but I dunno, I feel like I can't be the only person sick of adding AI to every damn thing. When I was applying to jobs last year, I ended up avoiding anything directly mentioning AI in the job description, because about 80% of the time it felt like it was some founder straight out of school who knew nothing about CS but knew just enough about how to proxy to ChatGPT that they were able to get a few million dollars of VC money, and they were extremely annoying to talk to. I guess having a bunch of people tell you that you're a visionary must give most people an ego, and I'm way too cynical to put up with that. I think iTerm moving this to a plugin is a pretty good idea. If people want to add AI crap into everything, don't let me stop them, but I don't really want it added to the default stack of iTerm.
- mmastrac 2y agoIt's fair to say you're sick of it. I never even used the feature myself, but here's the thing: I never even saw it and wouldn't have known it existed if not for the backlash. I had to search through settings to find any evidence of it. You say it's "shoehorning" on one hand, then "I can understand how a terminal might be able to benefit from AI" on another. It didn't send anything off in the background (you don't need an AI feature to do that, BTW). The backlash was completely unwarranted here, and I say that as someone who wouldn't bother using that feature at all.
- tombert 2y agoI see how what I said might sound contradictory, so let me explain. In the case of startups using AI, most of them have some marginal benefit from the AI usage, if a bit overblown. By "shoehorning", what I was saying is that there isn't sufficient justification for a lot of the AI usage; it makes stuff 1% easier (maybe), while making the product more expensive (only being subsidized by VC money or just operating at a loss so it doesn't immediately look like it is in the short term). I didn't say "shoehorning" to imply that there's zero utility in it, just that there's not really enough to justify a lot of it. > It didn't send anything off in the background (you don't need an AI feature to do that, BTW). Fair enough, I didn't look into the implementation details, and obviously you can have stuff sent in the background without AI (e.g. usage statics). Most AI stuff I've seen has been just proxied to OpenAI (or some competitor/affiliate), so I guess I just assumed that that's what iTerm was doing. ETA: Looking into this a bit further, I completely agree that the vicious comments that have been spreading in regards to this are completely ridiculous and mean-spirited. I'm sick of AI as much of the next guy but people are being pretty dickish about something that fundamentally they're getting for free.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 39896880 2y agoPeople clamor for open source software and then shit on the people who make it because they provided a feature they didn’t want but didn’t have to use.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Hasu 2y agoThere is a bigger story here - who uses iTerm2? It's gotta be like 95% developers, right? If your most technically capable users, who are usually the MOST excited about new tech, are the people who are ready to burn down the world to stop you from adding AI features, what do you think normal people think? I feel that, without several very major breakthroughs in the next few years, we're more likely to hit another AI winter in the 2030s than achieving AGI.
- thiht 2y agoDon’t confuse the vocal, insufferable minority with the silent majority (who either doesn’t care, mildly enjoys, or embraces AI features)
- orangesite 2y agoI think you underestimate the size of the silent insufferable minority.
- thiht 2y agoIt’s not insufferable if it’s silent. In the case of iTerm, the reaction of the vocal minority was atrocious, and completely entitled towards an amazing open source maintainer
- Hasu 2y agoAmong devs? That may well be the silent majority. Among normies? I don't think so.
- hobofan 2y ago> what do you think normal people think? They mostly don't. The most common objections to AI that come from the dev community are: privacy; IP rights involved in training data (and how it fucks over individuals) The general public almost exclusively judges the features that are handed to them in products based on their utility and not the above concerns, so they will always be less critical overall.
- 2y ago
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated earlier discussion: iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40458135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40458135 iTerm2 and AI Hype Overload https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40432446 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40432446
- PreInternet01 2y agoSo, what I see here, is yet another Open Source creator/maintainer being crowd-bullied into compliance with the (possibly correct, but never-mind) consensus on new features. It's my personal opinion, not backed by any scientific studies or whatever, that this kind of behavior directly leads to developer burnout, and is, put plainly, toxic and counterproductive.