8 ms·
T-Mobile users thought they had a lifetime price lock–guess what happened next
- anothername12 2y agoI guess I’ll look for a $10 gift card after the class action a decade from now.
- teeray 2y agoProbably expires in 30 days, so you better be vigilant.
- bts89 2y agoThree weeks ago I changed my Verizon FIOS plan and was told multiple times that my new bill would be $160. Guess what happened next! If your guess was they immediately raised the price of the services on my plan and billed me $220 instead, you’d be right!
- runlevel1 2y agoVerizon math can be a little wonky sometimes: https://verizonmath.blogspot.com/ https://verizonmath.blogspot.com/
- vincnetas 2y ago"was told" means nothing. If you don't have it in writing, they can say anything. One time when i was contacted by sales to offer me a "new better offer" i asked to send it to me in writing and they refused, because "policy". p.s. this is noname local provider that you have never heard of.
- teeray 2y agoEven if you have it in writing, you need to have the tenacity to hold them to it in court. They can do the fun corporate game of “computer says no” and defy your written agreement as a gamble that you’re not willing to spend time and money suing them.
- FireBeyond 2y agoAnd there will be some fine print on the website that says "Only SVPs and CxOs have the authority to bind us to an agreement."
- bts89 2y agoOh, I have it writing. A screenshot of the order, an email confirmation, and a physical letter. All directly from Verizon, all saying $160.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- henriquez 2y agoi got caught up in this B.S… literally got the rate locked T-Mobile account because of lifetime rate lock. then last year they sent me “opt-out” notification that my guaranteed rate was increasing unless I send a certified letter or some stupid shit. I dumped them the next week because i don’t have time in my life to play fuck-fuck games with shady companies. I hope there’s a class action lawsuit, I would gladly get on board.
- crooked-v 2y agoThe fundamental problem here is that courts bend over backwards to allow fine print that contradicts the plain reading of how advertisements and services and presented. Unfortunately, the only way it's ever going to change in the US is if somehow a Supreme Court is appointed that's far less business-friendly than it has been in possibly ever.
- vsuperpower2020 2y agoI'd be more fine with companies behaving like a swarm of locusts if they at least had to put on the box the ways they were going to fuck you over. A monkey's paw printer should have to prominently display "Proprietary ink only! Scanner disables itself when ink is low. While supplies last" on the front.
- dboreham 2y agoAll lawyers are black hats.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- silisili 2y agoI don't understand the move. Seems it would be ultimately cheaper(support, potential legal, churn, etc) and harbor more good will to just flag these old accounts and leave them alone. Most companies I've dealt with in the past just leave these older plans alone to rot, and try to motivate people off of them with new plans, new features, faster speeds, phone deals, etc. Not just arbitrarily deciding to jack up prices because "technically we're allowed to."
- xur17 2y agoI have one of these old grandfathered accounts from many years ago (< $20 / line for unlimited data, 5gb tethering, unlimited sms, and unlimited voice). What's weird is that they've actually upgraded the plan over time while keeping the price the same. It originally didn't include tethering, and was capped at 3gb of data.
- Dalewyn 2y agoI would hazard a guess that backend upgrades made keeping your plan as-original became impractical if not impossible, but hiking your price up and losing you as a customer was also wholly unappealing because any money is better than no money. So presumably AT&T did the next best thing for both you and themselves by silently(?) upgrading your plan to whatever was the new minimum of the new hardware while keeping true to the price lock to keep you as a customer.
- Akronymus 2y agoThe unlimited data but limited tethering is one of the more scummy moves by telecoms IMO.
- immibis 2y agoIs it? When you pay a certain amount at a buffet for unlimited food, they let you eat as much as you want at the buffet, but they don't let you bag it up and take it home. True unlimited costs a lot more. There are ugly ways to cheat the system by replacing your stomach with a food sack and not chewing.
- AequitasOmnibus 2y agoWhile not mentioned in the article, it’s worth mentioning that this also coincided with T-Mobile’s acquisition of Sprint. Specifically, T-Mobile made assurances that the acquisition would lower prices. Instead, within a couple years they exercised their newfound market power to increase prices a fair amount. The merger should have never been authorized.
- ramesh31 2y ago>The merger should have never been authorized. So that Verizon could own the entire market along with a few also-rans? It was a choice between the lesser of two evils.
- bsder 2y agoIf Verizon controlled that much, then it should have been broken apart. You don't fix a monopoly by creating more monopolies.
- ClassyJacket 2y agoHow is reducing competition good for competition?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> How is reducing competition good for competition? I am not familiar with the telecom market. But blocking mergers doesn’t necessarily increase competition. (For example, breaking up Walmart would reduce competitive pressure on Amazon.)
- alexsereno 2y agoHacker news is peak contrarian. If your stance was that this merger was incredible, your replies would be entirely about competition lol.
- adolph 2y agoHN has a diverse set of viewpoints. For any assertion one might make, there will be someone with the opposite viewpoint. In addition to out-and-out opposition or agreement that sounds vaguely oppositional, a comment might call for a pedantic annotation, a tangential aside or book recommendation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Teknomancer 2y agoDitched T-Mobile last month, disgruntled AF over the rate hikes. Helium gives me the same exact service experience at 1/4 the monthly cost.
- stronglikedan 2y agoI'm currently evaluating both on the same phone, and I have not had that experience. If Helium had as good coverage as Tmo, I would have already switched. Fortunately, Helium usually has coverage when Tmo doesn't, so I may keep both since Helium is quite cheap (and even close to free with discovery mapping turned on).
- dangus 2y agoHelium is just a T-Mobile MVNO. They’re not owned by T-Mobile, but they’re just an MVNO. Everyone can save by switching to an MVNO. The first trade off is that the big 3 carriers have essentially a tier list of customers based on what type of service they have for network priority. E.g., postpaid customers are highest priority, big carrier prepaid and big carrier-owned MVNOs are second, and unaffiliated MVNOs are placed based on the specifics of their agreements with the carrier. For example, Google Fi has high network priority because they undoubtedly pay more to use their networks than lower cost MVNOs. The second trade off is that MVNOs handle customer service and a lot of the customer facing administration. This can vary but is often pretty barebones for lower cost MVNOs.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- adolph 2y ago> Everyone can save by switching to an MVNO. I think you are better off not saying that. If everyone were to switch to an MVNO then the large carriers MVNOs depend on would not offer as favorable rates to the MVNOs. Reminds me of when Apple licensed their OS and promptly got spanked. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_Computing_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_Computing_Corporation
- tithe 2y agoI've had good luck with Mint[0], but T-Mobile bought them last year so who knows how long that luck is going to last. [0] https://www.mintmobile.com/ https://www.mintmobile.com/
- el_benhameen 2y agoI’ve been pretty happy with Mint, too, but 1) I’m working on the assumption that we’ve got about a year before major price increases, and 2) probably just a coincidence, but my service has been shit since the purchase was finalized (I’m aware that Mint gets deprioritized when there’s congestion, but it was less of an issue until a few months ago).
- indymike 2y agoI was on Sprint and T-Mobile bought Sprint. T-Mobile is robotically cruel to customers. T-Mobile is rule-bound and failure to comply results in employees being fired. Here's the difference: I got a defective phone with sprint: phone replaced under manufacturer's warranty immediately. Same defective new phone scenario with T-Mobile: no replacement because you didn't buy additional insurance - even though you got the phone a month ago. Sorry can't help. I wish I could help you but I will be fired if I deviate from the rules. Thank you for your understanding. Avoid doing business with T-Mobile at all costs. They are horrible. So, I'm happily with AT&T now.
- giancarlostoro 2y ago> I'm happily with AT&T now. I never thought I'd hear those words. The one time congress split up a company that I recall, it was AT&T because of all their awful practices, and for YEARS I have heard of their crazy fees and fines, and what have you.
- kmeisthax 2y agoT-Mobile was the US branch of Deutsche Telekom at one point AFAIK. The one German guy I know said that basically the whole country gets fucked on pricing and bandwidth, and that American residential Internet is vastly superior. It's not implausible to imagine the shitty behavior from German telecom companies rubbing off on their US subsidiaries.
- stkdump 2y agoAs far as I can tell prices in Germany are better than in the US, and broadband while not stellar is fine. My home internet is 500/100 speed and costs 35€ (with unlimited data and calls to landline and mobile numbers, for whatever thats worth). My mobile plan is 8€/month for 10GB of data (5G, of course not great availability outside cities, but LTE is not that bad) and unlimited calls and SMS.
- TeMPOraL 2y ago> The one German guy I know said that basically the whole country gets fucked on pricing and bandwidth, and that American residential Internet is vastly superior. Since "American residential Internet" has been the butt of jokes even in rural Europe for the past decade, I wonder how uniquely bad DT must have been for the US connections to compare favorably. EDIT: Or maybe it's the most developed nations being way past the peak of quality of life for its population (which I think is a pattern)? Reminds me of my employer from over a decade ago; at some point they had the bright idea to try and convert our work stations in Poland into fat terminals, with all the data being stored on the servers in UK. Problem is, their pricey London office Internet connection had bandwidth that was something like 1/10 of what I could get on the cheapest residential connection I could find in Kraków. Way less than any of us was used to. And they weren't planning to upgrade. IIRC, the whole idea got postponed indefinitely after multiple reminders that the London office is already so bandwidth-constrained that we'd rather look for another job than be stuck working in the London office in the first place, much less accept our local machines being limited by a link to their servers.
- petarb 2y agoAT&T prepaid plan is $40 for 8gb data. Pretty happy with this
- IAmLiterallyAB 2y agoThey've changed the plans a bit, you can get 8GB even cheaper I think. I pay $30 a month after the autopay discount. Though mine is only 5GB
- SkinTaco 2y agoThe problem with ATT prepaid is it's deprioritized to the same level as mvnos - might as well buy an even cheaper mvno plan at that point. Tmobile is the only big 3 carrier where all branded plans have the same priority
- cynicalsecurity 2y agoThis is ridiculously expensive from the point of European prices.
- afruitpie 2y agoNow that porting between MVNOs with eSIM is free and dead simple, I can’t think of a reason to stick with the big 3 carriers. The MVNO I stuck with even has a slick way to port between networks!
- carleton 2y agoDeprioritization is why - even 5G is unusable sometimes in busy places if you’re on an MVNO. I’d rather pay more for it to always work
- radicality 2y agoI’m curious, is there some kind of real-life benchmarks available online for this? I totally believe that a network would deprioritize the mvnos, and I’m guessing there is some pecking order depending on their contract with the network, but I’m curious how it converts to real world usage.
- joecool1029 2y agoIt's not really possible to benchmark real-world. But to see which priority your account is provisioned at just need ability to see lower-level information from the baseband. Deprioritization = QCI 9. Different carriers use different QCI's but 9 is lowest, 6 is usually highest priority. Network Signal Guru is an app for android that will report this information, but it usually requires root (I think the pixel phones do not, qualcomm devices usually do). The radio layer is where deprioritization happens, not through deep packet inspection (as would be the case for video throttling). Having a strong signal with good RF conditions deprioritization won't be noticed as much, also won't be noticed if the sector isn't busy. If it is busy and you are near cell edge, that's when speeds will fall off (as the radio layer will schedule less time and resources for your device, and the worse conditions means it can't send as much data with those resources allocated).
- teeray 2y agoIf the FCC were functional, it would be nice for carriers to expose priority in the phone icons. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had to explain to friends who lamented about “Full bars but no service, weird.” The current iconography is outdated and clearly confusing (read: misleading) to the public.
- djaouen 2y agoI think it's a bit silly to believe a company wouldn't raise prices eventually. I mean, it's been 7 years. What about inflation?
- Dylan16807 2y agoBandwidth gets cheaper every year to help offset that, and don't they have that fancy 5G network to tempt people into upgrading? If they wanted to give a 5 or 10 year guarantee, they could have. They chose to say lifetime. The wireless market hasn't fundamentally changed in the last 15 years (starting in the iphone 3g era), so they don't have any excuses about being caught off guard.
- otterley 2y agoWhile I agree with you, I also think companies shouldn't advertise in a way that strongly suggests that they won't ever raise their rates. It's a pretty scummy practice.
- creer 2y agoThe concept of inflation dates back more than 7 years. Even a corporation was aware of it 7 years ago.
- wayne 2y agoVery different from the airline industry which still honors lifetime flight and lounge passes sold decades ago. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/20/mark-cuban-bought-an-american-airlines-unlimited-aairpass.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/20/mark-cuban-bought-an-america...
- pimlottc 2y agoThat’s not the story I’ve heard. What I’ve read are stories of airlines who regretted the deals and went after those who used them extensively, looking for excuses to revoke them: https://thehustle.co/aairpass-american-airlines-250k-lifetime-ticket https://thehustle.co/aairpass-american-airlines-250k-lifetim... Anyhow, the Mark Cuban article says almost nothing about how the airline treated him, it’s just a light human interest story about an unusual and quirky thing a famous person did.
- jonfw 2y agoIf the claims in the article are true around 2.5k cancellations and ticket reselling, I'd say they found great reasons to revoke these airpasses.
- cjameskeller 2y agoI'm still on one of their prepaid "Connect" plans, and get unlimited talk & text, plus 12 gigs of data, for $35. Since I'm nearly always somewhere with wifi, I can't recall ever having run into an issue due to lack of data. I wonder if some folks could switch over to a plan like this and save money, if they planned media downloads to happen when they're on wifi?
- carleton 2y agoRather the opposite, I pay $20.99/month for unlimited for _just_ my iPad now on a different carrier because I don’t want to ever think about WiFi again when I’m not at home. Cellular is finally “good enough” that it’s better (faster/more reliable) than most hotel/public WiFi I’ve used in the past year.
- jerlam 2y agoI doubt most people know that prepaid exists and is extremely cheap, that they can easily port over their number to any carrier (required by law for a long time), or that they are using a small fraction of their "unlimited" data. My $25 prepaid plan comes with 16 GB of data, I don't even bother to use wifi on short trips. I used to manage my parents' plan, sometimes they barely use one GB a month.
- aliljet 2y agoCount me marginally confused. Has T-Mobile already increased prices? Who is presently engaged in suing them for this breach of contract?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vzaliva 2y agoOkay, they could not be held accountable for contract breach because there is a small print somewhere in a FAQ linked from TOS, but perhaps they could be sued for misleading advertisement? One car reasonably argue that "the price will never increase" is not the same as "if the price increases they will pay the final month".
- teo_zero 2y ago"We will not raise the prices." Small print: except, if we do, you'll get back your payment. Smaller print: except, we might give you a set of stickers instead. Even smaller print: except if we run out of them, then you'll get nothing.
- floppiplopp 2y agoOh no, business did a capitalism. In other news: Water still wet.
- ok_dad 2y agoI have a “select choice fam unl 50tt” which I’ve had forever (I buy phones outright to keep it) and still pay $85 for two lines. I don’t see any price increases for my account recently. I have unlimited everything except 5gb of tethering. If they raise my price I’d be upset but it’s still cheaper by far than any modern plans. Someday my kid will need a phone and I’ll get him a separate account so I don’t get conned into changing my plan!
- danpalmer 2y agoIf they only committed to paying the final months bill, that's a very limited upside for customers. Far more limited than what "no price hikes" sounds like. There's basically no penalty for T-Mobile – if they raise prices and people stay, they win, and if someone chooses to leave (which they could do anyway if the price changes), they lose out in nearly the same way as if they hadn't made the promise.
- bigbacaloa 2y ago[dead]
- _carbyau_ 2y agoThis is less a surprise and more an issue with false advertising. If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck should I have to read fine print to realise it is a pig? In Australia there are limits to what advertising can get away with, presumably US has similar.
- walterbell 2y agoA condition of the Sprint merger was that T-Mobile had to offer low-cost prepaid plans without an MVNO. The program is called T-Mobile Connect, https://clark.com/cell-phones/connect-by-t-mobile/ https://clark.com/cell-phones/connect-by-t-mobile/ & https://coveragecritic.com/t-mobile-connect-review/ https://coveragecritic.com/t-mobile-connect-review/ & https://prepaid.t-mobile.com/connect/phone-plans https://prepaid.t-mobile.com/connect/phone-plans Monthly price for USA-only unlimited talk/text + 5G/LTE data is $15/5GB, $25/8GB, $35/12GB + taxes/fees. Outside USA, T-Mobile pSIM Wi-Fi call/text continues to work with any cellular provider's eSIM data on the 2nd line of iPhone.
- jdietrich 2y ago>Monthly price for USA-only unlimited talk/text + 5G/LTE data is $15/5GB, $25/8GB, $35/12GB + taxes/fees. By global standards, that is hilariously expensive. Here in the UK, I pay $13/mo for unlimited talk/text and 100GB of 5G data. I can get truly unlimited data for less than $22/mo. https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/cheap-mobile-finder/sim-only/ https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/cheap-mobile-finder/sim-on...
- bruceb 2y agoThe US covers a lot more land. More towers to put up. Higher wages to pay. Less density than UK.
- murderfs 2y agoBy global standards, the United States has hilariously low density and has hilariously high incomes, which means it's significantly more expensive to maintain a network. You're comparing a network that doesn't have 5G coverage in towns 20 miles away from the center of London [1] to one that has coverage over a gigantic proportion of the area that actually contains people at any given time. [2] 1: https://www.nperf.com/en/map/GB/-/164526.Vodafone-Mobile/signal?ll=51.430512064768656&lg=-0.204620361328125&zoom=9 https://www.nperf.com/en/map/GB/-/164526.Vodafone-Mobile/sig... 2: https://www.nperf.com/en/map/US/-/85.T-Mobile-inc-Sprint/signal?ll=37.54411419454302&lg=-99.25048828125&zoom=5 https://www.nperf.com/en/map/US/-/85.T-Mobile-inc-Sprint/sig...
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoRecently got away from really unlimited Verizon 4G when they kept upping the fees and nonsense to the tune of $200/month. Spectrum unlimited is really cheap for BYOD, does 5G UWB, and rides the coattails of Verizon. And, unlike Verizon, gives tethering and wi-fi hotspot sharing for free.
- 8note 2y agoHa. I was on the simple choice iirc, and when they decided they wanted to force an upgrade, they just broke all the data, and the only fix was to change plans.
- Havoc 2y ago> It explained that the only guarantee is T-Mobile will pay your final month's bill if the price goes up and you decide to cancel. What a joke. Price stays the same until we issue you a take it or leave it ultimatum at higher price. So basically like any other price?
- mdrzn 2y ago+1 to EU and Iliad, which arrived on the market in about 2018 and started providing 9,99€/month mobile internet plans forever, but FOREVER for real. I still have that plan.
- zemnl 2y agoYes, there are people I know who are still paying the same price Iliad offered at launch: 5.99€/month for unlimited calls and messages, and 30GB in 4G+. That price was basically half of what all other available providers offered at the time.
- kotaKat 2y agoAren't all these contracts month-to-month anyways? T-Mobile can change their terms with 30 days notice and most if not all current T-Mobile customers can "just" leave. The only special gag now is that the average consumer now has "device installment payments" that become immediately due in full when you terminate your side of the deal, and we now tie subsidies to "promo credits" on those payments.