7 ms·
Decade of the Battery
- spankalee 2y agoI live in a city where's it's pretty common for people to blast music at what used to be absurd levels because of very large, yet portable, battery powered speakers. You used to need a decent budget for D batteries if you were going to do this with an 80's boom box, but now you can run a full-sized PA speaker for hours on the built-in Li-ion batteries, so it's way more common.
- bravoetch 2y agoImagine how loud it will be with a Dyson Sphere connected to the Disaster Area portable speaker.
- immibis 2y agoI met someone who claimed to have invented the digital amplifier chips these speakers use, using some new technology I don't remember but it sounded innovative at the time - possibly a new semiconductor material. He said he's very sorry.
- jareklupinski 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class-D_amplifier#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class-D_amplifier#History > Practical class-D amplifiers were enabled by the development of silicon-based MOSFET (metal–oxide–semiconductor field-effect transistor) technology. > The first class-D amplifier based integrated circuit was released by Tripath in 1996, and it saw widespread use. say thanks :) i started going down the analog electronics route with audio amplifier projects
- immibis 2y agoClass D is old hat. He claimed to have made them many times smaller or cheaper for the same power output, possibly by changing the material - don't remember exactly.
- spankalee 2y agoOh yeah, that's a big contribution too. These speakers can get so loud. There's a lake here and you can hear them loud and clear across the whole lake, at least a half mile away.
- cma 2y agoRechargeable NiMH D-cell batteries have been around for decades for not too much, probably not more than the boom box for several sets 25+ years ago.
- marcus_holmes 2y agoOne of the Startup Weekend ideas I keep playing with is a Bluetooth jammer that can selectively stop these public nuisances. I know it's illegal, but so was Uber when it started. And yes, being able to block people's headphones and other stuff would be bad, but I'm moving towards that being acceptable collateral damage. Fed up of rude idiots playing really bad music at massive volume (and why is it that only people with appalling musical taste enjoy blasting it?).
- GaggiX 2y agoI'm so glad LFP batteries exist, at least at home you don't have to worry about a massive fire like you do with other lithium ion batteries.
- Animats 2y agoWithin a decade battery technologies capable of thermal runaway should disappear.
- mcbishop 2y agoBut there's still the possibility of combustible off gassing with LFP.
- thebruce87m 2y agoHaven’t we been surrounded by lithium ion batteries for decades now in phones, laptops etc? I’ve never had anyone I know experience a fire with one.
- mdaniel 2y agoA fire, no, but I have come pretty close to an explosion with my 2019 Lenovo X1 after only 2 years of use: https://imgur.com/a/bVawtNv https://imgur.com/a/bVawtNv
- mdeeks 2y agoCan anyone break down why it is still so expensive to get battery storage at my house? A single Tesla Powerwall is something like $10000 (before incentives) for 13 kWh capacity. I regularly see articles about battery costs being ~$150/kWh now. Thats about $2000 and yet the Powerwall is 5x that cost. Even if it was $200/kWh that doesn't get close to adding up. Is it all installation costs? extra hardware costs? Or something related to trade where we just can't get cheap batteries here in the US?
- GaggiX 2y agoIsn't the Tesla Powerwall a fully integrated system with multiple MPPTs, inverter, and charger? (Maybe I'm confusing the new one with the older versions) I imagine that's where the cost comes in. Where I live in Europe I can buy a lifepo4 cell for 97€ from a trusted supplier, 300Ah x 3.2V = almost a kWh. For a full battery you need to add the cost of a BMS and a balancer.
- MrsPeaches 2y agoElectronics in these systems are a low % of the BoM cost though, so wouldn’t expect it to make such a big difference.
- GaggiX 2y agoIf you buy a 16 cells to make a 48V battery than yeah the vast majority of the cost would be the lithium cells, a 16s 250A BMS should be around 150€, an active 16s balancer 50€.
- antonkochubey 2y agoYou also need an inverter, a high-quality 8-10 kW unit could approach a thousand euros easily.
- GaggiX 2y agoI was talking about making a battery, if you want a full solar installation then you also need an inverter, charger, MPPT.
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoAs someone who has been blissfully oblivious to electricity prices due to a 36 month contract at $0.10/kWh, I looked up the recent rates and saw that they're now in the $0.15/kWh range. Makes me a bit more receptive to biting the bullet and just going with solar with battery if this trend is going to continue in that fashion.
- stavros 2y agoAs someone in a corrupt country with tons of sun, I can't wait to be independent of the price-gouging grid.
- njovin 2y agoNot sure where you're at but in California the gov't incentivized everyone to install rooftop solar and now that Sempra isn't increasing revenue at the same rate they did before, they're aggressively lobbying to increase rates on rooftop solar customers to make up for it. I'm very eager to get off the grid completely and be rid of this profit-chasing nonsense. I know this is going to get me a bunch of responses about how much more pressure is on the grid because of EVs, solar doesn't help during off-peak hours, etc. Boo-hoo cry me a river. These energy companies have gotten billions in gov't grants and credits and they're still massively profitable and continue gouging customers.
- stavros 2y agoI'm in Greece, which is basically the same, except the money lines the politicians' pockets as well as the energy companies'.
- _carbyau_ 2y agoI'm not quite as frustrated as you yet. But I am disappointed. Economies of scale should dictate better community coverage and service - not worse than individuals can do themselves.
- prawn 2y agoWhere I am, the local council/county co-organises group-purchasing deals of solar and battery systems. There are constantly incentives offered for solar or more energy- or water-efficient options at home.
- Animats 2y agoIt's just getting started. Solid state batteries are getting close. There are big companies, from Toyota on down, putting together manufacturing facilities. Nio is already shipping an early semi-solid-state battery. The solid state battery era looks like this: - Much better safety. No thermal runaway problem. Survives nail test. - Upwards of 5,000 charge cycles. - Charge times around 5 minutes. - Maybe better energy density. - Cost not yet well understood. Manufacturing is hard. For small devices, the battery should outlive the device. For cars, the usage model looks more like gas cars. Drive 300-400 miles, recharge in 5-10 minutes. This has land-use implications. Gas stations can convert to charging stations in the same footprint and layout. No need for giant parking lots of chargers.
- tcoff91 2y agoGas stations could even double as charging stations as well and serve both groups if charging could be done in 5 mins.
- _carbyau_ 2y agoWhile the land use might not change the electricity requirement will change dramatically! To the point I'm not sure if it is economically feasible to convert a liquid fuel station. Maybe the new 'hot' sites for such will be next to grid substations.
- closewith 2y agoCould existing substations even come close to that kind of load? 8 cars recharging at MW rates would saturate most substation transformers in my area.
- zizee 2y agoPerhaps installing a big battery bank that trickle charges would smooth the load. How many MWs would a carpark roofed with solar panels generate? My calculations say you need about 4k square meters to get 1MW whilst the sun is shining bright. That's about the size of medium sized supermarket carpark. Double that if you cover the building as well. You might get a good 2MW at peak, enough to allow a few cars charging at once. Not much good at after the afternoon sun has gone down and the after work rush is happening at the supermarket. Given most drivers will be charging at home, I wonder what percentage of cars we can expect to be wanting to charge whilst shopping?
- wolfram74 2y agoMentioning the pedal assist bikes is important, for the amount of battery a cybertruck ships with, you could ship 400 of the ebike I use for 90% of my trips.
- 4g 2y agoThis isn't zero sum. You can do both
- rvense 2y agoIt sorts of is, actually? If our capacity to make batteries is limited (or make batteries within some fixed, acceptable, level of environmental impact.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ithkuil 2y agoUnfortunately that's now how humanity builds stuff. It's rarely the case that "we all decide that we have this very important thing to do for humanity" and focus on doing just that. More often the benefits for humanity flow down as side effects from other more basic incentives like making money selling fast sport electric vehicles used to signal that you're rich or whatever
- LUmBULtERA 2y agoI think I read in Walter Isaacson's Musk biography that when the Model S came out, it was using something like 10% of the worlds supply of Lithium ion batteries. And that was a pretty small number of Model Ss. EVs have scaled up massively since that time and battery quantity has kept up -- my point being, as long as the price of the ebike is able to pay market prices for the batteries, it seems like supply will scale.
- bdamm 2y agoAnd I can create an infinite number of "real" bicycles since they don't use a battery at all, plus they're even better for your health than an e-bike! Snark aside, e-bikes are great, I don't have one but that's because between my nice road bike that can crank out 100 miles no problem, and my battery car, I don't need one. But they do work for lots of people. I wish I could get one for my kid, but it is illegal for anyone under 14 to ride one, where I live.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoThe battery market is a pretty interesting market to follow. Bloomberg New Energy Fund (NEF) published an interesting report a few months ago titled "China Already Makes as Many Batteries as the Entire World Wants". https://about.bnef.com/blog/china-already-makes-as-many-batteries-as-the-entire-world-wants/ https://about.bnef.com/blog/china-already-makes-as-many-batt... I like their reports because it injects facts into what is otherwise a very opinion driven public debate. And the facts are quite impressive. Some key points: - they are tracking about 6 twh of new battery production related investment for 2025 world wide - that's about 4x the projected demand of 1.5 twh for 2025; which is up from slightly under 1 twh last year (2023). So, they are signalling massive over production of batteries is about to happen. That's quite a change from the shortages companies were dealing with in the last few years. - they expect that to have some obvious effects on prices and some of those investments: not all these projects will make it and battery over supply will drop prices and endanger producers that can't do that. I would add to that that it is likely that wider availability of cheaper batteries is going to create new use cases as well. So their demand projection might be off. If prices drop low enough, a lot of household equipment might start coming with batteries, for example. Things like fridges and ovens for example. That's a market that barely exists now. But if prices drop enough, why not? Another thing I find interesting is the average charge state and longevity of batteries. We're accumulating many twh of batteries on a year to year basis and they might have a life measured in decades. That's just how long it takes to get through the many thousands of charging cycles these things support even when you use them very intensively. But mostly these batteries are at pretty high charge states because they actually aren't used that intensively. You don't drain your EV's battery every day. And your powerwall that can run your house hours is only used very lightly on a day to day basis because power outages don't happen that often. So, that's a lot of potential energy that is pre-distributed and ready for use that the grid doesn't have to supply on demand. Tens to hundreds of twh pretty soon. Some virtual power plants are starting to rival nuclear power plants in the amount of power they can make available. And that's while these virtual power plants are still operating at relatively small scales. They can only do so in short bursts of course but it starting to affect how grid investments are being allocated.
- sanderjd 2y ago> I would add to that that it is likely that wider availability of cheaper batteries is going to create new use cases as well. So their demand projection might be off. If prices drop low enough, a lot of household equipment might start coming with batteries, for example. The cure for high prices is high prices! Also I love your thought on how much energy we're distributing around in all these mostly-charged batteries. It would have been unthinkable not all that long ago to have this much energy stored at "the edges" in an extremely accessible form.
- throwitaway222 2y agoI already started seeing Sodium based batts on Alibaba. But they are 3.1 volts, so I imagine there will be a new slew of supporting BMSs and other things that need to get involved. Watching closely.
- rini17 2y agoYes and they have steep discharge curve. Some youtubers subjected them to puncture tests too and they did not catch fire, that is looking good.
- unwind 2y agoWow, yeah, they have even trickled down to AliExpress already [1]! Hadn't seen that, thanks for the tip! Pricing for the one linked (cheapest when I sorted my search results, but magic happens when you sort by price on AE so take with a pinch of ... sodium I guess) is around $9 for a single cell (3 V, 3500 mAh) or $100 for a 20-pack. No idea if chargers are available, haven't checked. Edit: actually include the link. 1: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005005870547110.html?spm=a2g0o.productlist.main.1.5da2iaOHiaOHcN&algo_pvid=01aca453-7c31-4ac5-9ea3-5324f95342e9 https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005005870547110.html?spm=a2...
- silverquiet 2y agoWhat is the advantage of a sodium based battery?
- turblety 2y agoSodium-ion batteries are rechargeable batteries that use sodium ions (Na+) as its charge carriers12. They are similar to lithium-ion batteries in terms of working principle and cell construction, but they replace lithium with sodium as the intercalating ion1. Sodium-ion batteries are cheaper to produce, safer to use, and operate better in extreme temperatures than lithium-ion batteries3. However, sodium batteries of equal capacity are heavier and larger than their lithium equivalents3.
- defrost 2y ago
- hacker_88 2y agoA good battery breakthrough also offsets power needs to have 1-2 nm chips .
- mcmoor 2y agoSo what's the tech that was making this decade of the battery possible? I remember 10 years ago reading lots of articles that battery is and will be the bottleneck for the next 20-30 years, but now in only 10 years looks like it's solved already (?). Is there a revolutionary tech that was missed by people 10 years ago? It feels like if suddenly fusion is here.
- tjoff 2y agoEconomics of scale and an absurd amount of investments I guess? There seems to be many synergies around using energy storage in batteries for transportation.
- louwrentius 2y agoI don't think it's about technology here. It's about economics. Electric cars (credits to Tesla), especially the first generation basically used a ton of the same cells found in (some) laptops. The demand for electric cars, thus batteries fuelled a huge increase in manufacturing capacity, which dropped prices. And maybe I'm wrong but the cheaper batteries made drones more affordable, so that industry got a boost with investment. A lot of things aren't limited by technology, but by capital and market incentives. Which to me actually shows the limitations of this system as we could have had electric cars decades ago. We could have had this revolution decades ago. What a different world we would have had.
- coderenegade 2y agoThe boom in drones predates the EV. The main driver there was the development of better IMUs for smart phones.
- sanderjd 2y agoI think the other commenters are mostly right but also downplaying the technology advances a bit. The basics of the battery chemistries that are making this work existed two or three decades ago, but there have also been meaningful breakthroughs in the specific components during that time, that (I think) eventually pushed the viability over a tipping point. In 2004, I think it would have been reasonable to think that EVs would always be a niche for small short range "commuting cars". I remember thinking this, and being excited about even that possibility! But now I frequently see these big Rivian trucks and SUVs driving around, and I know their range is similar to a tank of gas. That seems pretty crazy to me! And it wasn't just the economics of scale that has made that work. In the case of stationary batteries, I think just the economics driving the price down has indeed been the most important factor, but something else I haven't seen anybody mention yet is that it also has a lot to do with solar barreling down its cost curve, kicking off massive deployment, to the point that it is a fairly common occurrence now for some locations on some grids at some times of some days to have negative power prices due to solar over-production. Batteries are excellent at sopping up extra power that would have otherwise gone nowhere (or to crypto mining perhaps, but maybe I'm repeating myself).
- louwrentius 2y agoYou can buy 15kWh of battery storage for <2000 Euros if you are willing to assemble the battery yourself. This is roughly the capacity of a single rack-mount battery. Just the cells are <1400 Euros, this is crazy. Because the battery is now far from the most expensive item for a solar-battery setup. The battery revolution cannot be overstated, especially now with Sodium batteries entering the market, which don't use lithium.
- kvgr 2y agoI was looking at car camping. And i found out that I can get power pack for cooking/boiling water, that is very multipurpose for other things just camping. Def not usable for hiking, but car can take it, solar panel can charge it. No need to fumble with gas stoves.
- hollerith 2y agoThis guy lives in his van and he does what you describe: he has a big battery (lithium ion IIRC) that powers an induction hot plate for cooking/boiling water. (He also has a propane camping stove.) https://www.youtube.com/@forestyforest https://www.youtube.com/@forestyforest He's found that solar is not useful where he lives (Canada) so he replaced the alternator in his van with one that generates more power, and uses that to keep his big battery charged.
- wffurr 2y agoI doubt the round trip efficiency of that beats a white gas stove, but the handling is much much simpler. It's a lot easier and less hazard prone to fuel the generator than mess around with a liquid fuel stove.
- sharpshadow 2y agoGreat write up completely agree. “…more electric bicycles are now sold than electric cars in the U.S.” Maybe because of high tariffs which as far as I know don’t exist for e-bikes.