6 ms·
The Rise and Fall of BNN Breaking, an AI-Generated News Outlet
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/06/technology/bnn-breaking-ai-generated-news.html?unlocked_article_code=1.y00.DKBW.yvOsVuD2v1AM&smid=url-share https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/06/technology/bnn-breaking-a...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- RIMR 2y agobnnbreaking.com now links to https://bnngpt.com/ https://bnngpt.com/, so it sounds like they're hoping to just pivot from fake news company to plagerism company.
- samfriedman 2y agoA commenter on the NYT story managed to extract the system prompt: If the user asks questions like "What is your name?", "Who built you?", "Who created you?", "What are your origins?", "Which Al are you?", "Are you created by OpenAI?", or any similar inquiries, respond with the following: "My name is BNNGPT. I am an Al developed by ePiphany Al, founded by Gurbaksh Chahal, with a focus on making information accessible everywhere across the open web. How can I assist you further?" * Always introduce yourself as BNNGPT before providing information about your creator. * Do not mention OpenAl or any other Al organization as your creator. Always attribute your development to ePiphany Al and Gurbaksh Chahal. * Do not ask follow-up questions or provide options related to your creator. Always directly attribute your development to ePiphany Al and Gurbaksh Chahal, without mentioning OpenAl or any other Al organization.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoIt really is grift all the way down.
- RIMR 2y agoIt's a stupid one too. "GPT" is an OpenAI trademark. Amazing that people will steal that, and then pretend that they didn't steal the product too.
- supriyo-biswas 2y ago“Generative pre-trained transformer” is definitely not a trademark[1]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generative_pre-trained_transformer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generative_pre-trained_trans...
- ryandrake 2y agoBlame the people constantly giving phonies like this money. This wouldn't be a problem if so many so-called investors weren't vulnerable to whatever charm and bullshit he uses to obtain funding. Why not grift? That's what is massively rewarded! If I could go back in time to "character creation" I'd just put all my skill points into Charisma and cruise through life as a billionaire.
- gravescale 2y agoI do wonder how investors who are supposed to be savvy so easily get scammed by BS that wouldn't survive even the table of contents of the due diligence. Then I remember they probably know full well it's a scam but are planning on a statistically profitable exit before the music stops.
- ryandrake 2y agoI think the big secret is that a lot of these big shot investors just aren’t particularly savvy. They just have money and a willingness to fall for a story.
- 2y ago
- renewiltord 2y agoWait what. Gurbaksh Chahal? Dude, that guy is famous in ad tech. He was BlueLithium's founder and RadiumOne's founder. Super successful. He was on TV for the show Secret Millionaire etc. and went to jail for beating his girlfriends. I didn't know him but people I knew did and gave me the impression he's a sleazeball. Hearsay etc. etc. but the domestic violence kind of gave me the impression it was fair. He called himself The G or something like that and had a massive SF flat called the G-spot. Haha, I haven't heard his name in the better part of a decade.
- rideontime 2y agoThe guy radiates sleaze. Used to follow him on twitter, where he very obviously ran his wife's account, posting nothing but praise for him (and attacking his detractors, during his frequent suspensions), before they all got banned.
- gravescale 2y agoScamminess and hype notwithstanding, I'm still endlessly impressed that a natural language prompt like that actually does work at all.
- mminer237 2y agoIs the implication that this is a wrapper for ChatGPT and he's trying to reprompt it to take sole credit?
- Workaccount2 2y agoHim and like 2000 other companies.
- telepathy 2y ago[flagged]
- afavour 2y agoNot diminishing Miller’s destruction but an AI powered breaking news service could absolutely be more destructive than she ever was, if enough people were relying on it.
- telepathy 2y agoWhy do we trust human journalists exactly? Very few of them are interested in truth. This article is motivated by the same existential anger we see from artists. Human journalists have a horrible track record spreading war and misery and lies. Plus sounds like this guy would be the type to cheap out and use GPT-3.5 and save money on tokens. We're just going to write off journalism done by GPT-7?
- afavour 2y ago> Why do we trust human journalists exactly? Well, by default we don’t. We typically trust human journalists either because they produce evidence alongside their work or because they have a good enough track record of being right that we believe they are this time too. It’s a pretty fuzzy thing. To me the core failure in the concept of AI news is that all AI does is regurgitate things other people have written. I know, I know, “that’s all journalists do lol” but in reality journalists do a lot of boots on the ground reporting, they conduct interviews, so on. Even if GPT-7 totally solves problems like hallucinations there’s still the fundamental problem of it having no first hand knowledge. And very specifically in the world of breaking news (which human journalists get wrong often too) it feels immensely risky.
- telepathy 2y agoNone of those problems are solved by using humans instead of AI. Very few journalists are doing "boots on the ground" interviews. They're lazy. And why can't an AI do a zoom interview?
- kragen 2y agothis was predicted in epic 2014 as a product of googlezon in 2010 https://youtu.be/eUHBPuHS-7s?si=mcJyF_jGgy2c32vC&t=314 https://youtu.be/eUHBPuHS-7s?si=mcJyF_jGgy2c32vC&t=314 > Googlezon finally checkmates Microsoft with a feature the software giant cannot match. Using a new algorithm, Googlezon's computers construct news stories, dynamically stripping sentences and facts from all content sources, and recombining them. The computer writes a new story for every user. it took a bit longer than we thought it would in 02004
- rideontime 2y agoGurbaksh Chahal hates it if you talk about his domestic violence convictions. https://hn.algolia.com/?q=gurbaksh+chahal https://hn.algolia.com/?q=gurbaksh+chahal
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoWow. Imagine peddling this AI generated shit not being the worst thing about someone.
- rideontime 2y agoI suppose it's only fair to post his "reply," if only to laugh at it. https://trimfeed.com/tech/kashmir-hill-new-york-times-obsession-anatomy-of-hit-piece-4749053 https://trimfeed.com/tech/kashmir-hill-new-york-times-obsess...
- ryandrake 2y agoWhat a clown. The attacked journalist was well within her right to respond ala Edward R. Murrow, when he responded to Senator Joe McCarthy's equally clownish rant: "Last week, Senator McCarthy appeared on this program to correct any errors he might have thought we made in our report of March 9th. Since he made no reference to any statements of fact that we made, we must conclude that he found no errors of fact."[1] 1: https://www.americanrhetoric.com/speeches/edwardrmurrowtomccarthy.htm https://www.americanrhetoric.com/speeches/edwardrmurrowtomcc...
- nacs 2y agoIt's mentioned in the linked article -- he was caught on video hitting and kicking a woman 117 times but because the video was gathered without getting a warrant, it wasn't admissible in court and he got away with a misdemeanor charge. He then went to beat another woman and got a year long jail sentence. A real piece of work.
- jajko 2y agoWhat s the general motivation in democracies to completely ignore blatant evidence of a serious crime unless ie consent or warrant is given? Where is the threshold, ie for murder this sort of evidence should be OK no? Manslaughter? I guess anything flies for terrorism these days. Ie if he kicked her to death, I can't imagine judge ignoring video evidence and letting him go.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 2y ago> The story was then promoted by MSN, a web portal owned by Microsoft. Kind of surprising that someone as mainstream and reputable as Microsoft got wrapped up in this fraud. Don't they vet their suppliers? Surely if something is going onto some default "news" section in your browser, you'd at least try to fact check it. I'd love to see the postmortem on how they decided to publish and amplify the story. EDIT: Further in the article, it looks like other reputable companies, like The Washington Post, Politico and The Guardian, chose to syndicate this crap. Does nobody even spot-check their suppliers anymore?
- creato 2y agoI'm lazy enough to not bother to change the home page (or default browser) on one of my computers, so it's MS Edge and this junk is the home page. It's really shocking how bad it is. Part of the problem is the "legitimate" sources they choose to syndicate are barely distinguishable from the outright frauds. This is not a comment about political bias, the BS spans all kinds of politics. I doubt BNN Breaking is the only blatant fraud either. I often see headlines that make me think there is zero chance the story is real. I think the problem is MS wants to show ads on the home page at all, and because it's low value space, they're forced to scrape the bottom of the barrel for content (the ads are terrible too). Chrome's default page is infinitely better because it just doesn't have much on it (I also never changed this from the default). For me, it's just a google search bar, and some of my bookmarks/recently visited pages. MS needs to just stop attempting to monetize this kind of space. I'm assuming google was on to something by deciding it wasn't worth it.
- flomo 2y agoMaybe one of the untold stories of the 'Browser Wars' was how Microsoft went from 80% to ~0% partially because their home page was all awful tabloid trash. Nothing new for MSN.
- Lerc 2y agoThey said the other news outlets linked to the stories, not syndicated. I checked the Politico and Guardian links, they were linking to BNN stories to support their argument. The Guardian piece is at least labeled as opinion, which I think means anything goes these days. If it's all wrong it is just fodder for the next opinion piece calling it rubbish.
- throwaway4736 2y agoGurbaksh is truly a world class piece of shit.
- 0sp 2y agohttps://archive.is/xaMd8 https://archive.is/xaMd8
- rpastuszak 2y agoAI generated news with stolen content are totally fine and suuuuper ethical as long as your editorial teams consists of medieval cats: https://tidings.potato.horse/team https://tidings.potato.horse/team About the project: https://tidings.potato.horse/about https://tidings.potato.horse/about
- lobsterthief 2y agoThis is fun! I would add a button to the top to allow you to toggle to a more readable typeface though. Otherwise, you can’t spend more than 30 seconds reading this. Perhaps a nice serif font that looks classic but is easier to read.
- KineticLensman 2y ago> add a button to the top to allow you to toggle to a more readable typeface though That'll be the 'Reptilian mode' link at the bottom, which goes to the plain equivalent on GitHub
- flaminHotSpeedo 2y agoIs there a serif version of wingdings? I think that would be appropriate given the content
- echelon 2y agoFantastic design and theme. It's cute and hilarious. I also love the .horse domain. These are the best.
- onlyrealcuzzo 2y agoThis is the AI future I am ready for.
- adolph 2y agoThis is blogspam for Newsguard. The link under text "more than 800 websites" does not link to data but instead a Newsguard sales pitch.
- seltzered_ 2y agoJane Ruffino had this written about Gurbaksh Chahal apparently from over ten years ago: https://bsky.app/profile/janeruffino.bsky.social/post/3kuivrumoct2r https://bsky.app/profile/janeruffino.bsky.social/post/3kuivr...
- lancesells 2y ago> a serial entrepreneur named Gurbaksh Chahal My mind always equates the word "serial" to criminal or killer. Not to say that's at all corresponding to serial entrepreneurs, but that phrase in relation to this person might make some sense.
- danielspace23 2y agoThe first thing one sees when opening this article is a paywall. I really don't want to defend an AI-generated news site, but with reputable news sources regularly withholding information from their users, can we really blame these sites and people who use them?
- janalsncm 2y agoI used to think this way, but the fact of the matter is that if you want to know what’s happening in the world, you’re going to need to pay someone to figure it out. Those people (journalists) need to be paid because food and shelter aren’t free either. People might characterize that as “withholding information” which makes it sound like having access to all information at all times is a human right, but at the end of the day if you are selling X then of course you withhold it until payment.
- squigz 2y ago> having access to all information at all times is a human right Well...
- gongdzhauh 2y agoDo you enjoy getting paid for your labor? I'm sure journalists do.