7 ms·
All three game console makers have now abandoned X integration
- anotherhue 2y agoWayland is the future. On a serious note, did you know you can boot to gamescope and have a steamdeck like experience on your computer? https://github.com/ValveSoftware/gamescope https://github.com/ValveSoftware/gamescope FSR scaling and everything.
- ygra 2y agoThis is about ex-Twitter, not the X Window System.
- lyu07282 2y agoIt was obviously a joke
- taeric 2y agoI confess I thought this was a possible read for longer than makes sense. I still don't think of the social network as X. Curious how long it will take me to do so. I'm also curious why I would care that my console does or does not have linked accounts with social. Now curious if they have other networks.
- Marsymars 2y ago> Curious how long it will take me to do so. Maybe it will click in three years or so when trademark abandonment kicks in and some other company can start using the Twitter name/bird.
- r00fus 2y ago"Stop trying to make X happen" - everyone
- ryandrake 2y ago> I still don't think of the social network as X. Curious how long it will take me to do so. My guess is it will be effectively dead as a platform long before people stop thinking of it as Twitter. Imagine if someone took over the Coca Cola company, and suddenly rebranded all of the soda as "W". How long until people stopped calling the drink Coke?
- soraminazuki 2y agoEven the logo is the same.
- __rito__ 2y agoMusk went big on long-form video content and streaming. I don't know if he is still bullish on that. He projected X as a Twitch competitor where a lot of gaming would move. I think that's what this integration was about.
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoHaving actually spent a while pulling down & compiling dependencies & gamescope, on an AMD rx580, no, I could not boot to gamescope. Very unclear to me why it wouldn't start, wasn't leaving much for logs, but it wasn't starting in embedded/direct launch mode. (I really wanted to try Cyberpunk 2078 in HDR mode, which conventional Wayland desktops cannot do yet.) That said there are some much more polished attempts that should just work if you're willing to boot a purpose built os. I intend at some point to start cribbing pieces from chiemraOS, which seems to be what many are built off of, including the very very excellent Bazzite. Their gamescope-session work in particular seems crucial, https://github.com/ChimeraOS/gamescope-session/blob/main/usr/share/gamescope-session-plus/gamescope-session-plus https://github.com/ChimeraOS/gamescope-session/blob/main/usr...
- nshunter 2y agoSocial tie ins with gaming never truly worked despite about a decade of experimentation. Lots of the features from social networks instead got included in game design rather than relying on facebook and x for engagement. I imagine that UGC will still find easy mechanisms for sharing per title, but as a defacto option from big game makers it's done.
- jonhohle 2y agoModern Twitter/X to me is a lot like modern Star Wars. A lot of people, including myself, liked the early work, but the current management (and arguably a whole lot of people) seem to have liked very different ideas and gone with those rather than the things I thought made the original interesting. Of note: while the headline is completely accurate, I had no idea this was about X/Twitter and thought it was some game tech. At least in the gaming world of my kids and myself, social integration is a lot of fun. It’s possible that this was a money pit, but with all the garbage on Twitter, having a simple way to post game stuff seems like an odd category to weed out.
- throwanem 2y agoThe garbage is the point. Musk and like ilk don't hate the "cathedral," so called, because they believe it steers the public discourse; they only hate when they can't feel like they're the ones doing the steering.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> they only hate when they can't feel like they're the ones doing the steering. This is much more true of the “other side” than “Musk and like ilk”. The hate against Musk and X is primarily because a lot of people on one political side hate that they’re no longer steering public discourse. Also the current X does far less steering (in any direction) than the censorship heavy regime of the past.
- mostlysimilar 2y ago[flagged]
- tombert 2y agoActually Elon's politics aren't really the reason I hate him. The main reason I started hating him was calling a guy a pedophile because he didn't want to use Elon's stupid submarine in a cave rescue, but I also think that Elon is potentially complicit in some crypto pump and dump. I have no direct proof of the latter, other than I think it was a little weird that he suddenly was fully onboard with Dogecoin until he wasn't very shortly after.
- curtis3389 2y agoThis seems like a no-brainer for the console makers. The consoles are already sold, and they're making back any losses from that through games sales and subscriptions. Then X comes along and asks for half a mil a year. I'm sure they looked at their usage numbers and how people feel about X, and they decided they could cut the feature and not lose many/any customers. Feature cut; projected revenue remains the same; problem solved.
- b112 2y agoAnother aspect of things, is you can put an FAQ up, saying that suddenly they wanted cash. People get the "it was free now it costs" thing.
- NelsonMinar 2y agoI used to share a lot of screenshots from PS5 to Twitter. It was one of the easiest ways to get pictures off the platform. Now I use the Playstation App on my phone which works OK but is a bit clumsy. The Switch has a really wacky way of getting pictures off it; it runs an HTTP server on an ad hoc WiFi network when you ask it to! Every week I miss something else that we lost when Twitter got ruined.
- kelsey98765431 2y ago[dead]
- oidar 2y agoX is actively hostile to potential users/reader - I see no reason to look at any x domain related content.
- morkalork 2y agoOn multiple occasions a Twitter post is reposted on hn/reddit and in the hn/reddit thread people are complaining about how nobody is reading the Twitter replies and are just blindly reacting to the original post. Sorry, we're all missing the context but if you don't have an account, that's all it shows. So hostile. It turns away potential users at every step.
- Suppafly 2y ago>Sorry, we're all missing the context but if you don't have an account, that's all it shows. This. You used to be able to see the comments (although they were often in a weird order) and such but after the move to X, they removed that altogether.
- jedberg 2y agoAmusingly this was posted on reddit, and the top comments were all "What's X?" "Oh they mean Twitter why doesn't the headline say that?" "I thought this was some Xbox integration, didn't realize it was Twitter". Talk about the worst rebrand ever.
- duxup 2y agoI still call it Twitter because 100% folks will know what I mean. X ... even if they know what X is, it's too short and people mishear it / misunderstand it.
- GJim 2y agoWe've all taken to calling it Xitter...... pronounced 'shitter'. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Xitter https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Xitter https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Xitter https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Xitter
- r2_pilot 2y agoSame here. It shortens appropriately too.
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoIt is a stupid rebrand. But is the juvenile nonsense really just political Elon-Hate? “I say Shitter”… wow, that’s really clever.
- aaronbrethorst 2y agoI’d say it’s more clever than telling advertisers fleeing X to “go fuck yourselves”, but then again I’m not worth $200bn, so what do I know?
- GJim 2y ago> is the juvenile nonsense really just political Elon-Hate Juvenile? No. That is reserved for those who choose to refer to Mr Musk as "Xitler". Frankly, 'shitter' is a very accurate description of what x/twitter has become. You would need to have your head in the sand to think otherwise.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Uehreka 2y agoAs someone who just had to build integrations with all the big social media sites, this tracks. People thought I was crazy when I came back with the research that our TikTok integration would be free, and then our X integration would be $42000 per month. It’s absurdly easy to slide down their pricing ramp, which is more like a series of cliffs: $100/mo for basic, $5000/mo for Pro, at least $42000/mo for Enterprise once you exceed Pro’s limits. There are no amounts in between. It’s like building an API integration against a box of dynamite.
- Y_Y 2y agoif valid(API_KEY): detonate() else: detonate()
- koolala 2y ago"Free"
- ivanjermakov 2y agoFree as in identity theft
- NelsonMinar 2y ago420 is a weed joke
- paxys 2y agoWhen Twitter first rolled out their paid API tiers my company tried to reason with their sales reps that charging us for the privilege of letting our users share their content with Twitter was absurd considering Twitter was the one gaining more from the interaction than us. They wouldn't budge and asked us for I think $300K/month because of our high volume. "Lol, no" was a very easy answer.
- creshal 2y agoI really wonder what kind of business model you need to able to afford Twitter's API pricing. It seems so outlandishly ridiculous that it kills any use case I can come up with.
- dehrmann 2y agoShould have countered with "we'll keep the integration if you pay us $2,000 per month."
- me_me_me 2y ago"You want us to pay you, so our users create content for your platform?" What do you even say to that as twitter sales rep?
- wojciii 2y agoI'm just mad at the unsupported cesspool X has become and I'm glad that it's dying.
- renewiltord 2y agoSocial media sites can't charge to post. That sounds like a misunderstanding of who is providing the value here.
- JohnMakin 2y agoIt is however pretty reasonable to charge for API usage. Twitter in the past was a bit generous as to their limits. That said, absurd API pricing like this are meant to actively discourage you from using the API, which definitely does not help the product even if it may slightly help their bottom line.
- pcloadletter_ 2y agoI'm beginning to suspect that Musk's takeover of Twitter was a Bad Idea.
- turblety 2y agoI'm convinced Musk is intentionally trying to kill Twitter, and it's going exactly as planned.
- pcloadletter_ 2y agoWe're running out of alternative explanations. At this point an RNG could make better business decisions on average.
- dehrmann 2y agoMaybe out of spite, but originally, it was a joke that went too far.
- CaptainOfCoit 2y agoThat's all a matter of perspective. Bad idea for who? Musk? Certainly. The rest of us? Maybe a good idea, depending on what the final outcome(s) will be.
- pcloadletter_ 2y agoyeah, true. I didn't realize how much being on Twitter was bringing me down until a few months after I got rid of it.
- h2odragon 2y agoNever did see what "Twitter integration" added to anything, especially in cases like this. What does it add to the game? what does "Someone just achieved game token" tweets offer to the rest of the world? Same for any other social media; its not even "peanut butter in the chocolate" kind of natural marketing gimmick: its "you got your floor wax in my reproductive anatomy" wtf were they thinking in the first place?
- rchaud 2y agoCorrect, these integrations are mostly for spamming game-related activity to Twitter/other social networks.
- __rito__ 2y agoMusk actually was (and probably still is) bullish on long-form video content on twitter. He projected it as the twitch dethroner. I think that's what it was about. Being able to stream directly to twitter from Xbox/PS.
- shultays 2y agoTwitter charges corporates for using Twitter? If anything, the consoles should charge Twitter, for bringing in users and content
- dvh 2y agoI'm gonna play devil's advocate here. If the goal is to remove corporations from Twitter and turn Twitter into platform paid by people for the people, than it could be a good thing. Enterprises just flood Twitter with spam.
- burutthrow1234 2y agoExcept these integrations are used by the end users to post content to Twitter. If you really wanted to squeeze end users you could make them connect a premium account or something, but charging the console maker for the consumer's use of the integration is just stupid.
- gs17 2y agoIn this case though, it's preventing the people from sharing things easily. It's not "Nintendo can't have a free account", it's "Nintendo's users can't post screenshots from Smash Bros without jumping through extra hoops".
- rchaud 2y agoThe devil doesn't operate on the basis of "If" though. Far too much of the Twitter takeover debacle has involved self-appointed Musk whisperers to translate his diffuse ramblings into something resembling a coherent business strategy. That ship sailed when $54bn in cash changed hands for a perma-unprofitable social media site full of anonymous, untargetable users. Take out the enterprise spam, and you'll be left with celebrity spam, Youtuber spam, Hustlebro spam, crypto spam....the list goes on. Most social media content is spam, not organic content posted 'just because'.
- t_mann 2y agoI recently tried to open an X account, the process was punishing: the captcha was six images of ~5 dice each from an acute angle, and I had to click the one where the top faces added up to 15. That takes considerably more time than "select all the cars", especially if the correct image is among the last. And that challenge was repeated 10 times (with a counter to 10 shown from the start, so it wasn't just that many because of retries after failure). I actually went through with it, but in the end I failed to sign up because the verification email never arrived. I've since been wondering whether Musk now wants it to fail, so he can draw a line under this chapter and shift focus back to his more succesful ventures.
- flutas 2y ago> the captcha was six images of ~5 dice each from an acute angle, and I had to click the one where the top faces added up to 15. That takes considerably more time than "select all the cars" This has been a fairly standard captcha for the past few years across the "more attacked" providers. That one, Rotate the [object] to match this direction, Click the item in this image with the highest value, Click the dice that add up to [X], Which of these items doesn't belong, etc. They are all much more difficult than previous ones, and I've long wondered if they are compliant with various disability laws.
- t_mann 2y agoI get it, but 10 puzzles in a row? It's not like the number of puzzles makes a difference to a bot when they're all of the same type (except for the bots that guess randomly, but there would be smarter combinatorial ways to trip those up that are less user-hostile; eg simply saying "select all" instead of "select the one" increases the possibilities tenfold while increasing effort only ~twofold). You're going to be filtering out a lot of humans this way. I personally only went through with it out of curiosity, because I was half-expecting it to not work in the end - as it did, so at least I have a story to tell now.
- flutas 2y ago> It's not like the number of puzzles makes a difference to a bot They do actually. A lot of the captcha process isn't just yes/no to the answer anymore (though this signal seems to be increasing lately). They also monitor timings on clicks, movement of the mouse, etc to identify a bot vs a real user. More data on these signals = better reliability for detecting bots.
- MisterBastahrd 2y ago"We had something that was working, but then our owner decided to be a wingnut and turned the entire platform to a highly unprofitable pile of radioactive shit" is a hell of a business move. There's a reason that most super-rich people tend to deal with political content in a very hands-off manner publicly. If he had kept his opinions to himself instead of being a terrible shitposter, they likely still wouldn't be making any money, but the company would also be worth far more than it currently is.
- m3kw9 2y agoElon been really talking sht lately esp regarding Apples AI, zero understanding before tweetinf
- nullsmack 2y agoX who? Just say Twitter. Nobody in their right mind is ever going to call it X legitimately.