5 ms·
I see no real difference between 2 and 3. Once the data has left your device, it has left your device. There is no getting it back and you no longer have any co
by SoftTalker 2y ago
I see no real difference between 2 and 3. Once the data has left your device, it has left your device. There is no getting it back and you no longer have any control over it.
- r00fus 2y agoHopefully they have some toggle in settings for this.
- solarkraft 2y agoApple has demonstrated to be relatively trustworthy about privacy while most AI companies have demonstrated the opposite, so I do see a significant difference.
- SoftTalker 2y agoGoogle was considered very cool and trustworthy at one point also. "Do no evil" and all that.
- babypuncher 2y agoGoogle's entire buisness model was built on hoovering up and selling access to user data in the form of AdSense. Without that data, their business falls apart. Apple's business model is to entice people into a walled garden ecosystem where they buy lots of expensive hardware sold on high margins. They don't need user data to make this work, which is why they can more comfortably push features like end-to-end and no-knowledge encryption.
- doctor_eval 2y agoGoogle was cool, once upon a time, but they always used your personal info pretty openly. The CEO a himself famously said, “The Google policy on a lot of things is to get right up to the creepy line and not cross it.” Apple has taken a markedly different approach, and has done so for years - E2E encryption, hashing and segmenting routes on maps, Secure Enclave, etc. While I think it’s perfectly reasonable to “trust no one”, and I fully agree that there may be things we don’t know, I don’t think there it’s reasonable to put Apple on the same (exceedingly low) level as Google.
- cchance 2y agoNo they never were, they were "do no evil" but at the exact same time everyone knew they were an advertising company and most people in the field could see where it was heading eventually, or at least i'd hope. Apples motives are different, selling premium hardware and MORE premium hardware, they wouldn't dare fuck that up, their nestegg is hardware and slowly more services tied to said hardware ecosystem (icloud subs, tv subs etc). Hence the privacy makes sense to pull people into the ecosystem. Google... everything google does even phones, is for more data gathering for their advertising revenue.
- babypuncher 2y agoThe difference is Apple and OpenAI's privacy policies.
- cchance 2y ago#2 is publicaly auditable, 100% apple controlled and apple hardware servers, tied to your personal session (probably via the ondevice encryption), i'd imagine ephemeral docker containers or something similar for requests that just run for each request or some form of Encrypted AI Lambdas.
- madeofpalk 2y agoI think that is completely fair. I think also a bunch of people will trust Apple’s server more (but not completely) than other third parties.
- stnmtn 2y agoCertainly there's a difference. You are right that the jump is big between 1 and 2, but it is negligent to say that Apple, a company which strives for improved privacy and security, and ChatGPT have the same privacy practices.
- drpossum 2y agoNo, that's not the point. The point is neither of those companies could have the same values you have for your data and you are then leaving the security of that data in the hands of someone else. Even Apple, who is better than most, values your privacy with a dollar value representing your custom and their reputation. That is not how I value (nor most people value) their data. The latter point applies to any company, regardless of intention because security breaches are a matter of when, not if, and if anyone says otherwise they should not be talking about security.
- coob 2y agoMost people are happy for (2) already - iCloud Photos, Device backups, iCloud Messages… email. Those that won’t use those won’t use this either.
- privacyking 2y agoYou do realise that already happens though? If you read apple's privacy policy they send a lot of what you do to their servers. Furthermore how private do you think Siri is? Their privacy policy explicitly states they send transcripts of what you say to them. That cannot be disabled.
- underlogic 2y agoThat's the problem. These AI features may be "free" but is there an option to disable them system wide from rummaging through all your data and building a profile in order to be helpful? If not I won't update. And I mean one tickbox not a separate switch for every app and feature like siri has making it nearly impossible to disable
- sodality2 2y ago> Furthermore how private do you think Siri is? Their privacy policy explicitly states they send transcripts of what you say to them. That cannot be disabled. Ten minutes ago i set up a new Apple device and it not only asked me if I wanted to enable Siri, but whether I wanted to contribute audio clips to improve it. What, exactly, cannot be disabled?
- redwall_hp 2y agoYou can trivially find it in the Settings app after setup, too: Privacy & Security -> Analytics & Improvements -> scroll to the Improve Siri & Dictation toggle that explains that it controls whether Apple can store and review audio of interactions with Siri and the dictation function. Plenty of other options to review in the vicinity too, since the first party privacy settings are basically all in the same place.
- privacyking 2y agoThat is the option for the audio itself. The transcripts of the audio (you do know what transcripts are, right?) are always sent to apple as per their privacy policy. "When you use Siri, your device will indicate in Siri Settings if the things you say are processed on your device and not sent to Siri servers. Otherwise, your voice inputs are sent to and processed on Siri servers. In all cases, transcripts of your interactions will be sent to Apple to process your requests." It's pretty clear and not in dispute that your transcripts are always sent to Apple.
- Terretta 2y ago> I see no real difference between 2 and 3. This #2, so-called "Private Cloud Compute", is not the same as iCloud. And certainly not the same as sending queries to OpenAI. Quoting: “With Private Cloud Compute, Apple Intelligence can flex and scale its computational capacity and draw on larger, server-based models for more complex requests. These models run on servers powered by Apple silicon, providing a foundation that allows Apple to ensure that data is never retained or exposed.“ “Independent experts can inspect the code that runs on Apple silicon servers to verify privacy, and Private Cloud Compute cryptographically ensures that iPhone, iPad, and Mac do not talk to a server unless its software has been publicly logged for inspection.” “Apple Intelligence with Private Cloud Compute sets a new standard for privacy in AI, unlocking intelligence users can trust.”
- jeroenhd 2y ago"We make the hardware and we pinky promise that we will protect your data and will open source part of it" means nothing for privacy. Especially when things like warrants come into play.
- dudus 2y agoIt's a big mental gymnastics to do the same as Google and Microsoft while claiming moral superiority. Apple's thrown stones come back to hunt their glass ceiling.
- cyberpunk 2y agoEh with modern processor features like secure enclaves it's definitely possible to build systems in which the operators CANNOT access the information. (I worked on such a system using SGX for a large car producer, even physical access to the machines/hypervisors/raw memory would not give you access, perhaps the nsa has some keys baked in to extract a session key you may generate inside an enclave, but it would be very surprising if they burned that backdoor on anything as low fruit as this).
- 2y ago