7 ms·
The U.S. Economy Reaches Superstar Status
- TMWNN 2y agoThe desperation to spin the narrative to prevent Trump returning to the White House reaches new heights hourly.
- friend_and_foe 2y agoWhen a metric becomes a target it ceases to be a good metric. Someone on HN posited that the models we use for economic performance are overfitted, that they no longer actually gauge the performance of the economy. The economy, after all, is about finding optimal distribution of resources, and ultimately, all resources are produced for the benefit of human beings, so if people's experience on the ground, in reality, is that things are bad, maybe quit telling them they're wrong and go find out what's wrong with your models or measures? Just a wild idea, what do I know.
- sdsd 2y agoAh, yes. I read a good book about stories like this: The Ministry of Plenty's forecast had estimated the output of boots for the quarter at 145 million pairs. The actual output was given as sixty-two millions. Winston, however, in rewriting the forecast, marked the figure down to fifty-seven millions, so as to allow for the usual claim that the quota had been overfulfilled. In any case, sixty-two millions was no nearer the truth than fifty-seven millions, or than 145 millions. Very likely no boots had been produced at all. Likelier still, nobody knew how many had been produced, much less cared. All one knew was that every quarter astronomical numbers of boots were produced on paper, while perhaps half the population of Oceania went barefoot.
- bpodgursky 2y agoThe United States has more material surplus than any country in the history of the world. This is a really bad example because you could try to make the case that per-capita income doesn't accurately capture the difficulty obtaining education/healthcare/housing, but no serious person is contesting we have access to a vast quantity of high-quality consumer goods for peanuts.
- ARandomerDude 2y agohttps://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/analogy https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/analogy
- bbor 2y agoI’ll contest that! By what metric do we have access to a vast quantity of high quality consumer goods? Medicine, housing, and food are some consumer goods that many Americans have trouble affording. Plus, the number of Americans with replicators is 0; we’re an extremely, extremely underdeveloped nation in that regard, and have lots of room to move up. No, I wouldn’t rather live in China/russia/medieval Europe/on a desert island/whatever, to cut off any confusion there. I’m just saying “we’re rich comparatively” isn’t very useful in this case
- llamaimperative 2y ago"We're rich compared to [real things]" is much, much more useful than "we're poor compared to [sci fi novels]"
- bbor 2y agoThis would be true if we hadn't been living in a sci-fi novel for the past few decades/centuries... I think looking forward is a critical step at this inflection point in our path.
- its_ethan 2y agoRich is always, by definition, a relative/comparative term. As evident by you making _comparative_ statements about what Americans have to.. fictional machines from star trek? Saying comparative statements about wealth aren't useful is... even less useful? What are we supposed to do, gauge things by an absolute scale? That becomes useless pretty quickly unless it's updated to be _relative_ to some new standard (aka being comparative). So the metric by which Americans have an improved "access to vast quantity of high quality consumer goods" would be, from the article, the fact that Americans have had their purchasing power increase by 3% relative to other nations, which saw purchasing power of their citizens decrease. Things like housing and medicine are generally going to be expensive at any point in time (due to supply/demand and cost of development, respectively) but the increase in purchasing power outlined in the article is a pretty good (not perfect) proxy for Americans ability to acquire consumer goods.
- llamaimperative 2y agoAre you accusing someone (who?) of falsifying data? Where/when/why/who/how? It's not like the indicators are in some confusing disagreement. Everything points toward the economy being ridiculously hot. Of course there's one glaring exception: the people's vibes. Of course, vibes are highly malleable by media, culture, and internet commentators ambiguously gesturing toward the a gargantuan fraud with tens of thousands of individuals quietly acting in concert.
- its_ethan 2y agoYea I really like the quote the OP references, but it's not clear to me who is playing the role of the "ministry of plenty"? The author? The fed? And what stats referenced in the article are they accusing of having been retroactively revised (aside from the common minor adjustments that trail headline news by ~1month, which would already be included in the stats this article references).
- baybal2 2y ago[dead]
- mywittyname 2y agoIt's great that the US Economy is performing so much better than the rest of the world, but what good is that if people don't feel like it's going well? > The most recent report found that, from 2019 to 2022, the net worth of the median household increased by 37 percent, from about $141,000 to $192,000, adjusted for inflation. > An important caveat to the wealth statistics is that much of the recent increase came from the surge in home prices. These are two sides to the same coin. Rising home values are a zero-sum game. It makes people look wealthier on paper, but there's nothing good that comes from gains in housing prices.
- TMWNN 2y ago> It's great that the US Economy is performing so much better than the rest of the world, but what good is that if people don't feel like it's going well? "The thing I have noticed is when the anecdotes and the data disagree, the anecdotes are usually right. There's something wrong with the way you are measuring it". —[Jeff Bezos](https://sports.yahoo.com/amazon-ceo-jeff-bezos-explains-212315127.html https://sports.yahoo.com/amazon-ceo-jeff-bezos-explains-2123...)
- isk517 2y agoYeah, but think about how much money you'll have when you finally sell your house and live as a woods hermit.
- chasd00 2y agoI think the standard approach is you sell your house after raising a family and retiring because you don't need the additional space but a young couple starting a family does. Then you and you partner buy/rent a small condo on the beach and enjoy retirement.
- mtalantikite 2y agoAll the older people I know still have the same homes they had when their kids left home 20 years ago. Some of them have the retirement home near a beach, but it's in addition to the one they raised their kids in.
- nebula8804 2y agoI can't wait to see how all of this will come crashing down. I am old enough to understand that it will be some unique way that no one will see coming. Then there will be a few knuckleheads claiming they saw it all along after the fact.
- lazide 2y agoThat’s why it’s so useful to predict every possible type of implosion, so inevitably you’ll eventually be right. A broken clock with 12 hands is right 24 times a day.
- its_ethan 2y agoThere's a fun quote about predicting recessions, something to the effect of: "he's so good at predicting market implosions, he's gotten it right 7 of the last 2 times."
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- onlyrealcuzzo 2y agoThe way most bubbles end is that a decent amount of people say "this trend can't go on forever" while everyone else screams "LALALALA heard that before but the trend is still going, hope you like being poor". No one knows EXACTLY when the trend will end - which you generally need to get right to make a lot of money. But most people with a brain know an unsustainable trend will not last forever.
- jcfrei 2y agoCould one point explain the other? A basically frozen real estate market prevented a lot of people from buying real estate - as a result they spent more money on consumer goods, which boosted salaries of low-income groups? If that's the case then once the real estate market unfreezes and people spend more on their homes rather than consumption we'll see the economy tipping over? Both because house prices stagnate (or even sink), thus making existing home owners feel less rich and because new home owners have less money to spend (because their money is going to the new mortgage).
- xnx 2y agoPerception is reality. It seems that changing the direction of a trillion dollar economy ended up being easier than peoples feelings about it. "Truthiness" is an appropriate word here. The rapid step-change in the price of goods (robbery!) is overpowering the less visible gains in wages (hard-earned by the sweat of my brow!).
- hamster77 2y agoMaybe what people feel is more real / closer to practical reality than the numbers the elites point to argue otherwise?
- xnx 2y agoYes. Feeling is believing, but I don't know how policy makers should handle it when so much of how people feel is dependent on if their "team" is in the White House: https://news.clas.ufl.edu/partisan-politics-and-consumer-sentiments/ https://news.clas.ufl.edu/partisan-politics-and-consumer-sen...
- tivert 2y ago> Maybe what people feel is more real / closer to practical reality than the numbers the elites point to argue otherwise? Bingo. People who argue the economy is doing well based on some coarse high-level numbers are missing a lot, because the numbers are coarse and high-level. The most charitable interpretation is they're confusing the map for the territory.
- 2y ago
- frank_bb 2y ago[dead]
- the_real_cher 2y agoIts frustrating to get incomplete propaganda pieces from news outlets. * alot of media and govt sources are reporting the US has a k shaped economy. The people who are doing well are doing really well. The people who aren't doing well are doing really bad, and there's a lot of people who aren't doing well. * The reason immigrants account for so much post-pandemic growth is because immigrants appear to be replacing native born people in job growth. Lower paid immigrants taking jobs is ultimately an assault on the working class yet the left spins it like it's a good thing. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1oPUl https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1oPUl * Gov't spending is out of control and THE INTEREST on our National Debt just surpassed military spending. Which means the fed will have to print money or issue treasury bonds to cover the U.S. massive defecit every year, which will increase inflation continuously. Lessons to be learned: 1. Inflation is never going down 2. House prices are never going down 3. There is not a healthy job market if you are a native born citizen as there's a war on wages 4. Historically massive inflation has led to war
- MangoCoffee 2y agoMaybe because even cheap items like fast food are going up. The economy is great if you can afford the inflated prices on everyday needs
- kvonhorn 2y ago> fast food > everyday needs The cost of a lot of things, dining out in particular, were kept in check for decades because wages for labor were suppressed. The true costs of "everyday needs" were borne by labor to the benefit of the consumer (and arguably, the business owner). Now that we can't cheaply exploit labor post pandemic, costs for the consumer are going up. The rising incomes at the bottom rungs of the economic ladder, alongside rapidly (and long-running) spiking costs of real estate, are squeezing consumers as they buy groceries, gas, and yes, fast food. Putting the brakes on the costs of those is probably going to look like squeezing wages on low income workers once more.
- dgfitz 2y agoThis logic is flawed. Among other things, wages for fast food workers in California went from > 0 to 0 when they all were laid off. I imagine you make a lot of money.
- krunck 2y ago"Let’s start with economists’ favorite metric: growth." I stopped reading there. Unending growth on a finite body is called cancer. The world needs less growth.
- causi 2y agoAw shit. This is the kind of headline you see right before everything goes to hell.
- dgfitz 2y agoThe US is stumbling towards an election and everything will be held together with bubble gum and string until then. I can’t fathom why either party candidate wants to be in that position. It’s going to be a fucking disaster of global proportions when the gum dries up.
- karaterobot 2y agoAs always, be careful if you catch yourself being more skeptical about things you disagree with than things you agree with already.
- marcusverus 2y ago> From the end of 2019 to the end of 2023, U.S. GDP grew by 8.2 percent... This is a masterclass in deception. Here's the actual, plain English translation: "U.S. GDP growth averaged 2.05% during the four year period beginning in 2020." But 2% GDP growth per year is subpar, and we're trying to make it sound great! Well, folks are familiar with annual GDP stats, so giving them annualized stats makes comparison easy. To prevent this easy comparison, we won't annualize it! Instead we'll say: "U.S. GDP grew by 8.2% during the four year period beginning in 2020." But there's still a problem! 8/2 makes for easy mental math. The reader can still easily realize that we're talking about a paltry 2% growth. How do we handle this? Easy! More obfuscation! "From the end of 2019 to the end of 2023, U.S. GDP grew by 8.2 percent." Now the readers is two operations away from being able to compare the data! The greatest trick of all, of course, is that this odd formulation invites misinterpretation. Since we almost always talk about GDP growth in annualized terms, this sentence can easily be misread as saying "U.S. GDP grew at a rate of 8.2 percent from 2019-2023". In my opinion, this misinterpretation is practically demanded by context, as the actual (2%) figure does not fit into the glowing narrative at all.
- ARandomerDude 2y agoThat's because this isn't really an article about the economy – it's a Biden campaign message. Trump's message will be "you may not like me personally but the economy was better when I was president." The shills in the corporate media are already trying to offer a rebuttal.
- mindslight 2y agoI don't disagree but I still cannot fathom why the Democratic party is so ham fisted with their arguments. So much of the price inflation we experienced over the past four years is due to monetary inflation that was created under Trump. The ongoing income tax increases were baked into law by the Trump administration in 2017. The Republican party's strategy has basically become to wreck things, fiscally and socially, and then blame the Democrats when the delayed results become apparent. Personally I'm a libertarian who doesn't buy into the dogma of either duopoly party, but I'm voting conservative (which means Democrat these days) until the Trumpism death spiral has finished running its course.
- bparsons 2y agoThis article is a great example of how macroeconomic indicators are a poor measure of overall economic health. The real question is who is actually served by an economy like this. The basic bargain at the heart of the United States means that you put up with bad urban planning, public infrastructure and a criminal healthcare system in exchange for getting to drive a huge vehicle, cheap food and consumer goods and a detached home with a big yard. Now you get all the bad stuff, plus expensive food, unaffordable transportation options and a bidding war with Blackrock for your starter home in the midwest. But hey, the stock market is up!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- from-nibly 2y agoThis feels Orwellian.