10 ms·
Why are debut novels failing to launch?
- jonahbenton 2y agoMy long retired parents met and worked in publishing. The continued deterioration of the industry is a source of deep sadness for them. I personally however recently found my own ray of hope. By chance I started reading something I really liked, found it was published by a tiny house that has a subscription plan- which is different from an aggregator having a book of the month kind of thing- and publishes super niche unique voices, mostly translations into English. Have read 6 of their books this year, every single one has been just great. Think the breakdown of the big house and homogeneity of the star model leaves space for new shoots to find their audience.
- rudyfink 2y agoWhat you said reminded me of this Royal Road (https://www.royalroad.com/home https://www.royalroad.com/home) website I came across. It is not physical publishing (at least I don't think so), but it is a large collection of different authors who release books / work incrementally. The work mainly seems to be fiction of different varieties.
- davisp 2y agoRoyal Road is a place for a lot of folks to get audiences seeded before they inevitably move on to some combination of Patreon, Amazon Kindle Unlimited, and Audible. One very notable example of this is Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman. He's even just announced that he managed to sell publishing only rights to Ace for large scale distribution which to my knowledge is a first (from authors that started on Royal Road). https://x.com/mattdinniman/status/1780998536529883622 https://x.com/mattdinniman/status/1780998536529883622 Also, I'd highly recommend reading Dungeon Crawler Carl if you enjoy anything close to Douglas Adams-esque comedic sci-fi. Its definitely trends a lot more "adult" than Douglas Adams, but that's about as close as I can think of off the top of my head for comparison. And I'd very much recommend the Audible versions narrated by Jeff Hayes for anyone that does audio books. The Sound Booth Theater production is also good but I'd only recommend that if you're doing a re-listen.
- murphyslab 2y agoThe Dungeon Crawler Carl series' first 4 or 5 books (it's been a little while) were excellent. Carl's tone reminds me of a detective novel, while the setting is more reminiscent of Ready Player One and The Matrix. The genre is a LitRPG novel (admittedly a genre I'd never known existed until reading DCC), heavily doused with comedic elements. Lots of mature themes and references to sex, drugs, politics, and violence, but with some of the allegorical or illustrative critique (to the point of absurdity) you'd find with Douglas Adams or Terry Pratchett when discussing serious topics with parallels to real life, in an imagined scifi/fantasy setting. I'd recommend the series if for those who haven't picked up a book in a while and who would appreciate those elements.
- o11c 2y agoRoyalRoad has at least 3 major problems: * there's a significant conflict between "this is a place to read stories" and "this is just a place to advertise for Amazon" * the effective site rules are unwritten and quite arbitrary (one unwritten rule: you are not allowed to say anything positive about real-ish religions, only negative things) * way too much pedophilia, including in site-promoted stories. Unlike religion, it's clearly not something they put effort into removing.
- Narishma 2y agoAnother problem is the ratings. Everything there seems way overrated. You'll see a ton of 5-star or 4-star ratings for things that are barely readable.
- dageshi 2y agoWhen you've spent many a year reading machine translated chinese xianxia then indeed many stories on RR are 4/5 star worthy in comparison. Royalroad is not a place you go to find objectively good stories, it's the place you go to enjoy your particular blend of delicious trash because in the end you'd rather read chapter 1600 of the long running braindead litrpg than you would whatever just won the hugo's.
- lenkite 2y agoWasn't the case before, but RR allows banning readers from rating author stories. So, usually authors have become smarter and immediately ban readers whose review history looks critical. You cannot rate a story from which you have been banned. Of-course readers have also gotten smarter, many now leaving 0.5 stars for all new stories. If they are banned later, you can still adjust your rating. So now many new stories get a surge of 0.5 ratings.
- api 2y agoEww that’s not just a problem. The last two tell me something about the community. Hard pass.
- carabiner 2y agoNaturally, you mustn't mention the name in order to keep it exclusive.
- jonahbenton 2y agoThe publisher is And Other Stories, UK based. Not a pitch. Just my experience.
- handfuloflight 2y ago[dead]
- satvikpendem 2y agoWhat are the names of these books?
- jonahbenton 2y agoMammoth, Inland, Down The Rabbit Hole, Open Door, Zbinden's Progress, The Luminous Novel, I Don't Expect Anyone To Believe Me. Actually that is 7. All very different, but arresting. Purity, All Dogs Are Blue, and Lightning Rods are next up for me, not sure which one will grab me, probably Purity.
- lachaux 2y agoI am very glad that you find your own ray of hope. I understand the sadness that you parents feel. I know some people in publishing. The industry was in an mode of existential crisis when Amazon Publishing was launched. It then went through social media, Goodreads, etc. It seems the industry survives, although the future is still murky. The industry indeed needs J. K. Rowling, Sally Rooney, Colleen Hoover, celebrity biographies & memoirs etc. to survive. Good books will find their way to be published, and get discovered, maybe dozens of years later. I happened to read a novel by an English author published ~100 years ago. It is a good book, IMO. The publishing house had only one person. The entire office was one room in his apartment.
- boznz 2y agoSpent several years writing and editing my first book before thinking the job was finished when I hit the publish now button. But it is literally only half the job done. The hell now is unless you get friends and family or an agency involved to push it and market it it will languish on the 500th page of any Amazon search forever. Oh and did I say that there are thousands of books a day released and there is nowhere you can self-promote stuff if you do not have social media, HN and reddit will also immediately block self-promotion even if relevant to the audience (I guess I can understand why). I guess the only ones destined to read it are the AI training algorithms. Still it wont stop me writing, having a book published, even if nobody reads it is very self-satisfying and leaves something of you in this world when you are gone.
- pavlov 2y agoTen years ago I wrote a science fiction novel in Finnish, printed 300 hardcover copies at my own expense, and gave them away to people over the years. I would guess less than 10% of those copies have actually been read. (A few people claim they liked it, but of course that doesn't necessarily mean they read it.) So, a waste of time and money? That's not how I feel about it at all. The creative process was illuminating. And as you say, it's satisfying to think that there's now a physical artifact of my mind that's longer and deeper than any other work I've produced, and it will probably stay for a while on somebody's bookshelf after I'm gone.
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoExactly. Don't expect anyone to read what you wrote, much less commercial success, unless you were a Harvard undergrad English prodigy who joined Penguin publishing, or somehow wiggled into the circle of [City] Review of [Each Others'] Books. It's a one-way, time-traveling message in a bottle comprised of dead trees. Doing it for art is a wolf's howl that it lived and that it could. Although, it's gradually shifted into over-reliance on the linkrot of spinning rust, floating electrons, and burning transistors such that used and new bookstores and libraries are endangered species. Perhaps another cycle similar to the early medieval period maybe gradually happening as today's "Romes" decline in slow-motion, accelerated by climate change decline unless and until we save ourselves through economic and ecological limits.
- pfdietz 2y agoBecause there are way too many books being written.
- surfingdino 2y ago"Everyone has a book inside them, which is exactly where it should, I think, in most cases, remain." -- Christopher Hitchens
- _yb2s 2y agoI find that to be an awful attitude... self-absorbed people with nothing interesting to write about will assume it doesn't apply to them because they are so interesting, and people not so sure of themselves but having an actual unusual idea or story they are passionate about, could easily be discouraged from sharing something valuable. I say, if you have something to say that fits well in a book, write it. Let other people decide if it is worth reading or not. A lot of the best books ever written were kept private, or were not well received at first.
- pfdietz 2y agoI encourage you to read some random self-published e-books on Amazon.
- CuriouslyC 2y agoI encourage you to read some random publisher published books, that have been on the top of best seller lists. 50 shades of hot garbage comes to mind.
- surfingdino 2y ago50 Shades of Grey is smut with a stamp of approval of a large publisher. They allow it once in a while as a way to monetise human sexuality otherwise repressed and controlled by various powers.
- 2y ago
- japhib 2y agoSeems like almost every creative industry (music, video games, art, writing) is having the same issue: Creation & publication tools are getting cheaper & easier to use, which means a lot more people can publish their creative ideas. With such a huge number of choices, discovery is now the issue. IMO discovery of what is truly high quality is still an unsolved problem. Seems like recommendation systems generally just recommend things that are already popular. For someone that has zero following, but an interesting creative product, there's not much they can do. You're kind of relying on either "going viral" or hoping that someone with a lot of followers takes notice of your work and draws other people in.
- namaria 2y agoTime is a great filter. That's why it's commonplace to complain about 'art these days' and to be nostalgic about past books and music. Some of the greatest, most interesting books I've ever read are thousands of years old.
- rixed 2y agoYou can't know wether time is a good filter without assessing the value of what's been lost forever, can you?
- namaria 2y agoI can't know precisely how good of a filter it is but I'm not interested in finding out a definite figure. I have read enough great stuff from picking up a book from 300 BCE or so and I've seen enough BS ghost written flavor of the month non-fiction to know it's good enough heuristics to suggest it in this forum.
- samatman 2y agoA filter can be good in a couple of ways: it can filter out ~all of what you don't want, and/or ~none of what you do want. Time is a good filter in the first way, which makes it a good filter. Because a filter which doesn't substantially do the first of these things isn't actually filtering: the null filter filters none of what you do want, by failing to reduce the data stream in any way.
- surfingdino 2y agoThe market is dominated by large publishers. They do not need to compete, they have already won. At the same time, they don't want to loose the marketshare, which makes them less likely to bet on an unknown author.
- _tom_ 2y agoThe market is dominated by ebooks. Trad publishing gets a few home runs, but overall can't compete with the sheer volume of new independent books that come out each year.
- richardatlarge 2y agoSupporting evidence?
- surfingdino 2y agoTrad publishers + a savvy agent will make the author rich. A successful ebook will make Amazon rich.
- johnea 2y agoEven though I still retain an entire bookcase of novels (mostly sci fi) from my youth, I now find fiction to be, well... boring. Personally I'd rather read about something that actually exists...
- pfdietz 2y agoHow do you feel about history?
- thfuran 2y agoThere's hardly anything new there.
- optimalsolver 2y agoYogi Berra? I thought you were dead.
- pfdietz 2y agoNo one reads history anymore, it's too popular.
- coliveira 2y agoThe thing about modern publishing is that it is too much driven by genre, so if you read a few dozen novels of a particular genre there are no surprises left. I am similarly unimpressed by new books, so I either read old ones or just don't.
- WalterBright 2y agoI know what you mean. I have turned to reading history books, that are far more interesting stories.
- all2 2y agoHello, my friend. I enjoyed 1491, and I've been working my way through The Secret Life of Real Estate and Banking which is an economic analysis of the boom/bust cycle as it exists in modern fiat/debt based economies. Both are very different, but also very engaging and interesting.
- medion 2y agoPublishers only want to publish authors with large social followings. The first question they ask is a list of your socials.
- vundercind 2y ago… and lots of those are kinda bad. But it sells almost as well as a decent book, and you don’t have to spend as much promoting it, so it’s still what they want.
- bitmasher9 2y agoYou’re a social influencer with a non-fiction book out? Let me just watch your clips for 15 minutes and you’ll deliver all of the information in your three hundred page book. There’s no substance in most of them.
- _tom_ 2y agoBut, boy are they fast to write!
- Ekaros 2y agoI would argue that those works are at least decent or at least on some level competent. They might not have too much some vague artistic merit. But they are unlikely be completely unacceptable. Like no major consistent spelling or typographical issues, mostly coherent and consistent plot and so on. We rarely see or interact with truly below mediocre medium. Or filter it very quickly. Looking for example at Steam and your nth asset flip with poor 3d graphics and so on.
- richardatlarge 2y agoFalse: never had any publisher ask my agent about this, although no doubt it can be a factor if you have a huge following
- medion 2y ago
- SamoyedFurFluff 2y agoThere is a great podcast called the publishing rodeo where they talk about this. One of their episodes covered a minimum viable threshold where if there isn’t enough marketing points (a viral tweet, a lot of followers, marketing money, etc) there is no way for a book to succeed regardless of quality.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoThis is why Amazon can’t supplant bookstores because they, and publishers, act as curators for the deluge of creative works out there. (Not saying they are always right in their choices and certainly good stuff gets written that is never submitted to a publisher, but I would rather browse the shelves of my local bookstore—especially an independent one run by someone who cares very much about literature (as booksellers do as they’re otherwise not in that difficult business), than scroll through Amazon.
- Slava_Propanei 2y ago[dead]
- AlbertCory 2y agoI used the public library to get a lot of books that I'd never want to waste my money on. You can call it "market research." Verdict: there just isn't a market for serious fiction like there was 70 years ago, say. J.D. Salinger considered himself a failure until he finally got a story in The New Yorker. How many writers dream of that nowadays? Then there's Esquire, of course : https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/376430.Esquire_s_Big_Book_of_Fiction https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/376430.Esquire_s_Big_Boo... The urges that led people to read fiction then are now directed to TV, movies, and serials. We could decry it, but that's how it is.
- api 2y agoMy impression is that a good novel today being turned into a series or screenplay is what huge scale novel success used to be. Huge scale success with just a book is very rare, though there are some writers who find a niche audience. The thing I decry is the worthless idle attention suck of “social” media. That competes with all forms of quality art and content. Instead of watching good movies or listening to music or reading a book people are scrolling TikTok, Xhitter, Instagram, etc.
- AlbertCory 2y agoYep. Reading "the current thing some imbecile said" instead of "the best that has been thought and said."
- BarryMilo 2y agoI'm currently starting a publishing company in a niche Canadian market. What people in these comments (and really, most places on the internet) fail to grasp is the role of the publisher as a curator and editor. Unlike your friends, the editor is not your friend. They don't have a stake in your ego, they won't sugarcoat it beyond the veneer of professionalism. You need an editor who is not your friend, too say no to you. No, you shouldn't start your book with this cliché. No, you shouldn't have your character meandering aimlessly. No, you shouldn't use whedonisms. Exceptions apply, of course, but when the editor is your publisher and not your friend, "shouldn't" becomes "can't". Usually that involves saying no to 99% of manuscripts coming through the door. And this is how an okay story becomes a great book. Your editor, having read more books than you in their segment, knows the difference... usually. All manuscripts are at least a little bit bad, some books aren't. As you can tell, I'm no fan of self-publishing, I just don't believe anyone can be objective enough with their own baby. Now... I've read my fair share of bad books, especially recently. The publisher/editor is to blame 95% of the time. My theory is that being rigorous takes time, which is always in short supply, and skill. I believe people tend not to stay in the same role for too long anymore, lest they lose out financially. Which is totally fair, but skill (and the chutzpah to say "no") takes a while to develop, years really. And no one has "years" for anything. Except, of course, all the people in the industry who don't mind being poor. And people making bank, I suppose, but these are so few as to be statistically insignificant.
- lachaux 2y ago> Unlike your friends, the editor is not your friend. It is true. I would like to qualify it by saying "At the beginning, the editor is not your friend." A friendship, even very strong one, can be developed along the time, based on mutual respect and appreciation, temperament match, etc. Even then, a good editor will still be professional and be honest when they edit the writer's draft. A good book may not be a "successful" book, especially in literary fiction, since the post talks about novels. The reverse can be true as well. It happens often that the editor tells the author it is a good book, and the publisher allocates resources to marketing it, schedules book tours, etc. while at the same time both the writer's agent and the editor/publisher expect the book may sell only ~2,000 copies. The target audience are expected to be other writers, a subset of avid literature readers, etc. They don't expect it will earn back the advance paid to the author. The publishers have portfolios and long term visions. Of course, this doesn't apply to small publishers, most of which cannot afford it.
- bane 2y agoMany many years ago a friend did a stint at a major publishing house. Whenever she'd show up to parties she would bring in a small stack of unpublished manuscripts, we'd all get into the wine or beer or whatever and start reading particularly terrible passages to each other. Had she sought out especially bad manuscripts? No! She just grabbed whatever was on the "will read, maybe, someday" shelf in the editor's work area. I learned about Sturgeon's Law (90% of everything is crap) during these events. Most people think what they've written is interesting, or unique, or worth publishing. However, publishers have to make money, so they curate very carefully, edit the hell out of the raw manuscripts, and then only actually commit to publishing what they think there's a market for. Nearly zero of the random manuscripts that are sent in by unknown authors ever make it into this funnel, and the honest reason why, at least from what I have personally read, was because most of it was completely terrible -- in as many ways as you can think of terrible to be. Three other thoughts: 1. The great videogame crash of '83 happened because the dominant platforms at the time did not have a lockdown on curation, so anybody and everybody flooded the market with garbage. Consumers decided it was better to not buy anything than to chance spending the equivalent of nearly $200 in 2024 money and get trash. 2. A few breakout, self-published, authors are making it through the piles of junk, but they are few and far between. Andy Weir (the Martian) and Hugh Howey (Silo) come to mind. The "secondary" film and TV markets are so starved for good new ideas that their works are getting converted into non-print media almost as fast as they can get sets built and costumes sewed. 3. There's probably a new market for solid, well known, curators. People who make money sifting the dreck to find the Weirs and Howeys and surfacing the cream to the top. The creators are self-publishing, and the publishing houses aren't doing well these days. But the curation function is still wildly important and finding the right way to do it, and the business model around it, is perhaps the future.
- WalterBright 2y ago> The "secondary" film and TV markets are so starved for good new ideas There's a long list of very good scifi that has never been made into a movie. Instead, we get the Mandalorean which rehashes every spaghetti western trope. The character even sounds like Clint Eastwood. It has the hero breaking in the horse while the old ranch hand leans on the corral fence, for example. And training the village to defend itself from the bandits. And so on.
- motohagiography 2y agoWrite something someone wants. Literary fiction was art that discovered and expressed the essential, where cultural production today explicitly militates against anything that could be percived as essential(-ist). New novels are failing because the culture has no eros. Readers have become too socially poor to risk investing in ideas that could compromise their cultivated homogeny, and it's just too hard to care with any sincerity what someone brand safe for public radio writes about. I guess I'm saying novels would sell better if the people selling and publishing them produced something people actually wanted instead of churning out what they are being told by their granting agencies is good for their readers.
- adamc 2y agoThere are lots and lots of well-written, relatively obscure books. I don't think that has much to do with being "brand safe". It has to do with discoverability, network effects (people are more motivated to read books people they know have liked), and the vast number of books.
- stubish 2y agoI'd wager most books are content someone wants. A lot are even content a lot of people want. This is not good enough. Reaching the audience is the problem. Also, writing a book can take years. Writing for what people want today is how you fail, as people will have moved on in the five years it took to write, edit, sell and produce the work. If you can reliably predict market desires in 5 years time, you have a lot more than a best selling novel on your hands.
- Animats 2y agoBecause Barnes and Noble has 14 checkout shelf positions devoted to Taylor Swift magazines. James Patterson (Enterprises) has about a quarter of the new novel space, and Tom Clancy (RIP) has maybe a tenth. It's all about the brand.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> James Patterson (Enterprises) has about a quarter of the new novel space, and Tom Clancy (RIP) has maybe a tenth. It's all about the brand. There's an obvious reason for that: far and away the primary determinant - often the sole determinant - of whether you will like a novel, is the author.
- nottorp 2y agoThat's sad, because once an author achieves some notoriety, they are basically stuck into writing the same thing for the rest of their career, for fear that they will lose their existing audience.
- thaumasiotes 2y agoNot at all. Like I said, the determinant of whether you will like the book is the author. If they write something radically different from their previous work, and you liked their previous work, the odds are very high that you'll like the new book too.
- nottorp 2y agoAs a reader, but how about as a publisher, will you take the risk? :)
- richk449 2y agoIs that why John Irving keeps writing about bears and high school wrestling?
- barbariangrunge 2y agoDiscoverability sucks, for almost everyone, but especially for new authors. And that was before ai started flooding out “content.” Even if you get a publisher, great authors sometimes sell only a handful of copies. You find amazing books on goodreads by award winning authors with only 5 reviews. And that’s people who can get their novels manuscript even looked at by an editor. Lots of self published authors end up with 0-1 reviews How do you stand out in that swamp?
- HDThoreaun 2y agoThis is why you see these massive advances for known names. The only thing publishers seem to know is that authors who create their own publicity sell copies, and those that dont have an audience dont.
- inanutshellus 2y ago"Step one: hype the human, step two: publish their books" reminds me of being a senior in college and seeing and despairing at job postings saying "MUST have 5 years experience in [tech that came out 9 months ago]"
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoThe problem is that book publishing hasn't really been disrupted for a very long time. Amazon just switched it to selling online, but think about how much more you can engage with a book that you just read. Somehow no apps or ereaders allow for anything beyond reading the book text.
- dageshi 2y agoIt is being quietly disrupted, just probably not in the way people want. Webnovels on sites like royalroad.com monetised via patreon and then published on Kindle Unlimited & Audible offer a different publishing model to that of traditional books and one that works really well for the right genres. The audience that reads them is reading purely for entertainment, has vastly lower standards and is willing to directly support their favourite authors to the point where the most successful authors who started 5 years or so ago are now millionaires. But this is mostly an anathema to the traditional publishing industry and for the most part they're pretending it doesn't exist because they literally cannot compete with it in the niches it now dominates.
- ngcc_hk 2y agoWhilst reality bite and all said is the truth, there are odds. How about on a lady with kids on social welfare and had no name tried to publish a book about young witch growing up in a boarding school. And tbh I do not recommend her book for young kids, as it is very dark. Anyway, as said in another epic, there is always hope.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- metabagel 2y agoI hope that AI improves discoverability. It would be great if an AI agent can give me a list of books which I am likely to enjoy, based on the books I have enjoyed in the past. Even better if some of those picks are obscure.
- gfourfour 2y agoI think this is a really underexplored use case for LLMs. LLM embeddings are really good at encoding rich semantic information that’s easy to query and hack around with in a variety of ways. Retrieving primary sources that correspond to one or many thematic dimensions is one such case for embeddings, but most applications that do this portray it as a driver of RAG chatbots, when it could be an end in and of itself. I have an app that does your book recommending idea but with Wikipedia articles. I am trying to release it soon, once I get past my perfectionism, if anyone is interested. Expanding to non Wikipedia sources is an eventual goal. I basically never want to read chatbot output for pleasure. I want to read primary sources.
- nottorp 2y agoOn one hand, that's a good idea. On the other hand, do you really want to get stuck in a bubble and only read the same thing that you've read before and nothing new? If it's bad when Facebook does it, it's bad with book recommendations too if you ask me. And on the gripping hand...
- RivieraKid 2y agoThe total supply of good books and good content in general increases every year but the amount of time people spend consuming content is roughly constant. New books are not just competing with all of the books that were written in the past, e.g. East of Eden, but also YouTube, podcasts, movies, computer and mobile game - and the total supply of those increases every year.
- wslh 2y agoI think the answer is very short: marketing beats quality. We are paying too much attention to the content itself but the root cause is the distribution. It is the same with startups. This is already studied at nauseaum in search economics, long tails, the medium is the message, etc.
- _tom_ 2y agoWow, what a clueless article. Or maybe a deliberately biased article. The majority of sales and debut authors are ebooks, and traditional publishers aren't involved. This has been true for years. Read publishing is pretty much pointless if you aren't a celebrity. Yes, there are a few that make it, but a handful, compared to the numbers that make something significant self publishing. And the trad publishing process is so slow. You can write and market several books in the time is takes to get one book to reads the old way. If you aren't a celebrity, self publishing is the way to go. Not that publishing an ebook is easy, but the process of much more controllable by you. And the payback is much higher.
- richardatlarge 2y agoBut nothing here solves the problem of going from zero audience to some meaningful audience in a content saturated environment with a low attention span
- yxhuvud 2y agoHow can someone write an article on that theme without ever mentioning self-publishing? It may not be super big in mainstream books yet, but it is getting pretty common for genre literature to first publish and build an audience on something like RoyalRoad, then self-publish, and then get picked up by something bigger. And it also ties very much into some of the themes of the article to cooperate and do shout-outs to other authors, as that is super common in those circles.
- api 2y agoThere’s a pretty huge overproduction problem in the arts, literature, and music, and it’s being made worse by spam and hustle culture shit at least in the short term. All the spam and hustlecrap is ironically making good works more special but at the same time harder to find. I’d say first and foremost: don’t make art unless it’s burning a hole in your head and it must be made. That helps solve the overproduction problem. As for the spam and junk problem that’s a discovery issue. I’ve actually gotten back into reading lately. Good new stuff is as hard to find as it is to get it found. Of course like most readers I have a backlog… hence the overproduction problem.
- langsoul-com 2y agoReminds me of Diddy Squat, the farming show by Jeremy Clarkson. Farming, just by itself, is not profitable, so they need to do all kinds of things to make profit. Likr setting up a store, making a branded product, Ie making beer from the wheat, or social media on farm life. The tragedy is all the time required not farming. In the case of books, to first debut, you must already be successful or perish. Even getting accepted to a publishing house requires insane stats, and they're just beginning.
- ghaff 2y agoAnd it helps to know people. The one time I went through a publisher it was pretty much by accident because I had dinner with the appropriate acquisitions person and the managing director and then we ironed out details when I was in London a couple months later. I was intending to write the book anyway but wasn't planning on going through a publisher. Didn't make any material money but it was very useful professionally.
- mikemitchelldev 2y agoA debut novel that's not published is not necessarily a wasted effort. It can be adapted into a screenplay, which can be submitted to a variety of outlets, and the novel might be published later if successful.
- naveen99 2y agoLooks like I found a debut hn comment.
- mikemitchelldev 2y ago[flagged]
- naveen99 2y agoGreen account. Hacker news comment history is the new novel.
- richardatlarge 2y agoAlmost never happens; legal issues keep unsolicited screenplay submissions to zero
- mikemitchelldev 2y agoI meant that the person who wrote the novel can turn it into a screenplay
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoI assume I read far more than the average person (though possibly just average for HN) but I see clickbait headlines like "10 Best New Hard Sci-Fi Novels Released This Month" that just make me feel anxious as a reader that there's more content out there than I can possibly comprehend. Must feel even worse as a writer.
- intuitionist 2y agoOne thing that saddens me about the perceived necessity of new authors going on Twitter, BookTok, etc. to “build an audience” is that it seems to prevent anyone who wants to separate their literary life from their private life from ever again being supported by a publisher. Many authors over the years have felt the need to do this, for personal or professional reasons: J.D. Salinger, Thomas Pynchon, James Tiptree Jr., John le Carré, Joe Klein, Isabel Fall. I doubt that all those authors will be considered part of the canon in 100 years, and very possibly none of them will be, but I think the world would be poorer if they’d all been unable to become successful writers.
- ghaff 2y agoI don't know. This is sort of arguing that a world in which publishers were gatekeepers/PR agencies/etc. meant that authors could sort of hide behind that front--at the cost of putting their fate in the hands of their publisher. But I'm not sure how widespread/true that ever was. Authors went on book tours and TV shows all the time to promote their writing. I'm not sure how common the pseudonymous/reclusive successful author ever was.
- l72 2y agoI'm not as familiar with the book scene as I am with the music scene, but I see a lot of similarities. Discovery is a huge issue, and takes a lot of effort. I listen to a specific sub-sub genre of metal that gets no mainstream (even from "big" metal publications) attention. The best way I have found to come across new albums is to subscribe to really small labels that specialize in the genre of music. Many of these labels are hobbies or part time jobs for their owners, but I find they do an excellent job curating music I'll be interested in. The problem, is often subscribing and keeping up to date with these labels is really tough. Fortunately, for music, we have bandcamp.com which does a pretty decent job of this (although it takes some additional work [1]). If bandcamp.com went away, I don't know how I'd discover most of my new music. Does the book scene have anything similar? [1] https://blog.line72.net/2021/12/23/converting-bandcamp-email-updates-to-an-rss-feed/ https://blog.line72.net/2021/12/23/converting-bandcamp-email...
- beemanF 2y agoi think that books, movies, music are just becoming noise at this point. they are completely ephemeral. they are basically free, or ar least they would be if the markets were allowed to do what theyre supposed to do without copyright. and now with AI, the effect is only growing stronger. paying for media feels closer and closer to paying for air. it just doesn't make sense. its ephemeral and so abundant that its basically free. i think this might be our new reality. being an artist as a profession might not be a thing for much longer