6 ms·
What the hell, half melted starship actually did the landing flip and hit the ocean slow!!! That was amazing!
by pixl97 2y ago
What the hell, half melted starship actually did the landing flip and hit the ocean slow!!!
That was amazing!
- openmarmot 2y agoyeah that was absolutely incredible to watch. Starships fin was melting away like the terminator robot in the smelting pot but it still did its job. Absolutely excited about the future of humanity and spaceflight!
- bamboozled 2y agosame
- themgt 2y agoThat was seriously some of the most dramatic television I've ever watched. Video of Starship being melted/torn apart by supersonic plasma, the broadcast stream dying multiple times maybe due to ship destruction, then finally back online, peeking through the cracked camera to see the nearly destroyed grid fin STILL ACTUATING. The announcers laughing about the ship being "maybe held together by some nuts and bolts" and then it still pulled off the fucking landing burn! Absolutely wild and historic.
- mavhc 2y agoYou can tell the ship still exists because the telemetry still updates
- kevstev 2y agoI have never rooted for a flap so hard, and likely never will. I am ready to buy flap merch. The energy of the SpaceX employees gave me goosebumps, this was great, it was hard not to get caught up in it- you know this is the culmination of years of hard work that is mostly theoretical until tests like these.
- mrandish 2y agoYes, Flappy McFlapFin for the win on that flight!
- fifilura 2y agoI think the camera deserves a medal too!
- inglor_cz 2y agoLife is really beautifully unpredictable. When I got up today (Central Europe, so several hours ahead of Texas), I never had an idea that a random steel flap is going to be my new superhero in mere hours. Its tenacity in the face of hellfire was epic.
- ericcumbee 2y agohearing the spacex is half the fun. Its fun to hear them cheer. and then hearing the Gasps and "ooooooh"s and wondering what do they know thats happening.
- rtkwe 2y agoReally wish the camera housing had held up to get a complete video of the fin being eaten away. I wonder if any of the other cameras got good footage too because they stayed on the camera with the obliterated lens for a long time which makes me think the others also fair pretty poorly. There wasn't much to see on the fin cam after the housing broke until right at touch down.
- avmich 2y agoI'd really expect SpaceX to have more cameras, and to have some shielding - maybe so that cameras would get open shields at different points in flight, so they'd be protected before that. We only saw left-back flap, I suspect there's a camera looking also on right-back flap, maybe towards the engines section too. SpaceX is known to have rich telemetry, that would be awesome to see.
- rtkwe 2y agoThey had at least 3 (I think 4 but there were 3 visible at once) different camera's on the upper stage I think they also got destroyed though and the melting fin was the most interesting thing they could show so they just stayed with it. As neat as the idea of different shields is that's a whole extra layer of weight and controls for a non critical thing so I'm not surprised it doesn't happen.
- rtkwe 2y agoI might have been thinking of one of the earlier shots that had some of the booster cameras. There's only ever two views of the upper stage.
- cududa 2y agoCan you please explain how exactly you would heat shield a camera? Like, your suggestion is a box attached to the ship that changes its aerodynamic profile, with an actuator that can be a point of failure/ fly off and hit other critical instruments? They have lots of cameras. Were we watching the same video? The thing got absolutely melted and you’re complaining that you didn’t get a front row seat? 5 short years ago we would get a few frames from the camera on the barge where Falcon 9 landed and that seemed incredible. Just because they’ve accomplished something hard (mostly reliable cameras), doesn’t mean it’s suddenly easy and saying “why didn’t you just put more cameras on it?” comes off as mind bendingly pedantic
- zizee 2y agoA friendly fyi just in case it wasn't a slip of the tongue: grid fins are only on the booster.
- ceejayoz 2y agoGrid fins are only intentionally on the booster. This one just became one accidentally.
- codeulike 2y agoHoly crap, you're right, about 1h45m in the video (about T+1hr04m mission time): camera is nearly out but you can see engines relight and flap moving at Starship goes below 1km altitude. It got through re-entry and did a soft-ish landing! edit: From the telemetry at the bottom of the screen you can also see that it righted itself to vertical just before hitting the water https://x.com/SpaceX/status/1798098040588480826 https://x.com/SpaceX/status/1798098040588480826
- datameta 2y agoAbsolutely beautiful! The hypersonic plasma flow was like no footage I've seen!
- bufferoverflow 2y agoTheir older fairing reentry plasma also looked really cool https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ke_QI7_UtA8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ke_QI7_UtA8
- consumer451 2y agoDo we have Navy assets nearby to destroy it, or is it just going to bob around in the Indian ocean? Or will we trigger the abort system now?
- georgeecollins 2y agoGulf of Mexico
- consumer451 2y agoThis branch of the thread is about Starship, which landed intact in the Indian Ocean afaik.
- consumer451 2y agoI just found the area of the India Ocean via a post from Jonathan McDowell: https://bsky.app/profile/planet4589.bsky.social/post/3kub7756hx62l https://bsky.app/profile/planet4589.bsky.social/post/3kub775...
- datameta 2y agoI believe they said they would trigger the abort on splashdown.
- krunck 2y agoI assumed they would try to recover it. So much data could be gathered from the remains.
- mhandley 2y agoThe fact that it managed the flip and landing burn means the fuel tanks (i.e. most of the fuselage) must have suffered no burn-through, despite what happened to the front flap. They've obviously got some redesign needed on the thermal protection around the flap hinges, but broadly, the thermal protection system and aerodynamic control during reentry seem to have worked well enough. It's finally starting to feel like Starship could actually work!
- tocs3 2y agoOne of the NSF commentators commented the fuel for the landing burn comes from the header tanks (little extra tanks for this kind of thing). Still, I would think if one of the closed up sections had a hole that it would cause all sorts of other troubles.
- mhandley 2y agoYes, that is correct - they need the header tanks to make sure that fuel is immediately available, not sloshing around the main tanks as the ship flips. Rockets really don't like sucking in vapour. I'm not sure if they're pressurized separately from the main tanks though - I would assume not, as that would be more complicated, but I could be completely wrong.
- proaralyst 2y agoThe strength of the body of the rocket comes from some level of pressurisation – much like a drinks can. I suspect that if the tank got holed the ship wouldn't have held up during the flip
- proaralyst 2y agoImpressive the flap actuators held up too!
- notact 2y agoCan someone explain why reentry must be so hellish? The energy gained during the rocket burn into orbit must be bled off during reentry, and that energy is enormous. However, why must reentry occur so quickly? It seems if the descent into the atmosphere was slower, the heat shield would be able to radiate the heat energy away more effectively, thus lowering skin temperatures, and significantly reducing the engineering challenge.
- tocs3 2y agoThey use the atmosphere to help slow the ship down. It takes most of the tank of fuel to get up there and moving so fast. It would take most a tank to slow down. So, they would need about double the fuel plus some for landing. P.S. I have not done any of the math (I might be able to figure it out but it might take a week or two to figure it out). P.S.S : Maybe if they could refuel in space efficiently (asteroid mining?) it might be worth looking at but it will be a while before I would expect anything like that. It would just be the ship.
- bagels 2y agoIts more than double.
- baq 2y agoIt's mind-boggingly more than double. The rocket equation takes no prisoners.
- notact 2y agoI understand the atmosphere is used to slow the vehicle - it's basically free brakes that you don't have to carry with you. I never suggested using rockets in reverse to slow the vehicle down. What I am asking is, instead of effectively standing on the breaks and generating enormous amounts of friction in a short period of time, why can't the vehicle ease onto the breaks and spread the friction out over time so it can be more safely dissipated (via a more shallow reentry angle).