9 ms·
EU: Users who refuse scanning to be prevented from sharing photos and links
- seper8 2y agoWont anyone think of the children!!! Absolutely insane orwellian legislation being written by, at best, some of the least introspective forward-thinking EU drones... What the actual fuck.
- rightbyte 2y agoYe it is surrealistic to watch. It seems like all it takes is to point to a credible external threat and sane people are pushed down by 'lurker' insane people in a heartbeat.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rightbyte 2y ago"the chats of employees of security authorities and the military are also to be exempted from chat control" So the two major fields where you really want to snoop their private chats to see if they are up to no good, are excempted?
- usrnm 2y agoI'm astonished that the chats of EU officials and politicians are not exempt. A mistake, no doubt, one which will be corrected shortly
- rightbyte 2y agoThe ones pushing this probably think the secret police and military are firmly on their side.
- belter 2y agoThey are also exempt. We are not dealing with amateurs here... https://european-pirateparty.eu/chatcontrol-eu-ministers-want-to-exempt-themselves/ https://european-pirateparty.eu/chatcontrol-eu-ministers-wan...
- perihelions 2y ago- "As O'Brien passed the telescreen a thought seemed to strike him. He stopped, turned aside and pressed a switch on the wall. There was a sharp snap. The voice had stopped." - "Julia uttered a tiny sound, a sort of squeak of surprise. Even in the midst of his panic, Winston was too much taken aback to be able to hold his tongue." - "'You can turn it off!' he said." - "'Yes,' said O'Brien, 'we can turn it off. We have that privilege.'"
- wdb 2y agoAlways surprised why politicians get exempted from these kind of rules. You would think they would set the good example
- InCityDreams 2y agoAlways NOT surprised why politicians get exempted from these kind of rules. You would think they would set the good example. They're not stupid, and they're NOT example-setters (very few exceptions) - for myself. #never voted, and very proud of it.
- vault 2y agoI'm afraid there's nothing in your behaviour to be proud of
- another2another 2y ago"History is made by those who show up." (Disraeli) is the quote that springs to mind.
- everforward 2y agoThere are both good and bad reasons. The bad is obviously that they’re immune to their own legislation. The good is that it prevents incumbents from using this data as part of their campaign. It would be Watergate all over again. There is also data that probably shouldn’t be public. Locations and status of missile silos, troop locations, etc. In an ideal world, all of that would be on secured channels that are managed by appropriate entities. In the real world, it seems like a struggle to get troops to stop posting selfies with sensitive data on Facebook; I don’t doubt much more exists in private messages. I’m also about 95% sure our politicians (globally) are incapable of managing the OpSec of having 2 devices, one secured and one not, and using them appropriately. They’ll forget one or the other exists.
- r00fus 2y ago"Laws for thee and not for me" is one of the root tenets of totalitarianism.
- crest 2y agoIt's also going to be fun when it comes to communication of medical providers or lawyers. Both groups can be expected to be legally privileged and commonly come into contact with material they're legally required to process that will trigger (false) positives. The whole idea so braindead it can only come from a politician with a voyeurism fetish unburdened by any subject matter expertise.
- WA 2y agoHow is this supposed to work in reality? Do we really want to provide Meta, Apple and Google with a list of phone numbers of accounts of militarly and security personell in order to have their feature-flags for sharing links/photos enabled?
- karma_pharmer 2y agoThe cellular carriers very obviously already have a system like this for location tracking. Their tower dumps contain enough metadata to determine all the people who spend most workdays at office buildings in McLean Virginia. And then, of course, where those people sleep (i.e. charge their phones) at night. It takes positive effort to erase that data, and believe me, it's being erased. The powerful people don't want it to exist. So yeah, there is already a system for doing this kind of thing. It will be extended. Plebs like you and me don't get to use it.
- WA 2y agoThe carrier, for example Vodafone Germany, might have that data. How does that help to enable a feature-flag in US-based Meta's WhatsApp?
- karma_pharmer 2y agofacepalm
- Hizonner 2y agoUnless you have positive evidence, I'm gonna guess that the "powerful people" aren't that organized or that on top of things. But, sure, they'd like to be.
- raxxorraxor 2y ago> The powerful people don't want it to exist. Good on those powerful people then, because this data should not exist.
- mikrotikker 2y ago
- guiraldelli 2y agoI haven't gone in detail on the draft, but what is nuts is that those are exempt, as well as everyone who uses a service not-for-profit. So, if you self-host [1], you don't need to adhere to the legislation. But, wait… Are you telling me that security officials are allowed to use not their self-hosted infrastructure, but use public one to send (I assume, based on their exemption) confidential data? And, as @WA proposed, will be a list of contacts of these officials given to all for-profit organisations? What a stupid joke it is! [1]: See third row at https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/posts/chat-control/#currentproposal https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/posts/chat-control/#current... .
- eru 2y ago> So the two major fields where you really want to snoop their private chats to see if they are up to no good, are excempted? As far as I can tell from the article, the justification for the proposed rules is "won't someone think of the children". Those two major fields you mention might do well with more oversight in general. But I doubt they are especially prone to dealing with children?
- dotancohen 2y agoI'm a software developer. How much interaction do you think that I have with children? And if the discussion is concerned with what one does outside of work, well, presumably those exempted industries also have time outside of work.
- eru 2y agoI don't see your point, sorry? I was merely arguing against this remark: > So the two major fields where you really want to snoop their private chats to see if they are up to no good, are excempted? Those two major fields aren't especially prone to dealing with children. (They probably aren't any less prone than eg software development, sure. But that wasn't the point.)
- dotancohen 2y ago> Those two major fields aren't especially prone to dealing with children. Neither are software developers, so why aren't we exempt?
- afiori 2y agoI think you are missing the point, all fields should be exempt as this law should not exists, but those two fields are not very special terms of how much we should want them not to be exempt. It is not about arguing that only they should be exempt.
- 2y ago
- Scion9066 2y agoCould the platforms the authorities use decide to not exclude them and treat them the same anyways (ie scan them like everyone else's) or are they codifying that that kind of scanning only applies to the common people?
- fitblipper 2y agoThey are claiming that it is privacy preserving, since it uses AI and not humans, and only for catching csam Assuming those claims are true(I know, that is a big ask, but they claim it) what function do exceptions provide unless they are purposely giving those exceptions for the production and distribution of csam by those groups? More likely their claims of the privacy and/or purpose are false.
- RajT88 2y ago> Assuming those claims are true(I know, that is a big ask, but they claim it) They may even be true today. The problem is that if true, it won't stay true. Interested parties find ways to tap into stuff like this once it exists. Given enough time, they create a legal framework to justify it.
- lupusreal 2y agoEU officials are very afraid of the people. But if they aren't doing anything wrong, why are they so afraid?
- eru 2y agoOfficially, they are worried that something bad might happen to the kids. > But if they aren't doing anything wrong, why are they so afraid? I would be afraid of eg a would-be assassin, even if I never did anything wrong in my life. So this is a weird argument to make.
- matsemann 2y agoIt's weird how some parts of EU departments are so privacy friendly and forward thinking, and others are so incredibly backwards.
- BSDobelix 2y agoIt's not weird, minimal data for corporations maximal data and control for the states, i think it's disgusting but hey they say the EU is democratic so at the end of the day it's our fault.
- mrtksn 2y agoNothing weird, that's just how governments work when they are not united under a strong leader like Putin or Erdogan. Different organisations have different goals and those into "security" just want to delegate their jobs to computers when they chill, get paid and prized for their success. Some more cynical ones are also plotting for political control, I'm sure. I'm very annoyed by this trend of government organisations really really desire to look into our stuff all the so they don't have to do their jobs the hard way like finding suspects and investigating them. Bunch of wankers and nothing more, aren't they? If aligned government bodies is desired then a dictator is needed. EU isn’t suited for this.
- tryauuum 2y agoHmmm... I can assure you people doing security in the Putin's world also just want to delegate stuff to computers and collect salary
- mrtksn 2y agoI’m sure they will but you won’t have some governmental organizations trying to protect the privacy when others are trying hard to invade it. They will be aligned.
- Maken 2y agoI'm seriously surprised by seeing Erdogan and "strong leader" together.
- walterbell 2y agoOn a positive note, the backlash will inspire a new generation to consign fossils to the dustbin of history, https://youtube.com/watch?v=-wntX-a3jSY https://youtube.com/watch?v=-wntX-a3jSY The more you tighten your grip, the more star systems will slip through your fingers.
- anankaie 2y agoOne can only hope, though given how much more authoritarian everyone (in the US, at least) has gotten, I am not holding out much hope. Good luck fighting this; I mean that sincerely.
- walterbell 2y agoEvery action has an opposite reaction. Thanks to Apple's refusal to cede even a little bit of central control over their ecosystem, to enable decentralized innovation, members of their star silicon design team departed to start afresh with Nuvia. Now we have Windows Arm PCs with UEFI and upstream Linux support, "close enough" to Apple Silicon perf/watt. PC OEM price competition and enterprise volume buys will yield affordable Arm laptops in a few years. Framework has proven that laptops can be modular. Did they inspire Lenovo to make a more repairable Thinkpad? If Framework releases a modular Arm laptop based on Qualcomm/Mediatek/Nvidia, watch out. On the software front, the sold-out "Local First" conference recently wrapped in Berlin, https://www.localfirstconf.com/ https://www.localfirstconf.com/. If HTTP can be extended to support synchronization, it could dramatically lower the cost of cooperative infrastructure, including offline (think Cuba sneakernet) sync, https://stateb.us/what https://stateb.us/what & https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40480016 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40480016, tearing down big walls of tech and lobbyists. Some conflicts are won by making them irrelevant.
- squigz 2y agoIgnoring the fact that TFA is about the EU and not the US, can you elaborate on what you mean by that? Everyone is more authoritarian?
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- microtonal 2y agoRelevant comment from a previous time a link to this site was posted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40523902 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40523902 tl;dr the title is misleading. This comes from the European council (which consists of representatives of member countries) and is not a fact until the European Parliament has voted on it. It is likely that the EP will reject this proposal like earlier attempts. Yes, we should fight this , but it’s not the ‘EU’ who says this.
- raverbashing 2y agoAnd for the 3rd time people confuse the Council with the Commission ;)
- simiones 2y agoIn this particular case, the Council is still debating and amending a proposal by the Commission before it is sent to the EP to actually vote on. So I don't think anything there is truly wrong.
- Saline9515 2y agoEuropean parliament has no real power, it's a democratic illusion, just like the elections in USSR. You don't believe me? Then explain me how the EP repels an already voted law. It can't.
- izacus 2y agoEP rejected ChatControl once already. So what the heck are you going on about?
- prasoonds 2y agoEP is a fundamentally a weaker body than its name suggests. The European Council can keep proposing pretty much the same law over and over again until they get a pliant EP that will accept it. Once accepted, it's almost impossible to repeal the law by the EP because they will need the approval of the EC and Council of the EU, both of which have members that are not directly elected by the people. EC and Council of the EU is also that body which so far has proven to be far more authoritarian in it's approach. So, the parent is largely correct.
- draugadrotten 2y ago[flagged]
- 0dayz 2y agoIt really isn't. What are we suppose to find? Her sworn allegiance to the USSR? A bit nostalgic of her I suppose. No her connection to Thorn the US based company is a much bigger concern due to direct influence to the point of writing part of the suggestion letter for her to use.
- draugadrotten 2y ago> What are we suppose to find? Well, with recent revelations of money spent on EU politicians, it would not be surprising to find just that. Money. It's rather naive to think that all the Russian influence operations have been found and revealed already. https://www.politico.eu/article/voice-of-europe-russia-influence-scandal-election/ https://www.politico.eu/article/voice-of-europe-russia-influ... https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/jun/02/revealed-russian-legal-defence-foundation-pravfond-europe https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/jun/02/reveal... I ask myself, can someone who openly was a communist in adult age as late as 1990s and beyond, truly have left those beliefs and values behind?
- 0dayz 2y agoThere's an absurd amount of far right parties with much deeper affiliations with today's Russia. I don't think someone who was a communist over 40+ years ago in their idealistic youth is still clinging onto nostalgia. Especially when there's way more far left people simpling for Russia because "west bad", I don't see her views being reflected that way.
- staunton 2y agoPeople in the EU don't equate "communist" to "evil", or even to "wants everything to be like the USSR". Recently in the EU, foreign (also Russian and Chinese) interference has been more visible in parties on the political right. More generally, I would assume any party to be roughly equally susceptible to corruption and foreign influence, absent strong measures and procedures to find and prevent them, regardless of where it finds itself on the political spectrum.
- izacus 2y agoA gentle reminder that this week we're voting in EU election so it's a great time to check who supports Chat Control and to vote accordingly. The last attempts of this have been stopped by European Parliament so we need to make sure the new one stops it as well.
- surfingdino 2y agoThey all do, even if they say they don't.
- mhitza 2y ago> A gentle reminder that this week we're voting in EU election so it's a great time to check who supports Chat Control and to vote accordingly. Any idea where we can find that information (those who proposed and voted on it)?
- nickexyz 2y agoIn Sweden we have this: https://chatcontrol.se/status/ https://chatcontrol.se/status/ Hopefully other EU countries has similar sites. If you have a local Pirate Party, that might be a good place to start. I'm guessing they would link such a site.
- throw46365 2y agoIt’s not, as I understand it, something that the European Parliament has even debated yet. Nobody in the Parliament has proposed or voted on it, unless I have misunderstood. This measure is still being developed by the European Council, which is a non-legislative body. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Council https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Council It would have to be submitted to and taken up by the Parliament for the information you want to exist in a meaningful form. Parliament is not keen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_to_Prevent_and_Combat_Child_Sexual_Abuse#Legislative_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_to_Prevent_and_Comb...
- fxtentacle 2y agoI know this might not be what you're expecting to hear, but my reading is that the proposed law is pretty balanced. If I take pictures and never share them, no scanning is done. If I copy private pictures to my wife's phone when we are meeting in person, no scanning is done. Similarly, I can archive pictures to my PC or print them out and all of that respects my privacy. Only if I use a public service, like Facebook, WhatsApp, TikTok, is there the possibility of my pictures being sent to authorities if (and hopefully only if) the local scanning was inconclusive. But in that case, Facebook, WhatsApp, TikTok can (and probably do) already spy on me and my pictures. I don't think it's all that draconian for authorities to take a look, too, after you have already voluntarily !!! sent them to a for-profit corp with questionable morals. And I feel like the proposed law design also matches with the real risk profile. Pretty much all of the blackmailing scams that drove teenagers to suicide were being perpetuated from outside the country that the victim was living in, e.g. [1]. So it makes a lot of sense to more tightly control cross-country online messaging on almost anonymous platforms than in-person photo sharing. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-australia-68720247 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-australia-68720247 "Two arrested in Nigeria after Australian boy's suicide" EDIT: In case anyone wonders, here's the 100+ page EU report that presents their opinion of the facts and then makes suggestions, some of which are now being discussed: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2020/652718/IPOL_STU(2020)652718_EN.pdf https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2020/6527... Section 3.5.1. is about the scanning of your private pictures that Facebook is already doing, meaning regardless of how the EU decides in this case.
- johnbakerisback 2y ago[flagged]
- fxtentacle 2y agoYou sir, went with an (useless) attack instead of actually furthering the discussion.
- aaomidi 2y agoThere are some discussions that shouldn’t be legitimized with a real reply. Imagine this being a public street. A stupid comment would get heckled. If the commenter decided to stay there with a megaphone yelling about it, they might even get the megaphone ripped out their hand and completely sidelined. Some opinions are so _against the grain_ of society (or in this case, just stupid) that facing a reaction like you did is probably the least amount of pushback you could get.
- consp 2y agoWhile this is being put forward by the council, there still is a way to influence the end result by voting for a party not involved in this turd to get it rejected. The EU Pirate Party is still on the ballot in some places. If it ever gets promoted to law, my predictions is: ASCII art is back.
- iLoveOncall 2y ago> If it ever gets promoted to law, my predictions is: ASCII art is back. Actually 99.99% of users won't give a single fuck and will just allow scanning. People don't care at all in case you didn't notice.
- outime 2y agoThat's exactly what's going to happen, and the few people who actually care will end up in a list. It's all for your own good though, as terrorist and pedos will obviously be like "damn gotta find something else to do now as this is forbidden!".
- consp 2y agoIt was a sarcastic comment, and I guess you are right. If the detector has a false positive rate of 0.01% that still means ~50000 false hits every day, if every one sends one image daily. And my guess is it's WAY more than that in volume and false positive rate.
- rpastuszak 2y agoI'd replace "don't care" with "are intentionally misinformed / not informed enough" or "don't understand the consequences". It's hard to have time to think about these issues when you have zero free time, barely manage to make ends meet, don't have techie friends and are bombarded with propaganda. It's possible, but it's hard, especially when that very propaganda uses the main thing you work your ass off to scare you into submission.
- WA 2y agoNah, this plan is outright evil. We all learned from the cookie banner madness that everybody just opts-in to everything all the time, just to make the thing go away. This proposal gives us a fake choice, because so many coordination of real life activities happen in WhatsApp in the EU that you have to opt-in to still participate in a meaningful way. I'm not talking about sharing vacation photos with your friends, but stuff like: - here is a link that explains how to do taxes for your nonprofit - here is our new school logo - this is a link to the soccer tournament schedule and so on.
- pmontra 2y agoWait for the first hundreds of false positives and the stories in the news and the effects on the next elections (some parties will campaign over that.)
- Springtime 2y agoPer earlier news the scanning is said to have a 10% false positive rate[1]. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/voaicx/10_error_rate_is_okay_leaked_eu_commission/ https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/voaicx/10_error_ra...
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoBut by then it'll be too late. They will promise they'll tweak the filters and whitelists, but in the end, the scanning will stay. They only have to succeed once to implement this law, and it's here to stay... we have to succed in repealing it every time and must never fail.
- surfingdino 2y agoMorality police. Now with AI!
- ecmascript 2y agoWell well, time to vote for the anti-EU party.
- martijnvds 2y agoThe anti-EU parties are generally in favor of this kind of stuff.
- ecmascript 2y agoNot in my country, here it's the reverse. Even though, it's far easier to change peoples opinion in one country than in 28.
- mihaaly 2y agoOr kill the potential victims, that will prevent future crimes too!
- shafyy 2y agoThis is surely the wrong conclusion to draw from this.
- robertlagrant 2y agoI imagine the idea is that smaller-scale authoritarianism is better than larger-scale.
- ecmascript 2y agoWhy? The EU is inherently anti-democratic IMO. Most people have no idea what is going on, what laws are being discussed and so on. Why should the EU have power over stuff like this to begin with? It's stupid.
- shafyy 2y agoI agree that the EU is not perfect. But it's not anti-democractic. The European Parliament is elected democratically. Sure, there are ways we need to improve the legislative processes, but this doesn't mean the best thing to do is to disband the EU.
- vasco 2y agoIncredible that they think this will even slow anything at all. Some of these laws you can see a trade-off between safety and freedom, which you can decide where to position yourself. But in this one I really have a hard time seeing what even gets harder to do for criminals. If I'm sharing nasty stuff through one of these platforms and I can send text, I can send a link. In any platform "that doesn't allow links" you see people sharing them anyway through normal text, even if they have to create some new conventions. And you can also just use different platforms anyway, so where is the deterrent? This is just annoying based on people legislating for technologies they don't understand.
- seper8 2y ago>This is just annoying That's the most positive take you can have on this.
- spongebobstoes 2y agoHaving the bad content hosted "elsewhere" is still a good gain for any service provider. It reduces the number of safe harbors for harmful actors. Outside public content can be scanned as part of "defense in depth" too.
- arp242 2y agoI think you overestimate the technical knowledge and skills of many people. For every crafty career criminal there's a dumb idiot doing dumb stuff on account of being a dumb idiot. And even crafty career criminals can and do make mistakes. Of course it won't catch 100% of it, but very few laws or measure do that (and those that do almost always come with very high amounts of false positives). Also links are not hard to scan for either, and you can't "just" upload CSAM to anywhere either and not expect troubles sooner or later (unless you know what you're doing, in which case we're back to the previous paragraph). I think it's very hard to deny that of course it will catch a non-zero number of people, although it's hard to determine exactly how many beforehand. That doesn't mean it's a good law, it just means that all these type of "it won't even catch anyone!" argument are just bad arguments.
- 2y ago
- raverbashing 2y agoI think the same article was posted some 3 times this weekend in different forms I'm all for discussing the issue, but at some repetition exhaustion is a thing, updates without anything significant are not really updates and maybe Patrick should be aware of crying wolf (and it's also a campaign issue) At what point can we say HN is just going round and round? Or is it just pleasure with suffering?
- mihaaly 2y agoWhen responsible people with power feel powerless carrying out their responsibilities they tend to panic and force the innocents into an uncomfortable or damaging situation, endangering everyone instead of catching the comparably very few perpetrators doing the trouble. I seen too many of such examples throughout the years, bigger the public outrage, bigger the damge to the whole public instead of the very few involved or responsible. Who mostly thanks, carry out slightly differently in overall. But the public gets f'd.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fxtentacle 2y agoI'd say the big problem with catching those perpetrators online is that they will most likely not be inside your country.
- pzo 2y agoFor me it feel just like smoke screen rather than genuine intention to help child abuse. Is child abuse from predators such a big problem to variant all population being under radar? Most likely predators are not even 0.1% of population. It would be better instead to empower and educate parents with tools to protect their children rather than outsourcing to government or public companies.
- madeofpalk 2y ago> It would be better instead to empower and educate parents with tools to protect their children Do we think that CSAM comes from poor parenting? That the parent's didn't do enough?
- simiones 2y agoNot all of it, for sure, but certainly some amount of it. Most perpetrators of child sexual abuse are close to the child, either family members or authority figures (priests, teachers, etc). I expect at least some amount of CSAM originates from these places as well, that the child's parents absolutely had the power (and responsibility) to stop. Of course, a lot of it comes from major organized crime networks that parents are powerless against. But that then falls under the incidence of more regular police investigations to stop and curtail. You don't need to monitor everyone's chat history to be able to find and dismantle a crime ring.
- bowsamic 2y agoThe amount of identity verification we have to do in Germany is already obscene EDIT: Weird to downvote for this, I suppose that people here are in favour of removing privacy
- staunton 2y agoI thought Germany was pretty big on privacy protection. What exactly do you mean?
- seper8 2y agoYes but the state should know everything.
- bowsamic 2y agoTo get a SIM card, open a bank account, do any kind of investments, etc. you need to do a pretty extensive ID check, which involves going on a video call with an agent and holding up your passport and moving it around in all kinds of ways to show that all the reflections are there and stuff. It's pretty laborious and intrusive Basically you must have your identity fully checked by a third party whenever you do something that can be used for terrorist reasons, which currently includes having a bank account and using a phone. Adding instant messaging in general to that list would not be surprising. There is an entire industry in Germany and Europe in general built around supplying this service of checking people's identities.
- tdurand 2y agoThat is the kind of mess you get with such laws: https://mjtsai.com/blog/2022/08/22/google-account-deleted-due-to-csam-false-positive/ https://mjtsai.com/blog/2022/08/22/google-account-deleted-du... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32538805 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32538805
- Freak_NL 2y agoIt is really concerning that I probably need to ask my parents to stop sharing any photos and videos of my young son digitally (privately via WhatsApp) when he's staying at their place and they are teaching him to swim in their swimming pool. False positives like these can ruin your life.
- arp242 2y agoAnd without any protections Google would be a massive host and facilitator for CSAM. Let's not be naïve about this. Google support is notoriously non-existent and/or obtuse, and that's the real problem here. Combined with that it's a "ban for life" black/white type thing, that it's not really possibly to appeal anywhere reasonably independent, and that type of stuff. There's tons of innocent reasons your account can get banned, and this is just one o them. Doing anything that allows random people to upload or send stuff is being flypaper for the worst of the worst of dickheads. You really do need some kind of protection. I'll go a step further and say that providing such a large platform which ties in to so many aspects of life (whether you want to or not) means accepting some responsibility. This means having at least vaguely helpful support. And also means not being a massive host for CSAM. I remember a time when I worked as a repair tech and randomly clicked something on the frontpage of Google Video just to test if Flash Player was working without really looking what it was, and it was some guy blowing his brains out. And "young 12-year old Alice proudly shows her small tits" type stuff being quite common to just come across without looking for it on Kazaa, "warez" sites, and the like. Where do you strike the balance on all of that? Good question. But pretending the balance doesn't exist is not helpful.
- prasoonds 2y agoI love how Europe with all it's GDPR laws (even binding on the government in many cases) and specifically Germany and it's Datenschutz-fixated citizens is sleepwalking into DDR era authoritarianism. Stasi's wet dreams couldn't think about this much control
- moffkalast 2y ago> Previously unknown images and videos are also to be scrutinised using “artificial intelligence” technology. Can't see any way this could go wrong at all, none whatsoever.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- agilob 2y agoA bit off topic, but I was thinking recently if EU ever deregulates anything? Do they only add new laws and paragraphs? Are they rewarded in LoC? What are examples of laws they removed or deregulated?
- 54546ddd 2y agoLawyers and regulators are the strongest and most cutting edge sectors of the EU economy
- seper8 2y agoIts the reason why we only can compete with the US in legislation heavy businesses, which in the US is also slowed down by bureaucrats such as making planes and cars. Any other market and any developed country will have us beat.
- eru 2y agoAs a counter-example: Europe is pretty good at artisanal luxury items for rich people. Those are generally fairly lightly regulated.
- andreaja 2y agoThat depends on what you mean by deregulate. There's a lot of simplification through the single market and free movement of labor.
- surgical_fire 2y agoIs deregulation desirable?
- 54546ddd 2y ago[flagged]
- dachworker 2y ago
- mariopt 2y agoThis lasts until every single major app decides to exit the market and they are forced to remove this nonsense. At the end of the day Europe is not even the place where most apps are created, just a bureaucratic nonsense. If you though the cookies law were bad just wait.
- phicoh 2y agoI wonder if they are going to kill open source chat applications.
- seper8 2y agoIf and how :)
- phicoh 2y agoThe how is simple, all devices will be required to be as locked as iphones. No apps on your device unless approved by the vendor. Open source is fine as long as you jump through the hoops to submit it for review.
- poolopolopolo 2y agoso disable dev mode for all phones? This solution is far from simple.
- KETHERCORTEX 2y agoAs if one can just grab a PlayStation and start developing for it. The limiting tech already exists.
- graemep 2y agoVery likely, and self-hosting too. I imagine some sort of licensing system eventually.
- anthk 2y agoI doubt it. The day it fucks state level companies with issues accessing the Telegram API or libre/FLOSS APIs/services such as GUIX under Inria using XMPP/VoIP tools, the working days of these EU bureaucrats are numbered.
- 2y ago
- 54546ddd 2y agoEU produced tens of billions in lawyer fees. A regulatory superpower.
- brainwipe 2y agoI give it 6 months before someone goes to trial for sharing AI-generated CP and is acquitted.
- robertlagrant 2y agoLate stage sexual revolution.
- simiones 2y agoI'm pretty sure that in the EU (and the USA), even fictional CP is illegal. That is, even drawings or stories of CP are illegal, and certainly AI-generated images would fall under that banner.
- constantcrying 2y agoProbably yes, although in some EU countries having CP is below the level of a criminal offence, with the circumstances being that the images are artificially created even the minimum of three months of jail might not be considered.
- egberts1 2y agoAgain, easily circumvented by piping photo/image data stream into muLaw encoder then over voice stream/file. Effective but terrible Shannon's Limit though.
- pembrook 2y agoWhat’s unfortunate is that a lot of folks here will cheer on regulation of tech if branded as “pro-consumer.” Anything with the keywords pro-privacy, and right-to-repair, Reddit/HN types will eat up uncritically. “This is great!” But people don’t seem to understand, if you cheer when governments use their power to “protect” you, they don’t suddenly decide to stop doing it. Just because phase 1 was friendly to your pet interests, doesn’t mean phase 2 will be. I wish folks would look at all regulation with a much more critical lens, and be much more humble about implementing it. Decentralization brought on by the internet is messy, complicated, and scary. But it’s a direct transfer of power from central authorities to individuals. So whenever you bypass the messy, decentralized way of solving problems in favor of the easy centralized way (regulation), you have given up your power. You reap what you sow.
- kypro 2y ago[flagged]
- Hizonner 2y ago> When tens of thousands of school girls in the UK were raped and sexually abused by migrants in most cases there was nothing the authorities could do because they were 16. Rape is illegal in the UK regardless of the age of the victim. What you seem to mean is that you don't like their boyfriends and are upset you can't jail them.
- kypro 2y ago> What you seem to mean is that you don't like their boyfriends and are upset you can't jail them. I truly hope this isn't a genuine comment, but I'll reply assuming your comment was in good faith. Not going to lie I probably would have punched you in the face had you said this to me IRL though. Part of the problem was that many of the girls groomed were 16-18 so it was very hard to prove rape and coercion. Like most people from working class backgrounds I know a couple of girls who were groomed... At the start these girls are made to feel special because there's a guy in his 30s spending money on them and buying them gifts. These guys take these girls out for food and to the cinema and eventually the girls will develop feelings for their abusers. At this point they coerce the girls into sexual acts and isolate them from friends and family. One of the girls I know who was abused genuinely thought her abuser loved her, and it wasn't until a couple of years later when she was in her late teens that she started to understand the extent of abuse she was subjected to. While you're right that rape is illegal, it's not always clear to someone in the moment that they were raped – this is even more true of children. If a 16 year old child does something sexual because a much older person asks them to do it, is that because they're truly consenting or because they don't understand the situation they're in? I'm a guy, but when I was a teenager I was dating a girl that was quite abusive looking back on it, but I loved her so I allowed her to do it and honestly in the moment I didn't even really understand what was happening. In my case it was "just" emotional abuse, but the same can obviously be true of physical abuse too. Were it illegal for older men to have sex with children in the UK then it would have been far easier to have put an end to the abuse. But either way, you're just wrong on this. At this point it's uncontroversial that these young girls were sexually abused. The comment you made, however is a common defence made by the abusers. Anyone with any first hand experience of would know they were not boyfriends. In fact, these men were often married and lying to the girls about their relationship status.
- bouke 2y agoSo what about our fundamental rights, article 7? > CHARTER OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION > (2012/C 326/02) > Article 7 > Respect for private and family life > Everyone has the right to respect for his or her private and family life, home and communications.
- SanjayMehta 2y agoThere’s a deeper goal here. Europe has no obvious path for staying relevant in the near future since colonialism is long gone. EU prides itself on its institutions and their control over international trade and relations such as banking and insurance etc. This is the only way they can assert some kind of authority over primarily US internet businesses.
- kwere 2y agoColonialism except for few colonies here and there was a big source of cost for european Nations. Buying raw goods from cashstrapped Kleptocracies is a lot more efficient / cheaper
- SanjayMehta 2y agoNeo-colonialism in a nutshell.
- 8fingerlouie 2y agoSo if i want to keep my information private, i'll just have to revive my usage of GPG. Scan all you like.
- petre 2y agoUseless. Pedos will encode cp as text. As everybody knows this is not about the children but concerns how to snoop on the public in not so obvious ways.
- squarefoot 2y agoBecause you know, AI never gets an image wrong, right? https://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15817 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15817 Quite long paper, but rich in examples that speak for themselves, like AI mistaking a Starbucks logo for a Ferrari one, or an airplane for a baby stroller, etc. CSAM producers will always find a way to poison images or use other tricks to conceal them. There was one in fact years ago that involved appending a .rar archive to a .jpg image without renaming the image (including the .jpg suffix): an image viewer would correctly show the image ignoring the following data, while a .rar unpacker would ignore anything preceding the .rar header, thus the image, and would extract the archived file anyway without errors. One wonders if the capability was intentional and how many times this trick has been used to exfiltrate from somewhere sensitive data disguised as kitten pictures.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kkfx 2y agoMaybe some people will come back to PopcornTime (app, torrent-based movie sharing), Usenet etc and start to self-host more, witch might be a NICE BACKFIRE for surveillance capitalism...
- redeeman 2y agohow about... no? these regimes have ZERO legitimate authority to do any of this. They will of course disagree, as all criminal organisations do. At this point they really just qualify as enemy of the people
- sharpshadow 2y agoThis is really bad. I rather send no images and links, but find another way of sharing, like partial links as text. What a stupid implementation, also one could harm others by sending them things anonymously.
- RamblingCTO 2y agoYou really have to commend Ursula von der Leyen. She failed in Germany and moved up the ladder just to push this bs through and it looks like it could work this time
- irusensei 2y agoThey really want to push this don't they? But you will stop what you are doing to spread awareness, write articles, send letters to your representatives and raise hell doing activism so you can stop it. You might be able to stop this authoritarian proposal. And then they will just push it again with a different name and rewording. But while you need to devote your time and effort they are being paid for this and with your tax money (ha!) plus whatever those AI companies lobbying are putting into the table. And they just need to get it approved once before they move to the next thing-of-young-sebastian draconian law.
- welzel 2y agoWe should all support this law, just with one addition: All data shared by politicians, public servants and all of their family members within the EU has to be shared, analysed for corruption + stored forever. If we are all considered pedophiles, then all politicians are criminals. Yes, a few people will be wrongly accused and we all loose our freedom. HOWEVER, with every election we will get a small chance that the previous administration will get audited and corruption and other crimes will get uncovered. Seems to be worth it.
- palata 2y ago> If we are all considered pedophiles, then all politicians are criminals. Well you could do the latter without doing the former. Except that - of course - politicians would never do anything against themselves.
- hedora 2y agoIf this passes, I’m hoping it follows the gpdr malicious compliance route. In particular, the csam detector could false-positive on anything involving the currently ruling party’s political platform and on the face of any elected official.
- altairprime 2y agoCan ascii art QR codes be made using available fonts in the various EU messenger apps?
- ghusto 2y agoIt says I’ll be prevented from receiving images too. I’ll be refusing, and hopefully frustrating everyone who tries to send me an image. I can then explain why that feature is broken, which (with enough people) would put the spotlight on how unfair, dangerous, and ill thought out this is.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hsuduebc2 2y agoSo this is against pedophiles whatsapp groups or what? This is absolutely bizarre inefficient solution. They can't destroy tor pedo sites, or stop them from sending data in archive with passwords? These people are willingy inserting spyware into phones while constantly harrasing big tech for this. Clown world.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 6510 2y agoCan you prevent other people from using your devices? Do they actually need anything to accuse you? Who is to check the false positives and who checks the checking? Possibly worse than loss of privacy is that this would require computers to be entirely controlled by someone other than their owner. It rules out the pc like open ecosystem for phones.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoDumb question: How is it possible to stop people from sharing links if links are text. For example, what will prevent someone from sharing a link in a form that might not be "clicklable" but still communicates the location of the linked resource.