6 ms·
When Companies Ask for Your Social Security Number, Try Saying No
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/dyBeR https://archive.ph/dyBeR
- x3n0ph3n3 2y agoI say "no" every time, and people asking for it are flabbergasted and make it seem like I'm committing some sort of social taboo. "Why should I trust your company to protect me from identity theft?" is usually my retort, which they never have a compelling rejoinder.
- Nifty3929 2y agoThe problem with this approach is that frequently the business doesn't care much about serving you. If you say no, they just say that's okay. Come back when you will. And then what? Fine if there are many options, but often there aren't. I'm thinking medical and banking here, but I'm sure there are many more where all the companies that offer the service you want/need require you to give them your SSN.
- grogenaut 2y agoCan you legally open a bank account without a SSN? Legit asking. Same qq for medical.
- x3n0ph3n3 2y agoI always exclude my SSN on medical forms and have never had a problem. Banks are another matter...
- Nifty3929 2y agoLots of people in the US don't have SSN's, but are still entitled to medical services. The same is not true for banking.
- Nifty3929 2y agoPretty much no. Banks in the US are subject to Know Your Customer (KYC) laws that require them to collect a lot of personal information about you to uniquely identify you as an individual and tie you to past behavior and other entities you interact with. SSN is functionally a shortcut to most of this. Everybody has a unique one, and all the entities track you by it, so they can put those pieces together when and if necessary.
- yencabulator 2y agoI know you could in mid-2000s. Couldn't get a credit card without a safety deposit (deposit $X, get a credit limit of $X), though.
- willis936 2y agoWhere I've had the most friction is with background checks. They don't offer a "decline" option, so I have to either give them my SSN or tell them I don't have one. I have done the latter and it wasn't a big problem, just more work for them.
- vsuperpower2020 2y agoThe system we have with SSNs are just fundamentally flawed. It's like a password you can't choose or change, that is also in a million databases (in plaintext) and regularly gets stolen and resold. We have better systems for authentication and we're stuck treating this number like it has any value at all.
- pacificmint 2y agoThat’s right. You can use a number as a unique identifier for each person that everybody stores. You can also use a number as a secret code to authenticate yourself. But you can’t use the same number for both purposes.
- Terr_ 2y agoEven worse is going to be when people start misusing biometrics, where--like with SSNs--they make a very wrong yet temporarily convenient assumption that the information is secret.
- e63f67dd-065b 2y agoBiometrics don't have to be secret to be useful -- my home country has national ID cards with embedded fingerprint data, and certain transactions are required by law to have you physically present yourself and verify your identity with a fingerprint reader that checks it against your card's info.
- Terr_ 2y agoDoes an authority always inspects everyone's fingers to make sure nobody is wearing a gelatin pad, or is it a facility which has a rather expensive machine that does a lot of extra anti-spoofing tests? In general, the common situations some people wish they could use biometrics--like a grocery store payment--are also ones where it won't actually be that secure. After someone goes on a shopping-spree with your stolen fingerprint, you can't really change it.
- Galatians4_16 2y ago
- vxxzy 2y agoSSN was never meant to be a form of identification. Now, let’s figure out a way to consistently convert an individual’s DNA to a hash… oh wait. Worldcoin?
- esafak 2y agodon't give crud publicity.
- GauntletWizard 2y agoI personally think this is the wrong track to take. What we should do to social security numbers is make them so ubiquitous, make it so that you know all of your friends social security numbers, so that it is no longer used as a private identifier, which it isn't, and is thoroughly unsuit for purpose as. Especially as "AI", the ubiquity of chat GPT and AI generated images makes it easy to fake people, having a public registry of every real citizen becomes a much more sensible thing. There is an insane take on "PII" that the list of "Your real name and address" are sensitive information. A generation ago everybody's name and address were in the phone book, and we were better off for it.
- kibwen 2y ago> A generation ago everybody's name and address were in the phone book, and we were better off for it. Would you like to start? Please leave a reply to this comment with your real name, full home address, date of birth, SSN, and whatever other non-PII PII you have in mind.
- Terr_ 2y agoThe parent poster seems to be talking about it being a coordinated widespread effort, why are you challenging them to do something different?
- kibwen 2y agoBecause the specific risk to an individual from having their personal information publicized does not decrease when everyone else's personal information is publicized as well. If the poster above wants people to throw away the notion of privacy, then they have nothing to lose from leading by example. And if they refuse, that in itself is proof that their words are hollow.
- init2null 2y agoIt's tough to make that argument when those were the days of physical locations and card-based verification. While SS# is thoroughly unsuitable and personal info is even more so, that pragmatism and illusion of security serves as the foundation of government and commerce. What are we going to use instead? The likelihood of a truly national cryptographically verifiable smart ID card is seemingly nil given the patchwork quilt of laws in the US.
- rickydroll 2y agoI always say no. I can get away with it in every case except banks and loans. At the same time, anytime a company asks for your birthdate, give them a fake one. I frequently use my mom's birthday and a sibling's birth year so I can remember it.
- nullhole 2y agoThere's a spike in births on Jan 1st if website records are to be trusted.
- toast0 2y agoAn something like 10% of the population lives in Beverly Hills.
- el_benhameen 2y agoAnd one heckuva party line on 867-5309
- Hnrobert42 2y agoIn pretty much any store that has rewards account that you have to punch in a phone number (like a drug store, gas station, grocery), I use this number. Someone has always created one.
- galdosdi 2y agoBanking is actually a rare case where it makes sense because they legitimately need your TIN (taxpayer ID number). For businesses this is the same as their EIN (employee ID number) so no big deal. What's problematic that ought to be fixed is that for individuals your TIN is just your SSN. Lazy. We ought to just issue personal TINs the first time you file taxes.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 2y ago
- OptionOfT 2y agoThere is a doctor I visit and they have one of those kiosks that make me do shadow work, you know, checking me in, the work of a receptionist. It used to prompt for SSN. I would enter a bunch of zeroes. Now there is a button that says 'I don't want to give it'. And then the next screen prompts you for the last 4 digits of your SSN, stating that insurance companies need it. No. You already have a scan of my ID and insurance card. You don't need more.
- brlewis 2y agoI once insisted with an optometrist that they only take my insurance number and not my SSN. They contacted my insurance and the insurance sent them my SSN. I can't avoid medical insurance having my SSN because of tax reporting requirements.
- karma_pharmer 2y agoActually you can. Just don't give them your SSN. I did this with Kaiser Permanente and it continues to work just fine.
- cwillu 2y ago> They contacted my insurance and the insurance sent them my SSN If all you're doing is making them get the information from someone else, what exactly are you accomplishing? Adding a bit of friction to a process? I mean, fine, if that's the aim, but it sounds like this was intended as more of a “they don't need this information at all, and if you don't give it to them, then they won't have it” technique, and (apparently) that doesn't work.
- karma_pharmer 2y agoI told them they shouldn't give the insurance company their SSN. There is no "someone else" who will give the insurer this information.
- dimgl 2y agoI wish I could but I literally can't not do on Phreesia. And then I can't go into the doctor's office without checking in, which they won't do on paper if they use Phreesia.
- karma_pharmer 2y agothen stop giving them money
- malux85 2y agoI say no by default to companies asking too much information all the time, here in NZ companies seem particularly bad at asking for this info, and it's become so normalized that I always get weird looks when I say no, which annoys me even more. Why does my barber need my email address and phone number to cut my hair? Why does the supermarket ask for my address when I'm just trying to buy a bottle of milk? When I buy trousers it's sign up for the membership plan and fill out all these personal details. No, No, No. I'm not putting all of my details in your crappy insecure database - and yes, I know it's for "marketing" purposes, I dont want your spam either. It's infuriating.
- ptman 2y agoJust look at how it has been solved in Scandinavia, Estonia etc. I don't know enough about Indian Aadhar (?), but I assume that works as well. And start keeping a decent registry of people instead of relying on a once a decade census.