11 ms·
How actors remember their lines
- ugh123 2y agoLoved this quote from Michael Caine >You must be able to stand there not thinking of that line. You take it off the other actor’s face. Otherwise, for your next line, you’re not listening and not free to respond naturally, to act spontaneously.
- echelon 2y agoThe Meisner repetition technique is such a powerful method of teaching this. The technique has two or more actors repeating the same lines back and forth at each other, based on simple observation and repetition. But what's really being said and communicated is the subtext of how the actors sense and feel - not the words at all. Saying "you're wearing a blue shirt" might encode the thought "I don't like the tone of your voice" or "you've got a nice smile." And the other actor is meant to read that off of you and respond in kind.
- noufalibrahim 2y agoThis is very interesting. Some lines which I remember from movies, I rarely do so because of the words. It's almost always because of the way it was delivered and the emotion or "vibe" that it put out.
- eszed 2y agoOh, God. I can't stand Meisner work! I had to do a fair bit of it in graduate school, and it never, ever clicked with me. I could see it working for other actors, so I don't discount it, but I find it tedious in the extreme. Can you tell me a bit more about what you get out of it? What's your internal experience of the repetition exercises?
- echelon 2y ago> What's your internal experience of the repetition exercises? It's a lot like improv in that you establish an unspoken protocol for exchanging lots of side channel information. But unlike reading between the "yes, and" subtext to build a narrative world and rules, you're taking in raw, full sensory emotion in an intimate way by completely dropping your own filters. Brains melded, firewall open. You have to say what you see, what you understand, and what you feel. And you have to tell the truth and not lie to yourself and your partner. It's as uncomfortable as staring into their eyes, until it stops being uncomfortable. And you don't even have to be looking at one another. You can hear it in their breathing and the cracking of their voice. You know exactly how you feel about everything with exacting precision. You're uncomfortable and vulnerable and excited and anxious, and you let them know. Meisner removes all the social filters of the adult brain. All the platitudes and the scar tissue of decades of interacting with people in society. You stop judging and worrying and just say and do what you feel. And you hear it from them too, and you believe them because they're being honest with both you and themselves. You know if they're lying, because you've trained and can sense it. And you'll call them out on it. They'll do the same to you when you attempt to hide. They'll really dig in. Once you're under that spotlight, there is no hiding. You can go wherever you choose to go. It feels raw and weird and more intimate than being with a lover. With practice, "you're wearing a blue shirt" becomes "I don't like how you look at him and smile, but when you look at me you frown". And everyone cries and yells and things get thrown. On the spectrum of our robotic "how are you? / I'm fine, and you?" programming and a raw and intense fight with a lover, Meisner is the latter. Except you get to be that authentic for the entire range of human emotions: good, bad, happy, sad. A door to everything you could potentially feel. It's animalistic and completely cerebral. And it's real and you live it. Sometimes you come away shaking.
- eszed 2y agoHuh! That's my experience of performing, for sure, but Meisner wasn't presented to me that way. One of the teachers of a workshop I was in had studied with Meisner, and had led (I think?) the London Meisner Institute, so I figured I was getting it straight. She approached repetition exercises more like intuitive textual analysis - finding the subtext, as you (or someone else) said up-thread. I've never had trouble supplying more subtext than anyone could ever want, so that bit didn't do anything much for me. Neither did the crying and the yelling. I did too, just so as not to be left out (crying and yelling is always good fun), but they all took it so damn seriously that I wasn't sure where the line was between useful work and self-indulgence. Oh, and also I think a professional actor ought to be able to drop in without having to drag someone else through ten minutes of repeating the first three words of their lines back and forth until the syllables are drained of all meaning. True story! I was as good a sport about it as I could be, but gosh... It was drizzling, and the lighting guy fucked off for tea, and I sure wished I could too. I know more direct ways to get students to drop their inhibitions and tune into each other than repetitions. (Oh, and the audience! Everything I've seen of Meisner neglects the audience, and I think being aware of them is really important for stage work. Camera, same, for screen acting.) Anyway, I'm sure I'm just missing something, and being grumpy. Like I say, I've seen positive results for some actors (though not the chick in the rain), so it's doing something, and I'm glad it works for you.
- Keyframe 2y agoI can't tell from that angle, but having directed quite a few actors over years, there's a big difference in actors who've went to the workshops and internalized the process. It just shows, for the better and you can spot them rather quickly. Namely, you can tell they (for the better part) react 'naturally' making the character far more believable. Take what you will from this, but that has been my experience.
- eszed 2y agoThat makes sense. Someone else down-thread says Meisner isn't something they'd use after the beginner stage. I think, by that point in my career, I'd internalized enough of those lessons in other ways that it was kinda pointless for me. If I were still teaching I might give it a go with a beginner class - though I doubt I could teach it with conviction, so I'd probably call in someone else for a day. Like I say, I've noticed the same thing you have, so there's clearly something there. I've just never "got it", so it kinda fascinates me.
- MrVandemar 2y agoThis sounds like the basis for the "Baseline Test" in Blade-Runner 2049. Fascinating write up here: https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/blade-runner-2049-how-a-key-scene-differed-from-the-script/ https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/blade-runner-2049-how-a-key...
- tapotatonumber9 2y ago“These pretzels are making me thirsty!"
- crazygringo 2y agoThe Meisner repetition technique, sure. (Although it just doesn't connect/resonate for a lot of actors.) But the Meisner technique also teaches you to learn your lines by rote, practicing them in a monotone, intentionally devoid of meaning (the opposite of what this article describes), under the theory that this will free you to add spontaneous emotion in the moment. Whereas in my experience that's a terrible approach. It makes it vastly harder to learn the material (as this article suggests), and then students tend to perform closer to a monotone because that's how they practiced it and built an unconscious habit of association -- or once they're able to bring emotion to it they forget their lines because the emotion was overwhelming and they don't have the lines "in their bodies" connected to the emotions that are going on, because they learned them by rote. As you can tell, I'm not generally a fan of the Meisner technique overall...
- dbish 2y agoI love his way of putting it. Memorizing lines as a kid for plays always felt easy but it’s because of something like what he describes. My biggest play to memorize was as one of the leads of The Importance of Being Earnest in high school and a big part of knowing it end to end was how I memorize talks today, just repeating it until you become the part, and feel like you know “your part” not “the lines”. You’re not regurgitating lines, you’re stepping through and reacting based on a set of information to a point where you don’t even feel like you’re trying to react. This also helps a lot with improvising when things go wrong since you’re just following the flow your character would with the stimuli, rather then having to step line by line through. The worst people to act alongside were the rote memorizers who would break that flow to go back to a line that was missed or just freeze.
- eszed 2y agoYes, exactly! What's really exciting is that you will have trained yourself to think your way through the material in the same way that Wilde - or Shakespeare, or Beckett, or whoever - did. It's mind-expanding, in the best possible way. When I was in a classical piece I'd usually come off stage speaking iambics or couplets for a while, without ever meaning to.
- bloak 2y agoThat sounds great for the cinema: if it goes off the rails the director can let it run for a bit if it looks some great improv or else shout CUT if it doesn't. However, on the stage ... I'm not so sure ... your fellow actors might not be so flexible and you might need to help them. Also, stage drama doesn't necessarily aim for the kind of "naturally" that is expected in modern cinema: a lot of it is deliberately "theatrical" in one way of another. The audience can't see a slightly raised eyebrow so you can do some dramatic gesture with your arms for the audience while slightly raising your eyebrow to communicate something to your fellow actor. Perhaps. I don't have practical experience of this. I'm just speculating. I expect someone will tell me if I've got it all wrong.
- the_af 2y ago> However, on the stage ... I'm not so sure ... your fellow actors might not be so flexible and you might need to help them. Isn't this why they do stage rehearsals? Not so much to memorize the lines, but to see how each plays off the other actors. And it is while rehearsing that they can detect that something "isn't working". To me, what Michael Caine is saying seems essential for the stage, even more so than for cinema. For cinema, you can reshoot if a line or interaction feels unnatural. For theater you don't have this luxury. If you are saying out loud "memorized lines" you're really not paying attention to the other actor. Some theater is deliberately "artificial", but a lot isn't. And they definitely want to play off what the other actors are saying, otherwise it feels mechanical... which is what happens in unprofessional or kids' plays, everyone is "reciting" and it doesn't feel like a real play!
- ggm 2y agoThe tl;Dr is they do it by a massive investment in time and brainpower, mechanistically or not. Michael Caine contextualises it as living inside the characters mind. We can recall bashful by context is true. The depth of context an actor has to carry is far beyond that, it seems to go to motivation, intent and meaning in deep ways. The trope of an actor asking the director "what's my motivation" when they're a redshirt and die in scene 2 may actually be .. true: everyone probably has to know why they say what they say to remember to say it well.
- 082349872349872 2y agoI once asked a director "why do we spike the fine makeup station in three different fine places for the three backstage scenes?" and she replied "because the relationship between the younger actor and older actor changes between those scenes: in the first, the older is a mentor, and in the last, the younger has eclipsed him, so the angle of the station to the audience, literally upstaging the older actor, reflects his metaphorical upstaging during their careers." Not only did that make sense, but it's an example of even the scenery profiting from learning its motivation.
- eszed 2y agoIt's absolutely true, in the sense that everyone on stage / screen needs a strong internal logic for why they're doing what they're doing in order for that world to come to life. It's a basically satirical trope in the sense that only a bad and unprofessional actor would need to ask the director to tell them what it should be! Generally the translation goes the other way. The director gives a external-result oriented note (like, "I need you to be more frantic, here"), and then the actor comes up with the reason why that would be the case.
- ravirajx7 2y agoWow! Brilliant Read. I love how our mind loves to read and visualize scripts and it's like in between infinite thoughts going within. The time we repeat we think in some different way thinking "Oh yeah! Now I understand this more". Curious to know from the people who have read a lots and lots of text or books or watched movies.
- quartesixte 2y agoI have read a lot. And contemplative re-reading certain passages or re-watching scenes truly does activate further analysis. For your mind no longer has to decode the surface layer and then has time to search for other patterns. The more you read or watch the faster this becomes. The neat part is when you can do a double or even triple reading near instantaneously. It’s a little trickier for films, but still possible. I believe this is how your friends who are really good at just breaking down meaning on first watch are doing it —- they have gained media literacy skills that let them take in scenes in a blink of an eye. Practice your memory, and you can also hold past scenes in your head as new scenes come up. New connections made there too. Once I get started on a piece of fiction, I don’t exactly see the text anymore either — my brain starts constructing a sort of movie/diorama in my head and every subsequent sentence builds it more and more. Makes reading fiction great and emotional/symbolic analysis great but funnily enough makes me a weak analyst of the language and craft itself. Made my years in undergrad ironically challenging.
- quartesixte 2y agoThis resonates. As a frequent public speaker and coach of others in public speaking, the top priority is to just deeply understand the material. The second priority is to create the habit write like you publicly speak (i.e develop a style). You put these together, and you have no choice but to explain it the way you’d have written it anyways. This enforces resilience against interruptions and allows for improvisation. But this is hard. It requires two great efforts: to deeply understand the material, and to craft a speaking/writing habit that makes for powerful, public speaking. It doesn’t surprise me then, that actors do the same.
- rurban 2y agoThis would only work for actors bring able to play themselves, and nothing else. The screenplay is not always written for a specific actor, there are strange lines there that you have to transport naturally. There is where the method helps. play different personalities.
- stdbrouw 2y agoI'd add to those the necessity to have some distance from the material to avoid the recency effect. You can have that distance either because you'll be talking about something you haven't worked on for at least a couple of weeks, or because you've developed an ability to retain a birds eye view and adopt an outsider's perspective even when you're in the weeds. A lot of academic talks go wrong because, although the speaker deeply understands their topic, that teeny tiny detail that they were fiddling with yesterday is really not the thing they should try to communicate today, but they can't help themselves. Yet ask that same person to talk about their previous work, and you'll get a high quality impromptu introduction to the field.
- boerseth 2y agoI am reminded of Socrates, who lamented the practice of memorization being replaced with writing. Today one might dismiss this idea as silly, since memorization alone is frequently associated with dumb parroting and regurgitation, neither of which imply any depth of understanding. But from this discussion, we see the old man may have been on to something! If understanding something deeply is necessary in order to memorize it well, then one might achieve understanding as a secondary effect by aiming to memorize something by heart.
- grondilu 2y agoMy experience with learning chess openings is comparable : repetition is necessary but not sufficient. You need to "work" on each line, thinking deeply about each one and trying to find associations either between them or with things you already know.
- _glass 2y agoWhen I was beginning acting, I was mostly afraid of this, memorizing the script. But then after getting experience from fellow actors and reading up on method, I realized how easy that part is. You anyway approach the script slowly, first maybe even using your own words. This way the words flow naturally later on. I was never afraid of the script, just about inauthentic acting, which really can happen. You have to deeply immerse yourself in the emotional world.
- Paddywack 2y agoMmmm. I think I intuitively study like this, but I often have issues recalling the original word. For example - remembering “shy” for the dwarf “Bashful”, my brain will cycle through heaps of synonyms trying to pick which one is right (while not not making a fool of myself).
- eszed 2y agoThose are the most revealing moments! When my brain goes to a synonym it tells me that I understand the scene, but not the character. There's something different about their perspective and mine: why did I think this, but they thought that? "Mistakes" like that are gifts. (This applies far beyond acting. Why did a co-worker explain a concept this way, instead of that? It'll tell you something about their thought process - and yours - if you give it some attention and some thought.)
- Paddywack 2y agoThanks - such an awesome perspective! I’ll pay more attention to the character and see how it goes! It will save a lot of internal frustration if I nail that!
- eszed 2y agoIt goes as far as you want to take it, because every detail counts. I've done some long, long runs, and the ~300th performance is more interesting than the first. You get down to where you're working at the syllable level - noticing, for instance, that moving on this word, rather than that one changes the whole dynamic of the scene. You have to be blessed with a good script, and cast mates who'll follow you down the rabbit-hole, of course, but there's no bottom to it. It's endlessly interesting work, and deeply, deeply satisfying.
- coldpie 2y ago> I've done some long, long runs, and the ~300th performance is more interesting than the first. Your description really meshes with my experience playing classical guitar. It takes a few months of work to memorize the piece, but then the fun begins. I've played the same piece hundreds of times. Instead of it getting boring, I keep noticing some new thing in the piece every week, it constantly feels "new." Bring out the bass for these two beats on this measure; hold this melody note just a tad longer; the harmony in these two measures makes for a great descending line, make sure the notes connect. Stuff you don't notice on your first couple dozen plays, that endless repetition starts to bring out. It doesn't work for every piece, but for my favorites, it's really a bottomless hole, like you said.
- asimpletune 2y agoSomeone recently told me that they couldn't remember and recite historical stuff because it wasn't like math, which they could reconstruct from first principles. I replied that if you can begin to understand something you can begin to remember it.
- eru 2y agoThe bar isn't even all that high: your brain just needs a plausible story, but it doesn't really need to 'understand' anything. So a complete bonkers 'understanding' of history might still be perfectly serviceable to help you memorise it.
- WalterBright 2y agoOne glaring difference between acted speech and real speech is actors don't interrupt each other. Real conversations are often a bit of a mess.
- emmanueloga_ 2y agoSometimes they do! (to great effect). I feel a bunch of Woody Allen movies capture this (real conversations) pretty well.
- coldpie 2y agoOh MAN this is one of those things many script writers do (especially in video games) that drives me nuts. You can tell from the actor's line reading that the script read, "Don't tell me what--" to indicate that the speech was interrupted. But the actor reading the line just kind of awkwardly stops speaking after "what," instead of continuing the line and actually being interrupted. It seems to me, not being a script writer, like an incredibly obvious thing to avoid doing. Like if it's this obvious to me, then everyone who touches that script should know not to do that. How did it make it through so many people (writer, VA director, actor) with no one saying anything about it? But it keeps happening, over and over, so there must be something in that writing & acting process that I'm not aware of.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoI would imagine that in video games, it sounds so unnatural because the actors aren't actually performing together. The two people recorded those lines separately, so an interaction like that just isn't going to sound good.
- nyc111 2y agoBut there is a huge difference between film acting and theatre acting. In film you just memorize your daily lines. What I find magical is how these actors go into character and deliver a line naturally for that character. I assume for serious work they practice with their own acting coach behind the scenes and then also practice during the shoot according to the directives of the director. Here Nuri Bilge Ceylan shows how to eat walnuts https://youtu.be/G6_pwltI85Q?si=2NXm1HP54YbAhepV https://youtu.be/G6_pwltI85Q?si=2NXm1HP54YbAhepV It looks like the delivery of lines are the least important part. (In Turkish, but you'll get the gist of what he is saying.)
- dgan 2y agoMy random thoughts : human memory is more like linked lists, rather than hash tables At some point i was bored and wanted to learn by heart a pretty long poem (Lermontov, Demon). I was able to recite it for 15 min straight t normal talking speed, but if you d ask me to start in the middle, i wouldn't be able to. I had to come back to a known point, and go on from that
- Ekaros 2y agoRandom access is interesting. I have not used enough alphabet or months name to be able to place them right immediately. On other hand most numbers in 10x10 table come out straight or with pretty fast mental tricks. Or maybe some numeric things are just more memorable for me.
- ramenbytes 2y agoI can't find it right now, but there was a conference proceedings detailing efforts structuring human thought around cons cells.
- mcmoor 2y agoThis is also what I realized when memorizing Qur'an. It's really felt when there are some similar "nodes" that makes you confused on what should be the next node. Like if line 1, 16, 78 is almost the same, when you encounter one of them you'll be confused whether to continue to line 2, 17, or 79.
- n_plus_1_acc 2y agoI also have problems continuing with the right verse after the chorus of pop songs.
- LouisSayers 2y agoYou can get around this by creating memory palaces and breaking up the task into chunks and then inserting the chunks into places within your palace. Then you have direct access to the start of each chunk, so like a hash table of linked lists.
- 2y ago
- ajb 2y agoAt least some actors do do the initial memorization by repetition, which also tells us something about memory: the process is to try to recall lines 1-10, then repeat with lines 2-11, then 3-12 etc. At each step it may be necessary to look at a line but then hide it again before performing the act of recalling. This illustrates two things about memory: attempting to recall is the thing that causes you to remember, and also that to enter longer term memory is necessary to recall from that, rather than short term memory. Which the above process does by thrashing short term memory with too much data to fit. This doesn't get you to perfection, probably the process described in the article is necessary as there next step.
- PandaRider 2y agoAs a long-time Anki user (and memory enthusiast), I would like to offer some caveats for those transferring actors' memorization techniques to study techniques (programming languages, chemistry, math etc...) > This deep understanding of a script is achieved by actors asking goal-directed questions, such as “Am I angry with her when I say this?” 1. Do embed emotions. For example: Go's CamelCase for exporting variables implies capital letters want to be loud. 2. Do invoke experience. Don't merely read and write code, teach it and activate multiple sensory inputs and multiple contexts! > Deep, elaborative processing enhances understanding by relating something you are trying to learn to things you already known 3. Do chunk it. Instead of creating new standalone memories, chunk it with other programming languages' syntax. In summary, while engaging with the material is important, it is not sufficient for passive tasks (how many times have you read a book and forgotten the main points?).
- breck 2y agoAlong similar lines, Louis CK said he does not write down his material (or at least, did not until recently). He explained that _knowing_ rather than _memorizing_ makes it come out more natural.
- wintercarver 2y agoIf you enjoyed this article I’d recommend checking out the book _Moonwalking with Einstein_ by Joshua Foer. Great read and fascinating dive into the lives and practices of individuals that participate in memory competitions.
- sethammons 2y agoTell a professional the goal, not prescribe the steps. It works for convincing dialogue between actors and effective product delivery from developers. You could stretch this to avoiding micromanaging.
- circlefavshape 2y agoInteresting - as a singer I always memorize words by ... well, just by memorization. When I've been in (amateur) theatre stuff I've always been struck by how much more difficult it is to learn words that don't rhyme, but it never occurred to me that there might be other techniques apart from plain old repetition
- phtrivier 2y agoAnecdotal: for the specific case of "freshly written standup comedy routine", mental palaces [1] have proven effective, at least for me. Once you remember that "your next joke is about x,y,z", it's pretty easy to remember the joke itself. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Method_of_loci https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Method_of_loci
- follower 2y agoFortunately memorization isn't a requirement for stand-up or my stint performing it might've ended up even shorter than it already was. :D Like general public-speaking, approaches used by individuals to prepare/perform stand-up do seem to vary based on personal preference/comfort/style. (In a similar way I wasn't a fan of/good at "rote memorization" in my academic life either.)
- d--b 2y agoThis reminds me of Borges’s short story Pierre Menard, author of the Quijote in which a 20th century author called Pierre Menard steps in the shoes of Cervantes so much so that he actually re-writes Don Quijote, line by line, not because he wants to copy it, but because it makes sense to him at the moment when he writes it. A bit difficult to explain but it’s a must-read! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Menard,_Author_of_the_Quixote https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Menard,_Author_of_the...
- Tao3300 2y ago> Borges wrote the story while recovering from a head injury. It was intended as a test to discover whether his creativity had survived the severe septicaemia that had set in after his head wound became infected. I never knew that part. Adds a whole new dimension to the narrative when you think about it.
- follower 2y agoWell, that seems intriguingly topical in the current era of LLMs & occurrences of their verbatim reproduction of training data... :) Perhaps it's not mindless reproduction of the training data, rather, entirely mindful reproduction... :D The Wikipedia page notes: "Pierre Menard is often used to raise questions and discussion about the nature of authorship, appropriation, and interpretation."
- rapjr9 2y agoSo it seems like a corrollary of this would be that people do not remember what they do not understand and what they can not place in context, which could explain a lot of human behavior. If you do not understand something it mostly does not exist for you, you never remember it and never think about it. This is why complexity is used to hide and deceive.
- ape4 2y agoSomebody needs to write a play consisting of random words as a test of this ;)
- doctorhandshake 2y agoSomewhat related: there is an improvisation exercise in which two actors repeat one word only, back and forth, and follow the emotions they feel naturally. Frequently this results in what tonally sounds like a conversation, or an argument, etc., albeit free of semantic value.
- akavel 2y agoOk, so this interestingly connects in my mind with how older religions see it as important to teach their holy texts by heart (e.g., Jews learning the Bible, or Muslims learning the Koran): this article's claim seems to support the idea, that it should lead to a better understanding of the meaning of, and behind, the text.
- jnordwick 2y agoI've taken some Meisner technique workshops, and this is what changed my view of acting: > “Acting is the ability to behave absolutely truthfully under the imaginary circumstances.” The Meisner Technique is a brick-by-brick process designed to get you out of your head and into your gut. For that to happen, you must learn to put your focus and attention on the most important thing: the other actor." Actors under this don't pretend, they are. A lot of actors will practice their lines with just reading and reciting, no attempt at tone or inflection -- just flat recitation -- because if you aren't responding to the other actors you are just pretending. A lot of the warmup exercises are based around just responding to the other person in front of you. And they are a great way to get better at talking to people -- that's why I took the classes. Stella Adler has a great quote: "Growth as an actor and as a human being are synonymous.” I find it so much easier to remember lines with the other person in front of me - I don't memorize random facts well. They always have a connection to something else and I have hop from stone to stone of thoughts sometimes to remember what I was trying to sometimes.
- barbariangrunge 2y agoI’d love to hear any other details you or anyone else would care to share. I’m making an audio drama as a hobby and have never directed before, and most of my actors will be untrained volunteers. Posts like yours are so interesting
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gottorf 2y ago> you must learn to put your focus and attention on the most important thing: the other actor. Famously, Sir Ian McKellen had an emotional breakdown while filming The Hobbit due to extended stretches of talking not to other actors, but a greenscreen.
- anigbrowl 2y agoEven without greenscreen, actors in film and TV have to split their attention in unnatural ways. To preserve eyeline continuity in close-ups, actors often have to address themselves to a tennis ball or something near the camera lens, while their partner in the scene stands behind the camera. In the worst case scenario, sometimes the other actor is not even there when the closeups are being shot.
- risfriend 2y agoSomehow reminded me of how Michael Scott remembers things: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSi41cNvmXQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSi41cNvmXQ
- jjk166 2y agoAs someone who acts in their spare time, I think the article is missing three things. First, actors do actually have to mechanistically memorize their lines in addition to understanding them. There are plenty of instances where you need to recite a long string of words in precise order because that's what's in the script, not because there is some underlying logic that makes the word choice self-evident. While early in the rehearsal process it doesn't matter, in fact it's a good thing to play around with the script, by the end you need to have everything locked down. There is more to theater than just conveying a character's state of mind - people depend on spoken cues, particularly for blocking, and maintaining timing is critical. On the flipside of that, theater is inherently a variable thing. No two shows are going to be exactly the same. A prop may not function correctly, someone else may mess up a line, the audience may laugh more or less at a joke, etc. You need to be able to adapt in the moment, which means you can't simply remember your lines, you need to be present in the moment. That's the real reason you need to understand your lines. As an aside, it helps that the audience typically does not have the script memorized, so as long as things on stage are progressing naturally, mistakes tend to go unnoticed. Finally, I think people grossly overestimate the difficulty of memorizing text. We invented language long before writing, and it is extremely optimized for being easily remembered by illiterate peasants. Think about how many songs you know - there are probably hundreds if not thousands you could easily sing along to even if you haven't heard them in years. Think about how many movie quotes you can recall to interject a random pop culture reference into a conversation on the fly. Crack open a book you read 10 years ago to a random page and see how long it takes you to know exactly where in the story you are. You might mistake a word here and there, perhaps switch the order of some lines, but you'll remember the bulk of it without putting in any effort at all. Actors reread their scripts dozens of times, they put as great deal of effort into practice, and their success depends upon this effort, of course the end result will be more polished than baseline memory, but the difference isn't that big.
- tasty_freeze 2y ago> Think about how many songs you know - there are probably hundreds if not thousands you could easily sing along to even if you haven't heard them in years. If what you said was true, there would be no need for the lyrics display at karoke bars. Years ago (25?) there was a game where you'd draw a card and then have to sing part of that song (I forget the actual game as it was long ago, but that is close enough). Everyone was psyched and it seemed like it was going to be fun. Then we found out none of us actually remembered the lyrics -- we could get part of the chorus and that was it. No doubt there are people who are great at remembering lyrics, but I strongly suspect it is a small minority of people. I think people overestimate their recall ability because they are singing along to the song in their car (or wherever) and so if they have a moment's hesitation or any doubt, the song keeps going and they are quickly back on track. But without that unfailing guide, they'd quickly fall off the rails. I have that experience all the time as a musician of moderate ability in a moderate cover song band. Everyone has the experience of learning a new song, thinking "I have this song wired -- I can play flawlessly along to the original" but then the band gets together and tries the song for the first time and it quickly falls apart. Any little bit of hesitation or doubt quickly grows and infects the other players and soon people start arguing if the drums come in after the 2nd or 4th repetition of some phrase, etc, etc.
- renewiltord 2y agoFunny. Perhaps that’s the only way to do it. At one point in my life, I was part of a theatre troupe playing small locations for obscure plays. On one occasion, there I was in the scene and my line coming up in 30 seconds. A twinge of fear as I realized I had no clue what to say. The fear rose steadily, culminating in abject terror till one of the other actors turned to me and cued me up - at which point it all just flowed. Awareness of self outside of what you’re playing just destroys that flow state. It’s like that whether I think about the shuttle, the table tennis ball, or acting.
- austin-cheney 2y agoThe same strategy works for transforming a written essay into a memorized talk in front of an audience.
- follower 2y agoThe following remark in the article reminded me of one of the points raised in a video[0] on the "Answer in Progress" YouTube channel: "Deep understanding involves focusing your attention on the underlying meaning of an item or event, and each of us can use this strategy to enhance everyday retention." The AIP video is motivated by Sabrina's (video creator/presenter) frustration around having a memory that "sucks": "I can't remember a lot of the things I have done. I can't remember a lot of the things I'm supposed to do..." One of the points raised in the video was: "The most important thing for memory when an event is happening is to pay attention to it." Which seems to be consistent with the view expressed in the article. If memory is a topic of interest to you, you might find the AIP video a worthwhile watch: After investigating memory related research and conversations with people who have memorization related experience (both theoretical and practical) an attempt to memorise & recite 3,141 digits of pi in front of a theatre audience is made... (And, even if it's not a topic of interest, Sabrina's approach to both research[1] and presentation generally makes the result both informative and entertaining.) ---- footnotes ---- [0] "i memorized 3,141 digits of pi to prove a point": https://www.youtube.com/embed/KAjkicwrD4I https://www.youtube.com/embed/KAjkicwrD4I [1] As a university graduate with a focus in math, economics, & statistics, who often develops software tools during video creation process.
- alimw 2y agoThe words "cart" and "horse" spring to mind, in that order.
- golemotron 2y agoI wonder what the equivalent is for musicians who work without scores? Getting into the feel and emotional direction of the music you are playing?
- mariocesar 2y agoIt makes me remember Pedro Pascal and how he memorized scripts: https://people.com/pedro-pascal-reveals-tedious-way-he-memorizes-lines-8584716 https://people.com/pedro-pascal-reveals-tedious-way-he-memor... > "You use the first letter of each word in these sort of towers, these columns I guess," he said. "And then it's this very, very tedious way of making yourself learn the line." Reading the comments here on HN, I think it's safe to say that you need a combination of mechanical repeating and learning by heart.
- QuantumGood 2y agoI've trained voice actors for over 20 years, and the visual cortex being constantly activated as you are forced to stare at the words is a major problem for most actors. We have a variety of techniques for helping with this, but the one that works the best is "micro memorization": take a single sound group (linguistically, a speech chunk) of 2-6 words and repeat them with eyes closed. Anything longer and a small bit of anxiety ("am I remembering the words correctly?") creeps in and destroys naturalism. Eventually, the brain becomes attenuated to sharing meaning, not just words, and that becomes a habit that can be used when warming up a script you've never seen before. Also, just as a single multi-syllabic word follows a pitch and stress pattern, so do individual speech chunks. Speaking each chunk in the most natural /default pattern is difficult to learn to let happen naturally, and this exercise also builds skill in that area.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoVery interesting. It reminds of learning a music score on the piano--it works best, especially if you're not at an expert level, to learn a few measures and repeat those until you can execute them without thinking, and then move on to the next few measures.
- underlipton 2y agoOh, this is how you learn to draw. It's not copying or memorizing an arrangement of edges, it's learning how edges represent the shape, form, texture, and motion of an object. When you can draw something (particularly without reference), it's because you intrinsically understand that object's mass, volume, surface, and relation to other objects and its environment.
- davidrupp 2y agoI recently was asked to take over the role of Deputy Governor Danforth in The Crucible a week before opening. I accomplished it -- barely -- largely through rote memorization. Yes, I also had to imbue the words with appropriate intent and emotion, which I did not achieve by rote, but in a way it was comforting to have those specific words to start with, rather than make up some of my own that might or might not actually convey the proper intent, and almost surely not nearly as well as a luminary like Arthur Miller. As I see it, it's those words that establish my character, not the other way around. I like how Patrick Stewart puts it [1], as "dead letter perfect", which is apparently the default expectation in British theatre more so than, say, film acting. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2007/jul/29/theatre2 https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2007/jul/29/theatre2
- IndianScamOps 2y ago[dead]
- insane_dreamer 2y agoBut do actors do this because it helps them remember the lines better or because it's essential in order for the delivery to sound natural and not memorized. It has to be something that the actor, impersonating the character, would have said without being prompted. So if you can internalize the character, then the script is a logical result of what that character would naturally say--reducing the amount of exact memorization needed. But I'm not sure that it's necessarily that it improves memory itself. (Not saying it doesn't but there's a confound here, from a scientific perspective, that isn't easily disentangled).
- forgot-im-old 2y agoAs an aspiring actor in 1990, mastering the art of memorizing lines accurately has been a journey of both discipline and discovery. Initially, I struggled with the sheer volume of text, often feeling overwhelmed by the task. However, I soon realized that understanding the context and emotional underpinnings of my character was crucial. I began by breaking down the script into manageable sections, focusing on the motivations and relationships within each scene. I still felt repetition was my ally; I would recite lines repeatedly, both silently and aloud, until they felt second nature. Additionally, I found that visualizing the scenes and physically moving while rehearsing helped to cement the dialogue in my memory. Techniques like recording my lines and listening to them during commutes or integrating them into daily activities proved invaluable. Collaborating with fellow actors also enhanced my retention, as it allowed me to react organically and authentically during practice sessions. Over time, these methods coalesced into a robust strategy, enabling me to deliver my lines with confidence and precision, fully embodying the characters I portray.
- perch56 2y agoI was reading this comment and thought it looks AI generated. GPTZero’s scan resulted in detecting 100% of this text as likely AI generated.
- smeej 2y agoI wonder if/how this applies to memorization of long works that are not exclusively dialogue. Growing up, I knew a pastor who had memorized the entire New Testament. It wasn't a trick. You could drop your Bible open at any page, start reading half a sentence, and he could continue on from there as long as you wished. He really did have the entire thing committed to memory. When I asked him as a curious 12-year-old how he had done it, his answer was long on wisdom, but short on tactics. He said, "Don't overestimate what you can do in a year, but don't underestimate what you can do in a decade." Maybe that's the difference? Actors need to memorize their lines quickly, while he had as much time as he cared to use?
- aftoprokrustes 2y agoI actually came here to comment on how this memorization "technique" or "strategy" reminded me of what is done in some religions. Catholic meditation, for instance, is structured around _lectio divina_ and _meditatio_: the former means reading a sacred text slowly and attentively, "listening to it as if it was spoken by God". The latter means, after that careful reading, to ponder the text, take the time to reflect deeply on its possible meaning(s). I have no idea if your pastor had this kind of practice, but from the article, if he did, it might have helped him memorize the texts. And the memorization, in turn, moght help focusing more and more on the meaning, rather than the words. Also note that, as far as I know, all texts in the bible (except maybe some parts of the new testament, I am not sure) were transmitted orally for periods ranging from decades to centuries before being written down, and are structured in a way that helps memorization. We tend to think of memorization as unnecessary if we have unlimited access to the text, but this discussion actually makes me wonder whether memorization might be a powerful way to "unlock" the hidden meaning of some texts.
- smeej 2y agoI'm sure he loved the texts for their meaning. He dedicated his life to this work, after all. I find when I practice lectio and meditatio, though, I don't pay as much attention to the words as the images or sentiments or experiences that surround them. I spent the first half of my life (so far) in Evangelical circles, with that pastor, and became a Catholic in the second half, so have experience with both extensive rote memorization by chapter and verse, and now engaging the texts more comprehensively. Obviously there's also the difference between being a child and an adult, but I find that now I remember the sense of stories when I refer to them, not the actual text, except when I call to mind some fragment of a quotation from my childhood. I don't think either is necessarily better, and it's entirely likely to me that my overall growth in age and maturity would have led me to this deeper experience even if I hadn't converted. I just don't find it quite as helpful for memorization. By way of tangential analogy, my current (Catholic) pastor regularly tells the parishioners not to take it when non-Catholics accuse us of not knowing the Scriptures. He pointed out that not once has anyone in the congregation been surprised at how the reading ended. He says Protestants and Evangelicals tend to know Scripture like a mailman knows a neighborhood. They know the street names and numbers and can easily find them on a map. But Catholics know Scripture like families who grew up in the neighborhood. They may not know what number house Mrs. Jones lives in, but they know the Smiths lived there until Junior went off to college, and wasn't that the same year Younger Brother fell out of the tree on the corner and busted up his arm?
- r0m4n0 2y agoThis is interesting because I watch my wife who is a professional actor memorize long plays with truly mind boggling preciseness. Although understanding meaning is probably pretty important, for someone to truly be “word perfect”, meaning is not enough. You don’t want to forget small words that have little meaning. Her technique involves getting most of the way there then writing the first letter from all of her lines in a notebook and memorizing that. Kind of crazy
- motohagiography 2y agoperseverence is necessary to establish perfection. it's just reps. about 7-8x a year I memorize and perform monologues, usually several minutes in length with complete precision and without notes, which I have less than a couple of weeks to learn. I've tried memory palaces and mnemonics, but there is no substitute for just repeating it. even with spaced repetition most people emphasize the spaced and neglect the repetition part. just work harder, and when you're successful, give bad advice that knocks the ladder away behind you so people think you're a genius.
- gracebekcy 2y ago[dead]
- gcanyon 2y agoTo remember the seven dwarves: "two 's's, two 'd's, three emotions": Sleepy, Sneezy Dopey, Doc Happy, Bashful, Grumpy
- interludead 2y agoIn general, I did the same thing when I was learning poems. First, I immersed myself in the meaning of the poem, the story, the logic of the poem's construction, and the words would settle into my memory much more easily and quickly.