5 ms·
This needs a third-party evaluation. Nobody gets that much power from rooftop wind with small devices. Usually you need at least 16 square meters of intake area
by Animats 2y ago
This needs a third-party evaluation. Nobody gets that much power from rooftop wind with small devices. Usually you need at least 16 square meters of intake area to get 5KW.
Some similar devices with iffy claims:
- EIP - encased turbine for rooftop mounting [1]
- Sheerwind (active about 2014-2017) Really big funnels. [2] Critique: [3]
If ducting a wind turbine would help, everyone would be doing it.
[1] http://eiptechnologies.com/ http://eiptechnologies.com/
[2] https://web.archive.org/web/20171221050330/http://sheerwind.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20171221050330/http://sheerwind....
[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HtjKXb5gko0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HtjKXb5gko0
- metadat 2y agoYes, their generation numbers are not definitively defined in TFA, not even as a concrete typical range.
- goda90 2y agoHere's another one, Ventum VX175: https://ventumdynamics.com/ https://ventumdynamics.com/ Regarding what you said about ducting, I don't think that's a fair assessment. Really big turbines are the biggest bang for your buck, but they aren't exactly duct-able. And on the flip side, really big turbines can't be built in a lot of places. So the question is, does ducting help smaller scale turbines, and will placing smaller scale turbines where big turbines won't fit going to be worthwhile?
- Animats 2y ago> So the question is, does ducting help smaller scale turbines, and will placing smaller scale turbines where big turbines won't fit going to be worthwhile? Simple ducting does help some. A group at Clarkson has been working on this. They have a wind tunnel, so they can get solid data. [1] They have a simple duct around a standard wind turbine. This gives the effect of more intake area, and they get almost twice the output power. Unclear if this is cheaper than just increasing the blade length. Many people have been down this road. There are many, many variants on experimental ducted wind turbines. Just search for "ducted wind turbine". There are very few installations. Here's one of the few.[2] They're demo installations on college campuses. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EXxA-RkwuRY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EXxA-RkwuRY [2] https://www.ductedwind.com/blog https://www.ductedwind.com/blog
- BMc2020 2y agoThis agrees with what little I remember. Energy you can get out depends on swept area, and these don't have much of that (different rules apply to funnel designs like this one but the concept is still applicable). Wind close to the ground is too turbulent to get much power out of as well (imagine how many times it can change from blow to suck and back in a minute). They could have solved these problems, but I didn't see anything very different at their website, just creative funneling of air through a turbine. I wish them luck though.
- KennyBlanken 2y agoI was going to say the same - there was a big fad for building-top wind generators and then everyone figured out that the airflow over a building is really turbulent, which makes it pretty shit for power generation. Ask anyone who sails; trees and buildings shield a lot of wind out to surprisingly far away. The reason the big boys work well is because they are much higher above the ground where the wind is stronger and more consistent. That's also why companies are trying to make kite and blimp based generators work. Only place I've seen the rooftop turbines work was at an airport where the giant open space around the terminal buildings means winds are more even and lower to the ground. It feels like off-grid people mostly use it as a supplement for the stormy bouts where winds are often strong when solar yield is low...or as a backup in case their solar system breaks. They're happy if they meet the needs of their fridge, for example. Modern fridges use an average of less than 100W; lower if they're not self-defrosting.
- erie 2y agoThere has been several startups for the past decades who have tried this an disappeared afterwards.The real and legitimate research, development and improvement of wind turbines have been plagued by fad wind turbines. Fad wind turbines fly around Amazon selling big claims at breakneck speeds.
- gmokki 2y agoI've been interested in this company that has made vertical axis wind turbines for harsh conditions for 40 years: https://windside.com/gallery/ https://windside.com/gallery/ They have very slowly started to sell to wider market. Clearly they have never aimed at being cheapest, but their advertised maintenance free installation is a big plus. And also that the models can generate electricity at wind speeds from 2m/s to 60m/s.
- bruce511 2y agoWhen we talk about solar it doesn't really matter if you want to generate 100w, 100kw or 1mw. You're pretty much using the same tech, and the pre-requisite is simple "sunshine". But wind is more complex. If you want to generate a lot, then you need space (to build a tower), height (higher is better) and size (bigger is MUCH better.) And wind. But if you just need a little, say 3kw, then you're not looking for the best possible outcome, you're looking for local outcome. Most of us are location bound. I want to generate energy here - because I use it here. There are constraints (noise, size, height etc.) that I live with. Sure, I've got solar, my roof is full of that. Let's stipulate that economically I'm better off adding more solar. Let's also stipulate that my roof is "full". I get quite a few windy days (and windy nights) a year. If I harvest 1kw/h, I'd be happy. If I generate excess I can sell it to the grid. The obvious answer is still a 3 or 5 bladed conventional wind turbine. But that is both visual, and can be noisy. Personally, I don't need it to compete economicly with solar. I don't need it to be "perfect wind efficient". All I need is around 3kw capacity (for 1kw output) in a residential friendly package. Solar has shown that individuals are prepared to spend capital on residential generation. And in sufficient volume to move the grid needle. I'd love to see similar opportunities for those with more wind and less sun.
- kibwen 2y agoNote that wind is a good complement to solar, because it's largely driven by the heat from the ground rising upward, so it tends to start picking up in the afternoon/evening as solar starts to dip.
- IshKebab 2y ago> 1 kw/h Try again...
- paulryanrogers 2y agoCan you elaborate? Some of us flunked out of EE.
- IshKebab 2y ago
- aorloff 2y agoThey also have a hurricane upgrade package. Now we're cookin with gas
- zo1 2y agoThe evaluation just needs to be for longevity, repairability and maintenance needs/costs. The big purpose of wind for a lot of small scale installs is to augment solar for night time and/or continuous base load assistance to it, and not as a primary source of generation. I'd immediately get something that just gives me a tiny 300w on average as it means my 5kwh battery lasts 5 hours at night instead of 3 (made up numbers). That puts me soooo close to being full off grid it's not even funny. People talking about return on investment, payback periods etc are completely screwing over the uptake of solar and other non renewable sources.
- klunger 2y agoIn 2013, I had an internship at a kind of industrial incubator and fund in Kongsberg, Norway[https://kongsberginnovasjon.no/?lang=en https://kongsberginnovasjon.no/?lang=en]. Although that was 11 years ago now, and a lot has certainly changed in the industry, physics has not. At the time, they had an explicit focus on alternative energy technologies, so recieved a lot of proposals similar to this. I do not remember the details of my analyses anymore, but I do remember that every single one of them was rejected because none of them passed a basic back-of-the-envelope plausibility evaluation. These projects basically fail because their output is poor compared to other solutions of similar or even lower cost. It is also important to consider how much energy it takes to manufacture their solution in the first place. How long does it take for them to actually become net carbon negative? Does it even happen in the lifetime of the product? Sometimes the answer is no (in which case, what is even the point?)
- vasco 2y agoThe point might be as simple as a big building wanting reduced bills or energy independence without thinking one iota about the environment. It can also be to just signal that your big building is progressive and innovative, to attract companies to your commercial real estate.
- __alexs 2y agoI spent 5 years working in wind microgeneration (but with helical turbines) and entirely agree. Rooftop solar works because it's cheap and simple to set up. Wind is not that. The structural and installation requirements result in relatively high fixed costs. To offset that you need to scale the size of the turbine, and maximise the time they spend spinning. You can only go so big on buildings and the built environment reduces your capacity factor because there's loads of buildings blocking the wind.
- gumby 2y agoIn an urban environment is there enough updraft from "heat island" effects to harvest the energy? I kinda assume not else someone would have done it already, but maybe my assumption is wrong because it wasn't economic before and could be now.
- __alexs 2y agoThere is some but not nearly enough to generate useful amounts of wind.
- userbinator 2y agoFor those who are looking for a more intuitive understanding of what 5kW is, that's 6.7HP.
- _Microft 2y agoMore comparisons: the power of water cookers, (a single) electric stove top and fan heaters are usually in the order of 2kW (at least in Europe with 230V AC)
- quickthrowman 2y ago5kW is just enough power for a 5 HP motor at 230v 3-phase (12.5A), and not quite enough power for a 5 HP motor @ 208v 3-phase (13.8A). If #14 wire was allowed for branch circuits in commercial construction, you could use those as your conductors, that’s how small these things are. NEMA motor ampacity table: https://www.galco.com/circuit/fla_rate.htm https://www.galco.com/circuit/fla_rate.htm