9 ms·
“Dark money” groups help private ISPs lobby against municipal broadband
- Ajay-p 2y agoDark money is such a weird phrase and a mischaracterized label. The practice is not unique to any one group or issue. "Dark money" - defined as funds raised for the purpose of influencing elections by nonprofit organizations that are not required to disclose the identities of their donors - is used by all interest groups, good and bad.
- Etheryte 2y agoI think it's a very fitting label? Money is being funnelled for or against a cause, but there is no visibility into who's behind it, same as in being left in the dark.
- abenga 2y agoBut mostly bad. People paying for good (or more specifically, something generally popular) don't need to hide what they're doing, as a general rule.
- gruez 2y ago>People paying for good (or more specifically, something generally popular) don't need to hide what they're doing Is there numbers on this? Because of how "dark money" is defined (ie. any sort of 501(c) nonprofit), technically any 501(c) charity (eg. even something like NAACP) is "dark money".
- Ajay-p 2y agoWhat's your definition of "good" ? In the past, the right for women to vote, to get an abortion, for gays to be married, for blacks to vote without fear of harm, were all "unpopular-to-power opinions" and deemed "bad." It only becomes "good" when you personally believe it to be.
- abenga 2y agoThat's why I clarified using "generally popular". I mean more like "keeping with today's mores", which is admittedly a moving target in the long term.
- abenga 2y agoThat's why I clarified using "generally popular". I mean more like "keeping with today's mores", which is admittedly a moving target in the long term.
- Ajay-p 2y agoOk, I understand, but the mores of the day can go in the wrong direction. We hope they are positive but there's no guarantee they will be today, or in the future. However your comment raises one major point about mores of the day: They were accepted then but found later to be awful. People can be wrong and later realize their mistake, it's not something we think about when supporting a cause; how will I be viewed in the future for this? Maybe we should.. Until then, anonymity in donating allows someone to express their opinions as they see the mores of the day to be, now, without fear of retribution, and protected for the distant future when they've realized how wrong they were and changed.
- afavour 2y ago> not required to disclose the identities of their donors This is the part that’s always bad. IMO “dark money” is the perfect term. Even if it’s in aid of a cause I agree with I still think the concept is sinister and would rather it not exist.
- Gormo 2y ago> This is the part that’s always bad. What's the reasoning here? How is that always bad? There seems to be a lot of potential for abuse in forcing everyone supporting any cause to publicly disclose their identity -- supporters of a given cause could be individually targeted by opponents; people could be intimidated into supporting causes they don't actually favor. There's a reason we cast secret ballots in elections, and I don't see much of a difference in the risk/reward equation when it comes to donations to nonprofits and social causes, whether political or not. And what benefit do you get from knowing the identities of everyone donating to a specific cause? Are you going to oppose something you already reject on its merits even more because someone you don't like is donating to it, or change your mind and start supporting it because someone you like does?
- afavour 2y agoPeople being able to donate anonymously to an effort to shape public opinion feels fundamentally wrong to me. If they believe in the position being pushed they should be happy to be publicly associated with it. If they aren’t then I’m very suspicious about why. EDIT: the post I replied to was edited after my reply to add a lot of context that it now looks like I’m ignoring. Sadly I don’t have the time to address it point by point, so to clarify: this comment is a reply to the first line of the parent comment only.
- Ajay-p 2y agoDepends on the position. Donating in favor of gay marriage was once seen as a very bad thing with many negative personal consequences. My parents gave money to stop Proposition 8, but I don't think they would have if they knew their names (at the time) would be made public. It's only wrong to those who disagree with the opinion being shaped.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoI don't know that it must be political. What makes dark money distinct is that the source is undisclosed. Anonymous money = dark money.
- nimbius 2y ago> defined as funds raised for the purpose of influencing elections by nonprofit organizations that are not required to disclose the identities of their donor "Dark money" is the alternate term most of the beltway prefers as it keeps them safe from RICO indictments and uncomfortable attention to the hypocritic duality of a country that practically river-dances to democracy. This is just political bribery with more steps and ceremony.
- throwaway13337 2y agoAnonymity is a tool for those who execute negative externalities on society escape attribution. That is true. It's also a tool for those with unpopular-to-power opinions express them without fear of retribution in a society that insufficiently protects them. When it comes to money, though, those with more of it usually have less to fear from retribution. In this way, speech through money is a fairly dubious argument. It's, on balance, a definite corrupting force. Dark money is a good term because it implies a negative thing and that negative thing is a good guess here.
- Ajay-p 2y agoAt one point, whether it's to give blacks the right to vote, gay marriage, abortion, or other "unpopular-to-power opinions," were financed through anonymity. You're proving my point - it's only a negative term to those who dislike the issue it is supporting.
- Gunax 2y agoThe implications of requiring disclosure are significant. Do we really want to pass a law that says books, pamphlets, blogs, etc. cannot be published anonymously? Do we want to limit the amount of pamphlets you can print because some people can afford to print a lot? For instance, your very comment is published under a throwaway. Couldn't we say that your comment, being an attempt to influence us, shouldn't be anonymous? After all, perhaps you could stand to personally benefit in some way?
- throwaway13337 2y agoThe argument I made is not that anonymity cannot serve a good purpose. It can. However, anonymity has a cost proportional to its impact. That cost is that the impact of the anonymous act will have no retribution. A person is more likely to act in a negative-sum way with anonymity. Still, anonymity is essential because it protects the underpowered in their expression. We as a society have said that, on balance, anonymity with speech is good. And I think that's reasonable. With money as speech, this logic is broken. Money is the purest form of power within our society. Giving money is an expression of power. The more money, the more power to express. We then get all the negatives of anonymity with none of the benefits. What's more, as those with money can express a lot more than those without, the negatives are amplified. Another way to think of it is that freedom of expression as a sort of democratic value because it equalizes power. Speech as money removes the equality of it. To be more concrete, I believe that I can post anonymously but it would be dubious for me anonymously fund a lot of people posting here.
- j45 2y agoWhat would be a better word?
- mattmcknight 2y agoanonymous donor money
- j45 2y agoWord Obsfucated? Anonymized?
- legitster 2y agoThe article itself actually covers this point a bit: > Cannon said use of the phrase "dark money groups" when referring to 501(c)(4) organizations "often reveals a stunning level of ignorance." Cannon pointed to the Supreme Court's 1958 ruling in NAACP v. Alabama, which held that the NAACP did not have to provide its membership lists to the state. The court decided that "compelled disclosure of affiliation with groups engaged in advocacy may constitute... a restraint on freedom of association."
- jplrssn 2y agoLooking at the NoGovInternet site [1] mentioned in the article, their arguments against municipal broadband seem to mostly revolve around financial sustainability. They cite a paper that claims that 90% of such efforts fail to generate enough revenue to be self-sustaining. To me that seems like a strange argument against a municipal service. Surely no one expects other things like road maintenance to be financially self-sustaining? [1] https://www.nogovinternet.com/ https://www.nogovinternet.com/
- axus 2y agoThere might be some "good arguments" against increasing broadband competition through government action, but we all know the incumbents aren't funding these sites for love of a good debate.
- throwitaway222 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- schmidtleonard 2y agoOf course not, but the real objection is "it doesn't put money in my pocket" and they can't say that. The point of saying this instead is to make it just a little bit harder to debunk. Attention is a scarce resource, so that's enough to push it through.
- mminer237 2y agoWell in that case you're taxing people who don't use it to pay for it. If it can't get enough people wanting to use it at what it costs to run, I can see that as a good argument it shouldn't exist. (Though obviously I would take that data with a pile of salt.)
- Retric 2y ago
- throwitaway222 2y ago[flagged]
- vlovich123 2y agoWhile lobbying in some form has always existed, professional lobbying has exploded in the recent decades. Same goes for dark money which is a term to mean that the funding behind the lobbying is kept secret. For example, in 2006 there was ~$5.2M spent on it vs ~$1B in 2020. While the total number of lobbyists has stayed roughly the same since 1998, the amount of money spent on lobbying has skyrocketed. The truth is that we used to have better controls over money's influence on politics and it used to be criminalized and prosecuted better.
- pottertheotter 2y agoWhat they describe is literally the definition of dark money. Oxford Languages: "funds raised for the purpose of influencing elections by nonprofit organizations that are not required to disclose the identities of their donors." Wikipedia: "In politics, particularly the politics of the United States, dark money refers to spending to influence elections, public policy, and political discourse, where the source of the money is not disclosed to the public. In the United States, some types of nonprofit organizations may spend money on campaigns without disclosing who their donors are. The most common type of dark money group is the 501(c)(4) (often called social welfare organizations)." The article: "One prominent recent example is the "NoGovInternet" campaign run by the 501(c)(4) Domestic Policy Caucus. NoGovInternet has been fighting the UTOPIA (Utah Telecommunication Open Infrastructure Agency) fiber collective in Utah in what seems to be an attempt to dissuade other cities and towns from joining the multi-community network. The group's effort included TV ads as part of a campaign that reportedly cost $1 million. Nonprofits registered as 501(c)(4) "social welfare organizations" are allowed to engage in some political activity. Public broadband advocates suspect that 501(c)(4) groups fighting municipal networks are funded by private ISPs. There's evidence to support this belief: Even though 501(c)(4) groups don't have to reveal donors, they sometimes list ISPs as "partners" or as sponsors of a conference."
- chaps 2y agoMy prediction of municipal broadband is that someone down the line is going to submit a FOIA request for their neighbor's internet history and the municipality will accidentally fulfill the request in violation of the law. Or leak many millions' of peoples' internet history. Let's say, for example, a city hall member is on municipal WiFi on their personal phone while in-session. Instead of going through the difficulty of getting them to hand over their phone to a FOIA officer to search for responsive documents, why not just submit the FOIA to the municipal IT department and get the logs that way? Is there a good reason why this category of concern shouldn't actually be be a concern? edit: yes ISPs sell your data. that's a separate concern outside of this.
- jandrese 2y agoIs this any easier or harder than socially engineering the same logs out of a commercial ISP? Or just buying them outright because the commercial ISP has no legal obligations to keep the customer data private and already sells the data to brokers?
- chaps 2y agoIt's easier in that it's just an email and will probably be free. It's harder because it couldn't be a targeted attack and would need to rely on the failure of the people handling the request. But failures happen... constantly.
- cl0ckt0wer 2y agoWell, it's not like private companies aren't already selling your data: https://themarkup.org/privacy/2021/09/30/theres-a-multibillion-dollar-market-for-your-phones-location-data https://themarkup.org/privacy/2021/09/30/theres-a-multibilli...
- Gormo 2y agoYeah, I don't understand the arguments for "municipal broadband", which seems to be a euphemism for giving local governments monopoly control over ISP services. Why would we want political control in lieu of a competitive market and/or community nonprofits?
- legitster 2y agoOne niggly point I feel like making: When a lawmaker needs technical information about a proposal, they have to ask an industry professional. That industry professional may be paid to be there, and offers complementary research services to the lawmaker. (Or they may volunteer their time). This is lobbying, and oftentimes it's a good thing! I briefly worked for a lobbyist for a fisheries organization - he was paid by a fishing association to answer calls and put together reports about what sort of damage various laws were going to do to fish stock or fisherman's earnings for a particular region of Alaska. But it definitely creates a conflict of interest if only one side has someone there or that side is completely up-gunned. When a nonprofit group pays for political activities, I could see why someone might refer to it all as "lobbying". But if a lawmaker needs research or opinion from an industry professional, they are not going to call up someone from a "dark money" PAC when they can just get someone from Comcast on the line directly and all the free resources they might make available.
- ftth_finland 2y ago… or the lawmakers could (gasp!) do their damn jobs themselves and do their own research instead of relying on moneyed interests.
- pasc1878 2y agoNo - the lawmaker is a generalist and does not understand fully the issues for a particular proposal so they need a brief preferably from both sides. For example could you suggest the correct law for dealing with the environmental impact of a new building? If not where would you get the information from? Lawmakers do not have time to become experts in everything they deal with.
- ftth_finland 2y agoLawmakers being generalists does not preclude them commissioning their own research. Just being briefed on an issue from both sides isn’t sufficient, they could both be wrong.
- toastercat 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mrweasel 2y agoWhile I understand that the US is a much larger country, and to some extend have different requirements and the same things may not be profitable, why not "simply" require open access. The Danish fiber infrastructure is in large parts build by the power companies, because they where doing the digging anyway. Other parts are build by ISPs, or as municipal projects. Once the fiber, or cable, is established all ISP can use it. This ensures that all companies have almost the same coverage and can offer their services around the country, but cutting down on the cost, by preventing parallel infrastructure from being build. The areas where it's not financially viable to build out the infrastructure, like some islands, the municipalities or even the government, can step in an build the infrastructure, or pay a company to do it, and then leave the services to be offered by the ISPs.
- Enginerrrd 2y agoHow do they distribute bandwidth between the parties? What happens when a new company wants to use some bandwidth? Who pays for repairs and upgrades?
- mrweasel 2y agoThe company that owns the fiber, or cable, is allowed to charge a reasonable fee for managing the infrastructure. Because most of the companies owning the fibers aren't ISPs, but power companies or just infrastructure companies, the fee is normally the same for everyone. For bandwidth, I don't know, but they all share a database that customers can use to lookup what speeds are available for their address. I think what they do it that they have trunks coming in at various locations, so that after a certain point you transit from the fiber provider to the actual ISP. My fiber provide, which I never deal with, I only interact with the ISP, have connections to 130.000 homes and businesses. At their terminus the ISP needs to be present with a connection of their own, or more frequently, one they rent from back-haul providers. That allows me to pick from 13 different ISPs on a single fiber connections and about the same on the cable from the local cable-tv provider. Prices are pretty much identical, but then there are added services or the quality of the service where they differentiate.
- ftth_finland 2y ago
- tptacek 2y agoSeems like a waste of money? I'm on the commission in my wealthy, dense urban area that oversees questions like "should we municipal broadband" and it is really difficult to make the economics of doing that make sense.
- ftth_finland 2y agoIf your wealthy urban area’s needs are already being met, then obviously it makes little economical sense to overbuild.
- tptacek 2y agoMy understanding is that places like ours are the best case scenario with municipal broadband: most likely to see uptake (the lifeblood of these schemes), universal adoption of broadband, enough density to make last mile delivery feasible. But without significant scale and guaranteed uptake --- hard when you're competing with two household name ISPs --- the fixed costs of just running an ISP (or the backend infrastructure for a white-label ISP to build on top of) are prohibitive.
- ftth_finland 2y ago> My understanding is that places like ours are the best case scenario with municipal broadband: most likely to see uptake (the lifeblood of these schemes), universal adoption of broadband, enough density to make last mile delivery feasible. The best case scenario requires that the municipality is also underserved. > But without significant scale and guaranteed uptake --- hard when you're competing with two household name ISPs --- the fixed costs of just running an ISP (or the backend infrastructure for a white-label ISP to build on top of) are prohibitive. This is incorrect. Running an ISP is very cheap and the fixed costs are minor. It’s the building of a network that is expensive. Source: I personally run an ISP and have built multiple networks.
- tptacek 2y agoI've also run a relatively large (Chicago-scale) ISP. Here, we worked from minimal budgets and headcounts based on municipal networks in other states with published budgets; the costs are not minor. What I think I did there was misuse the term "fixed cost"; I was referring to the expenses we incur no matter how many residents opt in to the municipal network. Note that the economics here don't appear to work even given that we already have a municipal fiber network covering the whole municipality.
- guilhas 2y agoCan't understand what problem does public broadband solves At this point it would be for the gov to subsidise starlink terminals in economically unviable areas Opposed to health, trains, water other big infrastructures, internet seems pretty much a solved problem to be wasting money over it