5 ms·
Russia's glide bombs devastating Ukraine's cities on the cheap
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- logrot 2y ago[flagged]
- BugsJustFindMe 2y agoThe article makes a big deal about the gliding aspect, but the devastation it's talking about comes from being cheap retrofits of quite large bombs.
- melling 2y agoThey can released from a safe distance and have precision guidance(within 10 meters). Don’t put a 20 million jet at risk. The range seems to be about 60km? The weapons are large at 500kg: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FAB-500 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FAB-500
- pavlo 2y agoEspecially when the jets can release the bombs without entering Ukrainian airspace and not having to risk being shot down.
- rthnbgrredf 2y agoUkraine needs more airplanes themselves. With F16 they could shoot down russias Su-34.
- TiredOfLife 2y agoNot if they come with same restrictions as other us weapons.
- tim333 2y agoApparently they could shoot them down with patriot missiles except the US doesn't want them used in Russia territory. I'm not sure of the virtue of making Ukraine fight with one arm behind it's back where Russia can destroy all it can in Ukraine's territory but they are largely restricted on striking back in a similar way. I mean I can understand the desire not to escalate but it would seem reasonable to reciprocate whatever attacks the Russians are carrying out.
- hollerith 2y agoRussia destroyed 2 of Ukraine's Patriot launchers, causing Ukraine to decide to stop stationing them on the front lines. (Now they protect Ukrainian cities.) I think the argument you want is that if the US gave Ukraine a lot more patriot launchers, Ukraine would probably be willing to risk a few of them on the front lines.
- Hock88sdx 2y ago[dead]
- dragonwriter 2y agoThe devastation comes from the gliding aspect, which allows the bombs to be deployed from out of range of air defense systems, minimizing the defensive effect for Ukraine of Russia being unable to operate freely in the air over Ukraine.
- ChumpGPT 2y agoThe conditions the West has imposed on Ukraine are disgraceful.
- dantyti 2y agoto be fair, Ukrainians have shot down planes and helicopters in Russian airspace with Patriot batteries. The limiting conditions on doing more of that are ammunition (for cover), air defense interceptor and launcher shortages. Saying that the West is to blame for not producing cutting-edge interceptors (that are extremely in demand) as if they were knick-knacks is not entirely fair. I write this as someone who has donated a substantial percentage of my savings to support Ukrainian efforts.
- CamperBob2 2y agoProbably what the GP means is the requirement, imposed by the Biden administration, not to use US-supplied weapons to attack Russia directly.
- genman 2y agoIt is very risky to move high valued assets like Patriot batteries close to the front line as in that case these assets are within the reach of low distance surveillance tools Russia has in abundance. Doing this resulted in loss of actual Patriot systems in Ukraine - these were spotted by Russian surveillance drones and then attacked using ballistic missiles. Ukraine could instead attack launch sites on Russian territory - it has been proven to be highly effective in Crimea - but Ukraine is not allowed to use Western ballistic missiles for that.
- seventytwo 2y ago[flagged]
- exabrial 2y agoYou’re getting voted down which is unfortunate, because there’s a larger strategy here worth discussing. My opinion is thus: The US has learned from China’s low intensity conflict strategy. If the US had given Ukraine patriot batteries, F-16s, and tanks on day 1, The reaction from Russia could’ve been nuclear. As much as I want to see a bully get punched back in the face, It is not a good strategy to avoid disastrous escalation. Slowly ramping up the technology sent and uncuffing Ukraine gradually is the actual optimal path.
- SillyUsername 2y agoCan the UK's laser weapon Dragonfire take out these glide bombs on the cheap? That's in use now in Ukraine experimentally but 50KW seems like it might only be suitable for mortar rounds and light vehicle defence.
- timschmidt 2y agoThe glide bombs are very hard to track for directing anti-air fire, as they have no heat signature to speak of, emit no appreciable RF, and have relatively small radar cross sections. They're also moving very fast by the time they are near target.
- password54321 2y agoWhat is Zelenky's counterstrategy? "President Volodymyr Zelensky has repeatedly called for more air defence missiles and the supply of modern fighter jets." Genius.
- seventytwo 2y agoIf you have a better solution, why don’t you write a nice email to him. I’m sure he could use a brilliant military scientist like yourself…
- password54321 2y ago[flagged]
- schiffern 2y agoThis is war, not detecting too much salt (which arguable 'everyone' is an expert in). Complaints are cheap. If you can't say how or why a tactic is wrong, why should we believe you?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- password54321 2y agoNo one is going to give you an essay on what exactly they should do when they no one here even has all the intel. You can at best guess and present some technobabble that sounds plausible. But the current trajectory of the war and the perpetual cycle of asking for more should speak volumes on the current leadership.
- Someone 2y agoYou don’t criticize, you’re making an unsubstantiated claim. Criticizing requires making an argument, opening you up for counter-criticism.
- 2y ago
- coffeebeqn 2y agoWhat’s stopping Ukraine and its allies from building these? If they’re so cheap and simple. Let’s say you start pounding blocks down in the major cities in southwest Russia and see how they feel after that
- genman 2y agoExactly the opposite of what is not stopping Russia to do it.
- akira2501 2y ago> What’s stopping Ukraine and its allies from building these? A nuclear World War 3? > Let’s say you start pounding blocks Let's say we just start the peace negotiation process in earnest this time.
- squidbeak 2y agoWorld War 3 hasn't broken out despite Ukraine possesing JDAMs. Ukraine needs a powerful bargaining position before entering negotiations, and though it's regrettable this is the case, a powerful bargaining position derives from power on the battlefield. The best route to peace is therefore to give Ukraine as deadly a sting as possible.
- oblio 2y agoRussia's not going to use nukes, for the same reasons the US didn't use them in Korea or Vietnam or the USSR didn't in Afganistan.
- hollerith 2y agoThere was serious discussion in Washington of nuking China after China's entry into the Korean war. (Specifically, nuking concentrations of rice fields, causing starvation until the Beijing relents, at which time Washington would provide food aid.) When in the 1960s tensions between Moscow and Peking rose, Moscow asked Washington if Washington would be okay with Moscow's nuking China. (Washington replied with a firm no.) Although Russia is probably not going to resort to nukes, the risk is high enough that I wish my country (the US) had started drastically increasing American preparedness for nuclear war when it started sending military aid to Ukraine.
- monero-xmr 2y ago“Cheap but effective” is how all militaries outside of the well-financed West operate. One spends trillions on the most advanced planes and bombs and then the enemy sends retail drones with explosives.
- coffeebeqn 2y agoMost of the west since the Cold War has just assumed that they can have a show military since the US is the actual military power in their alliance.
- Beijinger 2y agoThe spending comparison may be inaccurate. The western military is grossly overcharged for their toys. Also: "Superiority" is a science fiction short story by British writer Arthur C. Clarke, first published in 1951. It depicts an arms race during an interstellar war. It shows the side which is more technologically advanced being defeated, despite its apparent superiority, because of its willingness to discard old technology without having fully perfected the new. Meanwhile, the enemy steadily built up a far larger arsenal of weapons that while more primitive were also more reliable. The story was at one point required reading for an industrial design course at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superiority_(short_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superiority_(short_story)
- mysterydip 2y agoI was under the impression that GPS was heavily disabled/interfered in the area. Do these use a different guidance system to reach their targets?
- born2discover 2y agoI would assume Russian military would not be relying on GPS but use GLONAS[1] instead. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GLONASS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GLONASS
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- seventytwo 2y agoRussia has its own constellation called GLONASS. It might be possible for Ukraine to jam that and GPS. I’m not sure how that would affect the bomb’s accuracy. I’m sure Ukraine is researching this.
- isubkhankulov 2y agoGPS is indeed jammed. Ordinance in such an environment often relies on interial navigation.
- 13of40 2y agoApparently they use a jamming-resistant GLONASS receiver module: https://mil.in.ua/en/articles/kometa-challenge-for-ukrainian-ew/ https://mil.in.ua/en/articles/kometa-challenge-for-ukrainian...
- LightHugger 2y agoGPS is almost never used for military guidance systems compared to inertial dead reckoning, GPS is too unreliable and easy to jam!
- sudosysgen 2y ago
- throwaway4good 2y agoAn article I read mentioned them taking a 1.5 ton bomb from 1965 (!!!) and putting a glide kit on it - thus adding a microcontroller, gps, wings, and electric motors. I am curious to see a teardown of the kit. Probably a lot of generic western components used just as with their drones.
- arprocter 2y agohttps://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/e4f0a90ddd7d4cd6b1d889704f6b2396 https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/e4f0a90ddd7d4cd6b1d8897...
- TMWNN 2y ago>An article I read mentioned them taking a 1.5 ton bomb from 1965 (!!!) and putting a glide kit on it - thus adding a microcontroller, gps, wings, and electric motors. As the article says, this is the Russian counterpart of the US JDAM. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Direct_Attack_Munition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Direct_Attack_Munition>
- cebert 2y agoIt’s crazy to me that $20,000 to $30,000 (£15,700-£23,600) is considered “cheap”.
- Detrytus 2y agoCheap relative to modern military equipment. Some bombs that US army uses cost north of $200,000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GBU-53/B_StormBreaker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GBU-53/B_StormBreaker Some of them are relatively cheap though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GBU-27_Paveway_III https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GBU-27_Paveway_III
- theshrike79 2y agoA Tomahawk cruise missile is about 1.3 million dollars
- nradov 2y agoIn a mobilized command economy like Russia today, monetary costs in terms of currency have mostly become meaningless. They're nominally paying in RUB which is basically "funny money" and no longer fully convertible to USD or UKP. Russian leaders don't really think in terms of monetary cost. It's more about making effective use of stockpiles and deciding how to allocate limited industrial production capacity. Most of the foreign manufacturing experts have left, and not many Russians have the skills necessary to mass produce precision parts anymore.
- Beijinger 2y agoWith the risk of getting downvoted, let me play the devil's advocate here. Russian economic growth hits 5.4% https://www.rt.com/business/597842-russia-economy-growth-quarter/ https://www.rt.com/business/597842-russia-economy-growth-qua... (Russian propaganda outlet. May not even open in your jurisdiction. Used it today because corruption allegations against Ursula von der Leyen appeared early there). The fight against Russian oligarchs has actually worked to the advantage of Putin. For the first time in 30 years, the oligarchs have to reinvest their money in Russia. I don't see a command economy. War expenditures are still pretty low measured in % GDP RUB which is basically "funny money". No, it isn't. Friends of mine converted dollar and rubles in Moscow easily. Western banks blocking SWIFT and other stuff makes financial transactions difficult. This does not mean the Ruble is worthless. Russia has a flat income and corporate tax of 13%. This may be eye watering for a westerner. Russia has raw materials, gas and oil. And little debt. I think the US has 300 times more debt and debt INTEREST payments have reached, according to a recent visual capitalist graph, 1 trillion USD per year alone. The war in Russia may not be winnable by the west. While the industrial might is bigger than that of Russia, China has more industrial capacity than the EU and US combined. And BRICS+ are working on their own currency to replace the dollar as the world reserve currency. Don't get me wrong. I am a western citizen, not from Russia or China as my nick may suggest, and not a fan of Putin. But it is very possible that Russia emerges as a major power from this conflict. Other outcomes are possible too of cause: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/13/ukraine-us-war-russia-john-pilger https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/13/ukrain...
- up2isomorphism 2y agoThis is just one fatal assumption that western had on Russia: they don’t know how to innovate and adapt to modern warfare. In fact it gave the western such impression only because it was not in a serious war for a long time.
- nradov 2y agoIf anything it's the opposite. Western military leaders have been shocked by how the Russians keep making the same avoidable errors over and over, and how long their cycle times are to adapt. Even today they don't really have a unified joint staff capable of gathering lessons learned and rapidly turning those into formal doctrine changes. But they do have the advantage of greater manpower and enormous equipment stockpiles, which compensates for a multitude of errors.
- dragonwriter 2y agoYeah, if there was a miscalculation of Russian capacity, it was not its ability to fight well, but its ability to absorb the cost of, and willingness to continue the campaign despite, fighting poorly, which is why actually scaling up production wasn’t an immediate response. Russia has taken (by the most conservative estimates) on the order of 10x both killed and wounded as the Soviet Union itself took in the nearly decade-long war in Afghanistan which was a major contribution to the collapse of the USSR in a little over two years.
- f38zf5vdt 2y agoThe West was startled by the fact that the Ukrainians were able to rout the Russians. Most Western analysts expected Russian to win in the event of an invasion and Zelenskyy pleaded with Putin not to invade the night prior. That Russia took almost 3 years and a presumed 300-500k casualties to begin deploying basic air support with guided glide bombs, like the west has been doing for 25 years, was indeed surprising. Every military has the ability to innovate and adapt because the life of every member of the military is on the line each day. It took an astounding number of embarrassments and lives lost for the Russian military to adapt, including a near coup by PMC Wagner.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- nojvek 2y agoRussia is playing the game of “I have nukes, so I’m gonna do whatever I want. I got tons of oil and customers flush with money. Smuggle rings to get whatever parts I need.” Ukraine is likely to lose. They’ve figured out precision destruction for less than a price of a car. Iran is likely to follow. Western weapons are better but too expensive. This is a war of attrition. Russia will keep on playing until Ukraine is bled dry. The counter strategy is to strike hot but they got nukes and not directly at war with NATO.