4 ms·
> grids were owned by many small regional power companies; thus, voltages and frequencies (42Hz was quite common) could vary a lot between each other It always
by lxgr 3y ago
> grids were owned by many small regional power companies; thus, voltages and frequencies (42Hz was quite common) could vary a lot between each other
It always amazes me that some countries are still operating on multiple mains voltages and/or frequencies while sharing a common plug standard, such as Brazil or notably Japan (where the 50/60 Hz division apparently runs through a densely populated area)!
Fortunately most devices I bring with me when traveling don't care and adapt to whatever, but being able to plug a 110 V hairdryer into a 230 V outlet without any form of adapter sounds scary.
- LeoPanthera 3y agoA difference in frequency is much less of an issue than a difference in voltage, I would have thought. Especially as 50 and 60Hz are fairly close to each other. The only big problems I can think of are devices that use the frequency as a reference, such as motors and clocks. But even then, they wouldn’t break, they’d just run at the wrong speed.
- rrr_oh_man 3y ago> The only big problems I can think of are devices that use the frequency as a reference, such as motors and clocks. This was my March mindfuck: That there are periods every couple weeks when the WHOLE ELECTRICITY GRID of a country is run with higher/lower frequency for a period of time to get your Chinese oven clocks back into sync.
- lxgr 3y agoLong-term grid frequency stability is something you take for granted, until it suddenly fails, like in most of Europe back in 2018, due to a political disagreement between Serbia and Kosovo: https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSL5N1QP2FF/ https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSL5N1QP2FF/ I also find it quite funny that our cheap oven clock is probably among the most precise (non-internet connected) ones in our apartment :)
- Scoundreller 3y agoWWVB de-rating has got us all a bit down in North America. Lots of consumer level “atomic clock accuracy” devices just don’t update any more. https://www.watchuseek.com/threads/wwvb-operating-with-reduced-power.5564472/ https://www.watchuseek.com/threads/wwvb-operating-with-reduc...
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIt’s a shame there aren’t more time tower sites broadcasting in a distributed manner for redundancy.
- Taniwha 3y agoNoted my car got time from GPS the other day and it got me thinking, why aren't there unencrypted packets on all wifi that distribute NTP time so my oven/microwave/alarm/etc can grab it from any wifi it can see (even if it's not paired to them) - bonus points if APs also hand out local TZ data
- joha4270 3y agoPhone networks can already do this. And its true broadcast, you can decode it passively without ever connecting to the network, so no SIM/transmission required. I have no idea this is actually enabled in networks in practice, but the specification exists.
- cesarb 3y agoAnd in my experience, it's often wrong on some towers. I can't enable the setting on my phone to automatically set the time from the network, because if I do, it gets several minutes out of sync with the real time, which breaks TOTP generation.
- lxgr 3y agoYeah, a large German cell provider had their time off by a couple of minutes some years back, which made the news as it resulted in people's alarms ringing late and them being late to work/school etc. Hopefully modern phones prioritize GPS or NTP derived time and timezone information over NITZ (which is how networks provide it). At least Android has the capability to do so, but it's ultimately up to device manufacturers, as far as I understand [1]. [1] https://source.android.com/docs/core/connect/time https://source.android.com/docs/core/connect/time
- AdamH12113 3y agoIt's surprisingly hard to keep a clock accurate over time. Typical crystal oscillators can gain or lose seconds per day. If you want to do better than that, you either need internet access (for NTP), a radio receiver of some kind (for atomic clock broadcasts, GPS, etc.), or a significantly more expensive oscillator. Having a frequency reference with perfect long-term accuracy that any electrically-powered clock can use for free is pretty convenient! I've often wondered how hard it would be to make portable battery-powered clocks use 60 Hz noise as a timekeeping source. Maybe I should make a project out of it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rrr_oh_man 3y ago> Typical crystal oscillators can gain or lose seconds per day. Are you sure? I only owned a quartz watch when I was a kid, but all sources I find on the web say even the lowest quality quartz watch movements are accurate to +- 20-30 seconds a month. For comparison: my several decades old manual Poljot loses some seconds per day.
- AdamH12113 3y agoThe Casio G-Shock I got in the 90s was ~66 ppm fast, which worked out to ~5 seconds/day. There are cheap crystals on Digi-Key with ~10 ppm accuracy, which is around 0.86 seconds/day. But crystals drift with age (and a tiny bit with temperature). Perhaps watches have improved since I last looked, but I would want to measure the actual real-world accuracy before believing anything better than 1 second/day.
- crote 3y agoYeah, that sounds about right. Crystal oscillators typically have an accuracy of about 20ppm, which is 1.73 seconds per day. Keep in mind that those number are a guaranteed worst-case performance - real-world performance is often much better.
- agos 3y agohow more expensive is a "more expensive" oscillator?
- Taniwha 3y agoThere used to be a local hydro generation that fed the local city, they had 2 clocks on the wall, one on the local grid and one on the national one - some time late at night they'd speed up/slow down the local grid to keep the clocks in sync
- pezezin 3y agoA difference in frequency is not that big of a problem... except for the fact that you can't easily transfer power across the two grids. Japan has some power conversion stations, but when the Tohoku earthquake and tsunami of 2011 knocked off several powerplants in the 50 Hz half of the country (including Fukushima), they could not transfer enough power from the other side, and the suffered many blackouts, even though the 60 Hz half of the country had power to spare.
- johannes1234321 3y ago> A difference in frequency is not that big of a problem... except for the fact that you can't easily transfer power across the two grids. And for everything, which uses the frequency as a clock.
- pezezin 3y agoTrue. Nowadays it is not a problem, but it makes me wonder how they could make 60 Hz television run on a 50 Hz grid.
- lxgr 3y agoI've been wondering that too recently, and apparently it wasn't that big of a deal [1] – more recent analog TVs weren't that susceptible to mains interference of the sort that benefited from being synchronized to the frame rate. In other words, the mains frequency was never used as a frequency source for TVs, and the apparent frequency match was only to make interference patterns not wander around the screen. [1] https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/164249/is-the-design-decision-for-different-frequencies-in-pal-and-ntsc-related-to-the https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/164249/is-th...
- lxgr 3y agoA motor running at 20% higher/16% lower speeds might break some things, I could imagine?
- quickthrowman 3y agoIf the motor is designed for it, then no. Many motors these days are built to handle variable frequencies on account of VFDs A variable-frequency drive is a motor controller that adjusts the frequency of the power delivered to a motor to speed it up or slow it down. It could possibly damage a motor that isn’t designed for use with a VFD. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable-frequency_drive https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable-frequency_drive
- mateus1 3y agoHere in Brazil we have voltages in different regions but we also have different voltages inside the home. My washer has its separate 220v circuit while the rest of the home is 110v.
- coryrc 3y agoDidn't know that was done outside north America.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lxgr 3y agoAs far as I know that’s usually a split-phase system: You get 110V between either phase and neutral, and 220V between the phases. In a three-phase system (like the ones used in most of Europe), that effect isn’t as pronounced since you usually have at most 120 degrees phase difference instead of 180 and the voltage between two phases is less than double, so less appliances make use of that (I think some stoves do).
- cesarb 3y ago> As far as I know that’s usually a split-phase system: You get 110V between either phase and neutral, and 220V between the phases. We Brazilians tend to call it "110V", but it's often a three-phase system with 127V between phase and neutral and 220V between phases. Or sometimes it's 115V from phase to neutral and 230V from phase to phase (probably a split-phase system like you said). And in that case, us Brazilians would still call the lower voltage "110V", and the higher voltage "220V". You can't trust a Brazilian when they say the voltage is "110V" or "220V". These numbers are only an approximation, which might have been correct for some places a century or two ago. And yes, it's a mess. Check the official list at https://www2.aneel.gov.br/aplicacoes/srd/frmConcessionaria.cfm https://www2.aneel.gov.br/aplicacoes/srd/frmConcessionaria.c... (link found at https://www.gov.br/aneel/pt-br/centrais-de-conteudos/relatorios-e-indicadores/distribuicao https://www.gov.br/aneel/pt-br/centrais-de-conteudos/relator...), which shows which voltages can be found in each city for the whole country. For instance, take a look at the city of São Paulo in the state of São Paulo (yes, it's the same name for the state and its capital city, this is also the case for Rio de Janeiro): - 115V / 230V - 120V / 208V - 127V / 220V - 220V / 380V - 220V / 440V A Brazilian would say "110V" for all these lower voltages between 115V and 127V, and would say "220V" for all these voltages between 208V and 230V. At least the frequency is always 60Hz (unlike the rest of South America, which uses 50Hz; we have to use HVDC links when importing or exporting electricity to the neighboring countries).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]