5 ms·
Downranking won't stop Google's deepfake porn problem, victims say
- richbell 3y ago> The search engine provides a path for victims to report that content whenever it appears in search results. And when processing these requests, Google also removes duplicates of any flagged deepfakes. > Google's spokesperson told Ars that in addition to lowering the links in the search results, Google is "continuing to decrease the visibility of involuntary synthetic pornography in Search" and plans to "develop more safeguards as this space evolves.” > ... > “Google has ruined lives and is shamefully inflexible at responding to developing problems,” Goldberg said, joining others decrying Google's move as "too little, too late." > Google's solution still largely puts the onus on victims to surface deepfakes and request removals, seemingly mostly because Google only proactively removes web results when content directly conflicts with the law or its content policies. While I'm usually highly critical of Google, it seems like they're already doing what they reasonable can? Google isn't hosting this content. Passing legislation is a necessary first step. Do we really want to set a precedent where Google is expected to proactively censors content that is, for all intents and purposes, legal?
- vouaobrasil 3y ago> Passing legislation is a necessary first step. Do we really want to set a precedent where Google is expected to proactively censors content that is, for all intents and purposes, legal? I would expect that in a sane society, everyone would do their part to stop something from happening when that thing is clearly bad, even if it is technically legal!
- richbell 3y agoWithin reason, sure. I don't think the demands being made are reasonable. Google is already doing their part to stop it from spreading, but they aren't the source. Compare that to something like malicious ads, which Google has full control over and directly benefits from.
- tekla 3y ago"clearly bad" is doing a fuck ton of work here.
- nerdjon 3y agoI kinda don't know how to feel about this one. This kinda seems like a continuation of the problem with revenge porn, child porn, etc just at a much larger scale and able to impact a lot more people. And that is a real problem and we should do what we can to product the victims. But I struggle with this quote: >. “Google has ruined lives and is shamefully inflexible at responding to developing problems,” Goldberg said, joining others decrying Google's move as "too little, too late." Google isn't the service that is generating these images, they are not hosting them, they are just the search engine to find where they are. Unless google blocks all porn related searches, I just don't know what realistically can be done about this from Google's prospective at any reasonable scale. The idea of a human looking at everything that google crawls just isn't realistic. And I have a lot of problems with Google. I just, am struggling with putting this on them specifically. Instead the legislation going after those that are hosting it, making it, etc which is mentioned in the article.
- f33d5173 3y ago*protect *perspective
- onemoresoop 3y agoThey are facilitators. If Google weren't so money hungry these kind of results wouldn't rank high enough to be discovered. They should probably continuously get fined until they alter their behavior.
- randunel 3y agoWhat should they be getting fined for? Ranking individual links according to some generic algorithm? Is there a law specifying what algorithms may be or not be used for individual or types of links?
- SpicyLemonZest 3y agoI don't follow what this has to do with money hunger. Is your contention that Google profits somehow from having these images be higher rather than lower in search results? Why would that be more profitable?
- superkuh 3y agoThe implicit premise of this article is that digitally edited photos and videos that appear like people actually are photos or videos of those people. This premise is false and so is all the reasoning that flows downhill from it. There are no 'victims' because there is no crime because there are no photos or videos of the victims involved. They're digitally created synthetics. It's not like photoshopping someone's face onto someone else's body is new. This is just hysteria exploited for attention which is money. Calls to criminalize digital image manipulation will result in situations where making fun of people in positions of power (political or celebrity, etc) results in prison; like in Saudia Arabia or Thailand. The implicitly proposed "solutions" do far worse damage than the "problem".
- commandlinefan 3y agoI wondered if anybody would have the courage to point this out, even on here.
- ozmodiar 3y agoI would equate this with a form of extreme slander, so your inference is wrong. They aren't a problem because they are real, they are a problem because they can be passed off as real, and the issue is in the reputational damage. I'm not saying there's a good solution but I don't think the problem should be dismissed so easily.
- johngladtj 3y agoThere is no slander here because there is no expectation that those are the actual people doing it.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoIANAL, but I'm curious: could watermarking (or prefacing) such videos with a "deepfake" indicator diffuse the slander liability?
- Ferret7446 2y agoBut if they were not yet passed off as real, is it pre-crime? If I create a satirical fictional work about someone, is it "extreme slander" because a portion can be taken out of context and presented as real? Should my work be preemptively censored?
- DNied 3y agoAs usual with tech giants, the burden of playing whack-a-mole with the perpetrators is left to the victims, while the company profits.
- more_corn 3y agoThis is nonconsensual so we should stop calling it porn. Sexualizing someone without consent is a crime. It is important to differentiate legal and illegal sexual content.
- Ferret7446 2y ago> Sexualizing someone without consent is a crime It is not, "sexualizing" isn't even well defined, and it isn't even enforceable without mind reading technology.
- rKarpinski 3y ago> "I'm here standing up and shouting for change, fighting for laws, so no one else has to feel as lost and powerless as I did," 14-year-old Mani said Don't existing child pornography laws and school code of conduct cover the 14 year old's case in NJ?
- lunaticlabs 2y agoI moved to Germany from the US, and broadly speaking (I have my own issues with German policies and politics) I like the system here better. In Germany, outside of being a “public” figure, you own the rights to your own image. Without explicit consent and compensation, you are not allowed to distribute photos of anyone. There are specific carve outs for notable events (if you are incidentally in a shot for something else, it doesn’t count), but otherwise seems notably reasonable to me. It definitely seemed odd when I first moved here, but seeing it in practice it seems fine.