8 ms·
The Age of Rage: Why Are People Are So Angry?
- relaxing 3y agoBefore we had spam there was junk mail and yes people complained about it.
- ofcourseyoudo 3y ago1. Any piece that uses Haidt's "Coddling" essay early on as support is questionable because that piece is horseshit 2. I'd be very interested to read something interrogating the Gallup poll quoted early... it seems to have interesting but vague questions like "Are you satisfied with the current size and power of the federal government?" or "Are you satisfied with the influence of organized religion?" ... but since people's different viewpoints would cause conflicting result-based reactions to those questions (if there was zero organized religion I would be VERY satisfied while certainly other people would call that disastrous)... then doesn't the Gallup poll at least partially become not about the direction of the country but how well the powers that be are "selling" the direction of the country?
- ovulator 3y agoTo address your second point, it is merely about satisfaction, not solutions or best optimal outcomes. The question is neutral to what the current state is or what the future state should be, only on their satisfaction with it. There isn't really a conflicting result if 50% of the people think we should live in a theocracy and 50% think religion should be outlawed if 0% of them are satisfied with the status quo.
- incomingpain 3y ago>Why are we living in an age of anger – is it because of the 50-year rage cycle? The cycle is 75-100 years. Pretty well documented, and happily increasing. We are in that post-great depression, pre-world war spot. Or if looking at the previous cycle it's the american civil war or if looking at the previous cycle it's the age of revolution. >And from CNN in 2022, “American happiness hits record lows.” Or from Gallup in 2024, “The percentage of Americans ‘very’ satisfied with lives near record low”: Nobody will deny that we live in the age of rage. >Viral videos on X/Twitter of societal breakdown are algorithmically promoted to millions, such as looting and physical violence, creating the perception by the public that lawlessness reigns and consequently having the effect of making people less trusting of each other. Overstating the amount of damage to trust that any of these are causing. At best you're pointing at the trend. >a more atomistic and less trusting society may also mean a less violent one, save for the occasional mass shooting I own a 22lr cooey that's old enough that it has been to a high school gun range MANY times. Why did we go from a society which could bring guns to school to 'mass shooting' is a key one in understanding what shifted. This has been ongoing since Columbine. >?Or the post-2010s rise in teen anxiety as documented by social psychologist Jonathan Haidt, which he blames on social media. You literally quote that the problem was identified in the 1990s with bowling alone, thus this blame on social media is just wrong. >All of this breeds well-earned resentment by the public against policy and business-elites. People know they are angry, but the reason behind the rage is being censored. You're not allowed to talk about what is causing the rage. But incidentally because you cant talk about it, you cant fix the rage and political polarization.
- hscontinuity 3y agoThis again leads me to believe that we as humans have not and may not evolve past the |individual| and breach the theoretical line between what is good for one (me) and what is good for all (everyone). Only when we as humans evolve our philosophy of existence in a manner which puts our continuity above all else, will we progress to our next universal evolutionary jump. Until then only modest progress will continue slowly understanding limitations of physical matter (resource depletion and renewing), social strife churning at a snail's pace (the entire world is uneven at many levels socio-economically), war among ourselves will continue (instead of protection from outside or unknown source, we force offensive military campaigns to manage more of the above), and lastly academia has been inundated with the likes of Catholic Hereticism in the likes of Galileo style subjection. We're nowhere close to evolving as a species on the whole. Combined with the perceived ideology that (right now especially), rigid frustration abounds in various social, work and familial circles simply due to the nature of our current macroeconomics. It's unfathomable to me that the grander picture is always blurred to the current state of existence.
- fullshark 3y agoA mix of serious problems, and a media no longer beholden to carrying water for the elites.
- chasd00 3y agoAnger can be used to drive engagement
- veunes 3y agoI used it to finally start to communicate my needs more effectively
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI guess that just beggs the question of why anger is so engaging, and why people haven't adopted behaviors and norms that suit themselves better.
- 93po 3y agoi'd say emotions are engaging, anger is just the easiest one to evoke by people who want to monetize your attention
- kibwen 3y agoEvolution takes generations. Society might adapt, if given enough time, and assuming that society can survive that long while trillion-dollar companies are incentivized to exploit human emotion in such a destructive way.
- schneems 3y agoAlso evolution doesn’t happen due to stimulus unless it affects fitness (just because we don’t like a trait, if people with it keep having babies at the same rate as others, then it won’t go away).
- schneems 3y agoThese aren’t conscious decisions people are making. It’s baked into our chemical systems (read thinking fast and slow for some more context). Millions of years of survival instincts don’t go away overnight. We are wired to pay more attention to negative things so we don’t get eaten. That wiring is exploited at scale in ways we never dreamed of. Even in the days before the internet, nightly news crews knew: if it bleeds, it leads.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoBecause we have given up the wisdom of expertise and curators to wisdom of the crowds. Guess what? Mob rule is dumb and incendiary.
- inopinatus 3y agoMob rule is curated by experts.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoNo it's self learning due to algorithms
- infecto 3y agoSample size of one…it feels true to me. Maybe it’s my age or I am somehow blissfully unaware it’s always been like this. It feels very true for me in America that the moment you like or dislike something or even have an opinion that is a shade of gray instead of black or white, that you immediately get dumped into a binary category. In America this seems to be extremely true regardless of ideology.
- joenot443 3y agoThis is in alignment with my past experiences too. After moving to America, I met a friend who told me she would never share a table with someone who voted Republican. I found this super surprising, but the rest of the group agreed. That was a hard rule for them. From what I've been able to gather, most privileged progressive white-collar circles in American cities tend to run almost exclusively Democrat. Has it always been this way? Have Americans always allowed voting habits to dictate their choice of friends? Back in Canada, of my three closest friends, one voted LPC, another Green, and another CPC. This next election I imagine it will be different. The amount of tribalism Americans associate with their two parties has always been so fascinating to me.
- to11mtm 3y ago> From what I've been able to gather, most privileged progressive white-collar circles in American cities tend to run almost exclusively Democrat. Has it always been this way? No and it's not always true. They just have different shibboleths and areas you'd see them. Rust Belt and Farm belt come to mind here. > Have Americans always allowed voting habits to dictate their choice of friends? At least in my lifetime, things started to polarize around the GWB vs Kerry election. Opinions on the war/etc caused some people at my college to change some friendships based on political affiliations... most people would just avoid talking politics though (touching on your previous question, someone in collage from a fairly well off family kinda got the wrong message from American dad, yet he just made sure to stop talking about how pretty Ann Coulter was in front of left wing people.) The elections after that amplified the split however. Obama's second election was, in my head, less 'contentious' than the first... but by 2016 I think everything was in full swing.
- silverquiet 3y agoRobert Sapolsky found the the most obvious predictor of stress in primate societies (measured via cortisol levels) was inequality. Speaking as a member of a highly inequal primate society, it makes sense to me.
- veunes 3y agoIt make sense to me too. Financial strain, limited opportunities, social exclusion and perceived unfairness can all contribute to heightened stress levels and anger towards life...
- ffsm8 3y agoIt might be unfair to focus on this, but that "perceived unfairness" just jumped out at be. My first reaction was to think "it's not just perceived"... but after a little introspecting, I couldn't help but notice how grim that statement actually is. It means that any mistreatment is fine - as long as the person can be distracted from it. And thinking about that reminded me how every new tech since the internet/90th has been increasingly distracting. There is a reason we've started calling it the attention economy after all...
- joquarky 3y agoIs something still considered an addiction if nobody cares to stop it? The way many people use the Internet now reminds me of an episode of Star Trek TNG ¹ where everyone is hooked on a game. ¹ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Game_(Star_Trek:_The_Next_Generation) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Game_(Star_Trek:_The_Nex...
- WillAdams 3y agoA fundamental measurement for this in a modern society is payslope: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/time-to-lead/how-one-company-levels-the-pay-slope-of-executives-and-workers/article15472738/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/time-to-lead/h... and it really should be a fundamental aspect of how companies are viewed.
- 3y ago
- highcountess 3y agoThe answer to this question cannot be provided because the powers that be refuse to even permit discussion of it and censor it and prevent others from even hearing things that contradict their programming and conditioning.
- marcodiego 3y agoThe reason people are so angry: algorithmic radicalisation aided by short shallow comments like this one.
- KerrAvon 3y agoYou can’t seriously write an article like this without reckoning with the rise of right wing fear and rage machine in the West. There are no mentions of Murdoch, Fox, or Limbaugh in this article.
- dude187 3y agoI didn't see any mention specifically calling out the left wing fear and rage machine either. So that makes sense! Or did I miss it?
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoSocial media, the internet, rising cost of living, inept leadership, kafqa esque government bureaucracy , stagnant employment opportunities, and perpetual renters. A perfect recipe for a French style revolution is brewing and the average elite doesn't realize it.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoThey do, that's why they're building killer robot dogs that do funny dances on the side.
- tekla 3y agoPeople aren't taught to regulate their emotions. Thats why the anger is so obvious, its just childish emotions all day every day.
- veunes 3y ago> People aren't taught to regulate their emotions. And this is very important skill.
- DamonHD 3y agoLots of adults don't warrant the title by their behaviour... "Adulting" licences should not be handled out in full on an 18th (or whichever) birthday, and should be partly revokable for various sorts of bad behaviour. And I'm not saying this claiming to be some sort of saint!
- analognoise 3y agoNow everyone gets to try to control everyone else rather than regulate their own emotions (“trigger warnings”), and you have the absolute shit show we have now.
- DamonHD 3y agoThis seems quite shallow, and uses as unalloyed truths many generalisations and absolutes which are simply not as claimed. Carelessly (or worse) using "always" when you don't mean it to make a thus-unsupported contentious point is indeed enough to make me angry!
- iambateman 3y agoIt’s easy to blame the media…so I will. For older generations, a constant drip of sensational sound bites, delivered at hourly intervals has been psychologically damaging. For younger generations, it’s different. When someone agrees with a post on social media, they tap “like”. When someone disagrees, they comment. Then, the only comments I pay attention to are the ones I find distasteful. As a result, it looks like my politically-noisier relatives and I have almost no overlap, even though we are really quite similar. If you agree, please validate my fragile self-image by upvoting this post. ;)
- ganzuul 3y agoAgreed but I also comment for validation.
- mrweasel 3y agoWhen I'm bored, unfocused, unengaged, I'll comment on a bunch of stuff, stuff that I really shouldn't. On better days in reminded by this quote: “Ask yourself the three things you must always ask yourself before you say anything. 1) Does this need to be said 2) Does this need to be said by me? 3) Does this need to be said by me now?” That stops most comments.
- throwaway984393 3y ago[dead]
- Aurornis 3y agoMy anecdote after working with college students: It’s obvious to me that they’re doing better than my generation in many metrics: Easy access to information that can improve their lives, massively more acceptance of everything from LGTBQ+ to simply being a nerd (which was relatively stigmatized even a few decades ago), significantly more job opportunities, remote work, international travel is common, they drive nice cars, get paid well (CS students in my case) and on and on. Yet their expectations have advanced faster than their quality of life. Some of the things they tell me are so pie in the sky that it’s hard to even begin to imagine how to return their expectations to reality. For example, many of them have picked up ideas that we should all be working 8-10 hours per week due to societal progress, or that the government could easily institute UBI at levels that had everyone living comfortable middle class lifestyles and made work optional. There is no critical thinking about where the money would come from or how anything would get done if nobody had to work, but they’ve seen it repeated so many times on Reddit that it’s accepted as incontrovertible truth. Every year I hear one student repeat the same argument that Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, or some other figure could cure global warming, world hunger, or other concerns and still have millions left over. Some people truly believe this. The other strange angle I’m hearing frequently is the idea that life was so much easier in the past. College students are convinced that I grew up in an era where work was easier and everything was cheap. They don’t believe me when I explain how hard my parents had to work, or the fact that my dad grew up in a house smaller than their college dorm (new construction college dorms are incredibly large and lavish, for some reason). The internet has told them that every prior generation had it easy and they their generation was the first to encounter any financial challenges, so that’s what they believe. Against impossible expectations like these, no amount of reality could ever be satisfying. I feel like I’m becoming an old man by watching these college students live comfortable lives, secure good job offers (this is what we help with), do work they enjoy, live in nice places, and still be convinced that everything is terrible because it can never reach the level of their expectations about the world. Note that many of these students are the kinds to turn their nose up at TikTok, have deleted their Instagram years ago, and scoff at people for consuming viral YouTube shorts, like mentioned in the article. Weirdly, the content they consume on their platforms of choice (usually Reddit) is actually worse in many ways. I think we underestimate just how bad and inflammatory the content on Reddit can be.
- dunekid 3y agoThere is rage, genuine rage; and there is rage as spectacle. Sometimes these overlap, but not necessarily. The spectacular rage is both incendiary and therapeutic. I can not help but remember this Black Mirror episode and see the parallel to it in many media : https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifteen_Million_Merits https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifteen_Million_Merits
- light_triad 3y agoIt’s partly the late stage effect of the ad supported everything business model. Rage is very effective to generate engagement, tribalism and passion. When major politicians are ready to exploit the us vs them dynamic to their benefit it creates a perfect storm. Also the Guardian and other news outlets have been driving this where every headline is about how one group or another is outraged it’s getting a bit ridiculous.
- verisimi 3y agoThis is a bit of a contentious opinion perhaps, but I think there is a generational thing going on. Younger generations seem to have a lot of certainty about what is good or bad (but how do they know?) and are unable to hold a conversation that challenges them without feeling offended. The idea of 'hate speech' is ascendent, that it is right to deplatform and marginalise. Mostly forgotten is the idea that people have freedom of speech, and that many and various opinions are fine, and should even be encouraged. If only a narrow (often corporate or governmental) set of opinions are acknowledged, yes many feel marginalised. Which leads to anger. And also leads to a deteriorating social situation where everyone is the poorer, even if they think they are right.
- ryandrake 3y agoWe could turn it around: How do you -know- that freedom of speech is some kind of absolute good? It seems this, like any proposition, should not be simply taken as axiomatic. Maybe reasonable people can disagree. Support for freedom of speech is indeed decreasing with each generation[1] and it is a pretty clear trend. Specifically, and from an older survey, 40% of Millennials are OK with limiting free speech that is offensive to minorities[2]. The age cohort trend is pretty clear here, too. While we may not agree, the next generations will shape things to come (assuming democracy survives). 1: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/08/30/more-so-than-adults-u-s-teens-value-people-feeling-safe-online-over-being-able-to-speak-freely/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/08/30/more-so-t... 2: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2015/11/20/40-of-millennials-ok-with-limiting-speech-offensive-to-minorities/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2015/11/20/40-of-mil...
- verisimi 3y ago> We could turn it around: How do you -know- that freedom of speech is some kind of absolute good? It seems this, like any proposition, should not be simply taken as axiomatic. Maybe reasonable people can disagree. Fair enough - but surely you can answer this for yourself? Do you prefer to be able to speak your mind or not? And if you do speak your mind, are you causing harm? You may then turn around and say 'define harm'. Fair enough again - but I would answer while words might offend, stir trouble, no physical harm is occurring - ie no harm done. And sometimes, what is being suggested, although unpleasant, will be closer to the truth (or at least sincerely believed). Which is a fair basis for social interactions. Sticks and stones and all that. The alternative is highly conformist and surely satisfies no individual. In general, people ought to develop themselves, developing a thicker skin perhaps whilst maintaining their sanity, in response to other people's words.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoAgency. All power has been effervescing up up up, into stratospherically high off C suites. We no longer see a local world that we have a place in around us; the decisions are all made in far off places & built by production line labor thousands of miles yet further still. Few about figure out an orientation & poise in the modern "thrownness" of being. Many do adapt & find a way, but Without agency, we have no core of self to believe in, to fall back in. Every offense grates further. Anger is for the reactive, for the unempowered, those without; those with a sense of self can have affronts big & small roll off, because they have a connection to meaning. They believe in something and their role in that something. Agency & self co-develop, and are the antidote to being easily swayed. (This is not a total answer. But I believe these conditions form a sizable chunk of the bedrock of our social conditions & experiences, set up what zeitgeists come and go.) (This belief in human agency is Ppart of the reason I believe so strongly in http://malleable.systems http://malleable.systems. Technology ought offer us a path to agency, a way to check the Black Iron Prison of consumerdom/control. This is a religious/spiritual calling, of letting people back in to systems, to me.)
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoSocial media pushed algorithms designed to enrage so that shareholders could make money on "engagement." Life is becoming more expensive. Inflation, shrinkflation, greedflation, convenience fees, subscriptions increasing in price and helpfully serving the ads they promised the subscription fee would remove. All of it collectively rising faster than the money a person can bring in if they're a wage-worker and not an investor who can live off of capital and on a megayacht. People aware that life is worse than they were promised, and going to get worse still, but being gaslighted or shamed if they voice it, and the entrenched players having the means to hijack the conversation and stifle dissent in a way never before seen in history. A lot of sci-fi demonstrates an oppressive regime by having the lower classes live in sterile boxes containing only what the regime wants and ceaselessly surveilling, meting out "justice" for the slightest infraction without appeal or mercy. Between being surrounded by GenAI phantasmagoria and shadowbanning, we're just building the digital equivalent and hailing it as Progress, Therefore Good. Pot's boiling, lid's locked in place, and it's only a matter of time before it explodes.
- thunderbong 3y agoIMHO, it's also the increasing amount of leisure time that we have now, coupled with smartphones.
- a_wild_dandan 3y ago1. Social media's objective function is engagement. Outrage and like buttons are highly engaging. 2. Tribalism + scale + time = two "us vs them" groups. Politically, FPTP voting mathematically implies spoilage; the Ron Paul example doesn't extol some virtue. 3. People are furious due to these (utterly preventable) things: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEJ4hkpQW8E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEJ4hkpQW8E
- atmosx 3y ago> My thesis has been that America is characterized by low levels of violence but also low social trust. Low levels of violence? Compared to whom? US ranks high in number of incarcerated citizens per 100k[^1]. There is no other "western" country in that list, for example. [^1]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/262962/countries-with-the-most-prisoners-per-100-000-inhabitants/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/262962/countries-with-th...
- nradov 3y agoThe US is kind of like two separate countries overlaid on the same geography. Violent crime is heavily concentrated in a small number of cities. https://www.cbsnews.com/pictures/murder-map-deadliest-u-s-cities/ https://www.cbsnews.com/pictures/murder-map-deadliest-u-s-ci... Outside those cities, violent crime is very low and comparable to other "western" countries. It's something that people see on the news but don't personally experience. In my relatively affluent city, the homicide rate most years is zero.
- rasengan0 3y agoHere's an idea: disconnect from online and reconnect with nature: go outside and proceed for the longest distance comfortable to a park, a tree, a weed by the sidewalk, lichen on a rock; anything growing and not human. [1] [1] Sophie L. Kjærvik, Brad J. Bushman, A meta-analytic review of anger management activities that increase or decrease arousal: What fuels or douses rage?, Clinical Psychology Review, Volume 109, 2024,102414,ISSN 0272-7358,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2024.102414 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2024.102414. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272735824000357 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S027273582...
- Apreche 3y agoIt is absolutely true that you can go touch grass to manage your anger. You'll feel much better. At the same time, some anger is legitimate, especially if you're talking about anger caused by inequality and injustice. If your solution to that kind of anger is to make it go away by disconnecting and ignoring it, you're only helping to perpetuate the inequality and injustice by pushing it out of your mind. Removing the anger removes some of your motivation for rectifying its cause. If you have illogical rage issues, like say road rage, yeah. Go ahead and take care of that however works best for you. If you're mad for legitimate reasons, I suggest letting that anger fuel you to act in a way to help bring about real change.
- annshress 3y agoWhile scrolling through Instagram, I came across a post discussing the practice of saving bacon fat for later use. Although I already do this myself, I was wondering about the benefits or uses of doing so. However, the top two comments on the post were rather negative and provocative. One commenter dismissed the idea as unoriginal, stating that another community had already been doing it. The other commenter expressed dislike for the taste of bacon-infused broccoli. This led to a lengthy exchange of comments between various users. I sometimes find myself inclined to getting enraged without considering them from an outside perspective. However, seeing from a third person's POV served as a good reminder to do so.