12 ms·
The surging demand for data is guzzling Virginia's water
- alistairSH 3y agoIs there some reason data centers can't/don't use a closed loop cooling system?
- jedberg 3y agoIt's expensive to build out and maintain. You also have to deal with leaks. But actually a lot of newer spaces are moving to closed loop because it's the only way to get enough cooling for the GPUs. The newest NVIDA GPUs require it.
- legitster 3y agoYou get much more efficiency out of the system when you lose the water to evaporation. It takes all of the heat with it. I know some data centers are experimenting with closed loops or wastewater systems, but while water is still priced so cheap in the US they are not in a huge rush.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jedberg 3y agoWe really need to figure out ways to get big fat data pipes to places that are naturally cold. Like imagine if we could get big pipes to Antarctica and then build data centers there. Plenty of fresh water and cold enough that you could almost just cool it with outside air, and you can exhaust the water right back outside to freeze back up. You could also use the exhaust heat to warm up the living spaces nearby. The only question would be, would it create so much heat in one spot that it would actually warm up the environment too much? The main thing stopping this now is lack of high throughput low latency data to the continent.
- MrLeap 3y agoThis is how the first chapter would start in a book where somebody builds a death ray in Antarctica.
- bell-cot 3y agoMinor detail: The myriad megajoules of heat which any major DC has got to breathe out...were previously inhaled as electrical energy. And multi-megawatt electrical service is quite difficult to source in most extremely cold places.
- jedberg 3y agoYou could use solar panels for 1/2 the year and wind all year. Some stations are doing that today. But yes, this is a major concern. A few modern nuclear plants would solve the problem, but you'd have to build them. It wouldn't be cheap.
- Scoundreller 3y agoWhile not “extremely” cold, Quebec’s hydroelectric dams are mostly in the central/north of the province. I think Norway is similar to the point where electricity pricing is a lot cheaper in the north because of limited transmission capacity. Both would be better choices than Virginia.
- dscottboggs 3y agoIsn't Antarctica melting already? We need to slow down damn it.
- jmclnx 3y ago>The only question would be, would it create so much heat in one spot that it would actually warm up the environment too much? I doubt it, the bigger issue would be Global Warming, but What you said makes sense on paper, but the center will sink into the ice quickly. I remember reading that a base down there had to be moved due to it sinking.
- AS37 3y ago> The only question would be, would it create so much heat in one spot that it would actually warm up the environment too much? Probably not at a large scale, although similar situations have led to odd headlines like 'Florida's manatees are addicted to power plants'. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20240328-floridas-manatees-are-hooked-on-power-plants https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20240328-floridas-manatee...
- hn8305823 3y agoThis article largely ignores the fact that there are common data center designs that use closed-loop cooling, and consume no more water on a daily basis than a barber shop. It's not even hard to build them that way.
- legitster 3y ago> Large data centers are resource hogs, using as much as 5 million gallons of water a day. While this is a lot of water, but as a point of comparison typical golf course uses about 100-200 million gallons of water a year. It's still a drop in the bucket compared to agriculture.
- chucksta 3y agoYou switched from gal/day to gal/year, converting shows golf courses using a roughly 10th of the same amount of water in a day ~500,000 gal.
- legitster 3y agoI'm fully aware. But I'm quoting the article and golf courses don't use a consistent amount of water day to day, so I am trusting readers to do the math.
- chiffre01 3y agoNot defending the water usage of golf courses, but 5 million a day is a lot more water than 100-200 million per year. I guess you could say data centers provide a tangible utility while golf courses do not.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIf the data centers are being used to ship mostly garbage entertainment video, then I would say the utility of both is similarly "tangible" (whatever that means), but the datacenter obviously delivers orders of magnitude more utility hours (to orders of magnitude more people).
- NegativeLatency 3y agoAnd here I am paying for energy to heat my house like a sucker, would be neat if we co-located data centers in cities and then captured/transported the heat to homes/buildings
- Symbiote 3y agoFacebook's data centre in Denmark does this. https://www.ramboll.com/extract-heat-from-data-centres/largest-danish-heat-pump-installation https://www.ramboll.com/extract-heat-from-data-centres/large...
- sdwr 3y agoIs that picture at the top real? It looks like aspirational pre-planning concept art!
- Symbiote 3y agoI'm not certain, but it looks reasonable for Danish architecture. I think it's here, but the StreetView photographs are old: https://maps.app.goo.gl/5M9pwoFgqceDXGtk7 https://maps.app.goo.gl/5M9pwoFgqceDXGtk7
- xyst 3y agoIf ISPs weren’t so stingy with providing symmetrical, >10 Gbps, connections to residential homes. Then we wouldn’t need to have centralized data centers that consume massive amounts of resources in a specific region. Instead we could have distributed these resources amongst the entire country. Create local jobs (imagine a local “data center” that serves resources to people of {city}, {state}. The internet should be distributed instead we have concentrated the vast majority of it into these “cloud” providers which subsequently hoard the wealth (ie, aws subsidizing the losses of the warehouse division), redistribute local resources to the top C-level executives and shareholders. Jobs outsourced (or “in sourced”) to people that have no connection. No care about the quality. Only care about fake initiatives and “mission accomplished” type milestones.
- jedberg 3y agoI don't think this would solve the problem like you hope. Case in point, Netflix has this setup already for streaming video. Tons of small racks all over the world. It's a huge pain to maintain and was only worth it because of the huge difference in customer experience. And even though they already have it, they still use AWS for all the control plane work, because it's just so much easier administratively. Admining distributed systems in just a few datacenters is hard enough. Doing it across thousands would be many orders of magnitude worse. Heck, most companies can't even handle two datacenters.
- cbrozefsky 3y agoHow many companies need netflix scale? A handful. So much of life online is not massive scale to general public streaming video with minimal latency. The cloud centralization in massive data centers is like CAFOs for computing.
- jedberg 3y agoI think you're missing the point. Even a company with that scale and resources has a hard time handling distributed systems. Even huge enterprises still use one datacenter because they don't have the talent and/or desire to do more than one. So expecting everyone to solve those hard distributed systems problems is untenable. That's why everyone is centralizing in massive datacenters.
- downvotetruth 3y agoFor data centers, let's use prime retail real estate at a freeway exit: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Loudoun+County,+VA/@38.9991678,-77.4776027,1652m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m6!3m5!1s0x89b6167499127435:0x1523a3579284188c!8m2!3d39.076767!4d-77.6536125!16zL20vMG1ubHE https://www.google.com/maps/place/Loudoun+County,+VA/@38.999... no where near where others might have a better understanding to put industrial property like the power company: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Loudoun+County,+VA/@39.2086898,-77.4660584,1647m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m6!3m5!1s0x89b6167499127435:0x1523a3579284188c!8m2!3d39.076767!4d-77.6536125!16zL20vMG1ubHE https://www.google.com/maps/place/Loudoun+County,+VA/@39.208... wonder what consultant won that job.
- greenavocado 3y agoIt makes more sense if you need to defend the location in wartime. It also might not be just a datacenter even if there is one above ground. Many innocent looking features have strategic military value. Another easy one is the random long straight sections of US Interstates or Mt Weather Emergency Operations Center.
- ipython 3y agoScroll to the northwest a bit and you can see that you can ride Metro straight to the data center! How convenient!
- downvotetruth 3y agoRemember to bring lipstick as the trashed empty lots nearby serve as a great wild boar attraction to kiss and ride.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- giantg2 3y agoWhy not used a closed loop system? Maybe something with geothermal cooling.
- agsnu 3y agoPresumably because it’s cheaper to use evaporative cooling
- nielsbot 3y agoCan't they use saltwater? Or grey water? What do coastline nuclear plants do?
- acbullen 3y agoI imagine the additional costs of cleaning/replacing tubing when contaminants accumulate from less-than-potable water outweigh the benefits (from the datacenter's perspective).
- alistairSH 3y agoNot coastline, but the Lake Anna facility in central VA uses lake water for cooling. It's a two-loop system - internal loop touches the radioactive bits, which is pumped to heat exchangers, and an external loop ingests cool lake water and dumps warmer water back into the lake. The "warm" side of the lake has more valuable housing because the lake remains usable for a longer period of time each season. There's a series of dams that keep the smaller warm section separate from the natural cold side. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Anna_Nuclear_Generating_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Anna_Nuclear_Generating_... https://www.virginialakehouses.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Lake-Anna-Map.png https://www.virginialakehouses.com/wordpress/wp-content/uplo...
- tectonic 3y agoThe number and scale of data centers around Dulles is just crazy. The power consumption must be absurd.
- alistairSH 3y agoI live nearby and whenever I drive/cycle through the area, I have to laugh a little. In person, it looks just as absurd as it sounds or looks on a map. $1 million homes surrounded by giant windowless hulks. It's possibly the most dystopian place in DC metro.
- venning 3y agoFrom the linked study: [1] Total operational water "footprint" of data centers in 2018: 5.13 * 10^8 m^3. Of that, indirect consumption through electricity generation: 3.83 * 10^8 m^3, or 74.7%. And indirect consumption related to water and wastewater utilities (non-electicity production): 4.50 * 10^5 m^3, or 0.09%. The study then does a reasonable job of discussing the concerns of building data centers in water-stressed places. This article seems to be another "didn't read the study, saw big number" thing. [1] https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/abfba1 https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/abfba1 (PDF page 7, section 3.1)
- causal 3y agoOkay that makes more sense. I was skeptical of the article's claim that the water was just being heat-vaporized into oblivion. That said, more water-sustainable power generation is clearly still a need.
- graphe 3y agoI've heard of data centers on ships or on the water, someone told me the internet wasn't green (big shock to me at that point) and what they're doing. https://news.microsoft.com/source/features/sustainability/project-natick-underwater-datacenter/ https://news.microsoft.com/source/features/sustainability/pr... https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/nautilus-data-technologies-launches-first-floating-data-center/ https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/nautilus-data-tec... Not sure why they aren't more standard.