2 ms·
The clear meaning I got from the ad was: we want to destroy everything and make you buy our product instead. I know that wasn't what they were going for (I'm p
by JohnFen 3y ago
The clear meaning I got from the ad was: we want to destroy everything and make you buy our product instead.
I know that wasn't what they were going for (I'm pretty sure, anyway), but it's very hard for me to interpret it differently.
I never connected it to the hydraulic press channel at all for some reason.
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoYou either get the symbolism of "let's crush all remaining vestiges of creative culture" or you don't. If you don't, that's fine. Policing the extent of people's reactions doesn't make for constructive conversation, and, ironically, is merely a different form of "over-reaction."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- timr 3y ago> You either get the symbolism of "let's crush all remaining vestiges of creative culture" or you don't. Correction: you either choose to believe that's the symbolism, or you don't. I "get" it, intellectually, but I don't think that was the intent of the advertiser, nor do I think it's the obvious interpretation of the ad. The obvious interpretation, to me, was "hey, we can piggyback on this hydraulic press channel meme and sell iPads!" Tellingly, few people care that the hydraulic press channel exists, despite actually crushing all sorts of stuff [1]. See also: the viral "does it blend?" ads [2], and any number of music videos or performances where instruments are destroyed [3] (practically a meme unto itself), etc. [1] including instruments (listen to the guitar 'scream' under the press!): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zsQOKKE7UbM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zsQOKKE7UbM [2] they blended a skeleton! oh, the symbolism! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AsTZm7QtY84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AsTZm7QtY84 [3] boom go the guitars (this, apparently, was not the one moment that mattered): https://youtu.be/QvW61K2s0tA?feature=shared&t=175 https://youtu.be/QvW61K2s0tA?feature=shared&t=175
- labcomputer 3y agoI think the ad is a bit a Rorschach test. Most people see a butterfly. Others see man violently stabbing a bicycle, and that says more about them than the creators of the ad.
- timr 3y agobasically agreed, except I think that the latter group is 90% comprised of people who see an opportunity for performative angst and/or attacking Apple.
- dxdm 3y agoOr, you know, _only_ seeing the butterfly and then being dismissive about other interpretations, maybe people who do that also have things revealed about them. ;)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- manux 3y agoThe intent behind media matters but isn't all that matters. How people might interpret something is important (albeit often unpredictable). I think the symbolism of "let's crush all remaining vestiges of creative culture" is a pretty obvious _potential_ interpretation from a _non-trivial amount_ of people. In that sense it is an interpretation that matters for our present discourse, even if it isn't the interpretation that the creator of the ad intended.
- timr 3y ago> How people might interpret something is important (albeit often unpredictable). It's a big world out there. There are literally billions of possible ways that people can interpret whatever you put out in the ether, and many of them are...precious...to the extreme. Worry too much what any one of them is going to think, and you won't do anything. The obvious conclusion, to quote every influencer on the internet, is: "Haters gonna hate", but admittedly, I don't work in Apple PR.
- atmosx 3y agoThe fact, the add went through a considerable amount of people and no one raised a red flag tells you all you need to know about the industry.
- xadhominemx 3y agoYes, that was what the ad depicted but obviously that was not the meaning of the ad. The ad was a metaphor.
- dnissley 3y agoMaybe you can go into that more. Where's that intuition coming from that tells you "Apple wants to destroy everything"?
- thomasahle 3y agoIf you are already weary of too many screens; and you find a world with more physical objects less bleak. It's not so much that Apple "wants to destroy everything". It's just that they care more about the digital world than the real world. This is the same intuition that makes people weary of virtual reality. See also this image of Steve Jobs' office vs Tim Cook's: https://www.instagram.com/starworldlab/p/C5TRLqAujPJ/ https://www.instagram.com/starworldlab/p/C5TRLqAujPJ/
- JohnFen 3y agoIt's in the context of how the FAANG segment of the tech industry has become overbearing and is cheerfully destroying all sorts of great things in order to replace them with more tech. It's not really about Apple specifically, but more that the ad is graphically illustrating something that already seemed to be all too true.
- steve1977 3y agoAt least I know now what HP channel means, I was wondering how Hewlett Packard was involved in all of this… I‘m getting old…