19 ms·
Apple M4 benchmarks suggest it is the new single-core performance champ
- adezxc 3y agoIf only Apple allowed to run VMs and other software like Linux on their iPads, it would be a game-changer. Right now, the iPads are mostly limited to media production tools + everything else you could get in an Android tablet, so it's pretty pointless for a user like me
- levesque 3y agoIs there really no way to do this?
- s3p 3y agoSidecar sort of does this right now? If you are fine with the iPad functioning as a low res display that the Mac can send a few windows over to. It doesn't work amazingly well for me but I have used it a few times.
- stetrain 3y agoNot officially. You can side load UTM using AltStore which requires you to sign apps using your own developer certificate and re-sign them about once a week to keep it running. The iPads have had the hardware in the M-series chips and the software in the form of Apple's hypervisor framework in iPadOS for a couple of generations now, but Apple hasn't enabled it to be used officially. I really wish they would just allow this on iPadOS. It still maintains the sandbox model Apple wants for iOS, it would just give a (contained) outlet for doing things that are difficult in native iPadOS.
- hhh 3y agoWithin 6 months iPadOS will have side loading in the EU.
- jijijijij 3y agoSource? I thought the DMA only covers iPhones. In any case, Apple still wants to "review" apps, and we want (arbitrary) user code execution on device. That's something Apple strictly forbids on iOS/iPadOS AFAIK (which is why we can't even have Firefox addons). Unless we can have at least true side loading, a DMA extension to iPad won't help. The DMA isn't really the right tool to liberate devices, since it's about market competition not consumer rights. I think it would be better to widely address this along right-to-repair, electronic waste reduction and consumer rights regarding actual ownership. Unconditionally locked hardware is ridiculous. I wish they would simply unlock the bootloader, so we can have Asahi Linux for iPad. They don't have to do anything else. Although Asahi is on trajectory to exceed MacOS performance and dev usability, I don't think they would lose their existing appstore cattle to Linux, but rather gain new hardware only customers.
- Tomte 3y agoThat was only the beginning: https://www.macrumors.com/2024/04/30/apple-must-allow-app-sideloading-ipads-eu-rules/ https://www.macrumors.com/2024/04/30/apple-must-allow-app-si...
- jijijijij 3y agoThx. Though, I don't see true sideloading (like on Android) specified. If apps still need Apple's approval, we will get "freedom" who to pay, not what to run. I still don't see device liberation within the scope of the DMA. However, if we're lucky, Apple may decide the app approval process may not be worth it, if they are not allowed to extort developers anymore, so they may allow unsupervised sideloading as a consequence. In any case, requirements and reality may take much longer to align than 6 more months, considering Apple's cringeworthy tantrums so far...
- lonjil 3y ago> Though, I don't see true sideloading (like on Android) specified. If apps still need Apple's approval, we will get "freedom" who to pay, not what to run. I still don't see device liberation within the scope of the DMA. But if Apple abuses its position as platform gatekeeper with the app approval process and rules, the EU will probably slap them down. The DMA doesn't care about device liberation, but it does care about fairness, so Apple will probably only be allowed to continue this if they act in very good faith towards 3rd parties, which doesn't seem like an Apple thing to do.
- fathyb 3y ago> The iPads have had the hardware in the M-series chips and the software in the form of Apple's hypervisor framework in iPadOS for a couple of generations now, but Apple hasn't enabled it to be used officially. They removed the hypervisor framework in addition to the kernel support for virtualization a few months ago unfortunately.
- jmkni 3y agoIf they could combine iPadOS and macOS, and have some clever way to flick between the iPad UI and the mac one, it would be an incredible device Plug it into a usb-c dock connected to a screen/keyboard/mouse and it's a Mac, put it on the little stand with the magic keyboard and it's a MacBook, hold it in your hand and it's an iPad My dream device
- akasakahakada 3y agoFirst let people seperate photos into different folders....
- mdavid626 3y agoWell, Microsoft tried this, it was called Windows 8. It failed miserably.
- jmkni 3y agoSadly it did, I had one of the OG Surfaces and really liked Windows 8
- s3p 3y agoI mean, their strategy was awful. They replaced the start menu for the first time with a whole-screen abomination that ruined power user workflows. They made the desktop TOO much like a tablet, it seemed like they wanted one interface for everything. Apple is very clear about their product differentiation and would never make macOS and ipadOS exact copies. Case in point: when they brought cursor support over, they painstakingly engineered it to work differently and snap to objects on the screen. I think if they did OP's suggestion and had a macOS screen show up when an iPad is connected to peripherals it would actually work out well.
- flohofwoe 3y agoWindows 8 failed because it tried to merge desktop and tablet UI paradigms. Switching between entirely different and separate "UI personalities" could work. I don't think the pointer vs touch UI is the main thing that people have in mind when wishing for macOS on the iPad though, instead a "proper" UNIX-style filesystem and shell, and the ability to install any software outside the app store via a package manager and without Apple's nanny reflex getting in the way.
- anonzzzies 3y agoEvery new iPad release people beg for this…
- lm28469 3y agoYou'll have to quantify "people", we're in a bubble inside of a bubble here on HN
- user_7832 3y agoIn his recent video MKBHD said the same. He’s certainly a tech YouTuber (probably the biggest) but no where as techy as the average HN crowd. A lot of comments on fetter & reddit also speak about this.
- detourdog 3y agoI was really surprised by his review. His review made it seem like technical progress was not a worthy pursuit. We should be satisfied with the status quo and Apple should stop setting goals.
- user_7832 3y agoI think it was more of how the latest iPads are still just a spec bump. The hardware has been perfect for several generations, it’s the software that’s holding the hardware back.
- detourdog 3y agoI understand that aspect but Apple has no choice but to push the envelopw. How important is his review if he has nothing to say?
- lm28469 3y agoThey sell 50m+ of them per year and according to Google there are 25m software devs in the world Even if they made every single one of them buy a new ipad every single year that would still be single digit change of revenue for apple
- dktp 3y agoAs much as I'd like to see it being more open, a lot of people seem concerned about security and are happy with the current state of iOS/iPadOs and not having to deal with troubleshooting of their families devices
- datpiff 3y agoThose two scenarios are not mutually exclusive
- wilsonnb3 3y agoIf the tablet form factor was really a game changer for software development, wouldn’t the surface line and high end android tablets be more popular for programming? Wouldn’t there actually be some popular Linux tablets out there? (I am aware that there are a couple of niche options) Touch screen interfaces are just not good for programming. Apple already brought all of the useful parts of the iPad to the Mac when they switched to the m series SOCs. Fanless design, long battery life, instant sleep/wake. An iPad running macOS has some niche appeal for people who want to travel light but I really don’t see it being a game changer at all.
- curt15 3y agoMaybe I'm just getting old, but my eyes find even a typical laptop display too straining for programming. I like my desktop monitors.
- user_7832 3y ago> If the tablet form factor was really a game changer for software development, wouldn’t the surface line and high end android tablets be more popular for programming? Not necessarily. The surface line has several hardware fumbles (especially regarding power budgets/efficiency). The A & M series chips could easily whip up most of their competition in the low power (>10 watt) segment, if Apple wanted. AMD and Intel push for high performance at 15-28watts on portables, which is too high for thin tablets. For maximum contrast: x86 tablets have fans. M1/m2 laptops can be fanless. (This isn’t to say it’s impossible but rather no company with deep enough pockets cares enough.)
- wilsonnb3 3y agoI don’t think I’ve heard people complain about the surface performance, power usage, or battery life in a long time. Probably not since the surface pro 3, around the time that intel was making haswell. Also the Surface Pro 7 was fanless with x86 processors, plus the small one (surface go, I think) is fanless and x86 but does have performance issues.
- bee_rider 3y ago
- nunez 3y agoI seriously hope that this is getting announced at WWDC this year. There is nothing obvious stopping these iPads from running Virtualization.Framework.
- MrSkelter 3y agoEasy porting would make everything slower. People would stop targeting Apple hardware and the machines would be running everything in emulation. Making porting difficult is a strategy. It requires publishers to make the leap and when they do they take full advantage of the hardware.
- sylens 3y agoGoing to be an awkward Surface event this month when they have to figure out how to message some accolade about the Snapdragon X Elite
- Aromasin 3y agoThey'll do what every vendor does; find that one workload that it's better at, and play that off as if it's that performant at every workload. Bad at 3DMark? Try Cinebench, Superposition, PCMark, Geekbench, SiSoftware Sandra, or even some other customer benchmarking software no one else uses.
- PedroBatista 3y agoQualcomm pulled an Apple with all the hyperbolic words and very specific and massaged performance numbers. Even without the M4 it would be awkward when those chips appear in the real World in real situations. IMO some people inside Qualcomm have been stretching the truth way too much even internally.
- TheCondor 3y agoWorse, it’s going to be a very expensive part. I know us nerds aren’t the market, but an mATX motherboard with elite x for like $700-800 would be a seller.
- overstay8930 3y agoQualcomm is laughing to the bank because MSFT doesn't have a choice.
- lunfard000 3y agobut consumers do? (almost) Nobody will pay apple level prices for something that has less software support and, overall, a worse experience than on macos. TBH, other than gaming, not sure why anyone is paying 1k+ for a Windows laptop.
- 3y ago
- TheArcane 3y agoThe best strategic decision Apple has made in the last 15 years is to vertically integrate and build their own processors. M-series is so far ahead of the game than an air-cooled M4 has better single-core performance than the best desktop PC chip money can buy. Incredible.
- criddell 3y agoI don't understand why the non-Apple world has been so slow to copy Apple here. Are there any Windows or Linux laptops that match even the oldest M1 machines in battery life and performance? I get that Apple has an advantage over companies like Dell and Lenovo in that they also build the OS but then there are Linux computer companies that have the source for everything and their machines are usually even worse from a performance / watt perspective.
- sureIy 3y agoI guess it exists, especially on the Chinese market, but the apps just are not there. Windows ARM is as popular as Windows Mobile 7
- 999900000999 3y agoI think most of us want an iPad that we can dock into a connected keyboard and use as a laptop. But from Apple's point of view they really need to sell us multiple devices.
- zarzavat 3y agoI find this decision to put it in the iPad Pro somewhat puzzling. One consequence of this is that nobody is going to want to buy M3 MacBooks for a while, knowing that such a big leap in performance is around the corner. Does Apple really sell more iPad Pros than MacBooks to make it worthwhile? I was under the impression that the iPad Pro is a somewhat niche product and the Air is far more popular.
- CubsFan1060 3y agoI think the theory is that there is going to be a large on-device AI push at WWDC. And iPads generally have a very long refresh cycle. In order for iPads to participate, they needed the M4's.
- wilsonnb3 3y ago> One consequence of this is that nobody is going to want to buy M3 MacBooks for a while, knowing that such a big leap in performance is around the corner. I think this is one of those things that only enthusiasts care about, and if you care that much about performance you’re probably one of the people who buys a new one every year or two anyways so they aren’t really missing out on your revenue. Most people just need or want a new laptop and order whatever one is currently available.
- hocuspocus 3y agoI think it makes total sense. I speculate the M4 might be too expensive to manufacture for a MBA right now. The iPad Pro is a relatively niche, slow cycle and high-margin product. People who buy MacBooks aren't suddenly going to stop or switch to Windows because of some Osborne effect. The entry-level M3 MBA is still extremely hard to beat at the same price point.
- re-thc 3y ago> One consequence of this is that nobody is going to want to buy M3 MacBooks for a while Like how long? M4 MacBook Pros could in theory launch in a month (i.e. WWDC). That's worthwhile.
- 3y ago
- wood_spirit 3y agoI remember the hype around the first M1 and getting one and it actually living up to the hype! It was compiling code twice as fast as the MBP I replaced and was booting way faster and was generally snappier in every way. I ran through lots of benchmarks but also tested on my own code. It was faster than the beefy servers I deployed to. But the absolute biggest game changer was that it was silent. Completely silent. Hadn’t realised how noisy computers had been until then.
- _mlbt 3y agoI dipped my toes in the water with literally the cheapest M1 I could buy…the base model Mac Mini was on sale for $499 so I sort of impulse bought it to see if it could replace my PC. I was blown away by the performance of this tiny little machine, even with just 8GB of RAM. I’ve since went all in with a M3 Pro MacBook Pro and its performance and battery life are insane. M1 and beyond definitely live up to the hype.
- kmlx 3y agoi was as impressed by gaming. being able to run a triple a game like resident evil 4 with everything turned to max on a mac laptop was something new to me.
- jsheard 3y agoIt's a shame there's still so few high-end games to flex the hardware. Publishers interest in doing Mac ports is still almost zero, as I understand it the Death Stranding and Resident Evil ports only happened because Apple bankrolled them so they'd have something to show off at their hardware launches.
- herpdyderp 3y agoYou can get lots of games to work through Apple's Game Porting Kit. My favorite way to do that is with Whisky: https://getwhisky.app https://getwhisky.app
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoHave they slapped a heatsink on it yet? Otherwise that is going to be bullshit or only measured for a fraction of a second.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoYes, the Apple logo on the back of the iPad is made of copper and acts as a heatsink. They said that in the presentation. I wonder how many people are going to get Apple-shaped burns and will get told that they're holding it wrong. Since they got rid of the stickers, they should include Apple-shaped burn pads.
- samatman 3y agoThis has been extensively tested with the other M series chips, for example: the MacBooks Air do not have fans, while the MacBooks Pro do. On very intense workloads, the fanless products do eventually throttle slightly. It's after several minutes, not a fraction of a second. If you have reason to believe this is only true for M1-3, but not M4, let's hear them.
- daghamm 3y agoM series have always been the champ of single-core benchmarks. AMDs strategy is to have many more cores, albeit not as fast. The main issue with M series is that a much of performance comes from the memory and that is very expensive to scale. That's is why Apple is still selling 8GB laptops.
- AlanYx 3y agoM series have always been extremely competitive on single-core, but not really "the champ". Now this one is beating the Core i9-14900KS in a device with only modest copper heatsinking (with a heatsink likely less than 3mm thick)! That merits the article title.
- paulmd 3y agoM1 Max beat 5950X in overall single-threaded SPEC2017 when it came out. It won big in some MT workloads too. Punching within its own weight class, laptop chips rather than expecting it to outright beat desktop chips... it beat the 5980HS and 11980HK in every single test. It just didn't sink into the public consciousness too well at that point because everyone assumed it must have been some erroneous test/outlier. https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performance-review/4 https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performanc... https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performance-review/5 https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performanc...
- daghamm 3y ago5980HS is a laptop chip, it is more fair to compare it to M1 and maybe M1 pro. While M1 Max can be used in laptops, the benchmarks I've seen have been for the mini/imac where it doesn't have power and thermal limitations of a laptop. Besides, the cheapest M1 Max laptop is $1000 more expensive than the most expensive 5980HS laptop :(
- lightweb 3y agoWill this processor suffer from the same vulnerabilities as was just discovered on the previous M1-3?
- madisp 3y agoThe performance/compute density of these is pretty neat, you could fit a lot of them in a 42U rack. Would love to see some blade or sled hardware based on Apple Silicon, think of the density of cpu/gpu/ram/npu :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mamcx 3y agoWhat is nuts? the numbers are for an iPad.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoAFAICT, Apple has three major advantages (note that architecture only has minor impact [1]) - first access to the best process - a great team - high bandwidth / latency DRAM Intel & AMD aren't that far behind on #1 and #2, but I'm surprised at how long it's taking them to catch up on #3. If they created and sold a chip with wide low latency DRAM on package they would simultaneously significantly increase their performance and also they would capture a higher proportion of the BOM cost of a laptop. Pedantic: AMD's MI300X has on package RAM, but it's not exactly a laptop chip... 1: Jim Keller https://www.anandtech.com/show/16762/an-anandtech-interview-with-jim-keller-laziest-person-at-tesla https://www.anandtech.com/show/16762/an-anandtech-interview-...
- Drive-by 3y agoThis piece incorrectly equates core and thread performance. They're not the same for the Intel chip due to hyperthreading/SMT. Measuring thread performance and calling it core performance is deceptive and undersells the capabilities of the Intel chip.