11 ms·
Bollards: Why and What
- philips 3y ago> The lanugage in the article is full of ‘this was an unavoidable tragedy’, though i think it’s obvious a local city engineer ought to be held criminally liable for their neglect. > Because not only was it entirely preventable, it was also statistically inevitable. Not putting bollards where they need to be is like not only not wearing a seatbelt when driving, but arguing that seatbelts should not be available in cars because usually they’re not needed This is 100% correct. A woman in Portland here was killed when a street racer plowed into a bus stop. The racer lived and the woman died. The racer got 36 months. Totally preventable. https://www.kgw.com/article/news/crime/portland-street-racer-pleads-guilty-sentenced-36-months-crash-2022/283-a067723c-8e45-4764-9ce9-33cb5aebbc07 https://www.kgw.com/article/news/crime/portland-street-racer...
- zer00eyz 3y ago[flagged]
- baobabKoodaa 3y ago> Likely a few too many I guess it's fun to be a contrarian, but I didn't expect to see a pro-death contrarian position here.
- bombcar 3y agoEveryone’s pro-death and some point, or we cover Everest in escalators. It’s all where the line between allowable risk and unacceptable risk is drawn.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoNo. There's a difference between saying: A) The cost doesn't justify the benefits and B) There's too many humans anyway The comment I responded to said B, not A. That's what I mean by "pro death". Viewing it as a positive that we reduce the amount of humans by... random deaths from traffic?
- zer00eyz 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paulgb 3y ago> now we want to filter for "statistically inevitable" I mean, yes? We’ve been making trade-offs to reduce statistically inevitable deaths for years with some real success stories to speak of. Getting doctors to wash their hands between patients, removing lead from gas, seatbelts, engineering safety factors, checklists in aviation, food safety standards…
- dumbo-octopus 3y agoIn the case in the article, it sounds like the killed person was walking down the middle of a totally ordinary sidewalk, not a bus stop or intersection or storefront or anything. Are you proposing we place bollards on the edges of every sidewalk in existence?
- BeefySwain 3y agoOnly the sidewalks next to roads.
- bobthepanda 3y agoWhat sidewalk isn’t next to a road? It’s in the name: side-walk.
- naikrovek 3y agoWhich is why they are so dangerous for pedestrians, even though nothing bad happens most of the time.
- geraldwhen 3y agoAnywhere street racing happens, legal or no, probably yes.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoBuilding streets is going to become pretty expensive if we follow that advice.
- bobthepanda 3y agoIt is probably much more doable, and less hostile, to traffic calm streets so that people cannot get up to such speeds, and also to reduce the necessity of driving so that there is no car to crash in the first place.
- sandworm101 3y agoCorrect. Cars need to be separated from people by barriers. But that goes both ways. Deaths by pedestrians getting into places they shouldn't are very common even absent roads (ie railroad crossings). Some have called for all railroads to be fenced off. But few want to live in a world with fences around every possible dangerous area. When I went to school there was no fence. Now schools are surrounded by so many that they look like prisons. Barriers can go too far.
- hmottestad 3y agoIt's an article about bollards and how they stop vehicles from hitting pedestrians. Fences to keep people out of places where they can easily kill themselves is very important, but doesn't have anything to do with the article. A trend I see on Twitter is that someone will bring up an important issue and comments will highlight that it's very important, but what about this other thing that is somewhat related but also unrelated. Not saying that you intended to do that here, but be aware that fences provide no security against cars and that the whole point of bollards is to stop cars from killing pedestrians who are not on the road.
- sandworm101 3y ago>> the whole point of bollards is to stop cars from killing pedestrians Except all those bollards that have nothing to do with pedestrians. Many are there to prevent cars deliberately accessing protected areas with absolutely zero thought about stopping a crashing vehicle. The most common use of bollards is to stop vehicles from parking where they shouldn't. Some bollards are even soft so that they can be driven over without damage to either party. https://www.maibach.com/en/soft-bollard.html https://www.maibach.com/en/soft-bollard.html
- estebank 3y ago> Some bollards are even soft so that they can be driven over without damage to either party. That's not a bollard. I'm assuming you're thinking of flex posts, or how some of us call them, car ticklers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 3y agoThat barrier looks bad, but i think the designer is doing two things by putting it inside of the sidewalk. It looks to be doing double duty as a normal fence, something to keep pedestrians and such from falling into the gully. If it were a wooden fence nobody would notice it. But they went with a metal barrier normally used for cars that now looks out of place. The other possibility is that the sidewalk may have been added afterwards. Turn the right lane into a sidewalk or bike lane and the old vehicle barriers will indeed appear out of place. There are far stranger thing out there on the roads. Strange doesn't mean evil. A third possibility is that the sidewalk may be designed for vehicle use. This is most common in "traffic calming" devices such as those tiny roundabouts. The sidewalk is kept low so that the occasional long truck (ie fire trucks) can still negotiate a corner by driving partially onto the sidewalk. If we want obstacles to slow cars down, we must still think about emergency vehicles. Even the most dedicated anti-car advocate doesn't dare complain about ambulances driving through pedestrian zones.
- DanHulton 3y agoI cannot imagine being okay with an ambulance rocketing down a sidewalk that is explicitly designed as a "pedestrian zone." The solution to emergency vehicles being unable to navigate streets in a timely manner is to redesign the streets, not to normalize the practice of endangering pedestrians. Additionally, if it is necessary to design a mixed pedestrian/vehicle zone, there are absolutely ways to go about that, with specific and different buildout and signage. Any city planner whose solution is "Oh, well, the emergency vehicles can just use the sidewalks to turn or pass other vehicles, and they'll be careful so it's okay" is committing malfeasance and should be held legally responsible for the deaths and injuries arising from said decision.
- sandworm101 3y agoWho said anything about speed? A vehicle like a fire truck can simply be too long/wide to get around a corner even at a walking pace. So they use the sidewalks. Emergency vehicles in pedestrian areas is a very common. So any barrier system needs to accommodate them. Every, and I mean every, neighborhood is laid out on the premise that firetrucks can get to every location. The size of buildings, even the width of city blocks, is often tied to the capacities of the local fire departments to push water using pumper trucks. Want multi-story residential areas? The roads better be able to handle ladder trucks too.
- matsemann 3y agoThe article touches upon how news stories shift the way problems are thought about, often in a way where problems stemming from cars are played down. This one is a go-to for me in showing how that works and what to do about it, it's Cam Cycle breaking down a news story about a collision: https://www.camcycle.org.uk/magazine/newsletter110/article8/ https://www.camcycle.org.uk/magazine/newsletter110/article8/ I can btw recommend following the World Bollard account the images are sourced from. I find the playful seriousness hilarious. It's sad that we need bollards so many places. Both for safety in regards to accidents. A more humane design of a street would make it impossible to speed too much or put pedestrians in harms way - if you need two hundred bollards somewhere along a street, other measures should've been taken instead (like traffic calming). But also because without them, some drivers will drive wherever, park wherever. No pedestrian zone remain untouched by cars without bollards. In my city we had to petition to get them up to keep cars out from somewhere they weren't allowed to be.
- gosub100 3y agoI only have the energy to refute 2 points in the article breakdown: 1) (paraphasing) "why was it relevant to say he was wearing a helmet". To raise awareness that it's critical that cyclists wear helmets to increase their chances of survival. 2) "he was struck...use of passive voice , not the result of one or other party's action", maybe because that information isn't available yet? And part of journalistic integrity is to not report that which isn't proven. It baffles me why cyclists expect to have any lower incident of traffic accidents than any other vehicle using common roadways.
- krisoft 3y ago> maybe because that information isn't available yet? What do you mean? The article they analyse says that a van struck the cyclist. The information is available and is disclosed in the very same article. Yet they use a passive voice.
- gosub100 3y agothe article may not have the final police report, maybe the cyclist veered in front of the van?
- woodruffw 3y agoBollards are fantastic technology: cheap to manufacture, easy to install, and life-saving (both in terms of crashes and also forcing drivers off of curbs, crosswalks, &c.). It's a shame that so many US cities are focused on installing pseudo-bollards and flexible strips of plastic, rather than putting down permanent protections for cyclists and pedestrians. One recent example of this is NYC's Gowanus[1]: they're redeveloping the area for residential use, including bike lanes and daylighting down 4th avenue (historically a high-volume, industrial avenue). But these bike lanes and daylight zones are protected only by plastic bollards, which even a sedan can comfortably park over. [1]: https://www.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/plans-studies/gowanus/fourth-avenue-corridor.pdf https://www.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/plans-studi...
- bombcar 3y agoFlexible markers (which aren’t even attempting to be bollards, to be clear) are usually a step up from a simple painted line and often recommended by fire departments and other emergency personnel as they can ignore them with their equipment.
- woodruffw 3y agoThey're often sold as "flexible bollards"[1], so I think it's fair to evaluate them by that title. I don't object to the idea that EMS or other emergency responders might need roadside access. From my experience, many European cities do this admirably by having retractable bollards embedded in the street, or by redesigning streets to have a bollard-free section (e.g. by the fire hydrant, where it's already illegal to park or idle). (There's also the irony of not placing bollards into a street crossing because emergency services might need it, when bollards might prevent the need for many emergency responses.) [1]: https://www.reliance-foundry.com/bollard/flexible-bendable https://www.reliance-foundry.com/bollard/flexible-bendable
- krisoft 3y ago> when bollards might prevent the need for many emergency responses I doubt that? If a bollard stops a car which would have caused an emergency that is often reason enough for an emergency response in itself. It doesn’t change the number of emergency calls, just changes the form of the emergency. Also the whole argument you are making is silly. A bollard on a street crossing can prevent some kind of emergencies (the kind a runaway vehicle would cause). It absolutely does nothing to prevent other kind of emergencies (like fires caused by faulty wires, or hearth attacks) but might lenghten the response time for those. There would be maybe some form of irony if emergency responses were only required because of runaway cars, but that is far from the case.
- apwheele 3y agoBollards are also good ideas to prevent intentional terrorist acts of driving cars into pedestrian areas, https://www.nbcnews.com/slideshow/terrorist-truck-attack-shocks-new-york-city-n816236 https://www.nbcnews.com/slideshow/terrorist-truck-attack-sho....
- forgotusername6 3y agoThe automatic bollards in my city, designed for exactly that purpose, have claimed over 200 tailgating cars since their installation.
- titanomachy 3y agoHow does that happen? Are they tailgating maintenance vehicles or emergency vehicles who are authorized to access those areas, and then the bollards go up again after they've passed?
- fsckboy 3y ago"tailgating" at a red light or in a parking lot might mean "following the car in front of you closely at low speed", and as such the driver might not realize there is an automatic bollard there. this pleases people because schadenfreude
- Aeolun 3y agoMost of those places do not have any automatic bollards. Who would place them at a red light?
- dghlsakjg 3y agoAll of the automatic bollards I've seen are very clearly signed, and frequently have lights indicating their presence. It is very rare that they are not very obvious. In any case, if you are following another vehicle so closely that you cannot see a hazard in the road in front of you, it is your fault for hitting that hazard (by law in most places).
- bobthepanda 3y agoI don’t know if it’s just me, but it is very hard to parse the title headers that say “What are not bollards.” It’s not a standard way to construct that thought into a headline.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- beAbU 3y agoAuthor is clearly not a mative speaker. I noticed one or two homophonic errors after a brief scan. But I like the headers, as I interpreted it as "bollards" and "not-bollards", kinda humoristic and fun.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bun_terminator 3y agoFunny that this is coming up. About 30 minutes after this post, a bollard played a pivotal role in the currently ongoing Formula 1 race
- leoc 3y agoDid a car in fact pivot around it?
- bun_terminator 3y agoThe car was supposed to pivot, but yeetet right through, taking it for a ride. Probably ending up causing enough damage to change the winnder of the race.
- otikik 3y agoWho is going to tell this person about stroads?
- andrewaylett 3y agoOne happy side effect of the response to terror attacks in the UK is that we've become quite good at bollards. For example, the Scottish Parliament has a number of benches and ornamental ponds: https://maps.app.goo.gl/biSpACmL1fSihqPL7 https://maps.app.goo.gl/biSpACmL1fSihqPL7. Or there's the classic ARSENAL: https://maps.app.goo.gl/xopzGGu8rUdWaTCe8 https://maps.app.goo.gl/xopzGGu8rUdWaTCe8. We're even getting better at providing more than merely paint as protection for cyclists: https://maps.app.goo.gl/2VT3SbjrK27w72826 https://maps.app.goo.gl/2VT3SbjrK27w72826.
- sleepybrett 3y agoUnfortunately in the US cars aren't as easy to get as guns...
- bigstrat2003 3y agoThat is utterly false.
- sleepybrett 3y agoIt is not, selling a car requires title transfer, buying a shotgun in most (i'm hedging a little here, it might be all) states requires passing an age gate (again 18 where i live which is the federal minimum (21 for semi auto)), maybe higher in other states). https://www.driveway.com/learn/selling-trading-in/what-paperwork-do-i-need-to-sell-a-car https://www.driveway.com/learn/selling-trading-in/what-paper...
- kube-system 3y agoNot all states require a title to legally sell a car, and some have exemptions for older cars too.
- kube-system 3y agoI think when people say this, they are mistaking requirements of banks and/or their state government for 'US' laws. The use of cars in the US is almost entirely unregulated by the US government. And for the requirements imposed by state authorities, many of them are implemented as prerequisites for registration, not for ownership.
- nmc 3y agoBollards are good at preventing the inconsiderate from parking on the sidewalk. For fewer people to be killed by cars, however, you want transportation infrastructure which does not rely on having fast metal boxes in close proximity to pedestrians (or cyclists, wheelchair users, etc).
- janalsncm 3y agoIn some places I’ve been, the sidewalk and road are separated by mature trees, with bushes between the trees. It enforces safety, adds distance between cars and pedestrians, and adds ample shade. In intersections, pedestrian islands are protected by bollards. In Singapore for example many of the busiest roads even have pedestrian bridges. It’s a major contrast with my experience of California, where any non-automobile transportation method is an extremely hostile experience. Pedestrians and bicyclists are truly second class citizens on the roads unfortunately.
- _whiteCaps_ 3y agoThere are old cannons that have been used as bollards: https://westevan.org/bollards/cannonbollards3.htm https://westevan.org/bollards/cannonbollards3.htm > The one on the right is a real cannon outside the main gate into the original Chatham Dockyard. It is one of a pair (see the gateway photograph in the gallery below). It had been one of the Royal Navy's biggest smooth-bore muzzle-loading (SBML) guns but when it was no longer fit to be used on a warship it was buried breech-down to protect the brickwork of the gatehouse from damage by carts and other vehicles. The muzzle of this one has been sealed off with a cross-shaped piece of iron. You can also see them as mooring bollards in harbours around the world.
- trhway 3y agoBetween our house and the road turn 30ft away was a thick reinforced concrete pole, a bollard of a kind, severely leaning from being regularly hit by tanks - the road was used by tanks driving from/to loading point, and the tanks in the convoy would regularly miss the turn due to the dust raised by the tanks in front of them.
- mlhpdx 3y agoIndeed. I din't know the term bollard applied to anything other than large mooring cleats. TIL.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- leoc 3y agoAbove all I want to see automatic bollards which pop up along the full length of both sides of a pedestrian crossing when the light is green for pedestrians.
- wonder_er 3y agosaaaaame
- tonymet 3y agoLA started installing plastic bollards on main boulevards like Venice, Olympic. I've had a few buddies injured, one severely, because the well-meaning bollards interfered with organic cycling paths and led to collisions. An organic cycling path is one where either there's no formal cycling path or the painted path is not actually safe for cyclists. Often engineers who install these devices are not regularly cycling on the routes, or even cycling at all. They are not aware of the natural flow of cyclists and how they interact with vehicles. They see a deterministic cause and effect of road markings to road behavior. True road dynamics among cyclists & motorists are non-deterministic. Another terrible example was installation of bollards along popular "group" ride routes where hundreds of club cyclists ride before commute times (before dawn). Thankfully we worked with the city to have them removed, but it likely cost $500k+ for the installation & removal. My point is that often well meaning safeguards end up causing harm, and that policy makers don't actually use the systems they are managing.
- hellcow 3y agoWilshire in Santa Monica also installed these bollards, and I feel less safe as a pedestrian, cyclist, _and_ when driving because of them. We know the solution -- build protected bike lanes, tax cars by weight, and close of some streets to encourage walking through neighborhoods.
- tonymet 3y agoVery good point . Another road in Fremont , ca installed plastic bollards but the traffic was 50-65 mph. Also the bollards prevented street cleaning from clearing debris so cyclists were forced to ride with traffic
- titanomachy 3y ago> Maybe it would feel poetic if he was also a car-user, having his life destroyed by a car, but he didn’t even have a car. Jesus Christ, does this author ever have a bone to pick. Implying that anyone who ever operates a car deserves (at least a little bit) to die a horrific death.
- bombcar 3y agoAn alternative (often temporarily) to bollards are jersey barriers - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jersey_barrier https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jersey_barrier They’re about $2k per 12 feet and are widely used to protect construction workers on roads. They’re also kind of ugly, to be fair.
- quasarj 3y agoThis is so poorly written, I can't tell if he's advocating for bollards or not bollards???
- dullcrisp 3y agoHe wants the bollards. Post some initial confusion about whether the road is on the inside or the outside of the sidewalk, this wasn’t very hard to follow.
- tmorgan175 3y agoThat's some writing under the influence if I've ever seen it. A shame, since the underlying argument is interesting.
- wonder_er 3y agoI was under the influence of _deep_ rage at American traffic planners and municipal 'engineers' who commit themselves, deeply, to dehumanizing decisions, and then spend meaningful effort preventing OTHERS from tending to the spaces that they use. It's one thing to be useless at your job. It's another thing to punch down at others trying to make their way through the world. When I talk to professional planners, they're always so cute. "Wow, Josh, you're so interested in this domain, why don't you get into planning?" I always say: If you were as good at your job as you claim to be, I wouldn't need to spend my precious time trying to fix your shit. When the websites and services _I_ maintain go down, I don't expect _you_ to show up at a public meeting to 'give input' on what needs to be done. I fucking fix the thing that's broken, and until then, everyone's justifiably annoyed that the service is non-performant. I expect minimum levels of safety and adequacy from the mobility network I use, for myself, my child, those I love, and indeed people I've never met. I don't manage to hide my contempt for the professionals actively involved in permitting the death of tens of thousands of people _every year_. But obviously, _obviously_, you don't have to read it.
- netaustin 3y agoThe purpose of the article is persuasive but the HN title is ambiguous and reads much more expository. I’m a New Yorker who walks, bikes, and drives, in roughly that order and it was clear to me that the author is pro-bollard.
- alistairSH 3y agoJust a minor counter- point… bollards are great for keeping cars out of places they don’t belong. But bollards on bike paths can be deadly to cyclist. My area used to place them at path-street crossings, to keep cars from turning onto the bike path, but after a few cyclists clipped them and died, the bollards were removed. The incidence of cars turning onto the bike path is low enough they weren’t worth the risk to non-cars.
- senkora 3y agoI am curious how the bollards were deadly to the cyclists (I'm not saying I disagree, I just don't understand the mechanism). Maybe they were just going a lot faster than I'm thinking of? The primary bike path that I use for commuting is the Hudson River Bike Path in Lower Manhattan, and there are bollards there at every intersection as a reaction to this terrorist attack: https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/sayfullo-saipov-be-sentenced-life-prison-2017-truck-attack-isis#:~:text=On%20Halloween%20afternoon%20in%202017,14%2Dyear%2Dold%20child https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/sayfullo-saipov-be-sent.... I sometimes find the bollards annoying, but I can't disagree with the city for placing them after that...
- alistairSH 3y agoThey were cente-trail (what would be the physical centerline, though there was no lane marking) about 5” in/back from the road surface. A car could get up onto the sidewalk that’s parallel to the road before striking the bollard. So, a cyclist would have to pass the bollards before stopping to check for traffic. I assume they clipped the bollard, lost control, and either ran into the road or something like that. This was 20 years ago now, so I don’t remember details.
- egypturnash 3y agoThe bollards were right in the middle of the cycle path?!? Yeah that's some shitty placement that's gonna endanger the cyclist by shoving them out into traffic.
- londons_explore 3y agoWith the advent of more and more cars with smart features, it might be cheaper to simply have "virtual bollards" which are programmed into the cars computer, and the car will never drive over them. Virtual bollards take up no space, are free to install, require no maintenance or repairs, etc. They also don't destroy any car that hits them. Virtual bollards can also be passed by ambulances and emergency vehicles easily when needed, unlike real bollards which often slow emergency response.
- tikhonj 3y agoWe can do this as soon as 100% of cars are self-driving and we can write software that is 100% reliable. How long can that take?
- londons_explore 3y agoIt doesn't need to be 100% reliable. It just needs to be better than current bollards - which are perhaps only ~10% effective since many accidents happen where there is no bollard to prevent a bystander being killed.
- iainmerrick 3y agoThat’s a nice idea but it would require a lot of elements to work in perfect synchrony to be really safe and reliable. In the foreseeable future, probably easier just to put physical bollards in. Your comment reminds me of a funny aside in Arthur C Clarke’s The Fountains of Paradise (wonderful novel, about the construction of a space elevator). A famous architect, designing the world’s longest and highest bridge, fights to avoid putting guard rails along the sides. His justification is a) cars are all computer-controlled and totally reliable in the book’s setting, so rails are unnecessary; some suspect it’s actually b) the bridge will look nicer without guard rails; or even darker, c) if a car does somehow go off-course, he’d prefer it doesn’t damage the bridge before plummeting half a mile into the sea.
- krisoft 3y ago> Virtual bollards take up no space, are free to install, require no maintenance or repairs, etc. They also don’t exists. That is an other important consideration when talking about them.
- crazygringo 3y agoThis article is a bit difficult to read, as it seems to be written with a heavy dose of sarcasm/irony. I genuinely can't tell what the author is arguing for, as it's extremely difficult to tell if he's quoting things because he agrees or disagrees with them. My biggest question is: is the author arguing that there should be spaced bollards along literally every sidewalk in the country/world, and around all edges of every parking lot? If so, it's an interesting idea, but I also can't help but think that would not just be expensive, but also possibly extremely ugly. I'm curious if there are estimates of both installation cost as well as lives saved and other damage to buildings avoided.
- alistairSH 3y agoCan’t speak for the author, but IMO… Everywhere a pedestrian might be? Probably not. But, we can do a MUCH better job building sidewalks and roads to increase safety. Lower speeds (not just posted limits, but road design). Raised sidewalks that are continuous, not the disjointed mess we have in much of the US. At bus stops, schools, and any shopping area where cars are parked directly adjacent to eh store front? Yeah, bollards should be installed.
- chatmasta 3y agoThe trouble is that we’re rarely “building sidewalks and roads” in a large empty space. Either there is already a road there, or there’s other immovable constraints like buildings and landmarks. If you’ve got some large empty space, then sure you can build a safe road and sidewalk. But the reality is that’s rarely possible, especially in urban areas that were originally planned in the horse and buggy era. The roads in the UK are narrow, and there’s limited parking space, so people park half on the sidewalk and make the road even narrower.
- drozycki 3y agoWhile vehicles partially on the sidewalk are a nuisance, they do provide a barrier between pedestrians and vehicles, and do have a traffic calming effect by narrowing the travel lane.
- Valerie_Wilson 3y ago[dead]
- ktosobcy 3y agoIf only cars weren't gigantic, oversized killing buckets... NotJustBikes just posted another video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JRbnBc-97Ps https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JRbnBc-97Ps) about the speed limit but touching on the same issue - less speed x less mass = safer environment -> less need for physical barriers (they even removed some street lights). Honestly, there wouldn't be that much need for bollard is majority of cars would be city-car like the one in 4:39 min (https://youtu.be/JRbnBc-97Ps?t=279 https://youtu.be/JRbnBc-97Ps?t=279)
- Theodores 3y agoExactly. Excellent video and far more serious than this article. Twenty is plenty and I don't see why that can't apply to rural roads too. For too long we have had motorists be able to terrorise any other lifeform off the road in the countryside. If you have dedicated car only infrastructure then that is one thing, but everywhere else, twenty is plenty. This might seem absurd given the lack of cyclists on the road, but it will foster growth of lightweight EVs rather than monster tanks. As a cyclist I want to see all the speed bumps, traffic lights, bollards and much else banished. Bring back trees, hedges and greenery. Whenever I see footage of places in China I see fantastic landscaping and wonder why we have to have broken glass, graffiti and rubble. I am with NotJustBikes all the way.
- brikym 3y agoThis clip shows how ridiculously large vehicles have become. Not only is the mass higher than ever but the front ends have become stupidly large which results in pedestrians being mowed down rather than rolling over the top. It's a symptom of american culture being highly individualistic and selfish. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6tMSEW_EBs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6tMSEW_EBs
- TylerE 3y agoIt’s hardly stupid and it’s not in the spirit of HN to go on such diatribes. Cars today are vastly, vastly safer than even 30 years ago, never mind 80, and crumple zones are a huge part of that.
- delta_p_delta_x 3y agoThat first image is from this junction[1] in Singapore. https://maps.app.goo.gl/cwAerb4uPN4KD6sR7 https://maps.app.goo.gl/cwAerb4uPN4KD6sR7
- wonder_er 3y agowhat a good find, thanks for the link! I opened it up, looked around, imagined the conditions that led to the photo I put in the article!
- spencerchubb 3y agoI've never thought about in my life. Now that I have read about it, I'm probably going to notice them everywhere. It seems like a remarkably simple technology that saves lives.
- nvader 3y agoI was recently introduced to the World Bollard Association Twitter channel, which is extremely compelling to scroll through, albeit not entirely wholesome. There's some amount of malicious joy as errant cars are punished by contact with bollards, as well as the gratitude for safety of pedestrians this purchases. It might be worth a scroll through: https://twitter.com/WorldBollard https://twitter.com/WorldBollard
- maxglute 3y agoVery cathartic.
- lazyeye 3y ago[flagged]
- fsckboy 3y agoin NYC, I don't worry about getting hit by a car; I worry about getting hit by bicycles/bicyclists. Most NYC streets are one-way, but I have to look both ways before stepping off of a curb.
- gpm 3y agoIn NYC in 2022 (the most recent version of this report) - 116 pedestrians were killed in crashes with motor vehicles - 15 bicyclists were killed in crashes with motor vehicles - 3 pedestrians were killed in crashes with bicyclists - 3 bicyclists were killed in crashes with bicyclists (unclear if that includes bicycle-pedestrian interactions or only bicycle bicycle, I suspect the former) - 1 pedestrian was killed in a crash with a "other motorized (not a motor vehicle)" This isn't isolated to the outskirts or something. In every borough there were > 10x the number of pedestrian fatalities from crashes with motor vehicles as crashes with bicycles. The same general trend holds for injuries though I trust the data a bit less since I can imagine injuries going unreported. I'd suggest that unless you have very atypical habits that put you in conflict with bicycles very often and cars very rarely, you are worrying about the wrong thing. https://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/bicycle-crash-data-report-2022.pdf https://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/bicycle-crash-dat...
- alistairSH 3y agoI have a feeling you’re both correct. Cars/trucks are absolutely more dangerous in a given interaction. But, the increased use of electric motorcycles/scooters on sidewalks is also leading to increased negative bike-pedestrian interactions. US e-bike rules are a totally inconsistent dumpster fire. The “standard” 3 tier rating allows class 3 e-bikes to travel at unsafe for sidewalk/path speeds (28mph), while also being in contradiction to many state’s moped/motor-scooterlaws. Yes, a pedal bike can also go 28mph, but very few people can actually go that fast where an e-bike can easily do so.
- ekimekim 3y ago> I'd suggest that unless you have very atypical habits that put you in conflict with bicycles very often and cars very rarely, you are worrying about the wrong thing. While you would be correct if only considering risk of death, this doesn't tell us anything about the incidence of non-fatal pedestrian-cyclist interactions and what the outcomes are. It would be perfectly rational to care more about cyclists if it was 100x more likely than a car crash and still carried a signifigant risk of injury, even if the risk of death is extremely low. To be clear I actually agree with you that cars are still likely the higher risk, just pointing out a limitation in your data.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nativeit 3y agoTangentially related: https://youtu.be/JRbnBc-97Ps?si=EJ8d3SVc7sy9_gc9 https://youtu.be/JRbnBc-97Ps?si=EJ8d3SVc7sy9_gc9 Not Just Bikes on speed limits.
- eecc 3y agoAmsterdam has many city-themed bollards along the city center streets to delimit the pedestrian part. Although they’re not deeply seated into the ground and will topple if a car hits them (but I guess they’re menacing enough to keep drivers from speeding).
- tcfhgj 3y agoOur city uses them to protect the city center from traffic while giving access to delivery vehicles, pedestrians and cyclists
- wdb 3y agoDidn’t stop Verstappen in Miami today :)
- llsf 3y agoFunny, just drove today in SF and saw and it looks like someone when straight into that house again... https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7475584,-122.44409,3a,75y,89.55h,81.07t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s9FJT8M5RQL50rXRRosKVeQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7475584,-122.44409,3a,75y,89... The City or the owners should put some bollards and be done with this once and for all. In the past 15 years they had some many cars crashing into their houses.
- Aurornis 3y ago> though i think it’s obvious a local city engineer ought to be held criminally liable for their neglect I’m always surprised when armchair observers casually call for criminal prosecution of engineers from other fields. There are obviously some cases where criminal neglect should be pursued, but the frequency with which people demand criminal charges against someone, anyone whenever something happens is getting out of control. I also don’t think these people have considered what would happen when the tables are turned on themselves, such as being involved in something like a security breach or any number of other scenarios where any of us could get caught up in a situation with damages to someone. There are countries where engineers are routinely held liable when anything goes wrong, and the outcome is not good. You get one of two situations: 1. Smart people avoid the job like the plague, knowing that they could end up on the end of a witch hunt trial when anything goes wrong. When the government strives to make an example out of someone, it barely matters if you did your job well or not. Someone must pay, and it might be you. So smart people avoid the job, leaving the role to unqualified people who will take the pay in exchange for the risk. 2. Nothing gets done or approved without incredible amounts of overspending to be extra-extra-extra careful. If you’re possibly criminally liable for damages in a situation and there isn’t much downside for you not approving it, the natural action is to avoid approving anything. Either that or you overengineer it to such an extreme that it’s incredibly expensive and maybe impractical to build, but hey, at least nobody can say you didn’t try. When you look at licensed engineering professions, they tend to be more about ensuring that designs meet agreed upon standards. If the engineer involved was following the standards and actually reviewed the design, it’s unlikely there would be any basis for criminal charges. If we abandon that standard and instead hold engineers to impossibly high standards of evaluating every design for worst case outcomes, then you get the nightmare situation above. But I guess this is the internet and articles like this are more about populist outrage than practical governance.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> When you look at licensed engineering professions, they tend to be more about ensuring that designs meet agreed upon standards. If the engineer involved was following the standards and actually reviewed the design, it’s unlikely there would be any basis for criminal charges. This still leads to bad results because then if ordinary practice leads to bad outcomes or inefficiency, everyone continues on with it because there is no liability for the status quo and potential liability for doing anything different. The thing that usually works is to put liability on companies that cause injuries through negligence, because then the company has the incentive to prevent injuries in the best way it can come up with, without specifying any particular method of doing it. This isn't perfect because then you still have courts deciding what "negligence" means and large companies rigidly conforming to whatever the lawyers say, but at least then they're operating in a competitive environment where the ones that waste resources being unnecessarily rigid make less money and the ones that fail to prevent the harm get sued. The problem is this doesn't work for governments because they're not subject to competition. Then they either immunize themselves from getting sued or waste a ridiculous amount of resources over-engineering a way to prevent the harm or fail to prevent it and get sued but it's the taxpayer who pays, and in all cases the harm falls on the public.
- jojobas 3y ago[flagged]
- loeg 3y agoYeah, they're a great bit of infrastructure to protect people from cars. Sometimes they can cause injuries that wouldn't happen otherwise, though: https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/king-county-to-pay-10m-to-cyclist-paralyzed-in-bollard-crash/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/kin... In general, I'm in favor of a lot more bollard use than we currently enjoy in the US broadly (or Seattle in particular).
- komali2 3y agoWe desperately, desperately need these in Taiwan. My friend was nearly killed a few days ago when a car bounced up off the road and smashed into a pillar less than a meter away from him. If he had walked a tiny percentage faster, he'd have been between the car and the pillar. Take a look at the southwest corner of this intersection: https://www.google.com/maps/@25.0409405,121.5642396,3a,75y,293.29h,74.4t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sfr1WB_F4Q7IOphNHM00drQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu https://www.google.com/maps/@25.0409405,121.5642396,3a,75y,2... or the northeast corner of same. Cars and scooters come flying out of that tunnel from the south at 40, 50km/h. If they happen to merge wrong and bump into a scooter, you've got a missile flying directly at a corner that often has nearly 50 people standing on it, with not even a curb to redirect it. I would say at minimum 50% of intersections in Taipei have no protection whatsoever for waiting pedestrians. I love Taipei and we have good public transit, but being a pedestrian here is often a fucking nightmare. Lord FORBID you try walking in the south by the way. Gaoxiong drivers are drunk 80% of the time and don't give a fuck. If you're in Taiwan and care about this, check out the vision 0 people https://www.visionzero.tw/ https://www.visionzero.tw/ https://www.facebook.com/VisionZeroTW?refsrc=deprecated&_rdr https://www.facebook.com/VisionZeroTW?refsrc=deprecated&_rdr There's a "ride of silence" ride coming up for murdered bicycle riders if you'd like an event. I LOVE the cone strategy in this article. I've been thinking of direct actions I can take to improve pedestrian safety and this looks like a great thing to do. Since I'm white and an immigrant I get a lot of leeway in Taiwan which I can leverage to do all sorts of things like this, since the cops are really hesitant to mess with people like me. A powerful privilege I can use for good.
- ideasphere 3y agoStruggled to get past the author using ‘Peddle’ instead of ‘Pedal’ multiple times
- orthoxerox 3y agoPeddle to the mettle, bay bee.
- Animats 3y agoJapan uses railings along major urban streets. They're sometimes bollards with horizontal rails between them. Sometimes decorative fences made from standard components. And sometimes just a standard rolled steel guardrail, even in cities. That's better than a bollard. It keeps cars off the sidewalk, but a glancing collision won't total the car. Redwood City is finishing up the bollard project from hell.[1] (The picture shows a similar bollard, not the Redwood City installation.) It's taken a full year to install two moving bollards. There's an underground parking garage under the street, so the bollards can't retract into the ground. So an unusual type of bollard that moves sideways was installed. Even that requires a base about six inches thick, which in turn requires a foundation. Construction couldn't go down more than a few inches. So about 50 feet of street, paved with decorative blocks, was torn up, raised, re-graded, the prefabricated bollard unit installed, and the vicinity repaved, with new drainage. [1] https://climaterwc.com/2023/05/11/31863/ https://climaterwc.com/2023/05/11/31863/
- jefb 3y agoI can't bring myself to believe that bollards are the answer. Placing them everywhere would be exceptionally expensive. Emergency vehicles would get stuck in traffic more often. Car accidents involving bollards would be more dangerous to drivers and do more costly damage to cars. While I agree that pedestrian lives would be saved, the net cost to human life likely remains unchanged.
- cjcuddy 3y agoOne of the biggest use-cases for Bollards that this post seems to miss is that they're a necessity for identifying countries/regions in GeoGuessr!
- fire_lake 3y agoAn interesting read. Note to the author if you are here: run a spell checker over your post!
- wonder_er 3y agofixed most of 'em. Thanks. For sure posted a draft, hadn't expected prime time like this, but turns out someone follows me via rss!
- Ellipsis753 3y agoLet's plug my own "joke" website about my love of Bell Bollards: https://bellbollard.com/ https://bellbollard.com/ We have bell bollard t-shirts: https://www.zazzle.co.uk/be_more_bollard_t_shirt-235008427749416060?rf=238991082020245161 https://www.zazzle.co.uk/be_more_bollard_t_shirt-23500842774... And we like to take photos pretending to be bell bollards: https://twitter.com/search?q=%23bellbollard https://twitter.com/search?q=%23bellbollard If anyone else wants to get in on this action, you're more than welcome. :D
- wonder_er 3y agoholy cow this is amaaaaazing, u/ellipsis753. My god. I want the t-shirt, I love the love for bell bollards, I obviously had a photo of one in the post but i didn't know there was so much love for them!!!!! I <3 this
- Aerbil313 3y ago> Please, please stop evaluating local transportation administrations as competent. I’ve hung out with these people, gone on walks with them, driven around with them, listened to them get excited about a new pedestrian affordence they’ve installed, and the lack of awareness and closemindedness (which is obviously necessary to sustain a shitty system creaking into it’s 100th year of existance) is stunning. > To interact with local transportation administrations requires that you 1) self-abandon, and 2) maintain performative allegience to a pseudo-scientific view of the world. There is a fundamental problem here. The problem of incompetence is not unique to transportation agencies, it's rather universal in many public and private sectors. Think about IT industry, think about US healthcare, think about the congress hearing of Pichai. There seems to be an incapability of humans societies to run systems at this scale with expected efficiency and competencies. It seems the whole modern civilization is broken at its roots. It seems that humans don't run the systems they claim to run, rather a systemic force or something greater than individual and collective humans, one that is unaffected by human motivations. There is a tangential problem here, which is the human incapability to comprehend the technoindustrial way of life [1]. I'm not talking about that: I'm talking about the problem that is human societies' inability to run technoindustrial society in an unbroken manner. I think, probably contrary to what most people think, the society worked back then, however differently to what it worked today. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQTuDttP2Yg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQTuDttP2Yg Excellent interview.
- adammarples 3y agoBizarre, I live one minute from the second picture, it's Green Lanes in London
- kmeisthax 3y agoEvery time I look at or have to use pedestrian infrastructure in the US I get the feeling that the local jurisdiction's road engineers think Pixar's Cars is an instruction manual. Like, they would love nothing more than for some master race of pickup truck bros to upload their brains into anthropomorphic cars, discard their primitive flesh, and then run over all the remaining meatbags that refused to join in.
- wonder_er 3y agoloooool this is gold. Author of the post, here, I love this. > Like, they would love nothing more than for some master race of pickup truck bros to upload their brains into anthropomorphic cars, discard their primitive flesh, and then run over all the remaining meatbags that refused to join in. :party:
- zdp7 3y agoAfter reading the article and the comments, I noticed there weren't statistics backing up either the article or many of the comments. In one of the comments the author of the article states their proposed solution would to put two bollards on each corner at an intersection. Considering the unkind descriptions of engineers abilities, I hoped their argument would be well thought out. You can judge for yourself. https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/road-users/pedestrians/ https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/road-users/pedestr... According to this webpage in 2021 there were 7522 pedestrian deaths on public roads. The first statistic to standout was only 23.6% or about 1775 actually occur at an intersection. The next statistic I found interesting was that only 18.63% of fatalities occur during the daytime. This strongly suggests the issue is visibility and not drivers cutting corners or plowing into corners. Alcohol was involved in 43% of accidents and 24% of that the pedestrian was the only one drunk. From my very short look at statistics, I believe bollards would have almost no effect on pedestrian safety. It's pretty easy to realize that it is people that are in the street already and aren't being seen. There isn't an epidemic of cars on sidewalks.