6 ms·
Let insects eat your plants
- vlaaad 3y agoI have a small garden on a balcony. I do it for a piece of mind. I help it grow and thrive, the beauty of the plants gives me peace of mind. There is no place for freaking saw flies in this equation, so no thanks, I'll continue getting rid of the caterpillars.
- carabiner 3y agoDid an insect write this?
- bl4ckneon 3y agoI believe it was a bunch of them in a trenchcoat!
- ourmandave 3y agoEarly media roll out for the coming cicada-pocalypse.
- hermannj314 3y agoNot serving water in restaurants fixed the water crisis and letting insects eat my roses will fix the bug crisis. As long as the farmers receiving billions of dollars a year in holdover depression-era welfare programs don't have do anything to combat the problem, we should be fine.
- FartyMcFarter 3y agoI find this kind of comment neither particularly amusing nor informative. Can you elaborate on those kinds of programs and their problems instead?
- whythre 3y agoThe above post isn’t about specific details, it’s about the idea of individuals being scolded into trying useless ‘solutions’ to problems caused by the mismanagement of entire industries. Industrialized farming involves a lot of pesticides. Acting as if the problem will get better if people just let pests eat their small garden plots is dumb.
- Ma8ee 3y agoThe problem will get better, even if the direct effect of no pesticide home gardens of course is negligible. But it helps change the mindset of people. People who live in garden with a diversity of wildlife, who find joy in the butterflies (and their larvae), who are appalled by the thought of poison their own air, water and soil, soon start to buy organic food and vote for stricter environment protection laws. In addition, while it might not change the world, the amount of pesticides and herbicides used by all the homeowners in a city like LA isn’t insignificant, in particular not for the local wildlife.
- antisthenes 3y agoI find this tongue-in-cheek commentary very amusing, especially considering the article is a perfect example of describing feel-good bikeshedding, rather than addressing actual issues that were called out (e.g. large scale farming and loss of habitat due to human development) If you want to read more, you can start at a very high level by Googling habitat loss and industrial agriculture, I guess?
- nemo44x 3y agoInstead of “habitat loss” I prefer to call it “starvation prevention”.
- elmomle 3y agoI think "starvation deferment" is a more accurate phrase. To prevent starvation we need to address the tendency of humanity to reproduce, and to consume resources, past the limits of what we can safely and reliably sustain. Taking more and more land, and increasingly suppressing nature, to create more food on a finite Earth simply kicks the problem down the road.
- para_parolu 3y agoNever heard about water crisis because of water in restaurants. Can you elaborate a bit? What place and time that happened?
- 2024throwaway 3y agoI believe you need to mentally append a /s to the GP's comment.
- kcplate 3y agoI still find it wild the number of folks on HN who seem blind to obvious sarcasm. Perhaps if english is a second language you get a pass, but if english is your first language…oof.
- MattGaiser 3y agoIt is hard to parse sarcasm in a world where opinions are much broader and varied than they used to be and signalling has become more pronounced and infused into life. You genuinely do get bloggers recommending ensuring you take a reusable bottle on a plane trip, that people take shorter showers, and don't leave the water running when brushing their teeth. It is reasonable to do all those things, but they are pretty small. Are these 3 sarcasm or real? - Wash your dishes in a bowl instead of a larger sink. - Fill your watering can waiting for the water to heat up - Put buckets in your shower. Answer. All real. One is a Google suggested tip for saving water. https://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+save+water+at+home&oq=how+to+save+water+at+h&gs_lcrp=EgZjaHJvbWUqBwgAEAAYgAQyBwgAEAAYgAQyBggBEEUYOTIHCAIQABiABDIHCAMQABiABDIHCAQQABiABDIHCAUQABiABDIHCAYQABiABDIHCAcQABiABDIHCAgQABiABDIHCAkQABiABKgCALACAQ&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+save+water+at+home&oq...
- specialist 3y agoThose tips on their own are fine. It is absurd and counterproductive to then suggest those measures will meaningful impact a regional multi-year drought, while farmers continue to grow alfalfa and almonds.
- phyzome 3y agoIf you want birds, grow plants that support caterpillars. It takes thousands of caterpillars to raise a nest of baby birds to fledglings. (This is true even for seed-eating birds.) Those caterpillars don't come from thin air.
- Spooky23 3y agoIt takes 3-5 “outdoor” cats to slaughter those birds in a few weeks.
- throw__away7391 3y agoAmazing how little attention this gets, people just shrug it off. If it were something man-made having the same impact as cats on bird populations there would be protests demanding that it be banned.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bitxbitxbitcoin 3y agoOne could argue that feral domesticated cats are a man-made issue.
- throw__away7391 3y agoOh yeah totally. I meant if it was something like chemical that only impacted birds or was caused by driving SUVs or anything like that.
- nicolaslem 3y agoYou mean windows? Estimates show they kill roughly the same number of birds as cats.
- Spooky23 3y agoCat people love their cats. Unlike dogs, there isn’t a direct human impact to negative behaviors of cats or humans poor management of them. Nobody really cares about birds, and “herding cats” carries the meaning that it does for a reason.
- DataDive 3y agoI do think that it is an interesting thought - even if I don't necessarily agree. If you go to any home improvement store, you'll see walls of insect-killing products; most appear highly toxic. Many people also exhibit overly fearful reactions to insects (or snakes, for that matter). The tradeoff is not between having or not having roses/tomatoes/beans, but should you go out of your way to take out all insects with the most toxic means possible? I read the article as more of a wake-up call and a bit of education, suggesting that maybe there is beauty and value in life in general, beyond us humans deciding what is valuable and what is not.
- the__alchemist 3y agoThe snake fear may be a deeply-rooted instinctual fear common to all primates! (Along with fear of falling...)
- jwells89 3y agoI don’t think people as a whole are as fearful of insects as they are avoidant of getting bitten/stung or having their living space and especially foodstuffs infested. It’s my belief that most benign insects just get caught in the crossfire.
- ainiriand 3y agoI see the problem in the same way as you. I have a small garden adjacent to my neighbours. This winter was quit humid and a lot of moss grew all over our gardens, he decided to use chemical products to get rid of it and any weeds for the spring. Now spring came and there are way less insects in my garden as opposed to last year, not counting the week of putrid fumes coming from his garden.
- beretguy 3y agoWhat if I only grow bug eating plants?
- _akhe 3y agoI did this with my indoor pots, had a couple of rolly pollies, was like oh cool I'll give them this rock and stick to chill on. Fast forward 2 years - The Interpot Federation of Rolly Pollies have sent me a declaration of war. They have a standing army of 4 million rollies and a mercenary crew of centipedes. Their demands are as follows: - Keep the strawberry tops flowing - More water but not TOO much water - The kids want a pump track to roll around on
- polishdude20 3y agoDid they colonize your desert regions? They always colonize the desert regions.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoYou lack predators to keep the population of the Interpot Federation of Rolly Pollies in check. As their God I suggest you encourage a religion that requires rolly polly sacrifice to please you. If they don't adopt there is always alien abduction or the threat of drought to urge compliance. You have to decrease their numbers before they start getting uppity thinking they can conquer the kingdom of god.
- jnellis 3y agoWho is that predator? I wish to hire them desperately. We had an agreement that the federation would stick to just the dead material but there are obviously some free thinking factions at work. Now I'm growing lettuce as just the distraction crop for them (and the slugs) to protect the other youngling starts and strawberries.
- mythrwy 3y agoChickens love rolly pollies.
- curtisblaine 3y agoDysdera Crocata is a spider literally evolved around killing and eating roly-poly. As they need to pierce the roly-poly's exoskeleton, their bite is painful (but harmless) for humans. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodlouse_spider https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodlouse_spider
- gtirloni 3y agoMaybe gigantic monocultures have something to do with the insect decline? I love watching the ocasional Surinamese cockroach in my garden. Even issued warnings to anyone thinking about killing them. But it's such a small scale that I don't believe I'm contributing anything useful.
- navigate8310 3y agoButterfly effect perhaps
- kulahan 3y agoGardening is one of those things where grassroots efforts really do have an outsized effect. An oasis of nature can make a big difference.
- ortusdux 3y agoAs I understand it, one of the best things you can do is not bag up your leaves in the fall. Many insects lay their eggs on leaves, with the goal of having them winter over and hatch in the spring. There is an industry around blowing, raking, vacuuming, and bagging leaves, which stops this cycle. I spread most of my leaves out along the back of my lot, and the rest go on the garden beds. It is also an easy sell to people who don't really care about insects. Mosquitoes don't reproduce this way, but the insects that eat them do. You also don't need to dispose of your leaves every year. You can use the leaves as ground cover, and run them through a leaf shredder to make mulch, which saves you from buying these every year. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/09/01/insect-removal-problems-ecosystem/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/09/01/insect-re... https://www.ecolandscaping.org/07/installing-and-maintaining-landscapes/mulching/the-value-of-leaf-mold-mulch/ https://www.ecolandscaping.org/07/installing-and-maintaining... https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/04/realestate/garden-mulch.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/04/realestate/garden-mulch.h...
- euroderf 3y agoRake the leaves into piles and hit'em with the lawnmower and collect'em in the lawnmower's leaf bag and then spread the shred. Some in the garden to rot thru the winter, the rest back around the lawn.
- darth_avocado 3y agoI do a no pesticide garden and insects are a part of it. It took me 4-5 years of not giving up to reach a state of equilibrium. The first two years, the losses were devastating. Plants were regularly eaten by unwanted insects like aphids and cabbage white caterpillars. And I had to keep adding more plants. Now I have 70+ plant species in my small backyard and the beneficial insect moved in. Spiders, ladybugs and wasps now take care of any infestation before it becomes big. And the ones that stay small are now just an acceptable part of the garden’s lifecycle.
- septic-liqueur 3y agoSounds great, would love to hear more about your method. What about weed btw ?
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoDon’t grow weed in your garden unless you are certain it is legal to do so.
- Loggias 3y ago[dead]
- darth_avocado 3y agoIt is a manual process, but I’ve become reasonably good at identifying them when they’re just saplings. 5 mins a day of just me pulling on stuff keeps the yard mostly weed free. I do let some “weeds” stay that are pollinator friendly. Also what has helped are native grasses and pollinator friendly ground covers like thyme that usually reduce the ability of weeds to take over.
- RetroTechie 3y ago"A well-balanced garden shouldn't be munched down to the ground and left a wasteland – that should never happen in a biodiverse system, says Jones." This. Care for the soil. And grow a diversity of plants. Then those plants -on average- will grow well, and strong enough to ward off pests. Some plants will do poor in a season, other plants will do better than usual. Have faith in your garden's ecosystem to regulate itself. So that you 'need' to interfere (read: work, remove weeds, and occasionally water) as little as possible.
- unstyledcontent 3y agoIf you plant something and nothing is eating it, it is not part of the ecosystemand might as wellbe made of platic. I plant native flowers and it is so gratifying seeing the abundance of life thriving on even the smallest plant. I also plant edible foods because I need to eat as well!
- engine_y 3y agoI was bought my vegetables from a guy who used absolutly no insecticides or pesticides. It was really great. He had a pretty decent area of land where he grew a plethora of crops. He told me that sometimes some of the plants were eaten but he had others so it's fine. The vegetables were very tasty and fresh and we loved it. We were glad to pay a bit more for fresh and poison free stuff. Unfortunately, after a year or so he went out of business because he let the insects eat his plants.
- deadbabe 3y agoThey ate his lunch :(
- hinkley 3y agoA year or so is probably not enough to build up the predator population. Intensive agriculture, especially as currently practiced, is all about local optima. If he’d ramped up slower and worked on predator habitat it might have gone better for him. I have wasps and beetles doing a lot of policing on my property. It’s fungi and weed species I struggle with, not insects.
- mrweiner 3y agoHow are fungi causing you trouble? I associate fungi as being positive for plant growth.
- cityofdelusion 3y agoAs a gardener, fungal diseases probably cost the most each year in plant loss. They are very difficult to eradicate once established and fungal spores are microscopic and very good at spreading. I’ve had years of 100% loss on tomato’s, peppers, and apple trees, all from tiny fungi.
- xolox 3y agoI grow mushrooms as a hobby and in that context my number one enemy is trichoderma, the green mold. This is because trichoderma is parasitic on other fungi, i.e. it doesn't colonize the substrates that I grow my fungi on, it directly colonizes (eats) the fungal threads (mycelium) thereby killing it off before it has a chance to "fruit" (produce mushrooms). This is how I initially learned that trichoderma is used as a natural "fungicide". In your specific case it might be interesting to investigate this in more detail, e.g. you can "inoculate" your soil with copious amounts of trichoderma to fight off other fungi. For more details here's a pointer to a rabbit hole: https://www.google.com/search?q=trichoderma+fungicide https://www.google.com/search?q=trichoderma+fungicide Sorry if you know all of this already, I was hoping it might help :-).
- Devasta 3y agoEveryone should get rid of their lawns in favour of native plants and flowers. So much time and effort put into maintaining absolutely useless, sterile wastelands, it's lunacy.
- mvdtnz 3y agoI didn't know anyone was fighting against insects on perennial plants. I've certainly never bothered, I've never seen insects do enough damage to be bothered. However, I'm not going to leave cabbage moths to destroy my brassicas, because they absolutely will not stop until the plant is a nub in the soil.
- bregma 3y agoI have current bushes. Every year, one day in June, the cutworms emerge and strip all the bushes of the foliage in about 8 hours leaving nothing but bunches of red berries dangling from naked sticks. It doesn't kill the plants, but neither do they thrive. Still, it's the tent caterpillars that are the worst. They'll strip all trees and bushes in a 20 metre radius and some years there's a nest every 10 metres. Not good in an orchard.
- sitkack 3y agoWhen I was kid, you could lift up a board in the backyard and find hundreds of bugs. Now my urban back yard still has bugs, but easily 1/10th or even 1/100th of what we had when I was a kid. I use zero chemicals, but who knows what the previous owner did. I'd really like to encourage a healthy bug population back there, any tips?
- daveguy 3y agoLet weeds grow in your yard. Cut it high -- ~3+ inches. It'll still be green if you're in a temperate climate (probably greener than your neighbors). Birds and bugs both love a more natural lawn.
- fmajid 3y agoKeep in mind your neighbors might not appreciate your insect-ful garden if it rubs off on theirs.
- hypefi 3y agoI have spent one year growing vegetables in my garden and observing the slow growth of the plants, and it was one of the most amazing and humbling experiences I've ever experienced, the dance of the insects around the plants, the ants the pollinators, the bees, the spiders who trapped and ate the insects, the insects of the soil all worked in a quite fashioned harmony, it seemed impossible that the plants could grow without the insects, as though the plants are the buildings of a city and the insects its inhabitants.
- genericacct 3y agook but no snails
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoWorks when Javascript is disabled: https://www.bbc.co.uk/future/article/20240503-why-you-should-let-insects-eat-your-plants https://www.bbc.co.uk/future/article/20240503-why-you-should...
- wakawaka28 3y agoThis has to be a joke, like many of the replies here. If you want a return on your investment of time and energy, you have to take steps to control the insects in your garden. That may involve beneficial insects or less-lethal solutions like soapy water, herbs, or bug traps. But insects will rock your world and kill everything, over and over, until you get them smacked down. What's next, let termites eat your house? Let mosquitoes and fleas bite you? Go live in a grass hut? For fucks sake...
- fnordian_slip 3y agoFunnily enough, I also found the article absurd and amusing, but from the opposite side. Without your comment, and others like it, I would have compared this article to one stating "don't raise your kids on fast food" or "teach children to swim if you want less deaths by drowning". In my neighborhood, nobody that I know uses active pest control for insects in their gardens. That is reserved for indoor plants. Snails are killed by most in some way or another, but even my parents - who are in their sixties - think that actively managing insect populations in the garden instead of just letting it reach an equilibrium died out in their generation. "insects will rock your world and kill everything, over and over, until you get them smacked down." Are there more problematic insects in the US compared to Europe? I can't comprehend that mindset, but maybe it's down to differences in flora and fauna between our respective gardens.